Parks v. Clarke et al, No. 7:2016cv00450 - Document 46 (W.D. Va. 2017)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/9/2017. (slt)
Download PDF
CLERT S OFFI U.S. ST. CE DI COUK' T AT ROANOKE,VA FI LED I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A R O A N O K E DI I O N V SI BE2 11 2 1 27 JUL C. U LF CL I - ERK X B : DEU L l'k Y PW E j D O LLY Y.PA R K S, Pl ntf, ai if C i lA c i N o. 1 c 00450 vi ton 7: 6- v- V. M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON NI H AROLD CLARK E,e aI, t . Dee f ndant . s By: H on. ihae F.Ur tki M c l bars ChifUnie St e Dit c Judge e t d at s srit Doly Y.Pa ks aVigi ai aepr e ngwih c l r , r ni nm t oce di t ouns l c me d t sa tonpr K e, om hce hi ci o . p s n t 4 U. C. 1 8 .Th rman n d fnd nsaec re ta df r ro fcaso t urua t o 2 S. j 9 3 e e ii g ee a t r u rn n o me fiil f he Fl nna Co r c i lCe e f rW ome uvn r e tona ntr o n.Pl ntf co pl nst tadicplna y pe lyw a ai if m ai ha s i i r nat s i mpos i vi ai ofd pr es gua a e d by t Foure nt Amendme . De e nt fld ed n ol ton ue oc s r nt e he te h nt f nda s ie amoinf rs mmayj d me t a dPli tf r s nd d ma i t ematrrp f rd s o iin to o u r u g n , n anif e po e , kng h te ie o ip sto . Afe rv e n terc r t c u t r nsDee d n s mo inf rs mma yj g n b c us tr e iwig h e o d,he o r g a t fn a t' to o u r ud me t e a e Pli tf f l t esa ih t vi ai ofac tt i rght a n if ais o t bls he ol ton onsiutonal i . On J 1 201 Pli ifr ceve a i tmtona c r f rc 201 t iobe ng a une 9, 5, antf e i d n nsi i l ha ge o ode , r s yi n Or r' Coreci lOfi r(1 O' Fose rpore t ts s w na nsont oft lg de.' r tona fce t ' tr e td ha he a pki C/ ) op he iht fxl eisd P an ifsc l a dç a a k db t g ts t a r sd i t sc l t k e a y itr n ie litf el n t ve s e oh i e j h t e i e n hi elo e p n z h nma ie fo o tp o t erl h s . .b c u e gjt salr h z r . tms r m n o f h i i t. . re a s q ij i ie a ad' g ' The ne da Pli ifr ceveda c oft c r a chos t pr e esa xt y, antf e i opy he ha ge nd e he oc dur nd Parks v. Clarke et al di c r s w a e Pl i i fr f ed ape ly of e ,dec i d a s a fadvi or a w a ved a s ove y he nt d. a ntf e us na t f r lne t f s , nd i Doc. 46 t e p f hourpr pa a i tm e. H ow e r s w a e t be pr e d li t he rng, o w nt our e r ton i ve , he nt d o es nt tr ng he a i t ha one i t and o sa ft siy on he be l, ndt s m i ni c os - xn i ton ve nma e ne t f e tf r haf a o ub t ne r s e m na i Dockets.Justia.com q si t c/ yose ue tons o o ' t nlPli ifpr fe e t the cel a ewoul t siyt tC/ Fose had a ntf o f r d ha r lm t d e tf ha O tr t ve o ne t c l 20 t ni s wa t food ofie i D- ng.'Pli ifpr f r û r pe d he e l 4 he ght he s he l ne fc r n wi ' antf ofe ed t tt sa fwoul t siy a tt s m ea t tC/ Fose ne rs ha he t f d e tf bou he a nd ha O t r ve poke t Pl ntf l l o ai if G e whi doi ...r mdsi D- ng. I r s et t qu tons C/ Fose ex ai d i pe tne ng ot n wi ' n e pons o he esi , O ' tr pl ne n ri nt par t ts fr ti tuced t celo upa st r movet na nsdurng c t ha he s nsr t he l cc nt o e