Dunleavy v. Medical & Mental Health Dept. et al, No. 7:2017cv00526 - Document 7 (W.D. Va. 2017)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 12/12/2017. (tvt)
Download PDF
CLERK' OF CE U.S. ST. : FI DI COURT ATDANVILE, L VA Fi ED L I TH E U N I N TED STATES D I STR I C O U R T CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR I O F V I G I A CT R NI R O A N O K E DIV ISIO N JU STI PA U L DU N LEA V Y, N Pl ntff ai i , M EDI CAL AND M ENTAL HEALTH DEPT-e al, ,t . Dee n s fnda t. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) 2E2 j2 2 1 07 a u ou ux C E K u Ac n u L R s:RA v DEPUT CLERK Y Ci lA c i N o.7: c 005 vi t on 17- v- 26 M EM OM ND U M O PI NION By: H on.Jac on L . i e u K sr Se or U ni e St e D i t c Judge ni t d at s s ri t J tn Pa Dunl a aVigi ai a epr e ng pr K ,fl d a c usi ul e vy, r ni nm t oc edi o ie ompl i pur ua t ant s nt o 4 U. C. 1 8 na ngt red fn a t:ç e ia a M e tl at De ty M ao Ge r e 2 S. j 9 3 mi h e ee d n s S dc l nd n a He 1 p .' j r o g M h ' He ee a Ca ai Bra Pa ks Pli ifge r ly al gest thi m e ca nee a enot mbr , nd pt n in r . a ntf ne a l le ha s di l ds r be ngm e a t Dufi l Re o lJ i.Thi m atri be o em ef s r e ng,puruantt 28 i t t he fe d gi na al s te s f r or c e ni s o U .S. j191 A. C. 5 1 Se ton 1 3 r qui e a s i ofpe s na f ul on t pa tofa de e nte t r ba e c i 98 e r s how ng r o l a t he r f nda ihe s d on t de e n ' pe s lc he f nda t s r ona onduc o anot r sco tr he ' nduc i e c i oft de e n ' po i e t n xe uton he f nda t s lci s o c tms Fih rv. a hnzo Mer . e Tr n i Au h r, 9 F.d 1 3 ,1 4 - 3( t r uso . s e W s i tn to Ar a a st t o .6 0 2 1 3 1 2 4 4h 'lmuS dimisa aci orcl m tldby a i t i 1dee mi t tt a ton o cam i gi ousorf l t s s ny ton ai ie n nmae f tr ne ha he ci r li s vol ais t saeacam o whihr l fma b ga td S e28U.. j 1 1 ()2,1 5 b( )4 U. C. 1 9 ec. o tt li n c ei y e rne . e e SC. j 9 5e() 91 A()1; 2 S. j 9 7 () Thefrtsanda d i udescl msba e uponSa i s a y merte slgalt r 'Scai ofi rnge e ofa is t r ncl ai sd sn ndiputbl ils e heo y,'çl ms nfi m nt lgali ees whih cl ry doe no e s ' cl mswhe et Sfctalcon e insa ece l ba ees ' Neizke e ntr t c ea l s t xit'or ai r he ça u t nto r lary s l s. t ' v W iims 4 0U. 31 , 2 ( 9 9.Thesc n sa d r i tefmiirsa d r f ramoint ds s u d r . la , 9 S. 9 3 7 1 8 ) l e o d tn ad s h a la tn ad o to o imis n e Fe ea Rul o Ci l o e u e1 6, c e t gaplitf' fcu l le ainsa tu .A c mpan n e sç d rl e f viPrc d r 209()a c pi n anifs ata alg to s re o lit e d 1 a s o t n pli sae n o tecam s o n ta teped ri e tt dt r l f' n s f ce tGta ta h r a d an ttme t f h li h wig h th la e s nil o ei a d ut in sl cu l e e i l alegains...t r iearghtt r ifa l to o as i o ele bovet s cultvelve....'BelAt.Cor v.Twom bl 550U . 5 he pe ai e l ' l l o. v, S. 44, Dunleavy v. Medical & Mental Health Dept. et al 5 5(0 7 (nen l u tto mak o te ) A plitf sbai frrl fs q ie moeta lb l a d 5 2 0 ) itr a q oain r s mi d . an if ss o ei te ur s r h n a es n t e r c ncu ins. .' I .Th r fr , plitf mutd l g fcss fiin t saealheee nso (h jcam. o lso . . d eeoù a anif s û l e a t ufce to tt lt lme t f te li ' ' ae ' Basv. IDu o d Ne u s& Co, 2 F.d7 , 6 (t Ci. 0 ) s E.. p nt e mo r .3 4 3 61 7 5 4h r20 3. Doc. 7 Deemiigwh te ac mjan sae apasbecam frrlfiR cnets ct ts t teurs tr nn ehr o littts luil li o ei s a o tx-pei ak harq ie e k terve n c utoda o i j dca e p re c a dc mmo sn e' As co t .u a, 5 U. 6 2 6 h e iwig o rt rw n t u lil x ein e n o n e s. h rf v lb l5 6 S. 6 , 7879 s ' ( 0 ) Th , c u tce nn ac mplitu d rRue1 b()c nie type dn sta aeno e tldt a 20 9. usa o r sre ig o an n e l 2()6 a d ni la ig h t r t nie o n f t asum ptonoftut be aus t y c itofnom or t n lbel a concusons l Alhough Ilbe al co tu a s i r h c e he onss e ha a s nd l i . d. t i r ly 'nsr e D oK c mpan, ie v. re, 0 U.. 1 , 2 - (9 2 , d n ta t sa imaesa v ae s