Muhammad v. Barksdale, et al, No. 7:2016cv00328 - Document 86 (W.D. Va. 2018)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 7/10/2018. (slt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
cuERK' of s z u. ol ' nce a. a7 Gour . AT DANVI E, LL VA FI LED Juk 1g 2 j ' g, I TH E U M TED STATE S D I N STR I CO U R T CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STR I O F W R G I G CT N R A K DWSO O XO E I IN a2 y 7 uD 'DL, j W l U : M ALC OL M M I H AM M A D , T Pl nt f , ai i f C i lA c i N o.7: c 00328 vi ton 16- v- V. G M O R AN D U M O PI I N N O E ARI,BAR K SD A LE ,e aI, t . De e f ndant . s By: H on. ls L.K i er Jac t on s Se o U ni e St esD i t i tJudge ni r t d at src M al ol M uhn m a a Vi gi a prs rpr e ng pr K ,c c m m d, r ni i one oce di o omm e ed t sa ton nc hi ci . plrua t 42U. C.j1 agans va i safoft Vigi aDe rme ofCo rci zs nt o S. 983 i t rous tf he r ni pa t nt re tons (VDOC' a dt eRe OninStt P io (1 P' .Plitf o anst a De e d n sfie t ( d ' n h d o ae rs n G ) ROS ' an ifc mpli h t f n a t ald o ) pr dea ua epr es i vi ai n oft Fouree t Ame m e ' DuePr es Cl us a ovi deq t oc s n olto he t nh nd nts oc s a e nd r i o f ssi vi a i oft Fis Am e e ' Fr eExe c s Clus a t Rei ousLa elgi us ea t n olton he rt ndm nts e r i e a e nd he lgi nd Us a dI t i n lz dPes nsAc (RIUI '.Dee d n sEldamo inf rs nmay e n nsi o aie ro mt t ç - PA' G ) fn a t e to o u i r j g n , n tema trwa r fn' t ama itaej d epls a t o2 U. C. 6 6B)1 () ud me t a d h te s ee e o gsrt u g t u n t 8 S. j 3 ( ()' . d r b Thema itae u erc mme st a Ig a tDee da t'mo inf rs gsrt j dg e o nd h t r n fn n s to o ummo j d me ta u g n, nd Plitf i l o j ce Afe rv e n t r c r Io e r l Plitf' o j cihs a o t h an ift y b e td. tr e iwi g he e o d, v rue an ifs b e to , d p t e me rpo t n r c mme d to a dg a t fn a t' t n frs mmayj g n . e r a d e o n ain, n rn De e d n s moi o u r ud me t o 1. A dititc rt trvi é:novoa pa tofarpor a r c src ou mus e ew ny r e t nd e omme tont whiha ndai o c pat o j cs a d imu tp o i eiside n e tra o i wh n ap ryr ie n w e d n eo a ry be t, n t s r v d t n pe d n e s nng e a t as s e vie c r Muhammad v. Barksdale, et al ne ag me ti a o j cin.2 U. C. 6 6 b ( )C) Or in v. oms n, 8 F.d4 47( t w r u n n n b e to 8 S. j 3 ( )1( ; p a o J l o 6 7 2 4, 4h Doc. 86 Ci.1 .Ther as ngne dnotbeea aeorlngt buti mus prvi as ii rtonae r 982) e oni e lbort e hy, t t o de pecfc ai l t t r t me n n f l p laer v e S e eg, ie S ae v Ca tr 5 4F.d3 5 3 0(t ha pemis n i g u a pelt e iw. e s ..Untd tts . re, 6 3 2 , 3 4h Ci. 0 9 .Ho ve, no rve i no rq ie whe o j cinsc n enlg lsue a dno r 2 0 ) we r X vo e iw s t e ur d n be to o c r e a is s n t Dockets.Justia.com fcua is s See e. ,Or a 68 F. a 47.Notbl /.novorviw i no rquie l na a t l sue . e g. pino, 7 2d t a y,. : e e s t e rd G whe pat ma e g n r l rc n l o yo j cin t a d n t ie t h c u toas cfcer ri t e ry k s e e a o o cus r b e to s h t o o dr c t e o r t pe i ro n h ma itaej d e sp o osdf ig a dr c mme d to s' J A dsrc c u t sas no g sr t u g ' r p e mdn s n e o n ain . . 