Roscoe v. Collins et al, No. 7:2017cv00494 - Document 119 (W.D. Va. 2018)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 6/26/2018. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
clEl ' OFFI U. . DI . -< s CE s ST COURT Ar DANVILE, L VA FI LED I TH E UNI N TED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI CT RGI A NI RO AN O K E DI SI N W O EM M I R O SC O E,JR . TT , Pl ntff ai i , L.COLEI e aI, NS, t . Dee f ndant . s J 25 2 1 UN 28 J C. DL C U D R sz t EU hPWC D Ci lA c i N o.7: 7- vvi t on 1 c 00494 ) ) ) ) ) ) ) M EM O R AN DU M O PI I N N O By: H on.Jac on L .K i er ks s Seni U nied St e D i t i tJudge or t at s s r c Emm itRos oe, r,aVig ni prs rpr ee ngpr K ,c t c J. r i a i one oc di o omm e d t i a ton nce l s c i l purua t 42U. C.j1 3a utc r ci la medialsaf 'alege delbe ae s nt o S. 98 bo ore tona nd c tfs l d i r t id fe e o t h sp ysc l i a dwatng Th smatri beo emeo t ma itaej dg ' n ifr n e o i h ia pan n si . i te s fr n he gsrt u e s rp r a drc mme d to ,owhc t epate ha eo j ce S e28U. C. 6 6 ()B) e o t n e o n ain t ih h ris v b e td. e S. j 3 @)1( . Fo t f l ng r as ,Iado t r por a r co me ton a gr ntt m o i f a r he olowi e ons pt he e t nd e m ndai nd ' he ton or a prl nayij ncin (h ç oin'. ei r nu to te ç to ' 1 mi M ) 1 . 2 k. A flo imaebr k Plitf' j w a d d ma e ane v o Fe nzr 3 2 7 a a elw n t o e an ifs a n a g d r e n b a y , 01 , nd n o a s r e nwie l sj w s u svea d y ltr n e ue t Plitf e d dalq i de r l u g o r d n a h t e rl a s ae .Co s q nl an ifn e e iu d it i y, b th do tnb e s r e ple df o st a h c ul n te t ealg dc n iue jw p i u a fe e n ev d t e o d h t e o d o a.Th l e o tn d a an r e c us d hi t no wa t e t a he al ge y l tt nt poundsdlrng ee n m o hs He a e m o t nt o a , nd le dl os we y zi lve nt . c mp anst thep i h sr man dt rae ato g t ej w i n lng rwie s u a di o li ha t an a e ie mte td l u h h a s o o e rd h t n s h de m e he e e d ald. Roscoe v. Collins et al Se r lmont a trc ve a hs fe omm e ng t a ton i 201 Pl i ifsl d am oton f a nci he c i n 8, antf e i or Doc. 119 p ei nayijmci n Th ij n t erle wa s ug ta an td fn a t d n itDr M ooe rlmi r nt to . e nu ci eif s o h g is ee d n s e ts . r , v 1 anifh dc pine ia amoinfratmp rr rs iigo d rCTRO'.Be a s s mepat s Plitf a a to d t s to o e oay etann r e ' cg e o ) ri e r ceve noieoft moton f aTRO a t i c elpa tci td i t e de i yhe i 1c % ei a e i d tc he i or nd her ouns ri pae n he vi ntar arng, ons t s se igp ei n r ijmcierle.S eUntdSae v W iet k 3 0F.d20 , 3(t Ci. 0 )(oiga e kn rl ay nl tv eif e i tts . n soc , 4 3 0 20 4h r20 3 n t mi e n c u t yca sf apoK fl gr g r ls o isc pin . o rma lsiy r ii e ades f t a to ) n Dockets.Justia.com Nur eBl ds ,Uni M a ge L. lns Food Se vieDie t rP.Scabe r Food Se vie s e oe t na r Coli , r c r oo r ry, r c M a ge Br k, a Ga1r mai ng de e na r oc nd û1 e ni f ndan s' Theç e i ng de e nt 'nn e i t t .' z G ma ni r f nda s' m d n he o nalc dgi ompli tbutnots cii ly nn an pe fcal med i t M o i n we e Of e Sele s Ofi e n he to r dc r l r , fc r Be t y J n Do #1( fst S h d e) J n Do # ( e iai nS afr, o n Do #1( f nl , a e e Of-ie c e ulr, a e e 2 M dc to tfe ) J h e Ofe st S h d lr, o nDo / ( re to a Ofke) a dJ l Do / ( re to l t r. ie c e ue) J h e / Cor cin l f r, n om e / Co r cina Ofke) 2 3 Them oton wass r e o de e n sDr M oor Nur eBlds Uni M a ge Coli , i e v d n f nda t . e, s e oe, t na r lns Food Se vceDie t Sc r ny,Food Ser ie M a ge Br ri r c or a be vc na r ock,a Ofk e Sele sonl Rei fwa nd f r lr y. le s a s r quese agans no de e lo e t d i t n- f ndan co r tona o fc r Lt Syke ,Sg .La ge Sg Fn me , t rec i l fi e s . s t r , t