Smith v. Newland et al, No. 7:2017cv00046 - Document 51 (W.D. Va. 2017)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/22/2017. (tvt)
Download PDF
CL RKSOF I us Dl . E ' FCE sTcouW ATRo i,A AsdK V FI LED DE2 25 2 1 97 I TH E I NI N J TED STA TES DI STRI T C O UR T C FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRICT OF VI NI RGI A ROANOK E DI SI W ON ANTHO I DEW AU E SM I , NE TH Pl ntf , ai i f V. BLUE RI E REG I NAL JM L DG O A U TH O RI TY LYN CH BU RG ,e aI, t . Def ndant . e s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) JULA w, ' L C RK I EY :Y; . N Cii Acin No 7 1 -v- 0 4 v l to . : 7c 0 0 6 M EM ORANDIM om xl f J ox By: Hoh. ihae F.Ur ns M c l ba ki ChifUnie St tsDit itJ e e t d a e src udg Ant neDe yne Sm ih, Vigi aprs ne pr e ng pr K ,fl d ave ii hoi wa t a r ni io r oc edi o ie rfed c mpli plrua t 42U. C.j 1 o ant zs nt o S. 983.Pli ifna asde e nt t Bl Ri Re onal antf mes fnda s he ue dge gi J i Auhoiy Ly c b r C uho i '; moh Tr n , mi itao o t eBl Rig al t rt - n h u g W t rt ) Ti ty e tAd nsrtr f h ue d e y' Re in l alCJ i', reJ n s a d Co rcin l sc r Ne a da dGa d .Plitf go a J i da1)Nu s o e , n re t a Of e s wln n d y an if ' o al ge t tDe e nt we ede i r t l i fe en t hi m e ca ne i vi ai n o t le s ha f nda s r lbe a ey ndif r t o s di l eds n ol to f he Ei h Ame ght ndme oft Unie Stt sConsiuton. De e nt fl a moton f s ma y nt he t d a e tt i f nda s ied i or um r j d me t t whc P an ifrs o d d, kn t smatrrpefrds sto 1Afe r ve ng u g n ,o ih litf e p n e ma ig hi te i o ipo iin. tr e iwi t erc r ,h c u t rn sDe e d n s mo inf rs h e o d t e o r g a t fn a t' to o umma yj d e t r u pn n . 1 . OnFe nlr 2 20 6 Ne a wa d i n teJ i' imaeta s é v nwll Ga d , b a y 2, 1 , wlnd s rvig h als n t rn po a l e d y i Pl i if a ot i t we epas e r . Some r be we n t l a. ourhous a t antf, nd her nma es r s nge s whe e t e he oc lc t e nd he J i,t ta por va a ci nt ly sruc a he ve cl 2 Ne 1nd e t d t ta po tva , a l he r ns t n c de al t k not r hi e. w a xie he r ns r n Smith v. Newland et al Doc. 51 ' ecuracpstetmeyfldfsrso s i o g sto t Deednsmoin( No. ) Th o t cet h i l ie t tep nen p oi n q fn at' t ECF 43. r i o Plit ffe a dto a rs o s swih u la eo c u'a dwl o t e kn mz xe so o t t d s ( ani i d d i n l ep n e to te v f o l n t u s e ig e tn in f i o o o ECF f l i t h me No . 748.S eFe . Ci P. ()1; D. . v R. 1c() Th S p e Co r h sma ece rta e e s 4 - ) e d R. v. 6b () W. Va Ci. 1 ()l. e u rme u t a d la h t v n p oK lia t mu tfl w r lso cvl r c dze Mc iv. tdS ae, 08U..1 6 1 3(9 0 ;e Cih n r ig ns s ol ue f iip o e l . Nel Uni tts 5 t o r e S 0 , l 1 8 )se c o v Ex lnGe eainCo. L. , 01F.d8 3 8 9 1 (t Ci. 0 )(eo iigadsrc c u t yin r a d . eo n rt o .L. C.4 3 0 , 0 -0 7h r20 5 rc r zn itit o r ma g oe n n t o sdradto lat aliat ryoe i voaino cutreso rlso po