'Z itit o r i lo t rq ie t rv e a yis ewh nnopa t o j cs S e eg.Th ma v At , 4U. 1 0 1 9 e ur d o e iw n su e ry b e t. e . . , o s . - 47 S. 4 , 4 n ( 9 5 ; mb v. v s 71 F.d 1 8 2 0( t Ci.1 8 ) 1 8 ) Cn y Da i, 8 2 9 , 0 4h r 9 3 . Th Fo rh Cic i h sh l ta a o j cigp rymu to j c d t s f in s e iii e u t rut m ed h t n b e tn a t s b e ts h u fce t p cfct wi y s a r a o a l t ae th d src c u t ft etu g omdf r heo j cin. Uni dS ae v. o s e s n by o lr t e itit o r o h r e r t o t b e to ' t tts ' e M ic te 4 8F.d61 ,6 2 (t Ci. 0 ) d et, 7 3 6 2 4 h r 20 7 . To c ncu e o h r s wo l d f a t e p r s o r q iig o j cins W e o ld t e wie ud ee t h upo e f e urn b e to . woul be pe m itng a pary t a d r ti t o ppea a is t twasbef e t m a sr t l ny s ue.ha or he gitae j d e r g r ls o t nat e a d s o e o o j cinsma et t ma itae u g , e ade s f he tl n c p f b e to r d o he g sr t j d e sr p r.Ei e t d src c u t ul t e ha et r ve e ey is ei u g ' e o t t r he itit o r wo d h n v o e iw v r su n h te ma itae j g ' p o o e f ig a d rc mme d to o c u t o h gsrt ud es r p s d mdn s n e o n ains r o rs f a ppeas w o d be r quie t r vi w is s t t t diti t co t ne r l ul e r d o e e s ue ha he src ur ve c n ie e . I et rc s , udca r s t c swo l b wa td a d te d src o sd r d n i a e j iil e ol e u d e se n h itit he r c u ts e fcie s b s d o hep fo ma itae j d e wo l b o r' fe tv ne s a e n l r m g sr t u g s ud e t r ne mde mi d. JJ F rhemo e o j ci n t a ol rp a a g me t r ie b f r ama itaej g ae . u t r r , b e to s h t rl e e t r u n s as d eo e gsrt ud e r I . y c n ie e g n r l b e to st t ee trt o t erpo t ndr c mme d to wh c h stesme o sd r d e e a o j cin o h n iey f h e r a e o n ain, ih a h a efc a af i et o j c.Ve e v. tu , 3 F. u . d8 , 4 ( . Va 2 08 . fe t s al o b e t n y Asr e 5 9 S pp 2 41 8 5 W D. . 0 ) m II. Th ma ilaej d ede cie t ecamsa f l ws e g s t u g s rb d h li s ol : o I ls Co lit ( k t Ie No. 1, Mt mma h s s e nl r u n l i mp an , Doc e tm ) l hn d a u d l o s me de e nt .The ede e nt i l Ea lBa ks l ,G.Ba ,Dwa Tur e , f nda s s f nda s ncude r r da e ker yne n r Arrp,W at r Swi y,Ro Syke , L. Coli ,A. Da d Robi on a P. ti le ne y s R. lns vi ns nd Sc r ny. M uha m a s Com pl n a l ge t the w a s he ed t a a be m d' ai t le d ha s c dul o ppea f r ro a I he i f r c a sfc to on Aprl 6,201 M thn m a sa e t the n CA arng o l s iia i n i 5. l m d tt d ha was no notle of tls he rng a was no pr e dlrng t he dng. t i d li a i nd t es nt li he a M ul mmm a alege t tt f iur t pr vi hi no i eandt f iur t a l d l d ha he al e o o de m tc he al e o low