r r Br y, M e de3 a c . n., a x 4 a , nd c paj , Them oto a ac ompa ngm e o a i n nd c nyi m r ndum s oughtpr lm i r r le aboutt a pec s ei na y e if wo s t ofhi c tonsofco ne e t r t iton a de a te t nt Fo t al ge r t la i s ondii v m n : eala i nd nt l r a me . r he le d e a iton, Pli ifr ue t a or rdi al wi de e an sa t i Ga s a es' r E s uli antf eq ss n de s lo ng f nd t nd her ls ocit 'fom t a tng, as hg n ei g a yl lwf ln ei gwi o t on mala dic mi mal, p a tn we p n i d rn , n l a u tmp rn t u g ig i n n o ng ig ln ig a o s l n h ) o oh rc n rb nd , gv n bo u c ag s, t ras itmiain, r sme t, a dd n i g r t e o ta a g) ii g g s h r e g h e t,n i d to haa s n g n e y n i j c mp an f r g etq' Fo t alg dyd l e t e tl rame , an ifrq ssàzo d r o lit o ms, lc . r he le e l ekin d na te t ntPlitf e uet l r e q ' t a tDr)M o r s l arng f rP an if. .ob o d re )tepo tstg r t t a rpar h t : . o e hal ra e o litf . t e r e ld h s t ey ha c n e i ( r P an it').. rman n ij de .Th ss o l bean o d r oamo eq lfe d n it o o a litfls . e ii g nu s i h ud E) r e t r uai d e ts, r r l s cait An t o ti fo t ts e ils afl e au to o ( an ifs . .e il g pe ils. d o ban r m ha p cait ul v lain f Plitf ) . rmazi n ij sb f r stg r i plrf r d . . Plitf as r q e tdata se t aS s xISae nude eo e t e y s eqo me . .' an if lo e u se r n fr o use tt r ' Prs whe eDr M oo edoesnotpr de de t ls r i st i a e . ion r . r ovi n a e vce o nm t s 2Pli ifco itntyna al deenda si bot i vi la ofi alca iis antf nsse l mes 1 f nt n h ndi dua nd fci pacte . 3Thi peronwa o i nal mii ntfe a & e .'' s s s rgi ly sde iid s ç ad M 4Alt s p o ee e tfrPanltrb c med fndn s Panf s a pe rdi amoint a n ( 1hee e pl xcp o i ae e a ee a t. i l t p ae n to o me d ECF r No 1 )ha Id ne ( No. ) Co s q nl Panh dn ve b e on da ad fn a t . 4 t t e id ECF 30. n e ue t i a e r e nj ie s ee d n. y, 2 Pl i ifalege s ve a e m pl ofr t lai Pl n ifd d notlket wa de e antf l s e r l xn es e ai ton. aitf i i he y f ndan t Of e M e s ket hi i o ofde e nt Sgt La ge,SgtFn me ,a Ofk e Br o sc r ade po o m n nt f nda s . r . r r nd t r ay n J 21 201 W he Pli ifc le dt a oprae sofM e ssa e e s M e de une , 7. n a ntf ha lnge he ppr it nes ade' tt m nt, a dial wedPl i ift beta pore t a de ala nt e o sdet prs n a f le y s lo antf o ' ns td o r nt ppoi m nt ut i he i o nd a s l c r d Pli ifwih adi cplnm. i r c i On J nua y 1 2018, antf l ha ge a ntf t s i i y nfa ton. a r 0, Pl i iftoode hi cel d s l at ran ofi e s fe fc r poke r de yt hi ,a Pl i ifwa t n f s l c r ed wih t e t ni u l o m nd antf s he aley ha g t hr a e hg bodiy ha m.Al o,Pl i ifas e t t the i ç nsse l bengplce i s r ga i f my . l r s antf s rs ha s s it nty i co a d n eg e ton or c mp annga d fleyc r e 'wih u aca sfc to herngi no alwe t la l s o lii nl q as l hag d' t o t lsiiain ai s t lo d o e ke l i 1 s r to c l f s eg egai n e l or howe sorouti r c e ton. Pli ifalo c r sde e r a i antf s ompli t ts m eofli ans ha o ls pe s ronalpr ry wa m isng afe r t l ng fom s gr a i andt tsa fdoesno gi M m ope t s s i tr e umi r e eg ton ha t f t ve i o ma c nf r l ompli f ant onns . t Pl i ifdes rbe li dis tsaci n wih Dr M oor ste t e .AferM e de c ncel d antf c i s ls s ai f to t . e' r a m nt t a a le t tans r i J 201 Pl i ifs w ade a pr vi ri Se e be 2017pe Dr M obr ' he r po t n une 7, antf a nt l o de n pt m r r . es c ula i r ue t Thepr de r c ons t ton eq s. ovi r e omm e d Pli ifbes e by sa fa ahos t l nde antf en tf t pia (M CV' .Ano a s r e na M CV sw Plitf i No e e 2 7a dnoe t r we et G $ ' ) rlu g o t a anif n v mb r 01 n td hee i wo : wa st s 'PlitY s a Thefrt ywa b r -r acngt ej w a d i lni gmea y o %x' an