Peterson v. Phipps et al, No. 7:2016cv00457 - Document 9 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/23/2016. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
clERl' oyFl tx - ts cs l A R A OKDs c u ' T O N s ,VAm n. ; Ll W. ' FI LED I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF W RGI A CT NI ROANOKE DI I O N V SI T RO Y PETE RSO N , Pl nif, ai if V. V. IPPS c & , PII , Dee a t) fnd nts. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) N0 23 2 1 V 06 J I t.-ty' UL ' t ; ) BY: , L CASE NO.7: 16CV00457 M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI By:GlnE. nr d e Co a ChifUn td S a e DititJ ge e ie t t s src ud Tr Pe e s a Vigi a i aepr ee ng pr K ,fl d tascvi rght a ton ptr ua oy t r on, r ni nm t oc di o ie li i l i s c i ls nt . t 42U. C.j1 3,algi t twihouthi pe si e oye sofRe Oni Stt Prs o S. 98 le ng ha t s nnison, mpl e d on ae ion (1 d Onin' vi ae hi c tmto lrght bypr di c e ofhi me c r or t a G Re o ' oltd s onsi ina i s ) ovi ng opis s dial ec ds o n a t e who m a t m publcr c d.Fr Pe e s sal to , heco tfndsno f c ualor tom y de he i e or om t r on' legai ns t ur at lga bassf a a tona e cai unde j 1 e l i or n ci bl l m r 983. Acc di yst c tdimis Pee s s or ngl he our s ses tron' a to wih u p eu iea fio o s cin t o t rj d c s rv l u . 1. Pe e s s cli s i t s ca e r lt t a to t de e nt a lge y t t r on' am n hi s ea e o c i ns he f nda s le dl ook i n c n u cin wih prvo lws is Pee s n h s fld a ans Re Onin o fcas un e 4 o j n to t e ius a ut tro a ie g i t d o fiil d r 2 U. C.j 1 S. 983.I Pees v.Baks l No.7: n tron r dae, 16CV001 healege t tofi asha f l 46, l d ha fcil d aied t a c moda e hi A s tu r i i di tr ne ds ladi t weght l s I Pe e s v. o c om t s a r elg ous ea y e , e ng o i os . n t r on Ba ks e No.7:6CV00207,n ong ot rt ngs Pe e s n a lged t tof i l us d e es i r dal, 1 m he hi , t r o le ha fc as e xc sve f rea an t m, a sn hm ph sc ln u is Pee s n c mp an t ti e c o t s c s s o c g is hi c u ig i y ia ij re . tro o lis ha n a h f hee a e , Peterson v. Phipps et al Doc. 9 De e ntPli ,t Re Oni n nur i die t ,wihouthi per s i r l a e pori of f nda lpps he d o sng r c or t s mison, e e s d tons Dockets.Justia.com ,. hi m e ca r c ds1 Pee s a s a lgest tRe Oni n i si t S.M c ni G ie a s di l e or . t r on lo le ha d o nve tga or Da el l l d f rp r wi c pis o Pees n'qme ia rc r ' ( mp .3 ECF No 1) W he Pees n e o t t o e f tro s dc l e o d. Co l , h ' .. n tro dic r d t una horze r l a eofhi m e ca r or , c s ove e he ut i d e e s s di l ec ds he ompli d t W a de Bar dal ane o r n ks e. I hi j1983c ant Pee s s sPhi ,a M c nil a Baks e c e ng n s ompli , tron ue pps nd Da e, nd r dal, ontndi t t t r l as of hi r c ds wihou hi co e vi a e hi c tt i ha he e e e s e or t t s ns nt olt d s onsiutonalrght,ca i i s usng G e lh d cie'a d d mgl e d n t As Es ln t l il c a lctr' (d.4. He s e l at e l ' n a ag o e o sa siae ls h ra le . I ) h n 1 ' e ks c mp nst r a dij n tv r l f o e ao y n n u cie ei . e II. The c t i r qui e t di m i s a a ton or cl i f l d by a pr s ne aga ns a our s e r d o s s ny c i a m ie io r i t g nme a e iy orofk e i t c tc no i ntf a c ni a ecli sort c over nt l ntt f r f he our an t de iy ny og z bl am he ompli ' ant i f i ous m ai i ,or f is t sae a cli on whih r le m a be g a t s rvol , lcous a l o tt am c e if y r n ed. 28 U. C. S. 1 5 a,( )1. A fio o cam i o S a e o a id s u a l mei e slg lt e r ' 91 A() b ( ) rv lus li s ne t s d n n n ip tby rt s e a h o y' b l oronetwhos f c ua c en i a eclary bas es .'N et v.W ila ,490 U . 