he pki i ounton Jme 1 t 8 and t ts bei ve s wa i t c r r m t J l 18whe Ra a wa c l out' ha he le d he s n he ontol oo s ure on n m dan s aled .' C/ Fose alo e ai d t ts a o he ofi r a es pos t l i ac l durngcou O t r s xpl ne ha he nd t r fce s r up ed o ook n e l i nt t a e sl lyt ng ...outofpl c ' o ddr s t l hi a a e. ' Dee n M ai J ne wasasi dast I tttona Hemi Ofke CtHO' a fnda t re o s sgne he nsiui l ng f r 1 ' nd ) c onduce t dicplna y he rng o J 25.J sde e t t wine sr que t a t d he s i i r a i n une one ni d he wo t s e ss nd e l xcudedfveoft ni wrte q si a ir lva t J sc i r d Pl i ipstsi pny i he ne itn ue tons s ree n . one onsde e antf e tm a r viwe C/ Fose ' a we st t wrte q si be or dee ngPl i ifguit a nd e e d O t r s ns r o he itn ue tons f e mi antf ly nd r omm e ng a $1 00 fne.De e n Syl aW is aUni M a ge , ppr ve t ec ndi 2. f nda t vi lon, t na r a o d he diposton a i s ii nd mpos d t $1 00fne. e he 2. i Pl ntf sad i sr tvea aloft c viton wa uns e sul Pli tf a g i ai if m nitai ppe he on c i s ucc s f . a n if r ued n l pe tne pa tha t c i nta buidi l book i c t d t tC/ Fose wa i t c r ri nt r t t he onfde il l ng og ndia e ha O t r s n he ontol 2 us 4 f nda mm own r oom durng c i ounto Jme 18. On Aug t2 ,de e ntTn y Br , who wa t W a de n t s he r n a t etme u edt isi i n lc n cina dfn o a p a.Br wnnoe ,n e ai: t i i , ph l he n t o a o vito n ie n p e l o mt td itr la Yo c am yo ha i or ton s cii t t c r e t tyou di notha u l i u ve nf ma i pe fc o he ha g ha d ve a t tmeo te h a ig . . g n if r to y u ma ha e o ti e t he i f h e rn . . Al y n o main o y v b an d 1Diobeyi a Or ri co i r d ac e y 1 ofens . Pe polc t rpori ofie doe notnee t s ng n de s nsde e atgor 1 f e r iy, he e t ng fc r s do pe s ly a ra adicplna yhe rngf ac e y 1 ofe e. r onal ppea t s i i r a i or atgor 1 f ns 2Afe Pli iffl t a tr antf ied he ppealW is n alege yc siedPli iff c a i I enal faisa lo l dl ha ts antf or ontctng ntr A f r nd , trae e t tk a yh rp io j bu ls serv ae ten meo tec reto a ofcrwh alwe h rt h e tn d o a e wa e rsn o nes h e e ld h a f h orcin l fie o lo d e o viw t c i ntallg book.Pl ntf rf e t na et o t b ,a W is n alege yw a dim isveof e he onfde i o ai if e us d o m he fk r nd lo l dl s s si Pl ntf' ver c plit a utt dici i r co ci ai ifs bal om an s bo he s plna y nviton. 2 a trt c fe he ompl to oft dicplna y he rng wilnotbe e e ti d,as ei n he s i i r a i l ntrane t decson o t He rngs Ofi r wa m a ba ed on t e de e he ii f he a i fce s de s he vi nc pr e e a t tm e of t he rng. Alo, t i or ai n yo a e es nt d t he i he a i s he nf m to u r pr e i i not i onnai n t t o f nde s ha r ady ac es t a i es ning s nf to ha fe r ve e c s o nd s c r di t y t yourr or d t si onta cor o ec de e tmony. Thi l ws tf l d,whe en Pli ifbei vesDe e s a ui olowe r i antf le f ndan sf ie t e tr t pr s t al d o nsle he oce s gua an e byt Fouree h Ame m e .Fis,Pl ntf c nt ndst tt l boo e t ihe r t ed he t nt nd nt r t ai if o e ha he og k sabls s t C/ Fose