Manning v. Virginia Dept. of Corrections, et al, No. 7:2017cv00103 - Document 39 (W.D. Va. 2018)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 2/5/2018. (slt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CL ERK: OFFI U,. ST COURS CE S DI . AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED FE 25 2 1 B 28 FRTVWETSAITITOTCGRA ::ICU l m ITIUIEETDSDSRC I U T YLaqv C O H NTDR TS C IVR II J A.. L? N E S N ER F O N UZ y .D RO AN O K E DIW SIO N D O UG LA S R .M AN NING , Pl ntf , ai if V. W ARD EN LA RRY T .ED M O NDS, D ef endant . ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) CASE NO.7:7CV001 1 03 M EM ORANDUM OPI ON NI By:Hon.GlnE.Conr e ad Se orUnie St e DititJudge ni td ats src ied hi vi i s i D ougl R.M anni a Vigi a i at pr as ng, r ni nm e oceedi pr K ,fl t s ci l rght acton ng o . u r42U. C.j1 al ngta prs n ofcil ha de e hi a c st lg maeil. nde S. 983, legi h t io fi as ve nid m c es o e al tras A fe r vi w of t r c d,t c tc l de t tt de e a ' m o i t dim i s m us b tr e e he e or he our onc u s ha he f nd nts ton o s s t e gr e i par and deni i par. ant d n t ed n t 1 Backgr . ound M a ni i i aceae a Dil Core i lCe e (G lwyn',sr i aprs n ng s nc r rtd t l wyn rctona ntr G l ' e vng ion Di ) sntnc i t iut yoft Vigi aDe t nto Core ton (ç e e e n he sod he r ni parme f rci s G VDOC') Afe h tldt s '. tr e ie hi ci lx i i t Unied St es D it ct Cour f t Easer D it i of V i ni t Court vi acton n he t at sri t or he t n s rct rgi a, he k n ed d f c e i s i hi c ot e i i nc e n s ompl i t a die t d hi E o pr vi s ci a we s't t e a n nd r c e m ç o de pe fc ns r ' o hr e t q s i : :1 W ho a e t i vi l w ho vi a e your c ns iuto lr g s ue tons : . r he ndi dua s ol t d o tt i na i ht ? How di d t s i viuas vi a e yo c nsiuto rg s Spe iy t f cs upo whih y?u r l t he e ndi d l olt ur o tt inal iht? c f he a t n c ey o s ppor t sa l ga i 3. W ha ha m ha you s f r d f o t a to oft s i vi ual? ' u t hi le ton. t r ve uf e e r m he c i ns he e ndi d s ' Or r12,ECFNo.2.M a ni t n s mitdaj1 f m t tna dt VDOC,Dil n, de n ng he pb te 983 or ha me he lwy $ Manning v. Virginia Dept. of Corrections, et al Doc. 39 and W ar Edm ondsas defendant of er s e descrpton ofhi cl m s,and i por ed by den s, f ed om ii s ai ncor at r er ef ence num er atached exhi t as f ualsuppor. The Cour t n tans er ed t cas ous t bis act t t he r f r he e ' e,becaus D il yn i l t i t W eser Dit i . her e lw s oca ed n he t n srct Dockets.Justia.com Li r ly c tue M a ng' s i sons pr s nt t f l w i s que e of e nt be a l onsr d, nni s ubm s i e e he olo ng e nc ve s rltd t hi j1 cams1 I Ma 201 i a i i n unr ae t te deend nt i t s eae o s 983 li . n y 5, n n ncde t eltd o h f a s n hi at y c e M a nig s f ed a ij y t t r uie s g r a d lf hi Gnonam bul or and as, n n ufer n nur ha eq rd urey n et m t c i d i a whe lhar' Co . 3, ECF No. onfne n ec i. ' mpl He ha alo be n di gn e w ih s s e a os d t Gs N oss,degener i l barand cer cals ne and dic dieas wih s Gpondyl i atve um vi pi s s e, t evere sci i t atca hat . i a chr c condii wih daiy consit acut pai ul f i s oni ton t l s ent e nf unctonal lm ii s pt s' I i tng ym om -' d. W he he a rve a D il i 201 he ha be n pr s rbe 800 m g.ofNeu on i f pai A n r i d t lwyn n 6, d e e ci d r tn or n. doc ora D il r duc d t do a oft sm e c ton t 1 m g X 3 'a a s pr s r be : t t lwyn e e he s ge hi di a i o 1 300 ' nd l o e c i d ç a l m g.ofel le ...f acut pai ' 1 M anni di notGnd t sm edi i com bi i t ow evil or e n-' d. ng d hi caton naton o beasefe tveastehi rdosgeofNe o i a fldç n rqu ts a c ant f fci h ghe a urntn nd ie G y e esgz nd ompli s or ma hel ' l at4. p-' d. AtDil y M a n wa a sgne t a h i ar f par e vi a or a a s h,he l n, nni g s s i d o ousng ea or ol ol t s nd s