Hale v. State of Tennessee et al, No. 7:2016cv00552 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/29/2016. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERKS OFFI U. DI COUFF CE S. ST. AT ROANOKE, VA FIED L I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A ROANOK E DI SI VI ON TH O M AS D.H A LE , d2V 32 2 1 96 J . oul c R ux BY; . LERK CA SE N O .7: 16CV 00552 Pl ntf , ai i f V. M EM ORANDUM OPI ON NI STATE OF TENNESS c AL. EE, , By: G l E .C onrad en Chi fUnie St esDit i tJudge e t d at src De e f ndant . Tho a D.Hae,a Tem e s i t pr ee ng nr K ,fl d tls cvi a ton agans m s l l s ee nma e oc di o ie li i l c i i t nlm e ous Te s e sa e ofi i s a ot r ,i l ng Ator y Ge r lErc Hol r The l r nne s e tt fcal nd he s ncudi t ne ne a i de . c ompli ls sva i wr ,crm e ,and l ga t msand ciesTe s ee a f de all ws as a nt it rous ongs i s e l er t nne s nd e r a , w elas phr s s s l a e ugge tng f der lc tt i lc am s1 Li r ly c t ung t a l a i ns si e a onsim ona l i . be a l onsr i he leg to , t c tdoc tdt pla ngasacvirght compl ntt r42U. C.j1 3andorBi ns he our kee he e di i li s ai mde S. 98 / ve v.Si Un n wn Nn d Ag n so Fe Bt e u o Nac tc ,4 3 U. 3 8 (9 ) Be a e x ko me e t f d. l a f r ois 0 S. 8 1 71 . c us r Hae ha notpr pad t r quiie flng f e,t c tas umesf pu pos softzsopi on t t l s e i he e st ii e he our s or r e li ni ha h i s e i t pr c e L f r pa p rsl e 2 U. C. 1 5 e s e kng o o e d q o ma u ei md r 8 S. j 91 .Upo rv e o terc r , n e iw f h e o d 1 Theco ai be ns mpl nt gi : . Nofln ti Wrt(et a an thep aea d d> iyo a b t s a saeas rc eern iig hs i ts) g is t e c n i t f nd y hee nd tt lo ak teig ifu n e (e r a d c r zt og nz to s a d g n s w/eieae idfee c s nle c s p e) n o np r a iain n a g d l rt n ifrn e b d lyigp oo gigt cu lmu a gi)e c siefree fre a o fn e- a an t ro s ea n /r ln n he re t s l sc x e sv oc no c d nd fe s s g is pesn , ofe e a ns pr y ofe e - agans fmiy,c t r ofe es ofe e agans publc fns s gai t oper f ns s i t a l ompu e fns , fns s i t i Hale v. State of Tennessee et al h at s ft,wefr T. A. 3 - 11 tr u h j3 -7 14 a dT. A.j4 - - 01tr u h e l aey lae C. j 9 1 -01 h o g - 9 1 - 5 n C. 035 1 h o g h j403 - 4.TieV1a dTil VI o a dt i wok e u ain-tet ns o ohe p o ms - 551 t l n te I n n o n r , d c to , rame t, r t r r pa , asg me t, d u tsig o-- o vcige ) flns rsrci /d b dc l o isi ina sin ns r g etn f c n itn td eo , etit e e /el r ntmto l ng asg me t,r t j bc mp n ain lv l, s i iay a t n a s n to s dsrmiain sin ns imae o o e sto e es dicpl l- ci s nd a cin , ici n to , i n o oii r c,ec Libite a c r a d stsato w/r tain Eija a r as mpin o rgn, a e t. a l is c od n aifcin abi to sc nd wad, su to f i r Doc. 2 rs ex esed, c ik pr s ompa ai ful i udi t i ntt or des i in of a oher alged r tve a t ncl ng he de iy crpto ny t le trfa o ,dshag i b n u ty d rs,etp