eue.Acodn l,h o c nie d iinafcs ign po ssn ilto f o rodr r ue f rcd r) crigy te t curwi n tcnie Plitf' u p r te a u tmeyrs nsst temoinfrsmmayjd jet o t l o o sdr anifs n emltd nd ni l epo e o h to o u r u gn n. 2 l Pl ntf vest i wm abo tuc a oa hi he on,whieNe anda Gadd ave l wasa ai ifa r hat t s x r k ppr c ng ad l wl nd y rt pas i s a t apake mi n.Thedipu eofwhih ve cl wa hi i no mae ilbec us t e de i sng crpe o r d nva s t c hi e s t s t tra a e he vi nce s unco r redt tt colii ha ne whiet tans r va wasmovi a eghtmie pe hot a t tt ntove t ha hat lson ppe d l he r po t n ng t i ls r t nd ha he r Dockets.Justia.com i pe td i f da a and s kewih t i ae i i Pl i ifc ns ce t or m ge, po t he nm t s nsde. antf ompli d ofba k pai ane c n bec us hi body hi pa toft se c i i t va upo i c ,a Ne a d o t a e s t r he tel age nsde he n n mpa t nd wlnd r ve he tans t n bac t t J i a oxi ae y fvem i esa y.Upon a rvi N e a a r por va k o he al ppr m tl i nut wa ri ng, wlnd nd Ga as t i tsi t y ne dedme c latnina t Jal a t ydeci Pli if ddy ked he nmae f he e dia te to t he i, nd he lned. antf s i heh db e ço n 'a u b i h r.Co s q nl Plitf wa r tme t hsc l. ad a e n j kig' bo t eng u t n e ue ty, an if s eu d o i el Thene da med c sa fr ceve Pl i i swrte r q s c xt y, i al t f e i d antY itn e ue t ompli ng t thi ba k ani ha s c wastg .N u s J ne exa i d Smiht s m eda Shenot i t m ed c lr c d t t i ht r e o s m ne t he a y. ed n he i a e or ha Pli ifs a ntf howe no ac e dites a e e e t me c lde rm e wihoutm o lt is . d ut sr s nd nt r d he di a pa t nt t biiy s ues Pl ntf e e e o y wih ver lc pli t ofl rba k pan,a hi l rba k s ai ifpr s ntd nl t ba om a n s owe c i nd s owe c howe d no sgnsofbr sng,r dne s s li o de or t i uii e s , welng, r f miy.On papia i t t l rba k a e , l t tons o he owe c r a Pli ifr s nde dl thurs' Pl i ifde a d t bet ke t ahos t lf X r ys a ntf e po d,t-ha t. antf m nde o a n o ' pia or a . Al o g t ij re a pe dmio t Nu s J ne , h d cd dt k e P an ifh u e i t t u h he n u is p re n r o re o s s e e ie o e p litf o s d n he h mor s e uppo tvebedsi t m e c ldepa t e untlt f c lt doc o c de m i Pli tf . ri n he di a rm nt i he a iiy t r oul xn ne a n if3 Nur eJ sc acedt doc or who o de e Tylnola Fl xe i,amus er a r s one ont t he t , r rd e nd e rl cl elxe . Two da a trt a i nt t f iiy doc o e m i d Pl ntf a di ys fe he ccde , he aclt t r xn ne ai if nd agnos t ed he c ompl ntasl ai umba sr n.The docoror r Tylnolf fvem or da ,Flxe i f rt n mor r tai t de ed e or i e ys e rl o e e da ,a f Pl ntf t r m an i t m e ca de rm e f moniorng. ys nd or ai if o e i n he di l pa t nt or t i Pli ifr m ane i t medialde rme t i M a c 4. Durngt ttme, s s antf e i d n he c pa t nt mtl r h i ha i nur e c ke on Pl i ifdal a hedi no c hec d antf iy, nd d t ompl i o pai e e a utmid s r ne son an f n xc pt