uc w wasno alo e t g t t l w lbr r t c uc l ga r s a c t l w d o o o he a i a y o ond t e l e e r h.H e w a a s notpe te t s lo nuit d o ore lw j nal oroh rlga assa ema l fo o sdeve s Howe r he was d r a our s te e l sitnc nuas rm uti ndor. ve , pe m itd t a di s i wrte r que t f c pi s o s c fc m a e i s f om t l w r te o, nd d, ubm t it n e s s or o e f pe ii t ral r he a lbr r a ha c t d t ma c tde i i i hi pl di . l Fe r r 201 M a ng a k d i a y nd s ie o ny our c s ons n s ea ngs n b ua y 6, nni s e . f a s a e ha a c pus f r ,bu waspr vi e a f d r lh be sf m i t a A m .Co pl 1 , or t t be s or om t o d d e e a a a or ns e d. m .6 1Dee d n Ed n sc ne d ta Ma nn sa n e c mplit h ul b ds se wi o t rj dc fn a t mo d o tn s h t n ig' me d d o an s o d e imisd t u peu ie h f fii t c y wihRul 2oft Fed r lRulsofCi lPr e e, c r uie t c or alng o ompl t e he e a e vi oc dur whih eq rs he omplitt povi ta an o r de ç so t n pansae n o tecam s o n ta teped ri e t ldt rl f'Fe . Ci. 2a() Ths h r a d li ttme t f h li h wig h th la e s nie o ei . d R. v P. ()2 . i t e' p itswela e Dept teEmtr Ditit u g ' od rt po ies eii fcsa o t ahcam, n igs on i ltk n. s i h sen src jd es re o rvd p cfc at b u e c li Ma nn ' e a e dc m nde omplitofe sno c pees que eoft e nt a is . Hi rla eon hi atc e t t povi an fr om lt e nc he ve s t sue s einc s ta hm ns o r de s ch deaisdoe notc u tl s ompl wih t mand t i Rul 8t tt c y t he ae n e ha he ompl ntis l mus saet cl m pli y a ai tef t tt he ai anl nd çh wl)ta teped ri e tldt rl f'I .AsMa nn i atn wi o tc u slh Fe e, h c uth s t o h t h la e s nie o ei . d s t e' n ig s cig t u o n e, o v rte o r œ h lbe al c tu d hi s i r ly onsr e s ubmison a a whol t c tu a s may oft r e tf t he ha prvi d i si s s e o onsrct um r he elvan acs s o de n s ppor of.i cams The eor t c r doe notfnd iap opraet dim ist a ton me ey f hi fiur t u t h s li . r f e,he ou t s i t pr it o s s he ci r l or s al e o pr det efcsi t ame dcompl nt ovi hes a t n he nde ai . 2 ECF No. 5. O n M >r h 1 ,M an ng fl d r qu s s a ki t lbr r saf f :i o m a i n a t 2 c 5 ni ie e e t s ng he i a y t f or nf r to bou ç he dif r n ki l fij n to s(n qh w t tl, th saueo l tto so fl gaEtt ' l t f e e t ndso nu cin a d o o 5e' ç e ttt f i ain n ii 't mi n sae . ha a , a E t t ha a ' f m i t a o t f de al f m pr vi us y pr de t o < vi be s' t a e be s' or ns e d f he e r or ' s e o l ovi d, w t l ci ij ton ( r nc 'f ms t Etndad moin f mll'a t lor pa pai gi) nunci Emege yl' or , wo t a r to or s,' nd wo t ma u rs sc s f f mlj' l a 1 - Hedi no rc i a fr ,ohe t nt fdeal be son Ar nd or s. d. t 920. ' d t e eve ny oms t r ha he e r ha a e. ou t s metme M y ngas rquesdGi o peti ngt ta fr(si d sc iy lvel vs he a i , nni lo e se G nf rani o rnse a sgne e urt e s . m e c l c ndii , c a sfc ton of m e c ly di a e prs r ,' a i or a i a t di a o tons' l s i a i ' di a l s bl d ione s' nd nf m ton bou G rs n rme ial ds be poe to fo p tn ils ro srs o ij r ' I .a 21 Th G io e dc l ia ld r tcin r m oe ta eiu ik f nuy. d t . e p y ' m at i spr ded t o w eeksl eri r ponset t sr eral ovi w at n es o hi eques wer acçor ng t M anni (vel t e, di o ng, l ' y e sve a o y (onc r d) i ol ay c va i nd nl c ene nv untr ommime t' 1 a 21 Oterpatcul lg t n. d. t . h ' ri ar e al m a e i sM a ng r q t d w e e nota l bl i t D il l w lbr r .3 S a fs esed t a t ral nni e uese r vaia e n he lwyn a i a y t f ugg t h t he addr r ess eques sf s m at i st t i tt i ator t or uch er al o he ns iutonal t ney. On Mac 21 201 Ma ng Gld a ç mege y me c ij ton' a d G 'i rh , 6, nni e n s r nc dial nunci ' n TRO' n e Buc ngha Cou y Cic tCo t Co pl 2- ECF N o.1 The Co tCl r di no of e a ki m nt r ui ur . m . 