319,327 d e a t l ont tons r e l el s' izke li ms S. (98 )(ne ei gt etnn ' rvoo s'a smial u e i te f n r2 U. C.j 1 5 d ) 1 9 itpr tn h e t i l u ' s i lry s d n h o ne 8 S. f 91 ( ). Se ton 1 3 pe misa agg ived pa t t fl a ci la ton a i ta pe s f r a tonst ke c i 98 r t n re ry o ie vi c i gans r on o c i a n t rc o ofsa el t tvi aed hi co tt i lrght . Coo rv.She ha 735 F. 153, mde ol r t t aw ha ol t s nsiutona i s pe e n, 3d 1 ( t Ci. 01 ) 58 4h r 2 3 . Li r ly co tui Peeron' co pl nt he a s rst tt de e nt 'dis m i ton be a l nsr ng t s s m ai , s e t ha he f nda s s e na i ofhi m e ca r or vi l t hi c tt tona rg t m ant i t prva y oft e r cor s di l ec ds o aed s onsiui l i ht o i an he i c hos e ds a defm e hi .Net roft s c am shasa lgalbass nd n d m ihe he e l i ny e i. 1 C0ur r cor r l t t i No. 7: t e ds efec hat n l6CV 001 , i s 46 n uppor of t def nda s' m oton f t he e nt i or s ummay j gme t Phips s mitd a afda i,e pli ng atc d me ia rc d c c r ng r ud n, p ub te n fi vt x ani tahe dc l eors on eni Pet s sr ntcompl nt abouthi w ei ,somach pai and di tve is . Cour r cor do not er on' ece ai s s ght t n, ges i s ues t e ds r l t tPhi hass it any afi vi orm edi r dsr at t t def efect ha pps ubm ted fda t cal ecor el ed o he endant 'm oton i N o. s i n 7: 6CV00207. 1 1 l 1 l i i N et r t Unie Stt Supr m e Cour nor a c twihi t Fourh Cic tha 1 ihe he t d a es e t ny our t n he t r ui s j ! r ogni d t t i a e ha a fm dn e al c tt i na r g t pr va y i t i m e ca ec ze ha nm t s ve t m nt ons iuto l i ht o i c n he r di l if main. Ad msv.Drw,9 6 F.S p .1 5 ,1 5 ( D.Va 1 9 ) Ot rcruist nbr to n e 0 u p 0 0 0 8 E. . 9 5 . he ic t o a es tlsis ha hed tha prs r do notha a c tt i nal pr t c e e ca i n ddr s li s ue ve l i t ione s t ve onsim o ly o e t d xpe tto ofprvac i prs team e r or whe t sa e has a l gii ae pe ogi a i t r s i i y n ion r t nt ec ds n he t t e tm t nol c l n e e t n a c s t te ' Se , .. S ao v. a b r , 0F.d 5 0 5 4 (t Ci. 01 )( ingo h r c e s o h m. e ea, e tn M y e c 61 3 3 , 3 9h r 2 0 ct t e ' i c s s. Cla l,wh n a imaes j1 3 camst a o fc r 't o ttto la to ha e a e ) e ry e n n t ' 98 li h t fie s mc nsi ina cins v u c us hi ad re physc l e f t r quii me c l te t nt t sa e ha a l gii t a ed m ve s ia fecs e rng dia r a me , he t t s e tma e i e e ti i si a i t r or oft tm e c te t ntand usng t r co dsi de e ng ntr s n nve tg tng he ec ds ha dial r a me i he e r n f ndi t m s ves i t tltga i .2 The c twil s he el n ha ii ton our l umm a iy dim is Pee s s prva y c am s as rl s s tr on' i c l i fi o . rvol us Pee s n' alg to t a t ed fn a t s me o d fme hm o ij r dh srpuain tro s le ain h t h e e d n s o h w en d i r nu e i e tto by r l sng hi m e ca r cor a s f ist sa e a co tt tona vi a i aci bl t r eea i s di l e ds lo al o t t ny nsiu i l olton tona e mde j1 8 Se P u v. vs 42 U. 6 3 ( 9 6 (i dngt a ûh itr s i rpuain a sre 9 3. e a l Da i, 4 S. 9 1 7 ) fn i h t G e ne e t n e tto se td t i t s c s i neihe Gi ry'nor l ope t gua a e d a i tsa e de i ton wihoutdue n hi a e s t r lbe t pr ry' r nt e gans t t prva i t p o e so 1w' .Ac o d n l, h c u t l s mmai d s s Pees n' d fmain cam a r c s f a ' c r i gy t e o r wil u rl imis tro s en to li s ) y l gal fi o . e ly rvol us Fo te ra o sae ,te c u tds se ' tro s c mp an wi u p eu ie a r h e s ns ttd h o r imis sPees n' o lit t t rj dc s ho fi o . The Clr i dr c e t s nd c e oft sme or ndum opi o a ac ompa ng rvol us e k s ie t d o e opi s hi m a ni n nd c nyi or t pl n i f der o ai t f . sxTsR:Thi t, a o xo mb r20 6 s z y f ve e, 1 . Chi fUn e St t sD i ti tJ e d a e sr c udge 2I ndeed, f al1 e essy pr dest he t ca e pr de sm a di cl e a pa i ' healh eder aw xpr l ovi hat alh r ovi r y s os tents t i o ma i a ne esay i o de t c du to ar n f lga s r ie .Se 45C. R. 1 4.01 nf r ton s c sr n r r o on c r ra ge or e l e vc s e F. j 6 5 . 3
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
