Hines v. Barksdale, et al, No. 7:2017cv00077 - Document 47 (W.D. Va. 2018)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 6/27/2018. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERKY OFFI ( ; aa ix . CK j A DFI I V ' T A VI A N Z LED J 27 2 1 UN 28 I THE UM TED STATES DI N STRI COURT CT FO R T H E W E STER N D I STR I T O F V G G I I C N A R O A N O K E D I SI N W O GREGORY S.HI NES, Pl ntf, ai if ' v. EARI C. , BARKSDATE, ta . , e l, Dee da s f n nt. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) J . n U u Bv: , D , RK c . E Ci lAci No.7:7-vvi ton 1 c 00077 : M EM ORANDUM OPI ON M By: Ho J c o L. s r n. a ks n Kie Se i rUnie St tsDit itJ e no td a e src udg Gr gor S. ne ,aVigilai t pr ee ngpr K ,c e y Hi s r ri nma e oc di o omm e d tlsa ton pm s nt nce li c i ua t 42 U. C.j1 3.Pli ifnn sa deenda s EalC.Baks l,whoi t f r r o S. 98 nntf me s f nt: r r dae s he ome W ad no t eRe On o S aePrs nCç P', n ROSP safOfie KemehRo e Kr e f h d i n tt io ROS ' a d ) tf fc r r t s , 9 Ofi e Ni hol sRoo a Nur eVi Phips Pli ifale st tDe e fc r c a p, nd s cky p . antf l ge ha f ndan si t mpos c u l ed r e a t ua pt s e i vi a i oft Ei h Am e e toft Unie St t sConsiu i nd mus l mihm nt n ol ton he ght ndm n he t d a e tt ton. Dee da t fldamoi nfrs mma yj d me t a dPlitf r s o e , kigt smatr fn ns ie to o u r u g n , n an if e p nd d ma n hi te lpe f rdiposton. Afe r viwi t r c d,Igr ntDe e n s moton f sl a y ' o s ii i tr e e ng he e or ' a f nda t ' i or lmm r j dg n . u me t 1. Pl ntf be n fghtng wih a t ri t i i a c owde housng l ton J 1 ai if ga i i t no he nma e nsde r d i mi une 7, 201 Ofi rRos wa i i t c tolb00 h,butno sa fwa i i t ho i l t 6. lce e s nsde he on r t t f s nsde he usng mi. Ofke Ros a tvae t wn nng buz ra or r d t t sop fg i a ledown. f r e c i t d he r i ze nd de e hem o t i htng nd i Alho h o he i t si t uni 1 y o t gr und,Pli ifa t o he i t co i t ug t r nma e n he t a n he o antf nd he t r nma e ntnuedt o Hines v. Barksdale, et al Doc. 47 fght Ofie Ros t n fr ar ofOlor snCa ilm (t ' s a twa dt m,a i . fc r e he ied ound e e i pscl GOC') pr yl o r he nd a n wn ne t m t sop fg i a ledown.N et rPli tf rt ot ri a e gai r d he o t i htng nd i ihe n n ifno he he nm t bOC s a i ac pr y s hemia a ntsmia t wha i co c l ge i lr o t s mmonl known a peppe s a o mac a i tt a y s r pr y r e nd niaes pes n' e e,h o ta dn s .S e ec, r v. hfet 2 0F.d8 3 8 (t Ci. 01 ( eciigt ro s y str a, n o e e . ..Pak S ilt 5 3 4 , 49 4h r20 ) d srbn he p y ilgclefcso OC sry . h soo ia fe t f p a ) Dockets.Justia.com - co id.Ofi rRos ne fr d sx non-ehalG mpa tr mple fce e xt le i l t i c ounds' r amulilt he . Of e i 'fom t-amc r lc r Ros paus d be wee frng e h r e e t n ii ac ound t a n or rt m t sop fghtng.Pl i ifdi not o gai de he o t i i antf d c ompl e n afe r t snz k hi rg caf l werba k,a a y, ve tr o mds t c s i ht l, o c nd bovehi lf e r s et a. A no de e n- f ndantofi e r s nde t t housng lni wih li K- By t stme, fc r e po d o he i l t t zs 9. hi i Pl i ifwa silfg i andha pi d t ot ri t down on t