3, . ur e k d t f r ny s ts a t r r s ns t M an ng' r que t f r co es of f de a r e or t hi que tons a if c o y e po e o ni s e s o pi e r l ul s o s si r di a pr si dat and ot i or aton about hi case. On M ay 16,2016,M anni egar ng oces ng e her nf m i s ng a s Gl d i hi Buc ngha Cou y c ur c s a E e tfe r pon e t c r sa t m ptt t a t l o e n s ki m nt o t a e ç rii d es s o ou t te c o hw r pr es ig cai . Jza 9. oc sn l m ' # . t ' 2Th ctto sotea nddc mpan i ti o iinsaetep g n mb rs asg e b tec uts e i in t h me e o litn hs pno tt h a e u et) sin d y h o r' a e e toni c e flng pr a t ECF N o.5 whi h i cl sM a ng' e hi t . l c r c as ii ogr m o , c n ude nni s x bis Thes u vaia e matral M a n r q td i l d: 'U . D e t ofJ tc Law En o c m e e na lbl ei s nnig e uese ncude C S. p . usie C f r e nt Asitn eAd nsrto Co e du o Mo e Corcin lLe ilt n a d Sa d rs -z e .1 7 )a d ssa c miitain mp n im f d l re t a gsai n tn ad - f d d 9 5 n o o Ri t o Ofe d r,Sa d r 26 (9 37 Am.Co l 2 ,ECF No 5 a a 1 7 Unv ri o Chc e La ghs f fn es tn ad - 1 7 )' mp. 5 . ; nd 9 5 iesw f ia o w Re e a tcec ld ufheRi t ofPrs r t M e c Car a t I plcai f rD rg De nde Prs e s viw ril ale r' ghs ione s o dial e nd he m i tons o u pe nt ion r a dP er l tie s'J.a 2 .Wh nMa nn ak dfrac p o teAmeia swi Dia it sAc CADA', n rti Dean e, #.t 8 e n ig s e o o y fh a ' r n t sbli t c h ie ' ) 4 U. C. 1 0 - 2 3 safp o ie h m wi o l ac v rp g f r h saue 2 S. j 21 1 1 21 , tf r vd d i t ny o e a e o t e ttt . h Atsom e poi ,M anni fl a r nt ng ied eques t m eetw ih an i tt i ator atDil yn. to t nsiutonal t ney lw He r c i d a unda e S nsiuto Ato ne Re ei ' ad s n t t hi r qu t had be n e e ve n t d s tt i nal t r y c pt' vi i g ha s e es l e r ved and t the woul be nott when t i tt i ator ar ved. A m .Com pl 22, ecei ha d iied he nsiutonal t ney ri . ECF N o.5. Therecei al pr ded a nam e and addr w her M anni coul w rt diecty t pt so ovi ess e ng d ie r l o t atr y i hene de ç n lg a ssa e. 1 (mphassi orgi l. Ma ng me he tone f e d t t e al sitnc ' d. e ume ' i n i na) nni t 4 w ih an i tt i a t ney on t occasi i t s i of2016. t ns iutonal tor wo ons n he pr ng J 0n M a 20,201 ,M a ng w r e a r ue tt t 1 w lb a y s a f s a i t the co d y 6 nni ot eq s o he a i r r t f , t tng ha ul notdo necess y r ear wihoutacces ng t l lbr y and compl ni t t ator ar es ch t si he aw i ar ai ng hat wo t ney viis ha no sf e ty hepe hi J a 29. A 1w lbrr ofcilfr r e o o st d t ulcinl l d m. A t a i ay fi a o wa d d ne f M anni sr ng' eques st an adm i s r or M r Oat ,as ng hi t ar ange f M anni t access t o nitat , . es ki m o r or ng o t lw lbr y hi sel ort ot he a i ar m f o herwie hel hi obt n t m at i s he needed. I Oat wr e s p m ai he eral d. es ot ba k t M a ng,as ng f pa tc ar a ut wha hi ne ds we e. 1 a 30. On M a 27, c o nni ki or ri ul s bo t s e r d. t y Ma ngrs e t thene de t dorsarhf t l msfrci na a cvic s s(ha he nni epond d ha e d o ee c ort ai o rmi l nd i l a e t t c was curnty atmptngt tl.'1 a 31 Oaesr po dt talw cekwo dmetwih ) re l te i o ie' d. t . t es nde ha a lr ul e t M an ng t a r s hi c e ns I ni o dd e s s onc r . d. l Jn , n igrq etdaP io e S l-ll Ltg t nMa u l n wa tl ta h n u e Ma nn eu se rsnr eflep t ai n a a d s od h t e i o had been s chedul t see t i tt i ed o he ns iutonal ator t ney, who w oul brng t r d i hç eques ed m at i . t eral W hen M anni s l tt i Ator Thom as on Sept ng aw ns iutonal t ney ember 8,2016,Thom as s d Ghe was ai i no ma a r ,s i hedin' e n kno wha aPrs he Se fHep M a lwasa i hedi he t de wa e ad d t ve w t io r l l nua nd f d c d tgi i t E nni ) b ca e he do tg tri re frbuyi b ouln' ve t o Ma ng e us n' e embus d o ng ooksorma ng ki 4 Among ot r t i , t i tm tonalatr y wr e a ltert M a ng> ti at n y as n f a he h ngs he nsi i to ne ot et o nni s ral tor e kig or G omplt c ofhi c i ialfl. 