Binns v. Commonwealth of Virginia et al, No. 7:2017cv00514 - Document 7 (W.D. Va. 2017)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/14/2017. (slt)
Download PDF
Binns v. Commonwealth of Virginia et al Doc. 7 CL S OFF/ E U . . ST O UR' . ERK' t 3 Dl . 3 AT ROANOG , VA FI LED I THE UNI STATESDI CT COURT N TED STRI DEC 15 2 1 27 FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRICT O F V I G I I R N A R O A NO K E D I I O N V SI G RE G O R Y BI N S, N Pl ntf . ai i f . V. COM M ONW EALTH OF VI NI e aI RGI A, t , De e nts. fnda t) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) J I Z ULA I DUD sv: , E RK o w 4. x Az C i lA c i N o.7: - v- 0514 vi ton 17 c 0 ' MEM ORANDUM OPI ON N By: M i hae F.U rbans c l ki Chi fUnie St t sDit i tJudge e td a e src Gr r Bi , oc edi pr K ,fl àcvirg sco ai , s ntt 42U. C.j ego y nns pr e ng o ed .i l iht mpl ntpurua o S. 1 983.By Or rentr dN o mbe 15 201 t c t r c e pli ift s i wihi 20 de e e ve r , 7, he our die t d a ntf o ubm t t n d fom t dat oft Or ra sae e ofas e s a i a ea co mtf ays r he e he de tt m nt s t, n nm t c t onn,a ac tfe nd erii d c py ofpl ntf st s f a co sae e f rt sx- o hpe i i medit l pr e ng o ai if nzt und c unt t tm nt o he i m nt rod m a ey ec di t flng oft c he ii he ompli ,ob ai d fom t a o it prs ofi a ofe c prs n a whih ant t ne r he ppr pra e ion fcil a h io t c pl i ifi orwa c i d dudng t tsxantf s s onfne ha i mont pe i Pl i ifwa a s d t taf ilr t h rod. antf s dvie ha alze o c mp ywo l r s tn ds sa o t sa to wih u p eudc . o l u d euli imis l f hi ci n t o t rj ie M o e t n 20 da havee a e a pl ntf ha f ie t c r ha ys l ps d, nd ai if s al d o ompl wih t de c i d y t he s rbe c n iin .Ac o dngy t ec u t imis st ea to wih u p eudc a dsrke t ec s o dto s c r i l ,h o r ds se h ci n t o t rj ie n ti s h a e fo t a tvedoc oft c t Pl ntf m a r fl t c am si as pa a ea i o e r m he ci ket he our. ai if y e ie he l i n e r t cton nc pli ifi pr pa e t c antf s e r d o ompl wih t not d c tons y t he e ondii . TheCl r i die e t s nd ac oft sM e o a e k s r ctd o e opy hi. m r ndum Opi o a a ompa ng ni n nd cc nyi Or rt pl i tf . de o a n if ' ErR Ti )L' dyf ee eg1.q. z . .J x s : h 1 aoocmbr2 7 r .. s 0 . # ' , . . . . , '. r t . . Chi fU nied St sD it i tJ e t a s rc gdge Dockets.Justia.com