Smith v. Clarke, No. 7:2017cv00335 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2017)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/18/2017. (tvt)

Download PDF

clE- s OFFIE u. . 3% C s DI ATROANQKQ, VA rl (D ' Lc JUL 12 2 1 g? I TH E U M TED STA TE S D I N STR I CO U R T CT FO R T H E W ESTERN D I STR I T O F V I G I I C R N A R O A N O K E D I SI N W O Lm Y W A YN E SM I , TH Pe ii ne , tto r V. H AROLD W .CLARK E, R espondent . ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) JULI C A BY: D CASE NO.7: 17CV00335 M EM ORANDUM OPI ON M By Ho Gln E. nr d : n. e Co a Unie St esDititJudge td at src La r W a Smih,a Vigi a i t pr e ng pr K ,fld t saci n asa peii ry yne t r ni nma e oce di o ie hi to tton . f ram i o h be sc r sun e 28U. C.j2 4. Upo rv e o S t ss b sin, h o t f a a opu d r S. 25 n e iw f mih' u miso t e c ur c n ld st ti mus b s mmaiyd s se wih u p eu iea as c e sv p tto . o t o cu e ha t t e u rl imis d t o t rj dc s u c si e ei n i S t c aln e t v ldt o h sc n i e n u d raJ ne20 1j d me to teLe mi h le g s he ai i f i o fn me t n e u h y 1 u g n fh e Cot y Cic t Co tunde whi h Sm ih wa c ced of s c mt r ui ur r c t s onvi t e ond de e m tr r a r lt d gr e zde nd ea e o f ns sa s nt nce t a t a of53 ye r i prs Hi die ta al a s eq ntsa e fe e nd e e d o ot l a s n ion. s r c ppe s nd ubs ue tt ha a c puspr ee ngswe et ucc s f . be s or oc di r ms e s ul l 201 Smihfld apeii frawrto ha sc pusunde 28U. C.j2254i t s n 4, t ie tton o i f bea or r S. n hi co t c l ngi t s s m e c ur , hale ng he e n onvi t o . The co tr f r d t r s c i ns ur e er e he e ponde ' m oton t di m i s nt s i o s s t t Unie Stt M ag sr t J o he t d a es itae udge who is d a Re ta Re m me ton fnd ng t t , s ue por nd co ndai i i ha Smih was note il t rle t r j2254. The c trviwe t Re ta Smih' t ntted o eif mde our e e d he por nd t s o j cin t rt a d is d a fna o d r a o tn t e Re r a t o n o o t e c u t b e to s heeo n sue i l r e d p ig h po t s he piin f h o r, Smith v. Clarke Doc. 2 gr ntng t m o i t di m i s a de ng ha a r le . Sm ih v. i . V i g zi D e tofC o r , a i he ton o s s , nd nyi be s e i f t D r . r ila p' r. No.7:4CV00686,201 W L 972742 ( . Va M a .4,201 ) ado i Smih v.Di.Viai a 1 6 W D. . r 6 , ptna t re r ni De to Co , . 1 p' f m No 7:4CV0 68 2 6W L 9 0 6 ( . Va 2 6 , p e l imis d 6 7 F. 0 6, 01 5 9 4 W D. . 01 ) a p a d s s e , 5 Ap x 1 7( t Ci. 01 ) p' 7 4h r 2 6 . Dockets.Justia.com . S t sg e a d d td hs c re t j2 5 pei o o J ne 2 ,2 7,a d te c u t mi in d n ae i u rn 2 4 t in n u 2 01 n h o r h t r c i d a doc t i on J y 1 201 Smih s ksha sr le ba e o t s alegai ns e e ve nd keed t ul 7, 7. t ee bea e if s d n he e l to : t e tilc u tg v c nsiuin l d f ciej r i t cins t e d fns r q e td b twa h ra o r a e o ttto al ee tv u y nsnzto ; h ee e e u se u s y d ne tsig f rg n ho r sd eo t fr nm a d o S t sfr am ij r ;t c u t re e id etn o u s t e i u n he ie r n n mi o e r nu y he o r er d h' i rf sngt a mi it e i e c ata s rp o v d oe d n et j r ve d d rn tila n e u i o d t n o v d n e rn cit f i e vie c he u y iwe u ig ra; nd ti co ms ' f itr t r s t s i s was de e ve pe f m a e. Sm ih ofe s no r s n ral t els a lle o aie he e s ues f di ror nc t fr ea o t thewasprve e fom r sng t ecli i hi prorj2254peii a t c tfnds ha e ntd r aii hes ams n s i tton, nd he our no s h r as The ef r ,t c tc ude t tSm ih' pe ii i a s ond or s e sve uc e on. r o e he our oncl s ha t s tton s ec ucc s i One. Pt s a tt 2 U. C.j 2 4 09,a fd rld src c u tma c n i r a s c n o l u n o 8 S. r 24 e e a itit o r y o sde e o d r s e svej2254peii lkeSmih' c rnts s i onl i t peii rscurss cfc ucc s i tton,i t s ure ubmison, y f he ttone e e pe i c ri a i n fom t Unie Stt Cour ofAppe sf t Fo t Cic tt tt ca msi t e tfc to r he t d a es t al or he urh r ui ha he li n he peiin me tc ran c ei s tf rh i j2 4 ( )3 . Be a s S t d e no d mo srt t a t o e e ti dtra e o t n 2 4 b ( ) c u e mi o s t e n tae h t t h he hm o tie s c c rikain,t c u tmus ds s t e p tto wih utp eudc a s b an d u h e t to he o r f t imis h eiin t o rj ie s s e s ve. ucc s i The Cl r i die t d t s nd co e of t s m e o a lm opi on a ac ompa ng ek s r ce o e pis hi m r nd l ni nd c nyi o de t Sm ih. r ro t ENTER:Thi t s da ofJ y, 7. y ul 201 U nie St t sD i t i tJ t d a e sr c udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.