1 a 3 M a ng idiae ,howe r t tt tilat ne di no s ndhi c ee opy s rm n 5e' d. t 4. nni n c ts ' ve ,ha he ra tor y d t e s fl a dh dKeue t po ieefciemssa c t (i d rn hstil:I. i n a rfsd o rvd fet sitn e o hm) u ig i r . d e v a' 4 copi oft m t gi 'aw ay. I at7. Thom as as M anni t expl n hi l pr em and es he o ve' d. ked ng o ai s egal obl t na vie hi ç veup, 'lne rwi ' l he d sd m,l gi youlll ve n- d. ' M anni f l an i onnalcom pl nton Sept m ber8,2016,s tng: ng ied nf ai e ti I i e ietfo myiiilrq etd td 52 -6 In e acs t te t s vd n rm nta e u s ae -01 , e d ces o h t s n e s r t do m e nl ul r s a c f l g c e pe ng a t be ool ec s a y o a ngf e e r h or e al as s ndi nd o s it M y i talneed r ubm ted. nii eques w as s t t Oper i M anager,who t t ent o he atons hen r pea e m y ne d a f wa de t s t M r Oa e .A s you c n c e ry s e M r e td e nd or r d hi o . t s a la l e , . Oa es i no a e t c pr he d be a e he s tm e hi r tng a t a m it l t s t bl o om e n c us en s ou i nd r ns ta s i on 5- 6 as ng w hatdo 1need? 5lp 24-1 ki 27-16 1 s t s e r ent he am eques back t t o hi ,he di r st pr blm ba k t M r .Ha s a t s c r e go on a o m ve t he o e c o s ni nd hi icl es nd n. M r Hanis di send a Li ar A i t see m e i M r Huddl t s of i and he s. d br y d o n . es on' fce . ddbigaGe reo La J u la dsirhth wa tl b Mr. ri t i rn ogtwn w o ma n adta e s od y s Hars o s w i t m e t pi a c s a brng i b k an t ts i. Thi Ll r y A i w e t ho t o o ck a e nd i t ac d ha ' t s b ar d n t s ho t sud Paalga t ngs Afe Ise ngt my ne d, s i t te n i o c ol o i y r e l hi . tr itni o e he ad ha ve n hi o nin,t tlne e ph iala c s a as pr e sona hep orlwoul s pi o ha ed d ysc c e s nd lo of s i l l d notbe abl t adequat y res ch,sr. eo el ear i ? 1 a 38 Ther s ns t t sc d. t . e po e o hi ompl i wasa t e a n m e tw i t i tt tona a t r y. a nt no h r ppoi t n t he ns iu i l to ne h D i s tsi d,M a ng t n fl d a r gul rgre nc on Se e be 1 s a i t the ha s a i fe nni he ie e a i va e pt m r 4, t tng ha d G ie r que tt l w lbr r c e ni ac e s t m a e i lt a m a pr de a eq t k l dge ç l d e s o a i a y onc r ng c s o t r a h t y ovi d ua e now e f ofhow t rsa c prs n,a Itgaec s sa /orci na/ vi c s t t co t sveal o ee rh? e e t nd ii t a e ndll rmi lci l a e o he ur; e r tm e t s ve ald pt' . A l r t r m e t l t Ator y w hi h ha pr ven t be i fe tve a t i s o e r e -s 1 e u n o ns . t ne c s o o ne f c i t he l t' 1 at39. l r pons t t quesi on t grevance f m ,<W hatacton do you want eas .' d. n es e o he ton he i or ç i tke 'Ma ngwr e: ç e s sea ve atc d,a ai 1beiveill e de t tIne d a n?' nni ot ç a e e bo ta he g n. le t's vi nt ha pl e wha 1'm bengd nid. l t () i e e ' d. ' W ar Edm ondss at i hi LevelIr pons t M anni s gr e den t ed n s es e o ng' i vance: l your grevance, you sat you ar bei de e a c s t t La n i t ed e ng ni d c es o he w Li ar A sa r ul oft sgrevance,you wantt bepr ded acces t t Law br y. es t hi i o ovi s o he Li ar br y. . ' Thers t oft i omalpr e srve lta Ms R.Hari,OSS ( w euls he nfr oc s e a h t . rs La Li ay Su r s ) r po d t If ma Co an #OW CC- 6-NF- 3 brr pevior es nde o nor l mplit 1 l 01 03 s a i t a n m e ha be n m a f r Of e e M a ng t t l t t e t tng, An ppoi t nt s e de o f nd r hni o a k o h I tt i ns iutonalAtor M r.Thom as on Sept ber 6,2016. 