p oft lni sais The antf s tl i htng d nne he he nma e o he l t t r . i t c it n l r f s or r t sop fg i bot be or and a trt K- bi t m . Onl nma es onsse ty e u ed de s o t i htng h f e fe he 9 t he y a tra he ofi e a oa he t i aesand de o d O/ s a wa t fghtphysca l fe not r fc r ppr c d he nm t pl ye C pr y s he i i ly br n up. oke Pli ifwast ke t t med c de rmentf a s s me a trbeng de ont mi t antf a n o he i al pa t or s e s nt fe i c n naed ofO/ s a A non- f nda nure notd Pl i ifhad s ti d a dogbiet hi rgh caf a C pr y. de e nt s e antf usa ne t o s i t l, lce a i on t l f sde ofhi he a a a i . Thentr e cea d t a a i ,d ued a r ton he e t i s ad, nd br sons ls l ne he br sons s gl s 't lce a i cea d a ba hut'he a r ton, l ne nd ndage t dog biemmks pl c Pli tf n am e ca cel d he t , a ed a n ifi di l l f robs r ton, a a ove dos ofM oti a Tyl nol2 Pli ifs w t f ciiy doc oro o e va i nd ppr d es t n rn nd e . antf a he a lt J 23,201 a r t nedt hi us lc l t f l w i da une 6, nd eur o s ua e l he olo ng y. Pli ifwasco c e ofa dicplna y i rc i f rfghtng,a Ba ks euphel t antf nvit d s i i r nfa ton o i i nd r dal d he c ci n a t a i sr tver vi w. A r gi a i sr t s e nty vac t d t onvito fer dm nitai e e e onal dm nitaor ubs que l a e he c ci n be a eBa ks ehadno bee r vi we t c ci n wihi t t n- y lmi. onvito c us r dal t n e e d he onvito t n he e da i t Pl i ifa gue t tOfk e Ros us d e e svef ceby s i t i antf r s ha t r e e xc s i or hootng he mpad r ound a t hi he Pli ifas agu t tNtrePhi ,ast ç e c lDe a t nt He d,' s ad. antf lo r es ha zs pps he ç dia pgrme j a 'was M de i r t l i f e e t hi ne d f m e ca t e t e ,i udhl m e a he lh te m e lbe a e y ndif r nt o s e or di l r a m nt ncl g nt l a t r at nt ne es ia e byt ee nt . Pl i ifar st tW a de Ba ks eGc r d up't a tonsof c st t d hes ve s antf gue ha r n r dal tove e 'he c i 2'heot ri t wass ntt ahos tl f he nmae e o pia. 2 li ç ubo d na e 'by alo ngt de tuc i ofr l va vi or c di . Pli ifale st t zs ç r i t s' s l wi he sr ton e e nt de e or ngs antf lge ha i i aG ommonocc re el'f saft s i c r t a i ts he . ts ç c u rnc q' or tf o hoot mpa t omds t nmae ' ads I. I A pat i e t ldt s mmayj g n i t pla i s teds l s dmaeil o fl, ry s ni e o u r ud me t f he e dng ,h ico e tras n ie t a a a fda t s nd ny fi vis how t tt r i no ge nediput ast a m ae i lf c .Fe R. v. ha he e s nui s e o ny t ra a t d. Ci P. 5 () t aeil a t'aet o ef csne e sr t e tbiht eee nso ap ry' c us o 6 a . < tra f cs' r h s a t c sa y o sa ls h lme t f a t s a e f Mq a to An e s nv. b ryLo b I .4 7U. 2 2 2 8( 9 6 .A g n i d s u eo cin. d ro Lie t b y.nc, 7 S. 4 , 4 1 8 ) e une ip t f ma e i lf c e s si,i vi wi t a s i eevi nc a a1 r a ona ei e e e d a t ra a t xit f n e ng he dmi sbl de e nd 1 e s bl nf r nc s r wn t r fom i alghtm os f vor bl t t no movi pa t a r as bl f tfnde co d r tmz he e r n i t a a e o he nng ry, e ona e ac r ul e t ave ditf rt no mova .JJ Themovi pat ha t btr n ofs ng t ti, ntng r c o he n- nt -I, ng ry s he lde howi -Eha s poi i t outt t dititc t t tt r i a