Owlfeather-Gorbey v. Bowles et al, No. 7:2016cv00544 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 12/6/2016. (kab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
I THE UNI N TE: STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN bI TRI OF VI NI S CT RGI A CLERK' AT CE U.S. ST COURT S OFFI DI . DANVILE,VA F L IE LD 0 2S 2 1 EC 25 R A OQDVSActi No.7:16-cv-0054%EPU7YCLxjx O N I IIQ on E Ci IN BuMr uRK a Yuc sc Jt xaE ;; t vi l MI CHAEL S.OW LFEATHERGORBEY,) Pl ntf, ai if ) ) ) ) J.BOW LES,e aI, t . ) Dee fndant. s ) 1 M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI By: Hon. ks L.Kie Jac on sr Se orUnie St esDititJudge ni t d at src #' . M iha lS. f a he - be ,af de a i a epr e ng pr K ,co me e t scvi c e Owle t r Gor y e r l nm t oc edi o m nc d hi i l ac i n ptr ua t Bi ns v.Si U nknown N a e A ge s ofFe Btr a (fN a c i s 403 U . to l s nt o ve x m d nt d. te u l r otc , S. 38 , 9 (9 ) b No e r1 , 01 Atteo e o t a to ,hec u t nnte Plitf 8 38 1 71, y v mbe 4 2 6. h nst f he cin t o r pe itd an if t a yt pr e L f mapa rsbuta s Pli ift ts hpemisonwo dbe o ppl o oc ed q or upe i dvied antf ha uc r si ul r s nde i Pl i ifhashadt e prorc esdim is d a fi ous malci ,orf f iu et e ci d f antf hr e i as s s e s rvol , i ous or al r o saeacam, u s n t 2 U. C. 1 1 () tt li p rua t o 8 S. j 9 5 g . Upon r vi w ofc t e or ,i a a sPl n ifha had a las t eeno ha ascvi e e our r c ds t ppe r aitf s t e t hr n- be i l aci nso a a spr vi l dim is d a fi ous asm ai ous orf f ii t sa eac am to r ppe l e ousy s s e s rvol , lci , or a lng o t t l i bef eflng t sac i Se Owleahe - be v. ac on. ta .N o. 1 c 00551 si o a or ii hi ton. e f t r Gor y J ks e l, 2: 6- v, lp p. t 4 ( D. . e t 2 , 01 )( imis dfrf i n t saeacam) Go b v v Th S aeo E. Va S p . 2 2 6 d s se o al g o tt li ; r e . e tt f i Vigna e a.No 2.1c 0 6 , lpo a 4 ( D. . a . 7 201 )( imis df rfiigt r iis t 1 . . -v- 01 4 si p. t E. Va M r 1 , 1 ds se o al o , 1 n saeacaml Gobe v. ie S ae . ta.No 2:8 c - 01 , l o a 34 ( D. . . tt li ; r v Untd tts e l, . 0 -v 0 21 si p. t - N. W Va p J l 7 201 )( imis df rf ingt saeacaml s e ec, r vv Fe Bt e u o Alo ö s u y , 0 ds se o al o tt li ; e . ..Go be . d. t a f c h l i r To a c s rn ms & Expo ie s ta.No. 1 -v- 0 26 si o a 5 1 ( D. . . a . b c o Fie r . lsv s e 1, 5:1c 0 1 , l p. t - 0 N. W Va M r p Owlfeather-Gorbey v. Bowles et al Doc. 4 1 201 )( ..S i r)(itn 25c s st tq aiy a srke ) s eas Co e nv. les n, 4, 2 M J, ebe t lsig a e ha u lf s ti s; e lo lma Tolfo 1 5S. .1 5 ,1 6 ( 01 )( od n aç ti 'd s sa i c l e r g r ls t t tmigo a 3 Ct 7 9 7 3 2 5 h li g t rke' imis ls omtd e ade s o he i n f s 1Pli ifsot rmoni ri M ihae Stve Go be . antf ' he ke s c l e n r y Dockets.Justia.com s b e u n a p a) M c va v. ie Sae , 6 J.d3 1 3 9(t Ci. 0 )( imis l u s q e t p e l; te n Untd tts 5 6 73 9 , 9 4 h r 20 9 ds s as wi u p eudc f rfi oo n s s ul n t ee mp e fo 2 U. C. 1 5 g ) t t rj ie o rv lus e s ho d o b xe td r m 8 S. j 91 ( ). ho Afe r viwi Pl i ifss bm isonsi tzsc vi aci n,i i cea t tPli ifdoesnot tr e e ng antf u s i n li i l to t s l r ha antf a l a f t i c tng t the i c r ntyt ra i mi ntt e tofa s ro physca lege ny acs ndi a i ha s ure l mde ny m ne