1 am r t ney em eques i t tng hat M r.Thomaspr de a sel hel ltgaton m anualt hel M r.M anni i hi l ovi f p ii i o p ng n s egal pr ess ogr . A n i s i a i i t yo c pl nti c t s t tM s Har i w a c r e t nve tg ton n o ur om ai ndi a e ha . rs s o r c i he r pons t your I or n r es e o nf mal Compl nt You ar assgned t t Par e ai . e i o he ol V i a or Recei ng Uni. Of ender as gned t t s uni ar not penuit t olt vi t f s si o hi t e ted o ph i al g t t La Li ar due t s urt r s . H o ver t f l w i ys c l o o he w br y y o ec iy ea ons we , he olo ng I e e t ton a e s s you co e ns I e e t ton M e or nd 81 1 mpl m n a i ddr s e r nc r : mpl m n a i m a um 0. , Atachment#1, sa es çOfe rr quii l ga a s sa e, us s bm ( a r que t t t t : f nde e rng e l s it nc m t u i e s t t t Tr m entD e t ent Secr al and expl n t l o he eat parm et . y ai he egalcases r r f equied or t i l ga wor The Se r t r m a r que tpr of f o t c t prort f ln he r e l k. c e a y y e s o r m he ours i o ii g t srquet Ofe r ae al d t ( c s a a tme an t y s l be hi e s. fndes r lowe wo 2) aes t i d he hal c pi d on s m o c or d pa r The e m us be r t ed t t e Tr a m e t o e al n ol e pe . s t e um o h et n S ceay u o c mpein o y u lg lp oe t l y u rq ie a dto a e rtr p n o lt f o r e a rj c. f o e ur d i n l o i d um e t to y m us r t n a c s i o de t r c ve a he . Fa l e t oc n a i n, ou t e ur a e n r r o e ei not r iur o r ur t s paperwor upon com pl i of your l et n hi k eton egal w or coul r ul i k d es t n r vi a cont aband char per OP 861. l you need t s t I tt i ecei ng r ge 1. f o ee he ns iutonal A tor t ney, you m us subm i an l tt i t t nsiutonal Ator r t ney eques t t W ar s t o he den' Secr r who wilpl you on a ls i or ofdat r ved. eu y l ace it n der e ecei ' On Sept ber 6,2016 you r ved an appoi m entw ih t l tt i em ecei nt t he ns iutonal Ator y. rhe m or ,b you own ad i s o M s H a sha pr de you w ih t ne Fu t r e y r m s i n, . ni s ovi d t caelwsmaera aonjwihassa c fom a ofnde La Li ayClr s a t il l t sitn e r n fe r w brr ek. I a 41 Fi ng no vi a i ofpolc Edm on r e M a ng' gre nc t be unf unde d. t . ndi olton i y, ds ul d nni s i va e o o d. I t Le 1 a pe lr s ns ,ChalneDa s( tngbyde inain o r o a nitaor n he vel 1 p a epo e re vi aci sg to f eginal dmi srt W e yHobbs up dEdmo 'Gndi Jla 45. nd ) hel nds ng. .s t t On Se . 30, 201 M a ng r c i d de e e c pt 6, nni e e ve f ns ouns ls m oto t dim is t e' i n o s s he Buc ngha Coun y c tca e a c ki m t our s , c ompa e by a fda t . M a ng m aie a r butalbre t ni d f i vis nni ld e t if o t Cour on Oct he t ober 11;however t cas w as di ised by or da ed Oct , he e sm s der t ober4,2016,and Ma nga ae The whe M a ng frtatmptdt Gl t sj1 a to i Nove r nni ppe ld. n, n nni is te e o e hi 983 cin n mbe 201 ,s e ofhi m a lngs i l ng hi m a y e bi do m e s w e e de a d i t D il y 6 om s ii , nc udi s n xhi t cu nt , r l ye n he lw n m air loom f i uf i ent.os age. or ns fci p t 6 Li rly c nsr ng M a ng' c anta a nde ( Nos 1 a 5,a as beal o tui nni s ompli s me d ECF . nd ) nd caii i hi rs e t t dee ns moi ( No.3 , hi cai ae t tt lrfed n s epons o he fnda t' ton ECF 3)5 s l ms r ha he dee a si efrdwihhi rgh t a c st c t r ae t ()hi saec tcvi a ton, fnd nt ntree t s i t o c es he ours eltd o:a s tt our i l ci ()hi unfld a no ale dl uni y ha ea c puscli ,()delysi t flng oft s b s ie nd w l6e y tmel b s or ams c a n he i hi j1 a ton,a ( hi i biiyt rs ac ADA a prs ersdia lt is sf posi e 983 ci nd d) s na lt o e e rh nd ion ' s biiy sue or sbl f ur ltga i A s r i i t s acton,M anni seeks m onet y dam ages,r ut e ii ton. elef n hi i ng ar ecover ofcost y s, a de l aoya dij tver ifrgadi a c s t Iga a ssa ea maeil. nd cartr - nunci ele e r ng c e s o e l sitnc nd tras n ng es D ef endant Edm onds has f l a m oton t dim i , and M anni has r ponded. ied i o s ss6 M a ni ha alo fld a moton t a nd hi c an t a d a tona fqs a d ne n ng s s ie i o me s omplit o d ddii l a t n w ' d f da s Oa e , Da s a Hobbs The courtw il gr ntM anni s m oton t amend and e en ht: t s7 vi, nd . l a ng' i o diec s r i e on t ne d f nda s8 r t e vc he w e e nt . l .Di si I scus on A Rul 1 b)6 moi t dimistsstelgals fce yofac mpl n t deemi