hi t bepr e a t sApdl6he rng vi a e hi d pr s rght t rt m o es nt t hi ai olt d s ue oce s i s mde he Fo te h Am e e t l a a st tM uhn m a a s cai t tt f lle ure nt ndm n . t ppe r ha m d lo l med ha he aitr o hsDu lTr ame tTe m, ç ' t gv hi ahe rngb f r pa i hi f i a e t n a (ç ) o ie m DTT', ai eo e lcng m on I s usalo vi ae hi duepr s rj s Muhn d as al edt t M Gt s oltd s oce s iht. mma lo leg ha t f iur ofDe e n sBa ks l a Tur rt r e e hi fom s he al e f nda t r da e nd ne o elas m r epegai n to whe hi dicplna y c ci wa r duce alo vi aed hi due pr es n s s i i r onvi ton s e d s ol t s oc s rg s i ht . M uhn ad a s a lged i li Compli t t o M a 1 201 he r ceved a mm lo le n ls ant ha , n y 5, 5, e i docl e fom Co ms l Dee ,r quesi t t a1 ofe r who wa e t l nt r m t eor l e tng ha 1 f nde s nt d o pa tcpa e i Rn a n fl o t doc nt s i t di twih wli h t rii t n m da il ut he ume ttng he e t lc hey wihe t f t M ul m a sa e t the wihe t r ceve t Com mon Fa e s d o as. mm d tt d ha s d o e i he r dit M uha a saed t t ac r i t l lm ,t f tofRa e. mm d t t ha, co d ng o sa he as mada i t be n so f l d by t f ass- t f as ofEi ulFirwihi t e da oft e of olowe wo e t he e t d t t n hr e ys he nd t Rn a n f s a t f s of Ei ulAdha wihi 70 da o t end of he m da a t nd he ea t d t n ys f he Rn a n. M uha m a a lge t t be a ehe wa on t Common Fa e dit m da m d le d ha , c us s he r e, he was de e t e t f a t . M uha a a l ed t t deza of t s nid hes wo e s mm d leg hat he li l he e f ass wa a vi a i ofli Fis Am e e t s olton ls rt ndme rg t t fe e r ie ofhi nt i ht o he r e xe c s s r lgi bele s a vi a e li rght t r RIO P A. I hi Compl i , ei ous i f nd olt d ls i s mde n s ant Mu mma alg d Gk ma a Ei u Fi , ndEi u Ad a (r )..i o tn hn d le e , G n d n, d l t a l r d l h a e . mp ra t p a tc l) f r M u l a mo t o p a e ,f si g s ciie a d c lb ai rcies o si ms n h f ry r a tn a rfc n ee rt ng tagl pe cie byAla ,( d, iho l c me o c ay a. Mu a d h t's rsrb d lh Go )whc ny o s n e er' h mma ' a s ale d t tde a oft f a t t li i pos d d s t t bur n'on t lo l ge ha m l he e ss o zm m e : ubsan ml de ' he a f e e r s ofhi r lgi n. r e xe ci e s ei o ( p r a Re o nd to 7 8) Re o t nd c mme ai n - . Th ma itaej d er c mme sFa tn Dee da t'mo inf rsl r u g n e g srt u g e o nd n ig fn ns to o lmmayj d me t b c us P an iffie t e tbiht t n d fnd n v oae fd r l a Th ma itaej g e a e litf ald o sa ls ha a y ee a t i ltd e e a lw. e g srt ud e d tr n dt a S u a dha o frdn e ie et t( r d l, ti G. ke, ne eemie h t s h mma s fee o vd nc ha Baks ae Arrp, Ba r Swi y M a Robi onqt a acin a i thi 'a di no desrbec tonsofco i me t t nd ns ook ny to gans m' nd d t ci ondii nfne ntha i lc t f d rld ep o e sp oe to s (d a 1 - 1) F rt rlg o cams t ma itae mp iae e ea u r c s r tcin . I . t 0 1 . o he eiin li ,he g srt j d ec n ld