i j w. s wa s y eb e l h a n mp a tn tl i plt s a t s ond wa wa by s ndi t e h down.Theor s ge r c a e , nd he ec y s a ng e t al ur on e omm e ndedi l s he e s d atco to - sn i t eteh-b tsi t a iulmaeyma n iS 'tej w.Bytetme . r si p in a dng h e t u ad h t t t tl y o fx'h a i h i oft M oton,Dr M oor ha s de Pl ntf t e h dt igt s pa a eviis Pli tf as e t he i . e d ml d ai ifs e t uil wo e r t st . a n if s rs t t h s n i h sc u e p i a dha no Gi e 't ej w.Plitf f rh rc mplist a Dr ha t e a dng a a s d an n s t t x d'h a f an if u te o an h t . . ' M o r r man l sd nitd s ies igh m t c a dt t&Dr M oo e i h ri gmo e(ij o e e i s l e ts e pt un l wie n ha : . r q s u t i ( n r sc B. Th ma itae u ec n u tda e i e tayh aigo M ac 1 2 8 Plitf, e gsrt j dg o d ce n v d nir e rn n rh , 01 . an if s ve a pds r ,a def nda sUni M a e r l one s nd e nt t nage Coli a Nlr eBl oe t tfed.Nonr lns nd zs eds esii d fn a t UriM a a e Dt a , lfe M e tl at Pr ciine CC IP' Br o h r, e e d n s l n g r mc n Quaiid n a He 1 a t o r QM ' ' o ks ie t h t 1 I Of erB.M uli ,SgtHal, ndDe a A s itntHubba d a s t sii d. sc lns . l a nt l ssa r l o e tfe s Pli iffl amoton t n nd a t c l i o t he i a as condm otont a ntf ied i o me t he oncuson f he arng nd e i o n n mo et a t we k a trt ehe rng OnM ac 21 2 8 tema itaej dg ,n e me d r h n wo e s fe h ai . rh , 01 ,h gsrt u e itr ala, g a e t s co m oton t n nd a a kno e d t fr tn i r nt d he e nd i o me nd c wl dge he is mende co pl nt6 d m ai OnAp i 1 20 8 t ma itaej d ealwe Plitf t eo po t lt t n ndt e rl 7, 1 ,he gsrt u g lo d an if h p rt iy o me h u c ompli a n.Theor rnot d Pli ifç ant gai de e a ntf t fl a Ame d Compl i a ng Adn may e n nde ant ddi m W ya tasapa t de e t ry f ndan a ale ng a a tona cai ofr tla i a i tt def nda s t nd l gi n ddii l l m ea iton gans he e nt f wihhol ng ac es t t Vigi aDe t ntofCoreci Gre ncePr e e ...' or t di c s o he r ni parme r tons iva oc dur . ' Th e d y ltro Ap 2 , 01 ,hema itaej g is dterp r a d r e a s ae n dl 0 2 8 t gsrt ud e sue h e o t n r c me ton f rt M oton, a dmut epa t so jce wih' t f te daype i ? e om nda i o he i n rod. li ri be td t l he oure n pl e n C. Th ma itae u g r c mme st t g a tt Mo ini p r.S e iial,he e gsrt j d e e o nd ha I rn he to n a t p cfc l t y ma itae u g r c mme dsg a tn t M oin o yGns f ra ir q e t t ec u toe tr g srt j d e e o n rn ig he to nl ç o a s t e u ss h o r t n e i 5De ol ssa t b r wa ltr on da ad fn a t nde tr dtec s. n Asitn Hu bad s ae j ie s ee d n a nee h ae 6Tha s meda , Dr Boat De alAs it ntHubbar Lt Sy s SgtFnr r SgtLar Tr t nt ta y . lye, nt ssa d, . ke , . me , . ge, eame Ofke Sxo , aigOfie L. ln, t eo S wad, a p rainOfie Bry Ofie Chlrs,n l r etn Hern fcr Mul sComslr o rsTrnsotto fcr a, fcr idesad i Ofke Me d weej ie Alo al e b tJn Do # ( dcto Safr weetr td Dee d nsLt l r a e r on d. s , lDo s u a e e 2 Me iain tfe) r emmae . fn a t . Syke ,SgtFq mer SgtLa ge Tr ame Ofie Se on,He rngOfie L. uli ,Couns l So r , s . r , . r , e t nt fc r xt ai fc r M lns eor wa ds Tr ns ttonOx ce Br y,Ofi rChidr s ,Ofke M e de ml Ofi rBe ly ener dt ca ea utt a porai r a fce l e s t r a , d fce nte t e he s bo wo weec lt o Aprl3,201 ls aer n i 8. 1S v rl ee a t h v be nj ie , e sn wav r o sr ie o e trda a per esn ete e ea d fnd ns a e e on d ben e t ies f e vc , r nee n p arc ic h r por a r ommendai De alAs it tHubbad tmel e e e t c eonM a 1 2018.On Jme 11 2018, e t nd ec ton. nt ssan r i y ntr d he as y 0, t , Par i Ad mswa s b t e frJ n Do # ( dc to Safr a dawav ro sr iewa is e t sme ti a a c s u si d o a e e 2 Me iain tfe) n mt ie f evc s su d he a d y Ad m W y tas wa j ie a dha no ye e e ue awav ro sr ie a. a at lo s on d n s t t x c td ie f evc . 