e 2( () ton o s s et h e ufiinc o ait o tr ne w he he t pl a rha pr pe l s e a c z bl c ai . Edwa ds v.Ciy o Gol bor 1 t r he e de s o ry àt d ogni a e l m r t f ds o. 78 F. 231 243 (t Ci.1 ) Se to 1 3 pemisa a ive pat t fl aci la ton 3d , 4h r 999. cin 98 r t n ggre d ry o ie vi ci 5 The d e n sc tue M a ng' s m ison a s e ng t sc ts r e oft Buc ngha efnda t onsr d nni s ub s i s s e ki hi our' eviw he ki m Co nyCic iCo r' ds sa o hssaec u t aea o t dclcr.Ma nn h ssae , o v rta 4h ) u t rut uts imisl f i tt o r cs b u me ia ae n ig a ttd h we e,h tt e l ddn t ninti cs fr e im 'a dta h me t n dteme ia cs o l t s o ta u e il(fac s t i o Peto hs ae o rve ' n h t e ni e h dc l ae ny o h w h t d na o c es o o lg lmàeil!whl liaig cn tue ij r. Op '/ b t l8 ECF No 3 .Hec mpan ta hsçae e a tras ie ig tn o si ts nuy' pnRe ut , t t ' a .3 o lis h t i e s c wa dsmqse a dh wa n t l we t d fn hi ef' I. s iE isd n e s o al d o ee d msl. d o ' 6 Bypr viuso de, t co ts m m aiy dim is d M anni scl m sagan tt VD OC a Dil m e o r r he ur u rl s se . ng' ai is he nd lwyn s l alyfi o . eg l rvolus 1 M a ig s tm e s l t sd f nda tsna easOas butprs d t, nn n omei s pels hi e e n ' m ion ocume srfrt t sofiilm nt ee o hi fca s Oa e , he s li t cou twilus i t sopi on. t s t pe lng he r l e n hi ni 8 M a nn h sfldaç u r J d me t moin( No 3 ) c mpann ta atrh ad dnw n ig a i ç mmay u g n' t ECF . 6, o liig h t fe e d e e e s ' o d e nt a fcst hi c s t o hi moton t a efnda s nd a t o s a e hrugh s i o mend,t dee nt ha f ld t r pond t hi ne he fnda s ve aie o es o s w al tons i a tmel m a ne. Gi n t naur ofM a ng' c e tons t c tc tue t moton a legai n i y n r ve he t e nni s ontni , he our onsr s he i s s ki e ty ofd f ul. Be us t cou ti onl now gr tng t m o i t ame t a te ne f t a ee ng nr e a t ca e he r s y ani he ton o nd o dd h w acs nd dee nt,howe r Oat ,D a s a Hobbsha ne rbe n s r d w ih t a nd c fnda s ve , es vi, nd ve ve e eve t he me ed ompl nt The eor, ai . rf e net rt y norEdmondsc n be hed i deaul f f ii t r s ihe he a l n f t or alng o epond t t a nde f cs The c ur w ild y o he me d a t. o t l en M annng' moton a c digl i s i c or n y. 7 a i ta pe s n f r a to t ke unde co o o sa e lw t tvi l t d hi c tm tona r g s ga ns r o o c i ns a n r l r f t t a ha o a e s ons i i l i ht . Coooe v.She ha 735 F. 1 3,158 ( h Ci.201 ) To s vi a moto t dimis : r e n, 3d 5 4t r 3 . ur ve in o s s , e a c m pl n m us c a n s fc e f c ua m a t r ac e e ast u t tt t a c a m ofr le t t o ai t t ont i uf i nt a t l te , c pt d r e, o s a e l i e i f ha i plusbl onisfce''As r tv.Ibal5 U. 66 678( s a i e t a -' hcof g , 56 S. 2, 2009)( tngBelAt.Cor v. quoi l l p. % Twombl 550U. 5 5 ( y, S. 44, 70 2007)(mpha i a d) e ss dde l. Gr j mus a c pta tu aloft f t lalgainsc ai d i t c ant' :A) udge t c e s re l he acua le to ont ne n he ompli . ' Erc o v.Padus 551U. 89,94 ( 07)( ttonsomitd . Morove,t algainsi a iks n r , S. 20 ciai te ) e r he le to n pr . c o K ompl i ar t be lbe a l do t u d t a l w t de l pm e t of a pot n i ly a nt e o i r ly ns r e o lo he ve o n e ta l meiorouscae.Huzhe v. we 449U. 5,9(980 ;Godonv. k 5 F. 11 11 rt i s s Ro , S. 1 ) : r Lee e, 74 2d 47, 51 (t Ci.1 ) Ho ve,mer $e 1c l ins'a ûthra r rctl o t elme t o 4h r 978 . we r e ç ga oncuso ' nd t l e dbae e ias f he e ns f l l a c us ofa ton,s ppore by m e e c l or s a e e s'a e no f c u a l a i nsa ne d a e ci u td r onc us y t t m nt ' r t a t al leg to nd e no bea c ptdastue J ç hiel alc l i c nprvietefa wokofac ant t c e e r . Z t l eg oncusons a o d h rme r W ompli , t y m us be s he t uppo t d by f c ua a l g tons' 1 a 679. re a t l le a i . d. t ' 6( hef me tlc tt i lrgh ofa c s t teco t rquie prs na horte $T) unda na onsiutona i t c e s o h urs e r s io ut