a e e ofe de et s o he src our - ha he e s n bs nc vi nc o uppor t nonm o ngpm y' the vi s c s . Ceoe Co v Cart 4 7U. 31 , 25( 9 6 .I temo a tstsist i b e m e' ltx m. . tet 7 S. 7 3 1 8 ) f h v n aife h s md n, ' t n t non- o ntm us s tf t s c fcf c st tde onsr t t e se e ofagenui he he m va t e orh pe ii a t ha m ta e he xitnc ne ' t es ve s e a s diput o f frtil3 J. a 322- .A cout may notr ol diput d f ct , wei t s e f ad o ra. .. t 24 IS J gh he e de e, m a de e mi tonsofc edi lt Rus e lv. ir yneCor ,65 F. 1 vi nc or ke t r na i r biiy. s l M c od p. 3d 229, 1 3 (t Ci.1 9 ) S e e v. u p , 9 F.d 1 9 1 2( t Ci. 98 ) I se d ac u t 2 9 4h r 9 5 ; osb e M r hy 7 7 2 7 , 8 4h r 1 6 . n ta , o r a ce sastuet e de oft nonc pt r he vi nce he movi pa t andr s vesa1 it r lco lc sa ng ry e ol 1 n e na nfit nd i e enc i t no m ovi pa t sf vor Chrbor a sdeFr ncev.Sm ih,597 F. 406, nf r es n he nng ry' a . m qe a t 2d 41 (t Ci.1 7 ) Ho v r ç mqr u s p re s e uain . .sno e o g t d fa a 4 4h r 9 9 . we e,ç e e n u po td p c lto . i t n u h o ee t g sl r u g n moin. En i v. tl sno Bus & Ed c Ra i I c, 3F.d5 , 2 l mma yj d me t to ' n s Na 'As ' f . u . do.n .5 3 5 6 ' (t Ci.1 9 ) 4h r 9 5 . 3Pl ntf orgi l algedt K- Ofi rNihol Roopus exc svef cebutnow c de t the ai if i naly le hat 9 fce c as ed es i or once s ha h sn va ecam a is Ro p.Co e u nl, o i pa tds mmayj d me t a o ibl li gan t o nsq e ty Ro p s ne u r u g n. 11 1. A .. Pli ifa gte t tOf rRos us d e es i f r ewhe o oft t e i n ntf r zs ha sce e e xc sve o c n ne he hr e mpac t r mdshi hi i t sdeofli he d.De e mi ng e e svef cede ndso T t f c ot t m n he i ls a t r ni xc s i or pe n ç her or e whe wa a id i agood f ih e f t o mai ai orr t r dic plneorm ai i l a s si ly s pple n at for t nt n eso e s i i lcousy nd aditcal f t pur eofc usnghnr . I a 3 21 Thef t r t c i ri l t ne f t or he pos a i m ' d. t 20- . ' ac o s o onsde ncude he ed or he a i ai off c t r l to hi be wee t ne d andt n mtoff c t tw a us d, he pplc ton or e, he e ai ns p t n he e he mot or e ha s e t e tn o ij yifitd t e tn o t et e t ot s ft o safa di mae ra o a y xe t f nur n lce ,he x e t f h hra t he aey f tf n n ts e s n bl pe c i d by r ponsbl ofi i l,a e l t m a t t mpe t s ve iy ofaf c f lr s ns r e ve es i e fc a s ny fbrs de o e r he e rt or e' e po e, u a whehe t pl i ifwasaci l r ssi nd t r he antf tvey e itng.Ki l y v. nddc on,1 S.Ct 2466,2473 ngse He ks 35 . ( 1 ) W lte v. b r, 75U. 31 , 21( 98 ) Co rsr c g iet t or cin o fcas 20 5 ; l ly Ale s 4 i S. 2 3 1 6 . u t e o nz ha c re to s f il mus a tçn ha t t rpr s e and fe nty wihoutt l y ofas c c nc ' t c s se, mde es ur , i r que l t he uxur e ond ha e.' W hily,475 U. a 3 Cons que l t c t us gi prs ofi il S de-a ng te S. t 20. e nty, he our m t vé ion fca s i wi r ngi d frnc i t ea o to a de c to o poiisa dp a tc st a i t er u g n a e eee e n h d p in n xe u in f lce n r cie h t n h ij d me t r ne de t pr s r e i e a o de and dicplne a t m ant i i tt to ls c u t ' Huds e d o e e v nt m l r r s i i nd o i an nsiui na e t iy. ' on