wa i t c r r m a notar mdhe c l whe t o f ns oc ur e hat O t r s n he ontol oo nd ot r e l n he f e e c r d. Se ond,Pl ntf diputsJ s'e de ir r lngst e l t wine s sa fvequesi c ai if s e one vi nta y u i o xc ude he t s e nd i tons a i e nt Thid, antf c lng t s fce y oft ev de s ppo tng t s nrl va . r Pl i if hale es he ufi inc he i nce u ri he c ci n.Fourh, antf c onvi to t Pl i if ompl i t tt c c i i cedhe Ear d Se e eCr di ans ha he onviton mpa t r ne ntnc e t (t C' ca sfc to c lu ainmo etal ih mo tsltrd rn ar u ieca sfc t n ç ' lsi ain ac lto r h reg t nh ae u ig o tn lsi ai ES ) o ges nd ca aor nd quiabl e if de ii 3 Pli ifs e dama a de lr t y a e t er le . c son. antf e ks l. l Dee d n sfldamo inf rs mmayj g n ag igq aiid i ni A p ryi fn a t ie to o u r ud me t r un u lfe mmu t y. a t s e tte t sl r j dg n it ep e dng ,h ds l e maeil o fl, nda afd vi ni d o l l mmay u me t f h la i s te icosd tras n ie a ny fia t s s w t theei n g n n d s u ea t a ymae il a t d. Ci P. 6a .M aeil ho ha t r s o e uie ip t s o n tra f c.Fe R. v. 5 () tra f c sa et enec s r t e t bls t e e nt o apa t sc us ofaci n. Anderon v. a t r hos es a y o sa ih he l me s f ry' a e to s Lie t Lo b Ic, 7 U. 2 2 2 8( 9 6 .A g n ned s u eo maeil a te it i,n b ry b y.n .4 7 S. 4 , 4 t 8 ) e ui ip t f tra fc x ss f i viwi t r co d a a lr as e ng he e r nd 1 e onabl i e e esdr wn t r fom i a lg mos f vo a et t e nf r nc a he e r n i ht t a r bl o he no movi pa t ar s na efc- rc dr tunaver c frt nonn- ng ry, ea o bl a tfnde oul et' dit o he mova .J..The nt .Z I J m ovi pm' ha t btr n ofs wi - ç ha i, ntngoutt t dititc u'- t tt r i ng t s he lde y ho ng t t s poi i t o he src ot t ha he e s 3TheESC s tm a i t c ran i ae who, l ePlitflwe es n e c d f ra o f n ec mmitd yse pples o e ti nm ts i an it r e tn e o n fe s o te k o o atrJn ay1 1 95 Imae s betoteES s se ma b a et rd c teln t o tersne c s n r f a u r , 9 . n ts uj c t h C y tm y e bl o e u e h e gh fh i e tn e . e Va Co ejj5312 2. -5 .-0 4 Aneiil imaei asg e t o eo fu lv l wihrtsrn igfo . d .-0 2 312 2.. l be n t s sin d o n f o r e es t ae a gn rm g z r t f a o - fdays c e tf e yt ry da ofconfne e .I M ay201 Pli ifse r ng r e o o our nd nehal ' r di or ver hit ys i m nt n 6, antf ' a ni age de r as d 9om f trand o hal da 'cedit t e da 'c edi. ce e ol ne- f ys r t o hr e ys r t 3 a a e e ofe de et s n bs nc vi nc o uppor t nonmovi pa t sc s ' Ce o e Com . Car t, 7 t he ng ry' a e. l t x ' v. te t47 U. 31 , 25( 9 6 .I t emo n s tsist i b r e ,h nt en n mo a t tstf rh S. 7 3 1 8 ) f h va t aife h s u d n te h o - v n mus e o t s cii f c st tde o ta et e se ofage nediput o f tf rti . I a 322pe fc a t ha m nsr t he xitnce nui s e f ac o ral d. t 24. A pa t i e tt dt s mma yj d me ti ter c r a awh l c udn tla ar to a tiro ry s nil o u r u g n f h e o d s oe o l o e d ain lre f e f c t tn i fvo o t en n mo n .W iln v Grfi , 5 F. 8 , 23(t Ci. 9 ) a t o q d n a r f h o - va t l ms . ifn 9 2 2d 20 8 4 h r 1 91 . i G e eu s p o tds e uain . .sn t no ht d fa asl r j d me tmo in. En i ç r n u p re p c lto . i o e ug o ee t l M mmay u g n to ' n s ' v. tlAs nofBus & Educ. di l ,53F. 55,62(t Ci.1995 . A pl nifca Na' s' . Ra o. nc. 3d 4h r ) aitf nnot u ear s o s t amo inf rsl r j g n t n n o c re tac mp an c aln e b s ep n e o to o l mmay ud me t o me d r o rc o lit h le g d y t mo inf rsl r u g n .Cla i e v. De t 5 5F.d3 4 3 6( t Ci. 0 9 . he to o l mma yj d me t o nnc r Mc vi 5 3 2 , 3 4h r 2 0 ) t A go r me ofs a s dunde j1 i e il t i ve n nt tcil ue r 983 s ntted o nvokeq lfe i uaiid mmuniy, c t whih r e n ia i s n mmuniy fom s ta pr tilbur nslkedi c ve y. C oope v.She ha ,735 F.3 15 t r ui nd e ra de i s o r 4 d 3, 1 8( t Ci. 01 )(iigM i hel Fo s t, 7 U. 5 1 5 6( 98 ).çhed crn o 5 4h r 2 3 ctn t lv. ryh 4 2 S. 1 , 2 1 5 ) Gf o tie f c qualfe i mt t t lnc st o i ra i e esst ne d t ho dpublcofk i l ii d m miy baa e ' mpo tnt nt r t-he e o l w i t as a ot abl whe t y exe c s powe i pons bl a t ne d t s ed of i sfo cc mt e n he r ie r nrs i y nd he e o hi l fcal r m ha a s e ,dita ton,a la lt whe t ype f t i dute r as bl '' Smih v.Ra r s m nt sr ci nd ibiiy n he ronn her is e ona y.' t y, 78 F.d9 , 0 ( t Ci. 01 )(uoigPe ro v. la a 5 5U. 2 3 2 ( 0 9) 1 3 5 1 0 4h r 2 5 q tn as n Calh n, 5 S. 2 , 31 2 0 ). Theç lfe i miy a l i t c lyi vest i uii :()whehe i l iid mmt t nayss ypial nvol wo nq res 1 t r he qua pli ifha e tbls dt vi ainofac tt i lrgh , nd( whehe t trg was antf s sa ihe he olto onsiutona i t a 2) t r ha iht c e ry e t bls d a t tme oft alege vi a i n. Ra v.Ca l a l sa ihe t he i he l d olto ' ub ' mpbel,785F. 8 881 l 3d 76, ( h Ci.201 .A tc 'ma a es t s t quesi i t or r...ha wilbes 4t r 5) ioul y ddr s he e wo tons n he de t t l t t 4 anifp sigysae i rs o s t temoinfrs mmayj d me th tt moins o l b Plitf asn l ttsn e p n e o h to o u r u g n ta he to h ud e d ne a pe tr b c u etepat sh v n t t o u tdds o ey.A moinfrsmmayj d me t yb e id s rmaue e a s h ri a e o ye c nd ce ic v t e to o u r u g n ma e flda a ytme a dPlitf fist s o ta s ec n o p ee t at esniloj siyo p st n.F d R. v. ie t n i , n anif al o h w h t h a n t rsn fcs se ta t utf p o ii e . Ci o P. 6b, d.Alo c u t s o l rs leq ai e i nt a tee ris o potni s d fn a t d n tls te 5 ()( ) s , o rs h ud eov u lt d mmu i th alet p ru t o ee d ns o o o e h i y y b n ft ftei nt b rs o dn t ds o r S e ea.Hu trv Br a t5 2U.. 2 , 2 ( 9 1. e eio h mmu i y ep n ig o ic vey. e . . , ne . y n 0 S 2 4 2 7 1 9 ) y 4 f iia et f i and e fc e diposton ofe h c s ' Esa eofAr tonc v.Vil of aclt t he ar fii nt s ii ac a e. tt ' msr l. Pi e u s, 1 F.d8 2 8 8(t Ci. 01 )(n en lq tto makso te ) A p an ifs n h rt 8 0 3 9 , 9 4 h r 2 6 itr a uoain r mitd . litf cam t u vv ssl r u g n , o ve, nyi rh c u t a s rs b t q eto si t li ç r ie l s mma yj d me t h we r o l f t e o rq n we rj oh u sin n he a fr tve''d. fimai 7' 1 11 1. Dee d n saee tte t q aiidi mi a s mmayj dg n be a ePlitf fn a t r n ild o u l e mmt t nd u r u me t c us anif f y f ist e tbls