iis t as s i at i t pr aton and flng ofm eani ull paper by pr di pr s s o sit nm es n he epar i ii ngf egal s ovi ng i oner w ih adequat l lbr i oradequat ass sance fom per onst ai i t l .' Bounds v. t e aw i ares e it r s r ned n he aw ' Smih,430U. 81 8 (977 . Su h lga assa epr r aec tttonal s fce t S. 7, 28 1 ) c e l sitnc ogams r onsiui ly ufiint i t y pr vi i m a e t G pa lt of brngi g c t m plt d c le ge t s nt nc o f he o de n t s he t biiy ca i n on e a e ha l n s o e e es r c tons ofco i me beoe t c rs' Le s v.Casv,518 U. 3 356 ( 996 ondii nfne nt fr he ou t.' wi e S. 43, 1 ) (mphai a d . Mor s cfc l s h lg asit c pr rms s d be G de t t e ss dde ) e pe iialy, uc e al ssan e oga houl G quae o a pe m i a i a e t e or pos i et ore ofr le ,de e m i t f c st tm us be p es ntt r t n nm t o xpl e s bl he i s e i f t r ne he a t ha t r e o m ake outcl m s underany a l e t ai vaiabl heori and t f am e pl ngs bef e t f alor s a e es, o r eadi or he eder tt c t s ul hewiht dos ' Stiklrv.W aes 989F.d 1 ,1 6(t Ci.1 3) ours ho d s o o. rc e ' tr. 2 375 38 4h r 99 . 8 On t o he ha t s rg of a c s doe no r q r prs t pr vi a i a e he t r nd, hi i ht c es s t e uie ions o o de n nm t l i n w ih ph i a a c s t a l w lb a y o t pr de hi w ih c pi s ofw ha e rt pe of i ga t t ysc l c es o a i r r r o ovi t m t o e t ve y lgalm a e i lt the be i ve t be ne es a y t hi ltga i efors Le i ,51 U . a 35 e t ra ha le s o c s r o s ii ton f t. w s 8 S. t 4, 356. M or ove ,prs ofi il ma i e r srci o i t s a e st a lbl lga e r fon fcas y mpos e titons n nma e ' cc s o vaia e e l m a e i s a s r i e , s l ng a t s r s rc i a e r a o l r a e t pe ol gi al t ral nd e v c s o o s ho e e ti tons r e s nab y el t d o n o c i er t I at361. A s s nt es s. d. uch,an i at s m er t etcalass tons abouta l as sance nm e' e heor i eri egal sit pr am ' defi enci orcom pl nt aboutresrctonson 1 lbr y us cannot wihoutm or ogr s ci es, ai s ti i aw i ar e , t e, s uppo ta c ns i to lc ai ofde a ofa c s . 1 a 351 To sa e s c a c a m ,t i a e r o tm i na l m ni l c e s d. t . t t u h l i he nm t m us s t how t s fc det i es i t l as s ance orm at i s avaiabl t hi r t hat pecii k enci n he egal sit er al l e o m esuled i pa tc a i e ha m t hi ltg to ofa n rvol us c a m orcl i s 1 a 351. n r i ul rz d r o s ii a i n onf i o l i a m . d. t , 53. f Thei t ma stsyt sij r ee n bys owi t tapla ngK prpae wa nmae y aif hi nuy lme t h ng ha e di he e rd s dimisd frf lr t s tsy s tc c lrquie nt(ha patc ajde e isi t s se o aiue o aif ome e hnia e rme t t riulr Gcince n he prs sl ga as it nc f c ltes' e t d hi f o l a ni g orR ha he ha s f e ar bl ion' e l s sa e a iii ' pr ven e m r m e r n t t d ufer d gua y a to bl ha m t th w ihe t brng be o e t co t ,b w a s sym i d by i de c esof c i na e r ha e s d o i f r he urs ut s o t e na qua i t l lbr y t he w as unabl even t fl a com pl nt' I at351. Concl y alegatons he aw i ar hat e o ie ai .' d. usor l i a tm e e de a or i onve e e t a i t ' l ga wor c nno s bou r l ys nc ni nc s o n nma e s e l k a t uppo ta de a o a e s r ni l f cc s cl m . St i er 989 F. at 1 ai rckl , 2d 383. A s an i talm a t ,M a ng' com pl nt and docum ent i i cat t he has had nii ter nni s ai s aton ndi e hat s e a ce s t l ga m a e i l a t t c t . A s a pa ol vi a o ,he w a ba r d b prs n om c s o e l t r a s nd o he ours r e ol t r s re y io s iy polcy fom physi l a t ng t l lbr . t do r ear D il yn ofi al have ecurt i r caly tendi he aw i al o y es ch. lw fci s m ade ext ve efor s how ever t pr de M anni w ih l ensi f t, , o ovi ng t egal as s ance. He has r sit eques ed t and r ved copi of courtdeci onsf r ecei es si or esear pur es and has had atl tt ee m eetngs ch pos eas hr i wih a i tt i na a t e a dic son wih lw lbr y peron