as o t r o litHan s Ken r 4 4 S 5 9 5 021 1 7 ) l o o c a n n t' d oct, u p ne de opi saut y a c tt i cl m snotce l r ie i ac pli . Se Br kv.Ca r l l F. 241, vel ng tt or nd onsiutonal ai lary as d n om ant e oc rol, 07 3d 2 (t Ci. 9 7 ( u t , .c n urn lBe u et . t o Ha tn 7 5F.d1 7 1 78(t Ci.1 8 )s e 43 4h r 1 9 ) L ti J, o c rig; a d tv Civ f mpo , 7 2 2 4, 2 4h r 9 5, e g ' . as God nv Le k , 7 F.d11 7 1 51( hCi.1 7 )(e o nzngta adsrc c utsn te p ce t lo r o . e e 5 4 2 4 , 1 4t r 9 8 rc g ii h t itit o r i o x etd o as meter l o a v c t fraD oK panig. su h oe f d o ae o r lit f Dockets.Justia.com Ci.1 2) a ogaedp. ohe g omdskyCnt ofm vesdev. c uchln,500U. 44 r 98 , br t . t r r t q y. ri M La i S. ( 991.Ho ve,Pli ifdoe no de ci a pes la to o si byde e nt 1 ) we r antf s t s rbe ny rona c r mison fnda He eeo Paks a o eq n l t c mbr r r , nd ons ue ty,he ompl i f ist sae adam upon whih r ifm a ant a l o t t i c ele y begr nt d agans t m .Furhe mor M e c la M e alHe lh De . i no a S r p 'f a e i t he t r e, di a nd nt at pt' s t t s n' or ' pe p r s so j 1 8 .S e ec, i v M ih g nDe to S aePoie 4 U. 5 , 0( 9 9 ; upo e f 9 3 e . ..W l . c i a p' f tt l , 91 S. 8 7 1 8 ) l c W e t At n , 8 U. 4 , (98 ) F r us nv. o g n No 19 c 06 8 1 91U.. s. s v. kis 4 7 S. 2 48 1 8 ; e c o M r a , . :0 v 31 , 9 S Dit LEXI 8 9 ,1 91W L 1 5 5 , t*1( D. Y. u e2 ,1 91 (o ldngt a ag o p o S 25 9 1 7 9 a S. N. J n 0 9 ) c ncu i h t r u f p ro n l l eç dc l tf, i n t ç ro 'o p po e o j1 8 ) c r i l , ds s es n e,i d ia saf' s o a s s n'f r u s s f 9 3 .Ac o dngy I imis k me ' pe tec mplitwih u p eu ie p ru n t 2 U. C. 1 5 b)1, o fiigt saeacam h o an to t rj d c , u s a t o 8 S. j 91 A( ( ) fr aln o tt li upon w hi h r i m ay be gr nt d. c elef a e Tot ee tn Plitf ma bea l t n meaç es n's b e tt s i vaj 1 8 , an if h x e t an if y b e o a s ro 'u j c o ut i 9 3 Plitf p i gr nt d t n da t f l a m oton t n e t c pl i t ts a esa c ai upo w hi h r le s a e e ys o ie i o m nd he-om a nt ha t t lm n c ei f m a begr n e agans a pe s a tng unde c orofsa elw. Se ec.Gor n,57 F. a y a t d i t r on c i r ol tt a e. . , do 4 2d t Pl i ifma fnd i pr f r bl t t kel rt n t n dayst c ul lgalr s lc , antf y i t e e a e o a onge ha e o ons t e e ot es r t nka hi algai ,a cfl ane c anti ane a spaaea ton.I Pl ntf hi bout s le tons nt ie w ompli n w nd e rt ci f ai if c o e n t ofl t mo inwi i tnd ys Plitf wo l n tb p eudc db c u eh i ho s s o t ie he to t n e a , an if ud o e rj ie e a s e s h alwe t fl ac mplitn an w a ds p rt a to a t tmeo hi c oc s b e tt t lo d o ie o an i e n e a ae ci n the i f s h ie u j c o he a lc b el tto peid.Se , ..Owe sv Ok r , 8 U. 2 5 2 9 5 (98 ) Va Co e ppia l i ains ro mi e ec, n . u e 4 8 S. 3 , 4 - 0 1 9 . . d , j8. -43( . 012 A) l Pl i ifi t a r he a l c f a ntf ns e d us s ld hoos s t s e a a e e o e k n m ndm e i t s c e, s ul know nt n hi as he ho d t a t ec u t yds s t ea nd dc mp an wihp eu iea fio o o f rfiigt h t h o r ma imis h me e o lit t rj dc s rv lus r o al o n sa eacli upon whih r le m a be g a e and a s s aSsrke. Pl i ifs d unde sa tt am c e if y r nt d s e s çti ' antf houl ' r tnd t thei al d onl t e û ti s'fo bot co pl nt i d src c ' and a pe l i ha s lowe y hr e t rke ' r m s h m ai s n itit ouls t p as n c ' ofa asbeor hei nol ral dt pr e dL fnnapa rswiho prpa ng ouls ppe l f e s onge lowe o oc e q o t unei t ut e yi t $400 flng f e a e ce t n c tons Co r s c e t d t s( hr e-ti 'r l a a he ii e bs nt rai ondii . ng e s r a e hi ç e srkes' u e s n t ec onomi i ntvef prs r t Gso a t nk'be or flnga c c nce i or ione s o tt p nd hi ' f e ii ompli .Se ec.Roa s a nt e. . , er v. uhm,No.107c 77,2007U. Dit LEXI 91 2007W L 440187,a *1( . M ih. Bl : v11 S. s. S 646, t W D. c De .1 , 0 7 . c 320) ExTlR: i l o d y o oe e e , 2017, Th s a a f c mb r . 1 S ni rUnie St t sDititJ o t d a e src udge