t vi a i ofa c tt i lrg . To sa ea d pr es cai , i t al o sa ih he olton onsiutona iht tt ue oc s l m an nma e m us s t how t ts wasde i d ofi ie lbe t, orpr r y' by gove n e ala ton. Se e. , ha he prve ' d f i ry l ope t ' r m nt c i e. c. Be eai S t,1 0F.d5 0 5 2(t Ci. 9 7 .W h nads l r p nat do sno v rt v. mih 2 3 0 , 0 4 h r 1 9 ) e idpi y e l e t na y i ve t r voc ton ofa nzd s nt ncngc e t pr t c e i e e t a e g r ly lmie t nvol he e a i cc e e e i r di, o e t d nt r ss r ene a l i t d o f e dom fom r sr ntt ti re r e tai ha mpos saypi la sg t ntha ds p on t i t i r lton t e t ca nd i nika r hi he nma e n ea i o t eo dnayicd n so p io lf .Se s ..S ndnv Co ne, 5U. 4 2 48 ( 9 5 h r i r n ie t f rs n ie e ec, a i . n r 51 S. 7 , 4 1 9 ) ( di t tdicplnays gr ai di no prs ntt t ofaypi l sg fc ntde i to hol ng ha s i i r e eg ton d t e e he ype t ca, ini a prvain i wlihasaemi çeaealbe t i eet. n zc tt ght r t i ry ntrs) Pli ifdoesnotde antf monsr t t tt $1 00fnepl e a aypi a a sgnii nt ta e ha he 2. i ac d ny t c l nd i fca ha ds p on he i r lto t t o di r i i nt ofprs lf Se Br t he v. ahe No. r hi r n ea i n o he r na y nc de s ion ie. e a c r M t na, 7:5CV00500,201 U. DitLEXI 1 1 6 S. s. S 05306,a *34, 6W L 4250500,a *1( . Va. t - 201 t W D. Au * , 01 )(i iga$1 0 fneddn p ea ay ia a d sg fc n h r s i i g. 0 2 6 fndn 1 2.0 i i pt os n t pc l n ini a t a d hp n compa i o t t or na y i ie t o p io lf) He d ro v. r i a No 7:7CV- 6 , rs n o he di r ncd n s f rs n ie ; n e s n Vicni, . 0 - 2 6 . 2 8U.. s. 00 S Dit LEXI 5 3 , t* 3 3 , 0 W L 2 4 8 , t* 0( . Va J n. 3, 0 ) S 2 0 a 3 - 6 20 8 0 4 0 a 1 W D. . a 2 2 08 (a ) afd 2 2F. p' 2 4(t Ci. 0 )( e c ra .Ev ni Plitf c n ito sme, f', 7 Ap x 6 4h r 2 08 p r u im) e f anips o vcin uli a ey c nge he ESC c t y sa usorf ur ESC e r ng r t e g m o hsltr t t tm t l ha d r usod tt ut e a ni a e i ht nt ae , ha c ngedoesnoti ia ef der ld pr e spr e tons Se J ms v. ohns No. ha mplc t e a ue oc s ot c i . e ol on J on, 7:9 v 0 0 , 0 9U. DitLEXI 6 3 0, t* - 1 2 0 W L 2 3 9 4 a * - ( . Va 0 c 0 2 7 2 0 S. s. S 4 3 a 71, 0 9 3 7 9 , t 2 4 W D. . J y27, )( l ngt neihe Vigi asaut norVDOC polcisc e t albe t i ees ul 2009 hodi hat t r r ni tt es i e r ae i ry ntr t f rESC) a fd 3 3F. p' 8 7( t Ci. 0 )(e c rn .Th sau oys h mef r o , f', 5 Ap x 2 4h r 20 9 p r u im) e tttr c e o e r igESC i c n iin la da t ds rto o p io o fcas S eVa Co ej 5 .- 0 ., ann s o dto a n the icein f rs n f il. e . d j 3 12 23 53. - 2. l aesdo no ha apr t c e lbe t i e es i e r ng as c fcr t ofgood 120 4. nm t t ve o e t d i ry nt r t n a ni pe ii a e c n u t i .Se De a i v J h o ,1 8F. u p. d31 , 2 ( D. . 