a t hi r s a c i n nsiuto l tom y nd s us i s t a i ar s nel bou s e e r h 9 ne ds Furhe m or ,w ih t m a e i l M a ni ac e s d,he w a a e t tl a sa e c tci l e . t r e t he t ra s n ng c s e s bl o 5e t t our vi ad i and t sf alci lri s adi on hi eder vi ght on. M oreover M anni does not show t t l of any partcul l , ng hat he ack i ar egal r our a es ce t D il lwyn pr ve t d hi f om pr pa i a tlng hi s a e c r l w s t or c us d i t be e ne m r e rng nd i i s t t ou t a ui a e to dimisd.Thea nde j1 3c antd snoti c t t tt Buc ng m Couny c t s se me d 98 ompli oe ndiae ha he ki ha t our dim i s d hi c s be a e of s e f r ti pr e or o he pr e a de e t i hi s se s a e c us om o ma tng obl m t r oc dur l f c n s s is onst the w a una et r s a c a D il y Si ia l M a ng' s i sonsdo no ubm s i ha s bl o e e r h t lw n. m l ry, nni s ubm s i t de c i a pa tc a lga a g n c iialt hi c s t the c d notdic rwih t s rbe ny riulr e l r ume t rtc o s a e ha oul s ove t hJ a albe lg lrs u c s Ass c ,d s t b iga v sd t a n t s o ij r h h sn t v i l e a eo re . a u h epi en d ie o me d o h w nuy, e a o e sa e f c sde onsr tng h t e d f nda t 'a tonshar ed hi s a e co tltga i e f t. t t d a t m t a i ow h e e n s c i m s t t ur ii ton fors Fo t s me ra o Ma ng' c mpl n fist sae a j 1 cli t tDil r he a e s n, nni s o ait al o tt 983 am ha lwyn pes nne hame hi a ly t b i hi fdeallwj t He s c e d i flng t sj1 ro l r d s bii o rng s e r a ui. t u c ede n ii hi 983 com pl ntand i subm itng hi am ended com pl ntand a t ai n ti s ai tachm ent The pos age pr em s i s. t obl n t Dil he lwyn m a lo c s d hi ,a t m os ,i on ni nc a de a of hi pl a ngs a d ir om au e m t he t nc ve e e nd l y s e di n e hi is butdi no pr ve hi f om fln o c us t di m i s lo a y c ai . Fort sa e x bt, d t e nt m r ii g r a e he s s a f n l m he t t d ras ,t c r wilga t moi t ds s ast Ma ng' cams()a () rgadi e ons he ou t l rnt he ton o imis o nni s li a nd c, e r ng hi pas cour Glngs i sat and f alcourt s t t i nte eder . The courtconcl ,however t M anni s aleged difculi i r ear ng A DA udes , hat ng' l fi tes n es chi i s s a s a e ha a c pu pr e di p es ntpo sbl a ce s t c r s c a m s t ts vi s ue nd t t be s or s oc e ngs r e s i e c s o ou t l i ha ur ve t m oton t dim is. M anni r he i o s s ng eques ed and coul not obt n f om t l lbr y a s at t d ai r he aw i ar te habeas f m ori or aton aboutt sat s at e oflm iatons. He as ert t hi ti ator y or nf m i he t e t uf i ti s s hat s ral t ne t pr de i f e tve a s sa e b t thi s a e sa u o y flng pe i e pie w hie he s ht ovi d ne f c i s i t nc , ut ha s t t t t t r ii rod x r d l oug hel i f lng s h a c a m . M a ng a s a l ge t the w a una e t ob a n a c s t t AD A p n ii uc li nni l o le s ha s bl o t i c e s o he 1 0 or i f m a i a utt rgh s of dia e i a e i prs The c tGnd t es a l g tons n or ton bo he i t s bl d nm t s n ion. our s h e le a i s f i e t t sa e pos i e a c s t c ur s c ai s t t Dil u fci n o t t sbl c e s o o t l m ha lwyn' l gala s s a e pr r m has se c it nc og a pr ve e hi fom flng sa e ha as cl m s a t t t pr gr m ' de e e w il ha m e nt d m r ii t t be ai nd ha he o a s lcinci s l r M a ng' f t e l i ton e f r so ha a a / rADA i s s nni s u ur i ga i f o t n be s nd o t s ue . 11 Concl on 1. usi For t s at r he t ed easons,t courtw il gr t m oton t dim is i par and deny i i he l ant he i o s s n t tn par. A n a opri e or w ilent t sday. t ppr at der l er hi The c e k wils nd a c y oft s m emor nd o ni n a d t a c lr l e op hi a um pi o n he c ompa yi g o de t n n r ro M a ng an t c ns lofr c d f rt de e a s nni d o ou e e or o he f nd nt . EN TER: Thi s day ofFebr y,2018. uar Seni Unied St t D it i J or t a es s rct udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