4 P ei n r ijmcier l f op e e tt d fn n sDr M o r a dHu b r l r m rf sn r l ay n t tv ei t rv p he ee da t . o e n b adö fo e u ig mi e t p o i eo g igd n a te t n t E an if wll t slws ii pe dng' o r v d n on e tl r ame t o plitfl z e hi a ut s n i . i ' Th ma itaej d enoe t e ep rie tfcs e g srt u g td h s e t n a t: n . Dr M oor ha ar dy pe f r e t prm a y te t nto i n ofs ndi t e h. . e s lea r o m d he i r r a me pto a ng e t - Pli ifs yss ndi t t eh ha c us d m or pai a hmsno c r ced hi bies he antf a a ng he e f s a e e n nd t or e t s t o c nc w f a he ood. - Pl i ifs ntf trr ques f r st t prs de a de rm e i J nua y a Fd u r antf e o l e t o m o he ion nt l pa t nt n a r nd br a y 201 a ki f te t ntt d lt pan a c r thi bie s he c n che f 8, s ng or r a me o ul he i nd orec s t o a w ood,but de alsa fhavenotofe edaddii lte t ntors r i et n ei r t t pai orbie. nt t f fr tona r a me e v è o m lo ae he n t T eHedDetsfrh Vi iiDe at n o Corcin (VDOC' p rotdytl h a nito te r na p r t f ret s : g me o û ' up r l od ) i ' Dr M oor t no l rs ePl n if e e f a e r nc t i Pl i i slws t . e o onge e aitf, xc pt or n me ge y,mtl antc a uis a i tDr M oor a er ol d. gans . e r es ve Pl i ifs antf oughtçe r nc 'de a te t ntf rs l n,pai l gu sa a i biiy sme ge y' nt l r a me o wole nfl m nd n pa lt l t e tf o b fr fln t M oin, ndDe tlAsitn Hu b r d e dter t s o a o d eo e iig he to a n a ssa t b ad e me h e ue t nota e e g nc alhoug VDOC polc i l d pa n ors elng i isde i to of n m re y t h iy nc ude i w li n t fnii n ç m e ge de a te t e ' G r ncy nt l r am nt' e ' Pl i ifhasnotbe n alo antf e l wedt r t r t t o a s geo a M CV t be e o e u n o he r l ur n t o xnmi d a ne bout . ' t ep i o t s c n a yte t n o to o r- r n i t ej w. h an r he e o d r z amç t p in f eb e kng h a . P an ifrtsli pan lve a aç o to 1 5t re nmo t sa tr h ij r . ' litf ae l i e l t 1 u f 0'hite n h fe t e nu y s 7 St f oft prs sm e c lde rme hast d Pli ift tt m e ca de rm e a f he ion' di a pa t nt ol antf ha he di l pa t nt doe no pr de tea m e f de t li s s s t ovi r t nt or n a s ue . Plitf sEx ii Th e 9o t ee d n ir he rn CEx btT1 e ' i t Co s lain an if hbt r e m h vie ta y ai g hii l e' s he n uttp r l Re rt t ii t outi de a pr de s r c m e tons9o Se e be a N ove r po de a lng he sde nt l ovi r ' e om nda i m ptm r nd mbe 2017.l s ws notbl t tDr M oor i t a horz ng a ntf t r f r a .M s t fr t t ho , a y, ha . e s he ut ii ge or he e e r l o, he ls pr vi rnotd*li ifha ne v dic o ta pai a Suggetd e l to by E CVjf o de e antf d r e s omfr nd n nd ç se vauain M s or posi ene v r par' Theorls ge 9om M CV as notdPl ntf c iue felngpai sbl r e e i.' a m on lo e ai irs ontn d e l n i 8De a As itntHubba d wasno adefnda whent M otonf raTRO wa fl orwhe t ntl ssa r t e nt he i o s ed n he e ie tayh aigwa c n uce S etsi dd rn t e ie tayh ai a h db e on da ad fn a t vd nir e rn s o d td. h etse u ig he vd nir e rng nd a e nj ie s ee d n whent r po twasr c he e r e omme to wasfl Howe r s di note e t c et i a trt r por a ndain ed. ve , he d ntr he as mtl fe he e t nd rc e omme tonwa i ued. ndai s ss 5 t m ont lt rbutr c me wo hs a e e om nded d s ca i e ve to a t spoi ,' e ni ba e on s mxi l nt r n i ns t hi nt'm n ng s d no t cr lmsa spr s ntasofN o mber201 he icl t nce e e ve 7. I. I A. A diti cou'mus r viw étno a pa tofar ta r c std t t t e e vo ny r epor nd e omme to t wlih a ndain o lc p ryo j cs al imu t r v d isid p n e t e s ni wh nap ryr ie n w e d n eo a t b e t, t t s p o i e t n e e d n r a o ng e a t as s e vie c r d an w a g me ti a o j cin.2 U. C. 6 6b ()C) Or in v. o