hr a ny e i us i l ij r wihnt eme nngo 28U. C. 1 5 g .Se . ..Chaev. M a1y 4 6F. p' nu y t i h a i f S. j 91 ( ) e e:, s O' le , 6 Ap x 1 5 1 6 (t Ci. 01 )( o igtep io rmu t ese n rle o a dd mo srt a 8 , 8 4h r 2 2 n tn h rs ne s b e kig eif m n e n tae d n e t a i i n n a t etmeo fl t ec mplit; tu v. o nha , 5 F.d2 3 a g r h t s mmie t t h i f ii h o an) Pets M me t u 5 4 3 9 , ng 2 6( dCi. 0 9 ( tngt c mplit t e e lan x b t e t i n n d n e i 9 2 r 2 0 ) noi he o an mus r v a e us ewe n he mmie t a g r t alg sa t ecamsi a srst q aiyf ri n n - a g re c p in .Plitf srpe td le e nd h li t s et o u l o mmie td n e x e to ) an if e ae f r i e on t phr s ti m i ntda r'i a i elanc he a e tm ne nge ' s n nvoca i ofa l be a c us on t ti not ton a l nd oncl i ha s e ildt a a sz i oft t ntte o n slmpton nlh.BelAt.Co p.v.Twombl 550U. 544,555( l l r y, S. 2007) . Pl ntf' co pl i agans t de e nt c er hi al ge lmie o no a ce st ai ifs m ant i t he f nda s onc ns s le d i td r c s o prs ad i sr tver m e e .Hem e i a ac e nceofnotha ng ac es t prs ion m nita i e di s ntons s ons que vi c s o ion a miitai erme ist a heç u frs a t a pan gnd ijzis d n a o me ia En ) d n srtv e d e h t t fe lq c u l i a ! nl e , e il f dc l a d s r me iains,t rast mys ft , engke tnfo d du s ntr c lsd y wih u s o sa d d c to g h e t o j a ey b i p i lo e n a iay el a s t o t h e n we ksc mpltl to d d , (n qsafh r sme t En qmic n u t lnd mu h, c e o eey l o e gq a d tf a a' ns a d s o d cs a l c mu h s m or .''2 W hiePl n ifalege unc f ra ec tonsofc i mentand al k oft pe ik e l aitf l d om o tbl ondii onfne ac ms ct . m e cai ns he doe no de onsr t t tt e al gai c nsi ean i i ntt e tofa di to , s t m ta e ha hes le tons o tmt mm ne hr a ny s ro p ysc lij r wihnt me nn o 2 U. C. 1 1 () S e ec.Br wnvBe r , 2 eius h ia nu y t i he a ig f 8 S. j 9 5 g . e s . , o a d 49 F. u p. d4 4 4 9( D. . 0 7 ( o dn prs n rscam t tna e uaeda n ssa d S p 2 7 , 7 E. Pa 2 0 ) h l ig io e ' li ha i d q t ig o i n t e t e ofm e c lc r a m nt di a ondii c d l ad t he r di e e di nots fci nty a l e t the r tons oul e o a t s as d uf i e l leg ha a t die s wa i ndi ora utt occz) s a e s mpe ng bo o lr. 2Plitf edi anot racin fld i t sco Owleahe - be v.Bo es N o.7: 6-v- 2,t an ifnot n he to ie n hi mt f t rGor v wl , 1 c 0052 hat hew a kepti t foodedcelbet enAugus 1 a Se e r6,201 s n he l l we t 8 nd ptmbe 6. 2 Ac o dn l Id s s t ea to wih u p eu ief rPlitf sfiu et p yt sln c r igy, imis h cin t o t rj dc o an if alr o a he ig f e a t tme o flngt c e t he i f ii he ompl i a dimisa lpe ngm o i nsa m oot Se ec. Dupr e ant nd s s l ndi to s . e. . , e v. l r 28 F.d 1 3 ,1 3 ( 1h Ci. 0 2 (e s nngt a t efl gf ei d eu ntl a Pame , 4 3 2 4 2 7 1 t r 2 0 ) ra o i h t h ii e s u po ii n ng ci la tonwhe L f nnana rspr so donota yt pli ifa t tt co ti not vi ci nq o upei oviins ppl o antf nd ha he ur s r q r d t pe tpl i ifa opporuniy t pa t flng f eafe r ogni ng pl i ifi e uie o nni antf n t t o y he ii e tr ec zi antf s i ei il t p o e dL f r p u rs. n lgb e o r c e q oma a pei) ENTER:T i G+a dyo Dee e,06 hs * a f cmbr21. ç l T e ni U nie St t D i ti tJ t d a es s r c udge 3
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
