Farabee v. Clarke et al, No. 7:2016cv00325 - Document 79 (W.D. Va. 2017)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/18/2017. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
? . cl - s OFFI U. . DI cour Ee CE s ST. AT m ou , VA FI K L ' . I THE UNI STATESDI TRI COURT N TED S CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A ROANOK E DI SI VI ON AF2 18 2 1 27 J w . uu BY n sy cu u sv ; , ' . BRI FARABEE, AN Pl ntf, ai if v. . HAROLD CLARKE,e aI, t . Dee fndant. s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) D LERK Ci lAcin No.7: c 00325 vi to 16-vM EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI By: Hon. i lF.Ur ki M chae bans UniedSt e Dit itJudge t ats src Bran Fa a ,aVigi ai aepr e di pr K ,c i r bee r ni nm t oc e ng o omm e edt sa ton pur ua t nc hi c i s nt o 42U. C.j 1 De e nt ha r s nde t t s onda nde c antwih amoton S. 983. f nda s ve epo d o he ec me d ompli t i f rs mma yj d me ts p re b a fd vt.Plitf ag e ta d fnd ns whoa e o u r u g n u po td y fi a is an if r u s h t ee a t, r a s cae wiht eVignaDe a t n o Co rcin (VDOC', e e hm a e u t s o itd t h r i i p rme t f re to s ç E ' d nid i d q ae ) t e t e ,f ci y a i s e e m e c t o unl w f l r t a ned a i pr s ne hi , e r a m nt or bl dm nit r d di a i n, a uly esr i nd m i o d m deni d hi t fee m he r dom t a s a e a dic i i t agans hi on a o mtofa dia lt Pr s nty o s ocit , nd s rm nae i t m cc t s biiy. e e l . , f ' )' !' t ' beor t cour i Plitf' motonf apr i nayij ncin. f e he ts anifs i or elmi r n u to *. . ' Pl i i fha be n f a ntf d e ound notg ly by r a o ofi a t a c vil c m it d t t uit e s n ns niy nd i ly om te o he Com m i s one oft V igi a D e rm e o Be vi r H e 1h a D e opm e a Se vi e s i r he r ni pa t nt f ha o al a t nd vel nt l r c s (co sine' f rte t n , u heh ssn eb e ta ser dit t ec t d o t eVDOC d mmiso r) o r ame tb t a ic e n r n fre n o h uso y f h s ' duet t r voc ton ofa s pe o he e a i us nded s nt nc i N o mbe 201 Pl i ifdoe notbe ivet t e e e n ve r 5. antf s le ha hi pr e c i m e i t V DO C i c s es nt onfne nt n he s onduc ve t hi physca ,e otona , nd ps hol c i o s i l m i la yc ogi al he lh,a he a kst s r hi s ntnc i t c t y oft Commi so ri t d. at nd s o e ve s e e e n he us od hè s i ne nsea Farabee v. Clarke et al Doc. 79 A p ei n r ij n to i a e ta r ia ya dd atcrme y W itrv. tr l s rlmiay n u cin s n x ro dn r n rsi e d . n e Naua Re . Def Councl l .555U. 7, ( ) A mova mus esa ihf ee nt beor a . i.nc, S. 24 2008 . nt t tbls our lme s f e p ei n r ij n to ma is e ( )h i lk l t s c e do t emeis ( ) i lk l t r l a y nu cin y su : 1 e s iey o u c e n h rt; 2 he s i ey o mi Dockets.Justia.com ! . s frirpa a eham i t a e eofprlmi r rle '()t balnceofe testpsi hi ufe re r bl r n he bsnc ei nay eif 3 he a , quii i n s f v r a d( )a ijmcin i i tep bl itr s.I . t2 a o ; n 4 n nt to s n h u i ne et d a 0. c A ferw e ghi t s co i r tons t c tfndst tPl i ifi note il d t a t i ng he e ns de a i , he our i ha a ntf s ntte o p ei n r ij n to Plitf d e no d mo taet el l o o i daea r l a y nu cin. anif o s t e nsrt h i i d f mme it nd mi ke ho irp r beham b f r rs lto o temoinf rsl r j d me t a dPlitf d e n t re a a l r e o e e ou in f h to o l mmay u g n, n an if o s o e t bls t the i lke y t s c e o t m e isofhi c a m s Fore m pl Pl i ifa s r s s a i h ha s i l o uc e d n he rt s li . xn e, a ntf s e t r ght a f ded de ai esunde t Fouree h Am e m e , he a knowl dge he i a pr s ne i s f or t ne r he t nt nd nt but c e s s io r s b e t oteEih hAme d n ' cu la du us l u ih nsca s .W h l Plitf ud u jc t h g t n me ts r e n n ua p n s me t lu e ie anifwo l pr f rt r c i co elngi t a ofm e c tons aprs ne ' diag e m e wih me c l e e o e e ve uns i nse d dia i , i o r s s r e nt t di a pes love t c ureofte t ntdoe notsaeaj1983cli W rch v. lns 766F. ronne r he o s rame s tt am. i t Coli , 2d 8 , 4 ( t Ci.1 8 ) Ru s lv. h fe , 28F.d31 , 9( t Ci.1 7 )( rc ra . 41 8 9 4h r 9 5 ; s el S efr 5 2 8 31 4h r 9 5 pe u im) M o e r de e nt e a n t tPl i iff ie t e us a i sr tve r e e be or r ove , f nda s xpl i ha a ntf a l d o xha t dm ni ta i em di s f e c omme ngt sa to a r quie by42U. C.j 1 () nci hi cin s e rd S. 997ea . Thebaanc ofe te pr s nty tpsi de e n s f vorbe us t y a em o ea e l e quii s e e l i n f nda t ' a ca e he r r bl t Pl i ifort c tt pr s nty de i how t a l a e r s c t m oniora tea han a ntf he our o e e l c de o loc t e our es o t nd r t Pli if sphysc ,e o i ,a m e alne ds nvol ng af de a co ti t da t day antf' ial m tonal nd nt e .l vi e r l ur n he y-o- a miitain o ap io i ac u s t j d cayg n rlyd sp r v so tl g.S e ec, d nsrto f rs n s o re he u iir e eal ia p o e f adn e . .. Bel W o fs , 41U. 5 0, 4 n.3 5 n.9( 9 9 (x lii t a man anigs c rt l v. lih 4 S. 2 5 0 2 , 48 2 1 7 ) e p anng h t iti n e u i y a o dera ope a i i tm ton i m a gea e f s on a e co i r tonspe ula l w ihi nd r nd r tng ns i i n na bl a hi r ns de a i c i ry t n t pr ncea pr esi e rieofc r cinsofcas.Thepublc' i eeti betr he ovi nd of sonal xpe ts ore to fiil) i s ntrs s te s r ed by no pr s nty i e f rng w ih pe la i s r ton,es ci ly i a c s ,lke he e ev t e e l nt r e i t na dm ni ta i pe a l n a e i r, i vi t m e a he lh te m e a phys c ls f t ofa i a e who r pe t dl har s nvol ng he nt l a t r at nt nd i a a ey n nm t e ae y m hms l.Ac o dn l, anifsmoinf rap ei n r ij n to i d n e i ef c r igy Plitf' to o r l ay n u cin s e id. mi E T RTi / dyfpi21. V N E :hs Y aoAr,07 l l+ - .2.. #. &-, ' 1 / , cT 1 ) à ' c ég:ï ;.' ) 'l U nie St t s Di t i udge t d a e s rc
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