ns n 68 F.d4 , 7 e r u n n n b e to 8 S. j 3 ( )1( ; p a o J h o , 7 2 4 4 (t Ci.1 8 ) Thera o i gn e no b ea o aeo ln h b ti mus p o ieas d i 4h r 9 2 . e s n n e d t e lb r t r e gty, u t t r vd p csc r tonal t tpe mism e ni 'lappel t r vi w. Se se. , lt d Stt v.Ca e ,564 F. a i e ha r t n ngf u la e e e e asUrie a es rtr : 3d 3 , 30( t Ci. 0 9 .Ho v r X n v rv e i n t e uie wh n o j cinsc nc r 25 3 4h r 2 0 ) we e , o o e iw s o r q rd e b e to o en lga is a no f t is s Se pe. ,Or a 687F. a 47.Notbl X novorviw e l sues nd t acual sue . e g. pino, 2d t a y, e e i n t e ur dt nap ryma e g n r lo c n l o yo j cinst td n tdrc t c u t s o r q ie ç whe a t k s e e a r o cus r b e to ha o o ie t he o r t as e ii e o i tema itaej dg ' p o osdfn ig a dr c mme ains' JJ A o p cfc n'r n h gsrt u es r p e dn s n e o nd to . . '1 . d src c u t sas no r q rdt r ve a is whe n p ryo j cs S e ec.Th ma v itit o r i lo t e uie o e iw ny sue n o a t b e t. e . . , o s . A1 , 7 U. 1 0 1 ( 9 5 ; mb v Da i, 8F.d 1 8 2 0( t Ci.1 8 ) ' 4 4 S. 4 , 49 1 8 ) Ca v . v s 71 2 9 , 0 4h r 9 3 . n B. A p ei n r ijmcini c nsd rdç ne ta r i r rme yiv l igt ee rie rlmi ay n t to s o i ee l xr o dnay e d n o vn h xecs a o av r for a lngpo r wh c i t bea pl dtzl i (h )lmi dcru tn e 'wh c f e y a e cz i we, ih s o p i oly n t e i t ic msa c s ih e e ce dyd ma di 'Di: Ir e. d v Br m h o hM e Co .9 2 F. 8 2 81 (t Ci. la e n t' rx sa lLt . . e r ug d. m , 5 2d 0 , 1 4h r 1 9 )(uoigI sn tAi F eg tCo v C. Ai F eg t l c, 2F.d7 7, 0 (r Ci. 9 1 q tn n tn r r ih . . F. r r ih n .88 2 9 8 0 3 d r 1 8 :.Th mo n f rs c r le b a st ebld nt e tbls t ee nso ap ei n r 99 e va t o u h eif e r h t e o sa ih he lme t f r l a y r mi ijmcin: 1 t emo n ' lk lh o o s c e dngo t emeiso t ea to ;()t e 2 n t to () h va ts i eio d f u c e i n h rt f h cin 2 h ! lk l o do irpaa ehàm t temo n i pei n r ij n tv rle i d nid;3 ta te iei o fre rbl r o h va tf rlmiay nu cie eif s e e () h th h 6 baa c o e uiistpsi temo a tsfvo ; n ()t a a ijmcini i t ep bi itrs. ln e f q te i n h v n ' a r a d 4 h t n nt to s n h u lc n eet Witrv. tRe. f Co nclIc, 5 U.. , 0(0 8 . ne Na. sDe. u ten .5 5 S 7 2 2 0 ) P ei n r ijmcierle i v li p io c n iin t t n ro yd a , r l a y nt tv eif n ovng rs n o dto s l be ar wl rwn mi mus e e nof t rt nne s r t cor c t hn m t c tf rquie prlmi r ylel xtnd urhe ha cesay o re t he r he our mds e rs ei nay eit a dbetela titu i eme n n c sa yt c re t h t r ' 1 U. C. 3 26 a( ) A n h e s n r sv a s e e sr o o r c t a hn m. 8 S. j 6 ()2 . ' c t tG ve s t nta we gh t a a r e i our mus ç gi ubsa i l i t o ny dve s mpac o publcs f t o t ope a i ofa tn i a e y r he r tpn ci na j tc s tm c u e b t p ei nayrle a s al epe ttep icplso rmi lusie yse a s d y he r lmi r eif nd h lr s c h rn i e f i co t 'obs r dbewe n fdealc t a saeox cil.Ll;s eAli rv.Pa rc 569 miy' eve t e e r ours nd tt as Is e tze de ik, . F.d81 , 2( t Ci. 9 )(ç i welstldt tf d rlc u t d n to c p t er l o 2 2 81 4h r 1 78 $t s l et ha e ea o rs o o c u y h o e f I e s pe wad nso saep na i siuinsa d no st os pe vs saep io g '(n en l u r r e f tt e l n ttto nd o t it u r ie tt rs ns. 'itr a l q o inmak o te l.Ano d rg a tn ap ei n r ijmcinmu t tt t ra o u tto r s mitd) r e rn ig r l a y nt to s sae he e s ns mi wh iis e , p dt lysaeistr , ndd s dbetea ts r sri e o r q rdi y t su d s e kal tt t e ms a e c h ct) etan d r e uie n r ao a l d ti a wih u rfr n i ohe d c n s Fe . Ci P. ( )1 . e s n be eal nd t o t ee e cng t r o ume t. d R. v. 65d ( ) 11 1. Obeto weefldb Plitf ( Nos8 , 5, . oe( No . 3 1 7) jcins r ie y anif ECF . 