dta Plitf f ie t e tbih as bsm ta b r e t h srlg o e rieby u g o cu e h t anif ald o sa ls u tn il u d n o i eiius xecs b i sr e Co n Faef o sise do t p ca'f o sf rEi u Fi a dEi ul ha (I a eng e v d mmo r o d n ta f d e il o d o d l t n d Ad . J. t s ' r J P an ifso j ci n t te esn i sa eo e ze .Hetist e tb iht v ro wa s litf be to s o h s dng r v m ld re o sa ls he aius y Ba ks l Arrp,Ba r Swi y,mz Ro ns n w e ei ve w11ii c am sa m osl r dae, ti ke , ne d bi o r nvol d 11 ls l i nd ty r ie a e Msr lgi cl m s wlih i tlnco it m osl ofi l lbesa co l i . e tr t s e i on ai , lc n lr nsss ty nvodng a l nd ncusons Re dls t a def nda ' pe s li ve e , antf a l t e t bls how a c ndii n gar e s o ny e nts r ona nvol m nt Pl i iff is o sa ih ny o to hee de e f sx mont a ROSP co tt t sa a y c la sgnii n ha dslp i r lto xpe nc d or i hs t nsiu e n t pia nd i fca t r li n ea i n t t eo dn r icd n so p io l e Se p ..S ndnv Come,51 U. 4 2 4 4( 9 5 . o h r ia y n ie t f rs n i . e eg, a i . z r 5 S. 7 , 8 1 9 ) f Cons que l Pl ntf i note ild t f de alduepr s pr e tonsa e nty, ai if s ntte o e r oce s ot c i boutMsbde c nfne e f o i m nt i s gr to e n i prs oo cal ha notf l we t i o polc e o pr e e . Se n e egai n, ve f ion i s ve olo d her wn ii s r oc dur s e. ec, l e Sae v. c r s 4 U.. 41( 9 9 ; c i v. t vo Fara . r ii, 0 F.d ..Urtd tt s Ca ee , 40 S 7 1 7 ) Rico Comt f ifx Vizn a 9 7 2 i 1 9, 4 ( t Ci. 99 ) De pt lsd saifcinwi t eCo nFaef o sl b a 45 1 69 4h r 1 0 . s ie l is tsa to t h mmo r o d i e ns i h ke s r e f t f ss Pl i iff l t esa ih a E ubsa ilpr s ur ' hi l om odiy hi e v d or he em t , antf ais o t bls ny l t nta e s e'on m & s t f s b h vira dt vilt hi b les' rf r eim ço c o s b t e f lo n t ep e e t o hls e a o n o o ae s eif'o o c l s h o e ewe ù ol wi g h r c p s f iq i t rlgo a f retn g o r me tl be eis o t eo ha d a a a d n n o o te eiin nd o fiig g ven n a) n ft, n h ne n , nd b n o i g ne f h p e e t o hgs r l in . . nteoh rh nd' Lo ea ev Le , 7 F.d 1 4 1 7( t Ci. rc p s f ij ei o . o h t e a . v lc . e 4 2 3 7 , 8 4h r g ' 2 0 ) Plitf sivo aino lb l a c n l so sa en t n ildt a m s mp ino tuha d 0 6 . an if n c to f a es nd o cu i n r o e tte o n su to f r t n c nno beus d t e tbls t cai . Se .e. , lAt.Com .v.Twombl 550U . 544,555 n t e o sa ih he l m e g.Bel l v, S. (0 7 .Ac o dn l no o PlitY so j cin aep ruai , ndla o t rp r a d 2 0 ) c r igy, ne f ani b e to s r e s sve a d pthe e o t n r co menda i e m ton. 11 1. Fo t ef r g i r a o s Io r l Plitf o j cins a o tterp r a . r h o e ong e s n , venz an ifs be to , d p h e o t n e d r c mme d to , ndg a t fnd n s moin frsl r ud me t e o n ain a rn Dee a t' to o l mmayj g n . * 3. E E Ti1 rdyoJl,08 NT R:hs. a fuy21. # : . ' * Se i rU zie St t D i ti tJ o lt d a es s r c udge 4
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