bo l oe s Fe ua y 27.No t l s Pli ifdi no e bi s f rng pa n on o he d .Fore m pl br r nehees , antf d t xhi t ufe i i t r ays xn e, o Fe a y 24,Pli tf wa c n bnz r a n if s onve sng wih ot ri t swhie o li bed wih bot l gs ri t he nma e l n ls t h e ta por va wa a et co i drvi t t J lwiho is r ns t n s bl o ntnue i ng o he ai t ut sue. 3 ematessi teme ia d p rme t r aj sa l a daetik ra ds rt ntergla Th trse n h dc l e at n ae du tbe n r hc e n ohe ha h e t r l m ate s i ot rc l. tr s es n he els 2 puled u a be knee . On Fe ua y28, ai ifwa m ovi i t c lwihoutc l p nd nt s br r Pl ntf s ng n he el t ompli . ant On M a c 4,Pl ntf t d m e c lsa fhewa ç rh ai if ol di a t f sç good't ber l s d ba k t ge r lpopul ton. ' o eea e c o ne a ai On Ap i 1, 6,a J la nita o t d NureJ rl 201 ai dmi sr t r ol s onest add Pl i ift t medial o antf o he c a nt ntls be a ePl i iffl d af m co ai ng a ppoi me it c us antf ie or mpl ni boutba k pai r l t dt t c n e a e o he a ci nti Fe u r Nur eJ c de n br a y. s oness he e t a nt e f Aprl4,201 Pli ifc m e c dul d he ppoi m nt or i 6. antf n t medialt be s e butr f e t pa t me c f e,sa i çlm no pa ng f t s Yo o c o en e us d o y he di al e ttng, ç' t yi or hi . u a 1a e tdoi a hi ' Pl i ifwasta f reda 1 r n' ng nyt ng. antf ' r ns e r wayf o t J lon Aprl4, r m he ai i 2016. Plitf a lsDee d n sf rlalig t r s o dra o bl't hsc mp an o b c an iffu t fn a t o i iln j o e p n e s na y'o i o lit f a k f pan be a ehe di notr c i X r ys a M Rl o aCT s a Pl i ifc ude t tNlr e i c us d e e ve a , n ,r c n. antf oncl s ha zs J s, one ' Newl nd',a Ga sa t a o isonsc nsi et i a s nd ddy' c s nd m s i o tmt he mposton ofc e a ii nzl nd t ua pt s e .Pl ntf a s c ude t tDef nda si eala e ' i thi f slng mus l pihm nt ai if lo oncl s ha e nt G t it d'agans m or i r a i sr tve g i va s dm nita i re nce . II. De e nt fl d amotoh t d s ist tpr e si o a i outi t pl a ngst t f nda s ie i o im s ha es nt nf e ton sde he e di ha t c ur wilnote l he o t l xcude. Cons ue ty, hec tte t t m o i t dim isa amoto f r eq n l t our r a s he ton o s s s in o s mma yj d me t4 A pa' i e tte t s mmayj g n i t ep e dn ,heds ls d u r u g n. zy s nild o u r ud me t f h la igs t ico e t ma e i l o fl ,a a a fda t s t ras n ie nd ny fi vis how t tt r i no ge nedipu east a ma e i f t ha he e s nui s t o ny t ral ac. F d R. v. 5 () M aeilfcsa eto en c s ayt e tbl hteee n so apat s e . Ci P. 6 a. tra a t r h s e e s r o sa i h lme t f ry' s c u eo a to An e s nv. b ryLo b .nc, 7 U. 2 2 2 ( 9 6 .A g n i ds t a s f cin. d r o Lie t b y I .4 7 S. 4 , 48 1 8 ) e une ipue o m a e i f c e ssi,i vi ngt r or a a 1r as bl i er nce d a t r fom i f t ral a t xit f n ewi he ec d nd 1 e ona e nf e s r wn he e r n a lg mos f vo a et t no m ovi pa t ar as bl f tfnderc dr tln aver c f r i ht t a r bl o he nng ry, e ona e acoul e t r dit o 4TheParisr ceve r s bl a e ii notc t tt cou ma c te e i d ea ona e nd xplct ie ha he rt y onver amotont dimist t i o s s hat rfrn e matr o tietepe dng it amoinfrs mmayj d me twh nteClr is e atmey eee c s tes usd h la i s no to o u r u g n e h ek su d i l Ro e r n tc .S eFe R. v P.1 () Ro e oov Garsn, 28F.d3 9 31 (t Ci. 9 ) sboo oie e d. Ci. 2 d; sb r . rio 5 2 0 , 0 4h r 1 75. 