Muhammad v. Gallihar et al, No. 7:2016cv00313 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/8/2016. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
r FRK' OFFI U..DI COURT d S CE S SQ AT ROANOKE, VA FJ LED I TH E INI N J TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STRI T O F W R G I I C N A R O A N O K E D I SI N W O ABDUL HAM ZA W ALIM UHAM M AD, ) ) Pl itf, an if ) v . ) ) ARW L J. GALLI HAR, & , c ) ) Dee n t) fnda ts. ) J 22 2 1 UL 22 JULA , D I BY; D C A SE N O .7: 6C V 00 3 1 31 M EM O M N D UM O PI I N N O By: Gl n E.Conrad e C hi U nied Stat D i t ctJudge ef t es s ri AbdulHn z W aiM uha mad,a Vigi a i ae pr e ng pr K ,fl am oton f - m a l m r ni nm t oce di o ied i or p ei n r ij n to t tt c u tas c n tu d a a ne cv lrg t c mplitu d r4 r l ay n u cin ha he o r lo o sr e s w ii ihs o an n e 2 mi U. C. 1 3 s etn itro uo yij n tv r le.Upo rv e o t er c r , h c u t i s S. j 98 , e lig n elc t r n u cie eif n e iw f h e o d t e o r fnd t tbe a eM tha mad i no e ild t s h r le , heac i mus be s mmiy dimi s ha c us l m s t ntte o uc ei f t ton t um l s s ed. M ul mad al gest ti Aprla M a 201 ad i srt sa Re Oni St t Prs mm le ha n i nd y 6, m nitaor t d on ae ion a ove hi f rr l st a i t Se urt Le l6. Laeri M a howe r ofi r a l dl ppr d m o ecas ik ton o c iy ve t n y, ve , fce s lege y m oe rtlaor dici i r c r s agans M uha t eait y s plnay ha ge ii mmad, ba e on fle al to of sd as legains mico uc . The dic plna y he i o fc r a l dl f ie t mai ai i ri iy a s nd t si i r arng fi e lege y al d o nt n mpa talt nd c c e M u mm a oft s dicplna y c r s M uha a sa a soft e c ci ps onvit d hn d he e s i i r ha ge . mm d' ppe l hes onvi to l we e silpe ng a t 'm e he sl t s a ton. I mi M a ofi i l r duc d M uha m a s r tl ndi t he t i ed hi c i n d- y, fc as e e m d' s cliy lve,and M uha d fa st ta a r s toft rduci ofkil wilma ht e trt e l mma e r ha s eul he e ton, t as l ke m r pe ta s re ofbookst thehasar a co plt d. e a eis ha le dy m e e M tha m a a s alege t ! on M a 26,201 whie he was i t s l m d lo l s ha y 6, l n he howe ,ofi e s r fc r Muhammad v. Gallihar et al Doc. 4 (u j ce ll t sx lhaa s n ' b b ign a ohe mae p io e t t a jc n ç b e td lml o e ua rsme t y rn ig n t r l rs n r o he da e t s i ' s hower t e , hus xposngM uhn madt a f lvi w oft ma sna d ge t s M thn a sa e i m o ul e he n' ke nial. l mm d t t s t tli c pl nta ha ls om ai bouttlsi de ,aswelasot rgre nce a al r a e t M sc am si li nci nt l he i va ppe s elt d o li n t sa ton, e silpe ng. hi c i r tl ndi Dockets.Justia.com , RK Bas on t alege e n s M uha mad contnds t t he i e il d t t pe ii d ed he l d ve t , m e ha s ntte o ms cfe p ei n r ijlcie r l f Ap a e ty h wa t t c ur t o d rRe Or o o fcas t rlmi ay nl tv ei . p rnl , e n s he o t o r e d l n fiil: o n e i dess fom m acng li r pea booksheha co pl t t sop t i E mpagn ofha a s e ' it r li lm e t s m eed; o t her û ca i r s m nt' a r t la o y dicplnar c r ;t ta f rhi t a l rs c y prs a t al hi nd e a it r s i i y ha ges o r ns e m o owe e udt ion; nd o low m t we rhi lf wrs a e o sdehi c l. o a s e t itbr c ut i s el Th pat s e i ap ei nayijmcin mus ma eace rs o n th thei l ey e ry e kng r l r n t to mi t k la h wig G a s i l t k t s e d on t me is t thei lke yt s f rir pa a e hn m i t a e ofpr lm i r o ucc e he rt; ha s i l o ufe re r bl r n he bs nce ei na y rle ;ta t e b ln e o e ui e tp i h s fvo ;a d t ta ij n to i i t p bl eif h t h aa c f q t s is n i a r n ha n n u ci n s n he u i i c itrs- W i tr v.Nau a Re .De.Comcl I . 