v. c ila , 0 U. 1 7( 9 2 . M M l n 5 3 S. , 1 9 ) i Ofie Ro ei e tte t q l idi l t a d sl r u g n f rs o t lc r s s nild o uai e mml y n l f ni mmayj d me t o h oi ng Pl i ifwih i antf t mpac r t ds Eve vi ng t e denc i alghtm os f vor bl t Pli if i t om . n ewi he vi e n i t a a e o antf, t i e de t tOfi rRos wa a tng i agood f ih e f tt m ant i o r sor dicplneand s vi nt ha fce e s ci n a t for o i a n r e t e s i i wasco pe ld t i e v neasbes hec d om t c r boot See e. , r rv. m le o nt r e t oul he ontol h. . c.Fn me Brr n 51 U. 8 5 8 2 ( 9 4 (ic si gc ae to l tt d t t miiaeimaeo ema , 1 S. 2 , 3 1 9 ) d s u sn o cina sars u y o tg t n t n imaevilnce. n t oe ) 4 Pli ifi ahi s c iy lve i a ei ROSP.4 Pli iff ug a i a ei a antf s gh-e urt e l nm t n antf o ht n nm t n cr wde housnguni a r f edt sop des t a a bl buz e , o d i t nd e us o t pie n udi e z r comm a ,ml OC s a nds d pr y. I e a ei t r nton wm r quie t so t fg ,butOfk e Ros wasr tit d t t mm dit n e ve i s e r d o t p he i ht f r e esrc e o he co r b00t a wihou t a ssa eofco r c i lsa fi t uni.Eve a trbei ntol h nd t t he s it nc r e tona t f n he t n fe ng wn n oft i pac r r ed he m t ounds afe be ng li wih ar md i t l a afe bei li wih a , tr i lt t ot n he eg, nd tr ng lt t r md i t bac Pl ntf c ime t sg . Onl t n di one o sx r undshi Pl ntf i t ot n he k, ai if ontr d o ht y he d fi o t ai if n he sde o t hea wliehewasm ovi a m s lng on s ar a a y fo t c r b00t i f he d zl ng nd si t is nd wa r m he ontol h. Reg r es t whe he Ros wass h a a ur t s tt thei e d t hi Pl i ifi t he a dl s o t r e uc n cc a e ho ha ntnde o t antf n he ad wih anon-e ha i c r md,OfierRos sus off c f o t c r b00t i de m e a t lt l mpa t ot fc e' e or e r m he ontol h s e d good f ih e l tt r sor dicplne.Ase de ed byt vi o r or ng, ihe t i c a t fbr o e t e s i i vi nc he de ec di net r he mpa t r oundsnort K- dee e Pl ntf 9o c i ngt fgh .M or over Pli ifs f r o y he 9 tn'd ni if m ontnui he i t e , antf ufe ed nl alc r to a dr ltdp i a d s lig, sl n te eij de ween ts sane fo t a e ai n n eae an n weln a sl g h s nu s r o u ti d r m he mi fg t Ac o dngy Ofke Ro ei e tte t q aiidi liya ds mmayj g n . h . c r i l, f r s s n ild o u lfe mml t n u r ud me t n B. Plitf alg st t rePhp , st ç e do t ( P)me ia d pat n 'wa an if le e ha Nu s ips a he G a f he ROS h dc l e rme t' s d lb rtl id fee tt l sijl e , v d nl b c u eh d e n ta r ewi t eme ia c r eie aey n ifrn o z nt is e i e ty e a s e o s o g e t h dc l a e i r h t twa pr ded by nm s sa doc or . A pli ifmus s ha s ovi e nd t s antf t how t tade e ntaced wih ha f nda t t de i r t i fe e e t as rousm e c nee t sae ac am unde t Ei t Am e m e lbe a e ndif r nc o e i dial d o t t l i r he gh h nd nt f r h t o si ina d r a o me ia a ssa c .W e t At n , 8 U. 4 48( 9 8 ; o t e mc n tmto l el l f dc l sitn e s v. kis 4 7 S. 2, 1 8 ) i Esel v Gn l, 2 U. 9 ,1 4( 9 6 ; n rv Domel , 2F.d2 0 2 2( t Ci. tl . mb e 4 9 S. 7 0 1 7 ) Co ne . r ly 4 3 2 , 2 4h r e 4Asi us a ROSP, Pl ntf s ual t ai ifwashous d t r i pa tbec us o hi