3 t non- va t J Themovi paryha t bzde ofs wi - tha i,poi i ou t t he mo n. Z ng t j he lr n ho ng t t s ntng t o he t dititc t t tt r i an a e e ofe de t s src our - ha he e s bs nc vi nce o uppor t nonmovi pa t sc e. t he ng ry' as ' ' Ceoe Co p v Cart, 7 U. 31 , 2 ( 9 6 .l t mo a ts tsistt bld n t nt e ltx r . . tet4 7 S. 7 3 5 1 8 ) f he v n aife ls t e ,he h i r non- ova mus s tf t s ik f c st tde onsr t t e se eofa g nui diput of m nt t e orh pect a t ha m ta e he xit nc e ne s e uppore s c ai n td pe ul to fctf til5 LJ a 322- .tM ereuns a or ra. I, t 24 G . . . . i no e s t nought dee ta o fa s mmayj d me tmo in. En i v Na 'As ' o Bus & Ed . d o I .5 F.d5 , 2 u r u g n to ' ns . tl sn f . uc Ra i .nc, 3 3 5 6 ' ( t Ci. 9 5 . A pat i e t ldt s mmayj d me t f h r c r a awh l c udn t e d 4h r 1 9 ) ry s ni e o u r u g n i t e e o d s oe o l o la t ar to ltiroff tt fnd i fvo o t non- o n . W iln sv. ifn,95 F. 820,823 ai na re ac o i n a r f he m va t li m Grfi 2 2d ( t Ci.1 91.A plitf c n o u ear s o s t amo inf rsl r j d me t on n 4h r 9 ) an if n n t s e p n e o to o l mma y u g n t me d o c re tac mplitc aln e b temoinf rsl r u g n .Cl a ia rv. r or c o an h l g d y h to o l e mmayj d me t o nn e M c vt, 5 F.d3 4 3 6(t Ci. 0 ) De it5 5 3 2 , 3 4h r 20 9 . A g ven n o t a s du d rj 1 8 ma iv k q ai di li Co p r o r me t fkil ue n e 9 3 y n o e u l mml t se n y. o e v. Sh e n 7 5F.d 1 3 1 8(t Ci. 01 )(iigM ic el Fo s 4 2U.. 1 5 6 e ha , 3 3 5 , 5 4 h r 2 3 ctn th l v. rgh, 7 S 51 , 2 ( 98 :.Th d crn ofq lse i nt G aa c st i ra titr sst en e t h l 1 5 G e o tie uai d mmu iy b ln e wo mpo tn ne et-h e d o od publcofi il ac t a ewhe t y e r iepowe ir s i fca s comt bl n he xe c s r re ponsbl a t nee t s e d i y nd he d o hil V of al f o ha as me ,ditaci n,a la lt whe t pe f t i dute r a ona y.' fci s r m r s nt sr te nd i biiy n hey ronn her is e s bl '' 5 anifsb if ep n et temoinfrs mmayj d e ti meeyab if n i n t nasd vt r Plitf' re rs o s o h t o u r u gn n s rl re a d s o a f a io o d caain, n tu ,td e n t o tmt a misbee ie c .S eF d R. v P. 6 c()(ç afd vt r e lrto a d h s i o s o c nsi e d sil vd n e e e . Ci. 5 ()4 6 fia io An de a ai us d t s clr ton e o uppor oroppo amo i mus bemadeonperona kno edge s toutf cst twoul be t se ton t s l wl , e a t ha d a misbl i e ie c , n s o ta teafa t rd caa tsc mpee totsiyo tematr sae .) seas d si e n vd n e a d h w h th f n o e lrn i o tn t etf n h tes