es fiueo c nsd rto s fa d ilg ly ote sn) ic re n a krpc , ue s so p l,alr f o ieain , ru ,le ai , t lc e , o ti tr n gie e l e s,p yme t rla e rsj dct, tteo ga d ,sau o ah s c nr oy e l nc ,i n e a n , ee s, e u iaa sau f u s tt e f bu g c l tto s sau o rp s : ie,( r esc mpe sto K uaiidi iiu l i nt, n i ain , tte f e o e wav r wo k r o n ain û lte ndvd a' mmu iy a d mi q ' a ot mater c tt l a afimatv ofens - e ng a adeens ., nhy her t s onsiutng n fr ie f e -defndi s f e, ( mpl2 ECFNo. . Co . , 1) Dockets.Justia.com t c u t st tt a to mus besz rl d s se wih u p eu ie b s d o Haes he o r fnd ha he cin t l mmaiy imis d t o t rj dc , a e n l ' m a prorci la tonst tha be n dim is d.2 ny i vi c i ha ve e s s e ThePrs Lii to Reor Ac of 1 s tntal a nde t L f ion tgain f m t 995 ubsa ily me d he q onna Da rs upei sa ue 2 U. C. 1 5 Th p r o eo t eAc wa t rq ieal rs n rcv lii a t t p y tt t, 8 S. j 91 . e u p s f h t s o e ur l p io e ii l g ns o a t flng f e i 1 1,et rt o h pr pay e ort ough i t lme swihhed fo t ltga ' ii e s n 1 ihe hr ug e m nt hr nsa l nt t l ' m he ii nts r i t tus ac ot . j 1 5( . Seci 1 5( de e t i tlme pa ntmehod t nmae r t c mt 91 b) ton 91 g) nis he nsal nt yme t o prs r who ha t hr e srkes'- t e prs s who ha had t ee pr vi c e or ione s ve t e ti ' t hos ioner ve hr e ous as s a a sdim is asfi ous m a ii us orf f lle t sae a cai ,unl s t t e srke ppe l s s ed rvol , lc o , or aitr o t t l m e s he hr e-ti r i maes o Gmmi e t a g ro s ro sp y ia ij r ' j 1 5 g . n t h ws t n n d n e f ei u h sc l nu y. i ' 91 () Cour r c ds r fec t t Hae ha had nlm e ous pdor cvi aci dim is d a t e or el t ha l s l r i l tons s s e s fi ous ma i ous orf f l e t sa e a c am . See e. ,Ha e v.St t ofM i M i a rvol , lci , or aiur o tt li , c. l ae ne nd nd S ae o Emeg nce , .1 1 - 4 tt f r e is No :6 CV- 21HSM- KI ( D.Tem.Oc.21 2 6 ( r e fn i S , E. r t , 01 ) o d r i dng tr eç tie 't e 28U.. j1 5 g a dr ci g Haet p e a $ 0 fln fe (iig h e l rk s' md r s SC. 91 ( ) nd ie tn l o r p y 40 ii g e ) ctn Haev Lo , 10 -v 1 0 ( . Te n. u e2 , 0 7 ( r e ds sigc s f rf ilet l . nc No. :6 c - 1 9 W D. n J n 6 2 0 ) o d r imisn a e o alr o t saeacaml Haev Lo , 19 -v 0 1 ( . Tem. a 2, 9 6 (r e d s si c s tt li ; l . ng No. :5 c - 1 1 M D. r M y 1 9 ) o d r imisng a e a gi lu l Haev. il ms No 19 -v- 1 ( . Te n. e t 2 ,1 9 )(r e ds sig s voo s; l W li , . :4 c 0 45 M D. n S p . 0 9 4 o d r imisn n c s a fio o s;Hae v.Rh a No.39 - c - 81 ( . Te n.S pt 1 , 1 9 ) (r e a e s rv l u l l e, :4 v 0 2 M D. n e . 