l h dicplna y ofe ehitr e he e n r a e f s engty s i i r fns so y, i l ngmuli ec r so t e t ni bodl hnr pos esi c ncudi tpl hage f hr a e ng iy m, s sng ontaba i tng aro ,a fghtng. nd, ncii it nd i i 5 1 9 ) A s ro sme ia ne di ac n iint a ç sb e da no e byap y iina 9 4 . eiu dc l e s o dto h tl e n ig s d ha h sca s m a t te t e oronet ti s o oust te n a l pe s wo d ea iy r og zet nda hv r am nt ha s o bvi ha ve ay r on ul sl ec ni he n c si frad co ' atn in. Iov. h e e 5 F.d2 5 2 (t Ci. 0 ) e e st o o t rs te to ' k S r v , 35 3 2 , 41 4 h r 2 08 . y ' De i r t i f e e er quiesa sae a t rt ha be n pe s ly a r off c s lbe ae ndif r nc e r t t c o o ve e r ona l wa e a t i c i as l ilrs ofs roushn m,ml t a t mus ha a m al r c z t ndiatng ubsnnta ik e i r d he c or t ve c ly e ogni ed he e itn eo s c ars Fn me v. e na , 1U. 8 , 3 ( 9 4 .d lb rt idfe e c xse c f u h ik. r r Brn n 51 S. 25 8 8 1 9 ) t ie ae n ifr n e De m a be de y monsr t by et rac a i e o r cce sdir ga d. M ite v. m ,896 F. taed ihe m l nt nt r e ll s s e r ' lir Beo ' 2d 8 , 51(t Ci. 9 0 ;sePnvs e r lLe v Clv ln , 7 F.d2 4 3 3( t Ci. 0 4 48 8 4 h r 1 9 ) e lih x e . e . e ea d 3 2 3 9 , 0 4h r 2 0 ) ( ( h e ie c mu ts o t a teo fca i q sin s b e tv l rc g ie ta h sa to :Tj e vd n e s h w h t h fiil n ue to u j ciey e o nz d h t i cins < weetn p r p it i lg to ta rs ') ç d fnd n a t rc e syb d se adnga r ia p o rae n ih f h t ik.'. ç ee a t cs e kls l y ir g r i ' A s tntalrs ofda rt ti eihe known t t de e ntorwli h woul be a r ntt a ubsa i ik nge ha s t r o he f nda zc d ppa e o r a ona epe s i t de e ntsposto ' M ite ,896 F. a 851 5 e s bl r on n he f nda ' ii n.' lir 2d t - 2. To s c d wih a t nsi i lm e ca te t e cai a i tno te tng uc ee t n mco tmtona di l r am nt l m gans n-r a i peror l apl i ifm us s s me, antf t how t tt ofi i lwaspe s ly ùw ol wih a dela of ha he fc a r ona l ved t ril ke t e ,dei r t l i e f r d wih ke t nt ort il a hodze orwa de i r t l am ht lbe a e y nt re e t a me , acty ut d s lbe a ey i fe e t t m e c pr de ' m ic uc whe e n a1 y pe s woul unde snnd t t ndif r nt o he di al ovi rs s ond t n ve a r on d r t ha t me ca pr de i bengdelbert yi feent JJ a 854.Supe vs y prs n ofiil a e he di l ovi r s i i ael ndifr . -- t I, r ioz io fcas r e t ldt rl o t epr fs in l u g n o tane me ia p rome.J S p r io y ni e o ey n h o e so a j d me t f ri d dc l e s r l Z u e vs r t la lt i notesa ihe m e e y by s wi t tas di t wasdelbe a ey i fe e t a ibiiy s t bls d r l ho ng ha ubor na e i r t l ndif r nt o pli ifsmedialnee J antf c d. . Z Pl i iff l t esa ih Nur ePli 'dei r t i fe e eorape v i a antf ais o t bls s lpps lbe a e ndif r nc r asve nd wi pr a pr tc ofm e c i fe e e.Pl ntf al t esa ih Nur ePli 'die t des e d aci e di al ndif r nc ai iff is o tbls s zpps r c 6 pe s nali ve e wih a ale d c nsi i lde i ton,a he c nno r l o r o nvol m nt t n l ge o tmtona prva i .nd a t ey n r s ndea s ror Se ec.M one lv. p' o Soc Se v . 436U . 