ttd'; e lo ' Mc i 5 U. a 1 3(9 3 (( eh v ne e s g etdta p o e ua rlsi odiaycvlliains o l . Nel 08 S.t 1 1 9 ) çWq a e v r u g se h t r c d rl ue n r n r ii i g to h ud , ç t bei er ee s ast e us mitke by t ewhopr edwihou co el Asweha not bef e,i t l nt pr td o o xc e sa s hos oce t t uns . ve ed or n he ong nm,e re etac t tsrc ad rnc t t pr dm alr quie e ss cfedby t l saur i t bes xpeinc e hes ha tit hee e o he oce e r m nt pe ii he egilt e s he t gu rne o e n n e a miitaino telw. (nen l o moea dq oaiàmakso te l; o r a v aa te f veha d d d nsrto f h a ' itra f o t n u tto r mitd)J u d n . ' J b , 51F.d 1 8 1 9 1 ( t Ci.1 91 (odn ta ap oK lia ti n te tte t s e il o sd rto t a e 9 2 0 , 0 -0 6h r 9 ) h lig h t r ig n s o nild o p ca c nieain o t e us af ilr t f l asr i f wad pr e a r quieme t ta1y pe s n ca c xc e alze o olow taghtor r oc dur l e r nt ha a r o n ompr he asea iy a a e nd sl s lwy r.Co s q e t tec u teest tev rte c mplitwhihsr e a a a a it tee tn te a e) n e u nl h o rrfr o h ei d o an, c ev s t n xd vt o h xe th y, i al tonsar bas o pe s nallnowl a i lbe aly c tue a t lgalcai . Se e. .Hai v. legai e ed n r o t edge nd s i r l onsr d s o e l ms e. c. nes Ken r40 U. 51 , 2 - (97 ) Ca syv Bao ,1 2F.d7 5 8 3n4(t Ci. 9 8; iimsv GrTm, r e, 4 S. 9 5 021 1 2 ; u e . lg 6 3 9 , 0 . 4h r 1 9 ) W ln . i l 9 2F.d8 0 8 3(t Ci. 9 ) 5 2 2 , 2 4h r 1 91. 4 S t v Ra , 81F.d 9 ,1 0(t Ci. 01 )( u tn Pe ro v Calh n, 5 U. 2 , 31 mi . y 7 3 5 0 4h r 2 5 q o ig as n . la a 5 5 S. 23 2 h ( 0 9 Th ç uai e i l t a ay i t pc l iv le t iq iis ()wh t r h 2 0 :. e ç lf d mml y n lss y ial n ov s wo n u re : 1 ehe t e q i ni y plitf h se tbihe tevilto o ac n ttto a rg t a d ()wh t rt trg t s anif a sa ls d h oain f o si in l ih, n 2 ehe ha ih wa u c e ry esa ihe a t tme oft alege vi a i ' ub v.Cn l a l t bls d t he i he l d olton. 'Ra mpbel 785F. 8 881 l, 3d 76, (t Ci. 01 ) s eI r Ale ,1 6F.d5 2 5 3(t Ci. 9 7 (t no fca ma cam 4h r 2 5 ; e n e ln 0 3 8 , 9 4h r 1 9 ) çA) fiil y li ( q lfe i l t asl ashi aci nsa eno cla l e t bls d t be be ua ii d mmlniy ong s to r t e ry sa ihe o yond t bo he unda i res o hsds rto ay a t o iy' .A ç o r ma a d e st s t q sinsi t eo d r. .ha f i icein r uh rt .) ç u t y d r s hee wo ueto n h r e . t t ' c wilbes f c lt t t f i a e fc e diposton ofe h c e. Esa eofAr sr v.Vil o l t a iia e he ar nd f i nt s ii ac as ' t t ' m ton: l. f Pi h rt 81 F.d8 2 8 8( t Ci. 1 )(nen l u tto mak o te ) A plitY s ne u s, 0 3 9 , 9 4h f 20 6 itr a q oain r s mitd . an i cam t u vv ss mma yj d me t h we r ot i Eh c u t a s rs bohq e to i t e li ç r ie u r u g n , o ve, ly f t e o rj n wer) t u sins n h s l a fr tve' l fimai -' d. 11 1. A. Pli tf f ist alegea f t h ol ng Tr nta f ist a lget tt Aut iy ha a n if a l o l ny acs w vi e nd a l o le ha he hort s a of i polc orc t t tc us d a de i ton