9 9 4 o d r d s si g c s a f o o s;Hae v.Bo d No.19 -v 01 ( . Te n S p .1 , 1 9 ) imisn a e s Hv l u l l y, :4 c - 41 M D. n . e t 4 9 4 ( r e ds s ig c s a fio o s;Haev.Co k, 1 1 -v 1 6 ( D. r M a 2 20 6 o d r imisn a e s rv l u l l o No. :6 c - 0 E. Tem. y , 1 ) ( de lsi Hae' j1 5( c es de nghi L f mapa rssaus a die tnghi t or r itng l s 91 g) as , nyi m q or upei tt , nd rci m o 2 Thec tr ni salkei our ecog ze i lhoodt tve mos pr ry lesi t Unie Stt DititCou'f t ha nue t opel i n he t d aes src r or he t Easem Ditit o Teme s e,whee Hal i c rnty conf d a ma de e nt ae a e l e oyed. t src f r s e r e s ure l me nd ny f nda s r pparnty mpl Bec us t a ton mus ce l bes a e he c i t lary umma iy dimis d bas d o Hae' prorfi ousl uis ho ve ,t c t rl s s e e n l s i rvol aws t, we r he om' c ncu e t a ds sa o ti c s wi o tpeudc,rte t n ta fr frhestee so j tc . S e 2 o ld s h t imisl f hs ae t u rj ie ah r ha rnse, u t r h nd f usie e 8 h U. C.j 1 6a ( dsrc c u to adsrc i whc i fld ac s lyig v n i tewr n dvso o S. 40 () ç The itit o r f itit n ih s e ae a n e ue n h o g iiin r dsrc salds s,o i i b i teitrs o j sie ta se sc c s t a y dsrc o dvso i whc i itit h l imis r f t e n h neet f u tc ,rn fr u h ae o n itit r iiin n ih t c udh v b e b o g t'. o l ae en ru h ' ) I / ' - p yt ef l fln fe ; l v, tee No 3:2 c 0 6( . Tem. a 1 , 2 (n l a d a h ' l iig e ) Hae S e l, . 1 -v-47 M D. r M y 8 201 ) sme ; n u Hae v. CX, .11 -v 1 3 ( . Te n. c 2 ,2 1 ta l. Be a eHae ce dy l NW No : 1c - 08 W D. n De . 8 01 ) s mel c us l la h st 'eGtie 't e j1 5 g , l ma p o e dL f r p u rs( t u p e y n o a l e G rk s'md r 9l () Hae y r c e q o ma a pei wi t rpa me t f u s ho t sln fe o l i h c n s o ta h f c s i n n d n e o s ro sp ysc lij r he i g e ) ny f e a h w h t e a e mmie t a g r f ei u h ia nu y. j1 1 ( ) 9 5g. l ae' c l l s ompl i us s Eng ih wor ant e ls ds a nd pt t a i mc u ton, but i o he wie s t r s i m pr he i e.3 The co tfndsno a lga i s nco e nsbl ur i le ton ugge tng t tHal i i i mi ntda rof si ha e s n m ne nge s ro sp y ia ij r s a t alw hm t pr c e wi t lws i wi u p e y n o t e eiu h sc l nu y o s o l i o o e d t Ms a ut t t rpa me t f h o h ho flng f M or ove ,Ha eha c e ry be n no i d by ma pa tdim is o de sofhi çlr ii ee. e r l s l a l e tse ny s s s al r r s flee t srke' s t . Ac odigy, h c u twi s mma y d s s t ec mpan wih u p eu ie ti s' Gt s c r n l t e o r l u dl imis h o lit t o t rj d c z l u d rj 1 5 g . An a r p it o d rwi is t i d y.Thecek wi malHae ac p o n e 91 ( ) pp o rae r e l sue h s a l lr l i l o y f l t tor ra t sme or nd opi on. ha de nd hi m a um ni ENTER:Th s %R d yo No mb r 2016. i a f ve e , ClifU ie Stt sDititJ le t d a e src udge 3 Forexa pI , Hal sa es: d eas be advied 1' w/ s onanceconcer ng s lve i boxi m e e tt < e pl s m dis ni ome i -n ng or sr tfght anywher do t m y expr s greft r d i and haler f m ed s 1 know 1m a prze tee i s e o es ed i u ne n t ed or o ' i a wo tbeltdo j tIk a t r8b a WTSP X3 t stme bak t b c beor o fn d o nd n' e wn us ie nohe t hi i c o a k f e fe de n c utro fns ' ( omp e fe e. Compl4. ' .) 3 1 I
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