0 0 , f',1 F. o d c tme e Blso . o ns n 2 S p 2 5 3 9 E. Va 2 0 ) afd 3 Ap x9 ( t Ci. 0 )( e c ra .Th efc o aca st ainr d to o t ea l yt p' 6 4h r 2 01 p r u im) e fe t f lsi to e uci n n h bit o k i em' ESC i t s ultvet c tt eade i ton ofapr ededlbe t i e e t Se Luke n s oo pec a i o onsiut prva i ot i ry nt r s . e n v. c t, F.d 1 2 1 3 9 (t Ci. 9 5 (ii M e c u v. n , 2 U. 21 , 29n. S o t71 3 9 , 9 - 4 5h r 1 9 ) ctng a h m Fa o 4 7 S. 5 2 8 ( 9 :.M o e v r acam t a p io oscasha en t o lwe t ero id p n e t 1 76 ro e , li h t rs n f il v o f lo d h i wn n e e d n polc e o pr e esdoesnots a e a c tt i i i s r oc dur t t ons iutonalc a m . Se e g. Sa n,515 U . a 48 li e. . , ndi S. t 3; UntdSttsv Ca ee , 4 U. 7 , 5 - 5( 9 9 ; c i v. t . fF ifx 90 F.d ie ae '. c rs 4 0 S. 41 7 2 5 1 7 ) Rico Cn v o ara , 7 2 1 9 1 9(t Ci. 9 0 . 45 , 46 4 h r 1 9 ) Be a ePl i ifdi notha af de a l pr eced it r ti a di t i c us antf d ve e r ly ot t n e es n voi ng he mposton of ii t m o tr tne s wa note ild t f r ld pr e spr e tons5 A c or ng y, he' nea y i , he s ntte o ede a ue oc s ot c i . c di l 5Nonehels , t r or s t e s he ec d howst tPli ifr ceve a ha antf e i d dvanc notc oft pr ee ngs ga tsi o e ie he oc di , ve e tm ny, andr ceve aw rtenr por de c i ngt ba e f t convi i a pe t See e. , olfv.M c e i d it e t s rbi he s s or he cton nd naly. . c.W f Donnel, l 4l U. 5 9 5 4 71( 9 4 .J n s a teI wa alwe t dse adc muaiea irlv n e ie c , s 8 S. 3 , 6 - 1 7 ) o e, s h HO, s l d o irg r u ltv nd ree a t vd n e a o wa tec s h r.S e eg, o v Brxo , 7 F.d5 , 0 (t Ci. 0 4). adv J h sn, 9 F.d 1 9 , s h a e ee e , ..Brwn . a tn 3 3 3 01 5 5 4h r 2 0 ;- r - o n o 6 0 2 0 8 W . 1 1 1 (t Ci.1 8 )s eas J n sv No t CaoiaPrs n r' bo Uno I c, 3 U. 1 9 1 ( 9 7 1 2-3 4h r 9 2. e lo o e . rh r l io es La r in.n .4 3 S. 1 , 26 1 7 ) , n CBea s t eraie o r n igap n lnttto aec mpe a ddfiutweh v as rc g ie t wie c u e h e lis f u nn e a isi in r o lx n ifc l t u , a e lo e o nzd he d rn igd frn et b a c r e ted cso so p io a miitaos' ; of, 8U.. t5 66 (grsn a gn eee c o e c o d d h e iin f rsn d nsrtr.)W lf41 S a 6 -7 Cp io ' t o t as muth v ten c saydsrto (ol tt c lngo win sejwih u b i s bett t uy fkilj s a e h e esr icein t i he al f tess to t eng uj c o md l mi i cipigc n tuin li e i ns'.Moe v rteewa to e ie c 'i terc r -C/ F se' rp l o si to a mp dme t.) ro e,h r ss me vd n e'n h e o d O o trs n t ' s chagi doc nt- t s r ng ume o uppor t c cin f Diobe ng a Or ra i tPli if who wa a sg dt t the onvito or s yi n de gans antf, s s ine o he cela woul havebe n i t celdurng c .Se Supe i e l nd d e n he l i ount e rntndent M as .Con'I t v.Hil47 U . 445,455 - s . ns. l, 2 S. ( 9 5 (e o nzn afd rl o r wi n trviw a c rc o fn ig a ln a to e ie e'i terc r 1 8 ) rc g iig e ea c u t l o e e c ua y f idn s o g s t me vd nc' n h eo d l s s p o ttefcu lidn s.Alo, o e ' e iinrc ie t lv l o rve u p rs h ata fn ig ) s Jn s d cso e ev d wo e es f e iw. 6 Dee d n saee tte t q aiidi fn a t r n i d o n l e mmunt a sl r j g n b c us Plitf f ist l f iy nd l mmay ud me t e a e an if al o e tbls t vi a i ofaconsi i lrgh . sa ih he olton tmtona i t IV . F rt ef r g i gra o s t ec u t rnsDee d n s moinf rsl r u g n . o h o e o n e s n ,h o r g a t fn a t' to o l mmayj d me t E NTER:Ths 9 i dyo Dee e,07 a f cmbr2 1. Chi fUnied St t D i ti tJ e t a es s r c udge 7