ofaconsiu i rght Net rTf ntnor n scal i y usom ha a e prva i tt tonal i . ihe e t Aut rt i la e unde at or ofr s he ho iy s i bl r he y e ponde ts pe i . Se eg. M onel v. p' ofSoc. a u ror es . , l De t S l .43 U.. 5 , 6 n7 6 - 4( 9 8 ; ha v. to ,1 F.d7 , 9 ( t Ci.1 9 ) ews, 6 S 6 8 6 3 ., 919 1 7 ) S w Sr ud 3 3 91 7 9 4h r 9 4 . Ac o dn l , e ta dt Au h rt a ee tte t s mmayj d e t c r ig y Trn n he t o i r nild o u r u m n . y B. Plitf fist s w t a Ne a , d y o Nt s J ne wa a r o o jcie an if al o ho h t wlnd Ga d , r l e o s s wae f be t r v e de efom whih a i e e was( awn t ta s t ta rs ofhn m e se t tt y vi nc r c n nfr nce I r ha ubsmzil ik r xit d, ha he d ew t ti e e ,a t tt y f ie t r s ndr a ona y t t rs Acc r ngl t y a e r ha nf r nce nd ha he a ld o e po e s bl o he ik. o di y,he r e tte t ml r j g n . nild o mmay ud me t 5 A pli ifmus s antf t how t tade e nta t wih de i r t i fe e et a s rous ha f nda ced t lbe a e ndif r nc o e i media ne d t sae ac am t rt Ei ht Am e c l e o t t l i mde he g h ndme . F es v.At ns 487U . 42,48 nt t ki , S. ( 9 8 ; tl v Gn l, 2 U. 9 ,1 4( 9 6 ; r rv. r ly 4 F.d2 0 2 2(t 1 8 ) Esel . mb e 4 9 S. 7 0 1 7 ) Come Domel, 2 3 2 , 2 4 h e Ci. 9 4 .Dei eaei ifrnc rq ie asaea t r oh v b e pes n l a r o fcs r 1 9 ) lb rt ndfee e e ur s tt co t a e e n ro al wae f a t y i c tng as t nta rs ofs doushn m,a t a t m us ha a t ly r c z d t ndi a i ubsa i l ik e r nd he c or t ve cual e ogni e he e itn eo s c ars F r rv. e na , 1U. 8 5 8 8( 9 4 .S eieaei ifrn e x se c f u h ik. a me Brn n 51 S. 2 , 3 1 9 ) r lb rt ndfee c ma bede y monsr t d by et ra t lit nto r c e sdir ga d.'M ite v. r 896F. ta e ihe c ua n e r e kl s se r ' lir Beo n, 2d 8 , 51(t Ci. 9 0 ; e Pars e rl Le v Clvea d, 7 F.d2 4 3 3( t Ci. 0 4 48 8 4h r 1 9 ) s e rih x e. e . e ln 3 2 3 9 , 0 4h r 2 0 ) (( h e ie emus s w ta t o fca i q sins be tveyrc g z dt a hi a to ç T1 e vd nc ç t ho h t he fiiln ueto u j ci l e o nie h t s cins weeç a prp it i l h o t a rs ') $ d fn a ta t r c lsl b d se r iga r i p o rae n i t f h t ik.'. ç ee d n cs e ke sy y irgadn n g ' A s tnta rs ofda ubsa i l ik ngert ti et rknown t t de e nto whi h woul bea r ntt a ha s ihe o he f nda r c d ppa e o r s bl pe s i t de e n ' posto ' M ite ,8 F. a 8 - A he t c e ea ona e r on n he f nda t s ii n. ' lir 96 2d t 51 52. alh ar pr vi rm a bedelber t y i fe e whe t te t e pr de i s gr sy i ompe e , o de y i ael ndif r nt n he r am nt ovi d s o os l nc t nt i quae,o e es i a t s k t c c e eori i olr bl t fmdn e t f i es I nade t r xc sve s o hoc he ons inc s nt e a e o l m n al am s. d. a 8 A s rousmedialne i ac ton t tl sbee di nos d by aphyscan a t 51. e i c ed s ondii ha t ha n ag e ii s ma tng te t nto o t ti s obvi t te n a1 y pe s woul ea iy r og z t ndai r a me r ne ha s o ous ha ve a r on d sl ec ni e he n c siyf