5 9 )DrMo r ECF s 8 , ù 9, a UrtMa a e Coln , o S r ieDie t rS ab ny, o d S r ieM a a e Br l , n nd l n g r l s Fo d e vc r co c r e F o e vc n g r o k a d i i : Ofie S l r ( No. 4 .Th p risd no c alng fc lf i s I ta t yo j c fc r el s ECF 8 ) e a te o t h l e a ma mdng . nse d,he b e t e e t t ema itaej g ' lg l nayssu d rW itra ds g e to t a Dr M o r 'n De tl o h gsrt ud es e a a l i n e n e n u g si n h t . o ea d n a 1 . edge he As it tHubba d c i t te tPl i iforf iiaet tke ' nt1 Ia knowl ,t s sxn r onthue o r a antf acltt ha at me .0 c 9Inoet tDr Mo r' s c n o jcini u tmeya i n tc n iee t ha . oes e o d beto s ni l nd s o o sd rd. ! 'So o ema beiv Plitf i as o jcigt t Oe a'o teMoina t t alg drtlain 0 me n y le e anif s lo betn o he nil fh to s o he l e eaito ' e b c reto a sat Ev ni iwa ma eo i ac u t o dc nsn es ha o jcin ii o rue .Plitf y orcin l tf e f t s d r f o r c ul o tz uc n b eto ,ts ver ld anif f l t esa ih ir pa a eha m,af vor bl i a o equii ,o t publc' i e e ti t c e One ais o tbls re r bl r a a e mbalnce f tes r he i s ntr s n Ms ontxt' c l Pl ntf f ce i t Ee r a tofdici hl byprs n ofi i si bydei to çealatz i t s ns halenge ai if a s s hatçve y c s pl e io tcal s fniin r t i oy' n he e e t tirs n sdrcl t p io rmic nd t'Co l a v. o s 7 F.d1 1 ,1 1 (t Ci. 9 6,jeLe s ha t epo d ie t o rsne s o uc. cl n M ni, 3 3 3 0 3 7 4h r 1 9 ) e wi y ' r . v. tn No 0 - 6 , 0 U. DitLEXI 5 33 , t* 728 2 0 W L23 2 8 , t* ( N.. g 1 , 0 7 Vi , . 736 3 20 7 S. s. S 9 7 a 2 - , 0 7 o 6 5 7 a 9 D. J Au . 4 2 0 ) ('h a t ffl fleds i iayc ag sd e no isl voaeap io rsc nsi ina rg t.l Alo c u t çne c o ii as icpl r h r e o s ttef ilt rsne' o t o l ihs'. s , o rs t l ng n mt ' mus gi prs of i sG der ngi defr nc i t a i a e uto ofpolcesa pr tc st ti t ve ion fcal ç -a ng e e e n he dopton nd xec in wi ii nd acie ha n 7 l I pat s c n en , n asih mo iiai nt t ema itaej j ' s g e to s ul ri ' o c r s a d lg t dfc to o h gsrt ud es u g sin ho d e n ei r t t m .N e rhees ,Ia ptt r por a r c me ton be us net rt m lo ae he ve t l s do he e t nd e om ndai ca e ihe he ma itaej d e ss g e tdrle n rt wo dn o t ij n to atr t efndn so fcs gsrt u g ' u g se eif o he r ig f he n u cin le s h i ig f a t a c usonsofl nd oncl i aw. 1 Pl i ifstfc e l s w sa lkelhoo ofs ce so t m e isoft aci Sç r antf tfii nty ho i i d uc s n he rt he ton. ve al de e nt a gu whe he r tla i i pr ry pl a d.Re r e s Pl i ifse de e ofonf nda s r e t r ea iton s ope l e de ga dl s , antf vi nc : g igp i a dn t ina deiin ispr sn safi c a et t d fnd n k w hes i rd on an n udto l fce ce e e t ar h s ha a ee a t ne ufk e pana ddn t n t a d e si.S eEsel v. mbe 4 9U. 9 1 4 ( g 6 tic si i nd i ohig o d rs t e tle Gn l, 2 S. 7, 0 l 7 lds u sng d l rt id fee c t as ro me ia n e ) Plitf s fe sir p r b ehn m i hkpan ei ae n if rn e o eius dc l e d . an if u fr re a a l r f i i be rman a$ o to 1 'o t p i s aet i e mo t a trh sij r , esil n no e is t u f 0' n he an c l hde n nhs fe i nu y h tl c n t 7 a e u tl c e f o , ndme ia a dd n a saf aen twi igt a d e st e ec mj an s d q aey h w o d a d c l n e tl tfs r o l n o d rs h s o lit. l : Theeq te tp i Pl i ifsf vorasPl ntf i e ild t c ran de a team e t rt uii s i n antf a ai if s ntte o e ti ntl r t nt mde he Ei t Ame m e ,Dr M oo ei c t st hedoe notwa t pe s l pr vi t t gh h nd nt . r ndi a e he s nt o r onaly o de ha te t nt a t VD OC i silr po i ef t tr dng te t e .Thepublc r a me , nd he s tl es nsbl or ha ende r a m nt i t do e yha a i e es Gn m i m i ng c ti e f r nc i t or ry a s ur nl ng m ubt dl s n nt r t l ni zi our nt re e e n he de l nd ec e nni i o t ep io s se ' S e ec, a v. uz v, 0 F.d 8 2, 0 (t Ci. 0 2 .Ye,he f h rs n y tm. e . ..Be r Ka tk 3 5 3 0 8 5 8h r 