ROGERS v. HOLCOMB

ROGERS v. HOLCOMB
1930 OK 293
289 P. 349
144 Okla. 16
Case Number: 20734
Decided: 06/10/1930
Supreme Court of Oklahoma

ROGERS et ux.
v.
HOLCOMB.

Syllabus

¶0 Appeal and Error--Nullity of Case-Made Settled and Signed Without Notice to Opposite Party.
Where a case-made is settled and signed in the absence of defendants in error and without notice of the time and place of settlement of the case-made being given or waived and no stipulation entered into as to the correctness of the same, such case-made is a nullity and brings nothing before this court for review.

Error from District Court, Alfalfa County; J. W. Bird, Judge.

Action by Sam Holcomb against Andy H. Rogers et ux. Judgment for plaintiff, and defendants appeal. Dismissed.

A. J. Stephens, for plaintiffs in error.
Sam P. Riding, C. S. Ingersoll, W. L. Owen, and J. C. McClelland, for defendant in error.

PER CURIAM.

¶1 This cause is before the court on motion to dismiss the appeal. Several grounds are urged in the motion to dismiss the appeal, but we deem it necessary to notice but one.

¶2 The case-made attached to the petition in error filed in this appeal was settled and signed in the absence of the defendant in error and without notice to him of the time and place of presentation of the case-made to the trial judge for settlement. No stipulation was entered into as to the correctness of the case-made, nor was the notice of the time and place of settlement in any manner waived.

¶3 Where a case-made is settled and signed in the absence of the defendant in error and without notice of the time and place being given or waived and no stipulation entered into as to the correctness of the same, such case-made is a nullity and brings nothing before this court for review. Riley v. Hammer et al., 138 Okla. 230, 280 P. 825; Liberty Life Ins. Co. v. Green, 133 Okla. 58, 270 P. 1111; First State Bank of Oilton v. O'Bannon, 128 Okla. 16, 260 P. 1062; Carr v. St. Louis-San Francisco Ry. Co., 118 Okla. 223, 247 P. 38; Morris v. West Publishing Co., 118 Okla. 237, 247 P. 52.