rad co ' atnin. I v. h e , 3 F.d2 , 41(t Ci. 0 8 . e e st o o trs te to ' ko S rve 5 5 3 25 2 4 h r 2 0 ) ' lbe a ey ndif r nt at a e Bo h med c a non- e ca pe s t i al nd m di l r onne ma bedei r t l i fe e . A he lh c r l y . pr vi rmay bede i r t y i f e e whe t te t e pr de i s gr sy i mpe e , o de lbe ael ndif r nt n he r am nt ovi d s o os l nco t nt i deq t ore es i a t s k t c cinç ori i olr bl t f na uae, xc sve s o hoc he ons e e s nt e a e o unda nt lf r s . me a aine s M ite ,896 F. a 851.A non- di a prs n of i lm a bede i r t l i f e e twhe t lir 2d t me c l io sc a y lbe a e y ndif r n n he o fcalwaspe s nal i ve wih ade alofte t e ,dei r t l i e f r d wih aprs n f i r o ly nvol d t ni r am nt lbe a ey ntr e e t io 6 docorsteam e t ort cty a ho ied orwasdelbe atl i f e e t t m e ca pr de ' t ' r t n , a il ut rz i r e y ndif r nt o he di l ovi r s mic s onduc whe e na1ypes woul t sa t ti me c lpr de i beng t n ve a ron d mdertnd ha he dia ovi r s i delbe ael i fe e . I a 85 i r t y ndif r nt d. t 4. # ; Pl i ifsc antf ' ompl i ofl rba k pai de piea a lt t n bult di no de c a ant owe c n s t n biiy o m a e d t pit çsrousme c lne d'a doesnotdes ibet dypeofbaba teame t Eiht te i dia e ' nd c he G t r dc r t nt he g h Ame m e twasi e nd ' n nt ndedt pr ve .' Sni v. De la 9 F.d 5 6, 91 9 (t Ci. 9 6 ; o e nt' pes Tel, 5 3 8 5 -2 7h r 1 9 ) s eCo pe v Ca e 9 F.d91 , 6( t Ci.1 9 )(ttngt t n ra he a dp i d n t e o r . s y, 7 3 4 91 7h r 9 6 sai ha mio c s n ans o o rs t telv lo as ro sme ia n e ) Plitf fist d mo tae o j cieyal i a ie o h e e f ei u dc l e d . an if al o e nsr t, be t l l n v d lg t s fv rb et h m,ha a alg da u eiju te t dwihr s, ln la F e ei ih mo t a o a l o i t t n l e c t nty r ae t e tTy e o, nd lx rl e c nsi e asg ika tp y ia ij r S eS s b ev. ph , 9 F.d 1 9 1 1( t Ci. o tmts inf n h sc l nu y. e o e e Mu y 7 7 2 7 , 8 4h r 1 6 (e o nzn ( s ro me ia n e t s ly E v l s ls o lf o p r n n 98 ) r c g iig a eius dc l e d G ual i ove) o s f ie r ema e t u n d sbit , rac n iin frwh c lc o te t n p peu tssveep i' ia l y o o d to o ih a k f r ame t e t ae e r anl. i Pl i iff ist e t bls N e a so Gaddy' delbe a ei fe enc r lt d t t antf a l o sa ih wlnd' r s i r t ndif r e ea e o he pur td one- y de a f ram e ca e mi ton.6 See eg. W e v. m i llh,281F. pore da l y o di l xa nai . . , bb Ha dtla Ap x 1 9 1 6 (t Ci. 0 8 ( n Eih hAme d n vo ain o yo c r, o v r i t p' 5 , 6 4 h r 2 0 ) $ W gt n me t ilto nl c u s h we e,f he delyr ulsi s s tntalha m t t paint' Thee de ei notdiputdt t a es t n ome ubsa i r o he te .). vi nc s s e ha Plitf t l Ne a a dGa d u o a viga t eJ i h wa j kn a o tn e igme ia anif o d wlnd n d y p n ni n t h al e s o ig b u e dn d c l c r .S eJ h o v. io e ,1 5F.d 1 4,1 8 6 (t Ci. 9 )( oi t a a o fca ae e o ns n Oun n s 4 3 6 6 - 9 4h r 1 98 n t h t n