2 0 ) t t ' publc a s ha a i e es i e urng sae ofk il co por wiht Ei ht Am e m e a i i lo s n nt r t n ns i t t l a s m t t he g h nd nt nd n t fmdst tmaybebe trs ntt mii t ,a nott c he l ha te pe o tga e nd o ompe a e Ei h Amendme c am s ns t , ght nt l i . ter u pne t r n e e t p ee v itr l r e a ddsil a dt manani ttto l e t i ' Hu o v h ij d n ée e d d o r sre nena o d r n icpi n o iti nsiuina s clt ' dsn . ne r y. Mc iin 5 3U..1 7(9 2 .I i n t ymeec a c t t anifi h u e a Re Ono SaeP io a a M l a , 0 S , 1 9 ) t s o b r h n e ha Plitf s o sd t d in tt rsn s l Le ls i ae;hehasco m itd s rousdici i r i tonsa e bie i cabl be o slkefoodi ve- nm t m te ei s plna y ngaci nd xhi td nka t e havir i l ng hscl.Futemoe cnme n i sgrgto ino d e da ay iaa dsg i n hrsi irlt nt i el rhr r,o f metn e eain s t eme n tpcl n int t adhp n eqi o ka o teo dn r i ie t o p io l e Se. ..S n i. v. n e251 U.. 7 , 8 , 6 8 ( 9 5.Plitf d e h r iay ncd ns f rsn i . e eg- a dn Co n r 5 S 4 2 4 4 48 - 7 1 9 ) anlf o s f no ha aco tt inalrghtt bei ar r td wihl a pa tculrprs See e. .M e hum v. nw 427U. t ve nsiuto i o nc ce ae t n ny rl a ion. . g. ac Fa S. 21 , 232 (9 6 .Plitf' rq etfra o d rg n rl p e ni sc t saffo tuc ighi 5 2 -4 1 7 ) anifs e u s o n r e e eal rve t e miy tf rm o hn m, y ng R nde i 'hi i pe tng hi malwa ni oror rnghi t co y,c r ngdicplna yi r ci ,or hi rng' m ns ci s i, r ng de i m o mpl ha gi s i i r nfa tons ' rj ci g iv n ef r i smpyu wok bl a dc n o b G arwl da . Se . ..1 U. C. 3,6a() eet re a c oms s i l n r a e n a n t e ç ro y rwn' e eg, 8 S. j 6 ()2 . ng n ' 2 M o eo ,a s ces o t Sir parbl hn m'i r c r hi de altea e ,notas ultvef rof r ver ny uc s n he tre a e r ' nquiy oncens s nt r % nt pec ai ea rt laton,a t a ompa ng or s ul r me t thn m. eai i nd he cc nyi der ho d e dy ha r 8 Ifndt tPl ntf ha s ife W i e i a ton t t r a o no e i t r po ta i ha ai if s ats d ntr n ddii o he e s ns t d n he e r nd rc e omm e ton. nda i Thepa tes conc r wih t s ri ' e n t he ugge t r dy wa r n sm odiyi ist nns The sed eme ra t f ng t e . Ei h Ame m e r quie sa foft VDOC t pr vi de a team e , team e by a ght nd nt e r s t f he o o de nt l r t nt not r t nt s c fcpr vi r Thi c to i e de e by Pl i ifso te t e hit r a t VDOC pe ii o de . s ondii n s vi nc d antf wn r am nt so y s he ha r pe t dl r nde ed de a ca evi pr de so he t n Dr M oo e. s e ae y e r nt l r a ovi r t r ha . r Pl ntf sExhi tThr es ai if bi e howst ti wa Dr M oor who hadt a hort t r f r ha t s . e he ut iy o e e Pl i ift t or lslgeon a M CV ,1 an dDe a As itntHu r t tfe t ts has antf o he a tr t 1 nt l ssa bba d esii d ha he ar nge te t ntwih out i pr de s The et de e nt ,i t rofi i ca cte , ra d r a me t sde ovi r . s wo f nda s n hei fcal pa ii s h vet ea to yt gv Plitf ter me yhes e s Goo ti fo ' ç aiidd nit)o a h uh dt o ie an if h e d e k :G b an ' m'a ku lfe e tsg r t r o a s cait a1 1 e l to o P litf s . .e ii gij re 'beo ed r e g lt rl pe ils' : 1 vauain f an if ) . rman n nu i s' fr ç d ri he ' 51 o ng p t u g r t t a rparPlitfls . . e iigij re . os s r ey ha c n e i an it') . r mann n u is' ' De e nt Coli ,Sc r ny,Sele s a Br k a gtet s f nda s lns a be l r , nd oc r z he ugge t e t bl mle i sed quia e i f s o eb o da dç n s a i iiua wh n t e p o el beo et eCo rl 'De t l ssa t v r r a n ç dl) n ndvd l o p y t r p ry f r h u t:' n a Asitn bi j Hu b r I i no n c s ayt r s l tero j cin sa iga d pes na j rs ito b ad. t s t e e sr o e ove h i b e to , tndn n , ro lu idcin c nc r i De tl ssa tHu bad 1b le e a t ep e e t t tt p ei lr ijmcin o enng n a As itn b r . eiv , t h r sn ,ha he rlmhay n t to c bena r y t ior d t Dr M o e onl Itus t