658,66 n. 691- 4 e po t upe i . e. . , l De t f . r s, S. 3 7, 9 ( 9 8 ; l c v. e h, 7 F.d3 , 0 ( t Ci. 0 ) ç s ha v. to ,1 F.d7 , 1 7 ) Tnzo k Fre 2 5 3 91 4 2 4h r 2 01 ; f S w S rud 3 3 91 7 (t Ci. 9 4 ; e as J n sv. eln 1 4F.d6 0 6 7( t Ci.1 9 ) At s, 99 4 h r 1 9 ) s e lo o e W l m, 0 3 2 , 2 4h r 9 7 . mo t h pli ifpoi st NurePhi rs et a a nitai f m afe heha ale be n antf nt o s pps' e pons o n dmi srtve or tr d r ady e r la e 9o t me ia c l.Ho v r ç a s p ro ' a trt -a td nilo ag iv n efls ee s d m he d c l el we e,G ) u el rs fe-hef c e a f re a c al ( frs tofetbls ngj 1 la lt ' Dù ol v.Ra No.7:2cv001 201 U. Dit a hor sa ihi 983 ibiiy. pa a ' y, 1 39, 3 S. s. LEM S 1 71 2, t* , 3W L 4 51 3 , t* ( . Va J l 2 , 01 )( ag n , .. 1 8 a 23 201 4 2 6 a 8 W D. . uy 2 2 3 S r e t M J) (ii Br o sv. a d 1 7F. p' 9 , 2 ( dCi. 0 :.Fu t r r , aniff i t ct ng o k Be r , 6 Ap x 23 9 5 3 r 20 6 rhemo e Plitf al o s esa ih t tunc tm tona m e c lc r i wi s e a pos a unr a ona ers of t bls ha onsi i l di a a e s de pr ad nd es nd e s bl ik h r o c nsi in ln u y Se m ..S a a v. re, 3 F.d3 8 3 2 (t Ci. 9 4 . n m f o tmto a ij r . e e2, lk n Po tr 7 7 2 6 , 7 4 h r 1 8 ) M or ove ,Pl i i sdi a e m e wih m e c lpe s e r antY s gr e nt t di a r onnela utt c ls ofte t ntc nno bo he otr e r a me n t s c e d a a j1 8 cam.S e eg, rg t Col , 6F.d 8 , 49(t Ci. 9 5 . u c e s 9 3 li e . ..W ih v. lns 76 2 41 8 4 h r 1 8 ) i Ac o dn l Nt s Php i e t ldt q lfe i liya ds mmayj d me t c r igy, l e ips s n i e o uaiid mml ' n u r u g n . r t nt Pl i ifc antf ompl nst tBa ks l Gal ai ha r da e tlowed's ve la ef a oft fgh ç o be m e ' ur ilnc oot ge he i t d co t G l ra ia e'' nd dir ga de polc e a pr ed e whe r vi wi t dicplnar no onge val bl 'a s e r d i i s nd oc m s p e e ng he s i i y c nvcin.Plitf fi!t e tb ih a yij r a o t h d s iln r c n cinb c u et o ito nn if al o sa ls n nu y b u t e icpi ay é vito e a s he con c i hadbe n va a ed o a nika i r vi SeeM o. Kan.& Te Rv. Fe s 1 viton e c t n dmi s tve e ew. . x. v. ni , 79 U. 4 2 6 6( 9 0 (e o niigmo tq e to srq ienoa we) Fu te mo e Gpoito S. 0 , 0 1 0 ) r c g zn o u si n e ur ns r. rh r r ,f lain s i no as t ntve cai o def ns buta Gu eofe de .' Hodgev. a - ar St es I , s t ubsa i l m r e e rl vi nce '' W lM t or s nc. 36 F.d4 6, 5 (t Ci. 0 ) Totee tn Plitf s e t i os s p r o yla iiy 0 3 4 . 0 4 h r 20 4 . h x e t an if e ks o mp e u e ds r ib l 4 t 7 o Bmks ef OY c rRos sus off c ,t c am mus f lasOfi e Ros di no us n dal or e e' e or e he l i t ai fc r e d t e e e svef c i vi a i n oft Ei t Am e e . Se ec. Sha 1 F. a 799 xc s i or e n olto he gh h ndm nt ee . , w, 3 3d t (e u rn a afr tv c u a l i v li t ec n tmto ln u ys fr db t ep an ig. rq iig n fimaie a s l i n ovng h o si ina ij r ufee y h litf nk Ac o dngy Baks aei e tte t q lfe i l t a s mma yj d me t c r i l, r d l s n ild o uaiid mml y nd u r u g n . ni I7 A. Fo t f rg i gra o , g a tDee d n s mo inf rsl r u me t r he o e o n e s ns I rn fn a t' to o l mmayj dg n . ENTER : s Thi wda ofJm e 2018. y t , ; ? h x * eni Unie Stt Dit tJ t d a es sdc udge 8
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