fiil ng mus a t ly d a t i e e t ta i a e ss t cual r w he nf r nce ha n nm t ' ympt m ssg f t pr s nc o apa tc a o i niy he e e e f ri ulr c ton a t taf iur t dr w s h a i e e em a pr e ac am f ne i nc butno ondii nd ha a l e o a uc n nf r nc y es nt l i or glge e t 6Plitf a k o e g sh s san dt alg dij r a ac nsq e c o a a cd n a dn t rm a y anif c n wld e e u tie he le e nu y s o e u n e f n c ie t n o fo n itnin l c b Ne a dp Ga d .Cf Jb a v. se, 8 F.d5 , 7(dCi. 01 ) Co sq e ty ti c s ne to à a t y wln r d y . a b r Fih r6 3 3 4 5 2 r2 2 . n e u nl,hs a e i ce rydsig ih be9o Th mosnv Co n at No. 5 7 6 , l o a 1 -9(t Ci. c 1 , s lal itn us a l m o o . mmo wel h, 1 - 8 0 si p.t 8 1 4h r De . 8 p 2 7 .I Th mpsn,n imaesae atibl EihhAme d n e c siefrecam a an t c re t na 01 ) n o o a n t ttd ra e g t n me t x esv o c li g is a orci l o ofke bec us t tox ce ale y dr veata por vanwiht i e t ha m t i t i i t r a e ha r lgedl o r ns t t he ntnt o r he nmae nsde. 7 acam u d rteEihh Ame d n) Ac o dngy Ne a da d Ga d a ee tte t li n e h g t n me t. c r i l, wln n d y r n i d o l q aiid i ni a d s mmayj d me t o t i cam. u lfe mmu t n u r u g n f r hs li y Pli iff l t esa ih Ntr eJ ne 'delbe aei fe e e.W hie Pli ifma ha antf ais o t bls ts o s i r t ndif r nc l antf y ve wa e t got ahos t lf ra X r y,M Rl o CT s a Ntr eJ ntd o o pia o n a ,r c n, ls onese l t d hi a vaua e m nd r f r e hi t t f c lt docùrf f l w - Ntr eJ sas s ug pr s rptonst e e r d m o he a iiy t or olo up. ls one lo o ht e c i i o ma nagePli ifsdic f ta hadPl ntf tm por rl r a sgne t t m e c de me antf s om or nd ai if e a iy e s i d o he dial pm nt f m or co f t ebe ng durng t i e i .Ntr eJ sl ke t a hort t or rt or e m orabl ddi i he nt rm ts one ac d he ut iy o de he s htdi nosi t ss a Pli ipsdia e nta ta c s ofteam e doesnotsa ea oug ag tc e t , nd a ntf s gr eme bou oure r t nt tt n a to a ecam.W rc tv Coln , 6 F.d 8 ,8 9( t Ci.1 8 ) Ac o dn l Nms cin bl li ih . lis 7 6 2 41 4 4h r 9 5 . c r igy, e J ne i e t ldt q aiidi nt a d s mmo j d me f rti cam. o s s ni e o u lfe mmu i n u t y u g nt o h s li C. Pli iff l t pr e a hi m or t n aco l o y al ga i ofr t lai n.Adn s antf ais o es nt nyt ng e ha ncus r le ton e ai to m v Rie 4 F.d7 , 4(t Ci.1 9 ) Plitf r l so t ewo dçeaito 'nt . c , 0 3 2 7 4h r 9 4 . anif ei n h r ç tlain'i he e r c ompli t buthef ist de c i t r t la o y a t o ison,ora t r Acc di y, an, a l o s rbe he e a it r c , m s i co . or ngl Dee d nsaee t ldt s mma yj d me tfrt i cam. fn a t r ni e o u r u g n o hs li t I V. Fort f e ng r s , diput ofma e i lf c e ss andDefnda sa e e il he or goi ea ons no s e t ra a t xit , e nt r ntted t sl r u g n . ol mma yj d me t EN TER : Thi s > o De e e, 0 #. y f cmb r 2 . l).. ' ('i j::' ; t; -L ( .- , 'f *rz. '# / . ' . . . . . ChifUri Stt s ' 1tJ e e lt ae c udg 8 . ,z. -