tDr M oo ewilc an rowl al e o . or y; r t ha . r l ompl a i s t y nd s ue he r f a ,a It s t tt VDOC,vi isç hn o J DoeOf- ie Sche e 'and e en'l nd nzt ha he a t vo r ane fst dul r' Tr ns rai n Of e s wile f c ae Dr M oor sr f ra lkei woul a ot rmedia a po tto fc r , l f e m t . e' e e r l i t d ny he cl 1 rhus Ia notpe s dedby Dr M o r' o j cina dt u sa tae p ofrta h i t bet dr c 1f m r ua . oes be to n ms b tnitd r fe h t e s ma l o ie t Plitf' de a c r wih outi pr de s Dr M oor alo a gue t tt tmonyaboutAda W ya tsalged an ifs ntl a e t sde ovi r . . e s r s ha esi m t' le dieci t tDr M uor s dno l rtea non- me ge de alne s dbee ude a hea s y.Howe r r tve ha . e houl onge r t e r nt nt eds houl xcl d s r a ve , 1ma no sl rl rj c s c tsi n whe c n iei ap ei n r ij n to meeyb c uei, rue d . y t l iy ee t u h etmo y n o sd rng rl ay nu cin rl e a s taa n o mma mi ma iamisbea asbsq ettil S eUnv o Te v. me sh 4 U.. 9 3 5(98)C( qbe nd sil t u eun ra. e i. f x. Ca nic, 51 S 3 0,9 1 1 A1 p el n r ijmcini c so rl pa tdo t bai o p o e ue t t r ls fr l nde d nc ta i ls rlmiay nt to s u tmai n e n he ss f r c d r sha ae e s o ma a vie e h ts es y c mplt ta i atil ntemeis'. o ee h n n ra o h rt.) ' rfra i iso d n r c ms o b sn s .2 Se w etv. ki , U S. 2 5 ( 9 8 ( tng eerl n t r i ay o e f u ie s1 e s At ns 487 4 , 4 1 8 ) noi . me ia p o e so l a t e c lro saelw whe c n rde t te tp io r) d c l r f sinas d md r oo f tt a n o ta d o r a rs nes. Ad iin l , rti t ea to yt mo iyt eprlmiayij n to t ef c t t epu p s dto al 1 ean h uh dt o df h ei n r n u cin o fe mae h r o e y unde l ngt r i f Se e. ,M ovi SvseI .v. ryi he ele . ee g. e . nc M i a i Audi Diti .71 F. nne pols o srbs, 7 2d 4 7 4 0(t Ci.1 8 )(ttn t a mo iiainsc nb ma ei l h o s bs q e tc a g s 2 , 3 8h r 9 3 sai g h t d fc to a e d n i t f u e u n h n e g i t fcso t 1w o f ra yohe g o r a o ) n he a t r he a r o n t r o d e s n . l V. Fo t f r g igr a o ,h p ris o j cin aeOVERRULED;h r p r a d r he o e on e s ns t e a t ' b e to s r e te e o t n rc mme d to i ADOPTED; n PlitY smoin frprl nayijmcier le i e o n ain s a d an i to o ei r n t tv eif s mi GR ANTED i pa t n r. Dr M oor i hi ofi i c pa iy asPl ntf ' de ita Re Ozi S a ePrs s l . e, n s fcal a ct ai ifs nts t d lon t t ion, hal wihi t n da r f rPli ift t or ls geo a M CV who e l t Pli ifi Nove be t n e ys e e a ntf o he a ur n t vauaed antf n m r 201 f a e ua i a utli pai a i biiyt c w f a t ti t bec 7 or n val ton bo ls n nd na lt o he ood nd ha s o omplt d ee wihi t ryda .l t tpe s n c nno c plt t e ua i wihi t ry da ,t r f r l t n hit ys f ha r o a t om e e he val ton t n hit ys he e era mus bem a t a sm ia pr e sona i t s mepr c ie gr up f t te l to t be t de o i l r of s i l n he n a tc o or ha vaua i n o c ompl t d wihi tlry da . I t tpr tc g oup c nnotc m pl t t e l ton wihi t ry e e t n lit ys f ha aci e r n o ee he va uai t n hit : da ,t r f n'lmus bem a t asmia pr f so lt c ys he e e a t de o i lr o es i na o ompl t t te l ton wihi t ry e e ha vaua i t n hit da . ys ENTER:Thi X * s d yo J n , 01 . a f u e2 8 ' @ . w' ' ' Y % ' Se rUnie St t sDititJ e ni t d a e src udg 1 Couns f Uni M ana L. Coli ,Food Se vieDie o P.Scaber Food Ser ieM ana rBr 2 el or t ger lns r c rctr r ry, vc ge ock, a Ofke Selr lt re e eda a a a eonbe fofDe alAs itntHubba dandTr ns t in Oo ce nd f r le s a e ntr n ppe r nc hal nt ssa r a porato r Br y.Ti ,c e f De alAs itntHubba dandTr ns tton Ofke Br wilr ceveacua notc oft a l ouns l or nt ssa us r a pora i f r ay l e i t l ie he pei nayijmcin.Se . ..Fe . Ci. 6 ()2 . rl r nt to e eg. d R. v P. 5 d() mi 1 0
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