5 5 U. 7 2 ( 0 ) çsuig a n eet' ' ne tr l s f z i. nc, 5 S. , 0 2 08 . ç s n l p ei nay ijlci n b sd o y o apo sbit o ir p rb eh r i i c n itn wi 'te rlmi r n l to a e nl n si l y f re aa l a m s n o sse t t h n i h' fc ta ij nci r le i t n e ta r i ay r me y t a ma o l b a r e u n a ce r a t h t nu tve eif s t xr od n r e d h t y ny e wa d d po la a s wi t tt pl i ifi e ild t s h r le .'I a 22. ho ng ha he antf s ntte o uc ei f' d. t M uhn a sm o i f i e l ut y r le doe no de onsr t a lkelhood t the mm d' ton or nt roc or e if s t m ta e ny i i ha wils f rir pa a e ha m wihoutpr m ptc ti e v nton. Att mos ,he a lgest the l ufe re r bl r t o our nt r e i he t le ha hass f r f le dicplna y c r es a hasbee e ufe ed a s s i i r ha g nd n xpos t m a e nudiy,r c al ofe i ed o l t a i ly f nsve co me s a t ea sofm or r t la o y c r es The cou tcn m nt , nd hr t e e a it r ha g . r nnotfnd t tt e a lga i i ha hes le tons a e s fcente de ofi i ntal ir pa a e ha m worhy oft r que t i e l ut r r uf i vi nce mm ne ld re r bl r t he e sed ntroc o y rle .Ac o dngy tec u t l d n M u a d' moin f ritro u o yij cier le. eif c r i l ,h o r wi e y h mma s to o n elc t r nun tv eifl l M or ove ,a i e l ut y r le i t o y f m ofr le M uhn a s e i t s a ton,t e r s ntroc or ei f s he nl or ei f mm d e ks n hi c i he 1 M uhammad alo r ssa tmpor r r tani or r Temppr r r tani or r a e is onl s eque t e ay esr i ng de . ay esr i ng de s r sued y rrl whe temo a tp o e ta hewils frij r i rle i n tpa tdbeo etea ves pat c udbe aey, n h v n r v s h t l ufe nuy f eif s o n e fr h d re ry o l n tte a dh v o p ru iyt rs o d S eF d R. v P. 5 1 S ha o d rwo do l ls u tls c tme oi d n a e p o tnt o ep n . e e . Ci. 6 48. uc n r e ul ny at ni u h i i a ah mi g o ap ei nay ijmcin c ul b arng d Asi i cer9o teo te ta Mt a d i n t s e n n r l r nt to o d e ra e . t s la m h ust h t l mma s o mi h e tte t apei n r ijncin,h c u t sn bai u o whc t wa thm atmp rr r s ii ode. n i d o rl ay nu to te o rsnd o ss p n ih o n i e o ay ekanng r r l mi c u twild s ist e e t ec s wi u p eu ie p ru n t 2 U. C.j1 5 b ( )2f r o r l im s h ni a e t t rj d c , u s a t o 8 S. r ho 91 A( )1, o f itr t sae ac am t t r le s a lle o t t l i o he ei f ough . An a r prae or rwilis t sda . t3 pp o i t de l s ue hi y W hl d s sa o ttsa to wi u p eu ie la s Mu mma fe t r fl l s ie imis l f l cin t t rj d c e ve hn d ' e o e i ' i ho r el i cam si ne a s pa a e cvi aci ns he i r m i li n w nd e r t i l to , s e nded oft Fe r lRulsofCi lPr dlr he de a e vi oce ze. A c m pl i is l mus i l t c am sa t f c si s o ant te f t ncude he l i nd he a t n uppor oft e c am s Suc deais t hos l i . h t l m a no bepr vi d m e ey by a tc ng a sa k ofunlbee doc e ai n a a fda t . I y t o de rl ta hi tc a ld um ntto nd fi vis n addii n,a t s c thasa s d M uhn m a i pr vi usor r i ot rc es hi pr tc of to s hi our dvi e m d n e o de s n he as , s aci e c ppi hi own s r a fda ti o t pa c ho ng s wo n f vi nt wo- ge hunks usng hi pe s nal c e t d ( f vi' , i s r o ly r a e t fda t' a f m ,i t c ptbl The na r w m i i lne o hi a fda tf r ma hi ha or s ma ce a e. ro tng i s n s fi vi o m ke s ndm ii tng nea l i ry mpos i e t r d, a t t pa f ma of t f m e otr s hi t s i sbl o ea nd he wo- ge or t he or nc lage m o ubm t muli e,ove l ppi ve sons of e nt ,i t a o one ompr he i a fda t'ttng hi tpl ra ng r i ve s nse d f ,c e nsve f vi sa i s co e e ve so ofr l nt e nt,as r e e d i t c mplt r i n eeva ve s ef r nce n he ompli is l. Shoul he fnd i a nt t ef d i t nec s a' t ptr uef rhe cvi a tons he mus elm i t t no e pl a ng de i e e e s z o ls ' t r i l ci , y u t i na e he t d e di fcincis. The Clr i die t d t s nd c e o t s memor ndlm o ni a a co nyi e k s r c e o e opi s f hi a l pi on nd c mpa ng or rt pl n if de o aitf. ENTER:Ths % g d yo J l, 2016. i a f uy Chif nie St t sDititJ e e t d a e src udg 2 Und rj1 1 A()1,t c u ti rq ie t ds s a y a to o cam fldb ap io ra ans a e 9 5 b () he o r s e urd o imis n cin r li i y rsne g i t e gover nt entt orof ri t c tdee mi t aci o cahn i G rvolus mai ous o f ist sae a nme al iy sce f he our tr nes he ton r l s ç i o , lci , r al o tt f cam upon whihr le ma bepa e ' li c eif y nt d.' 3 I i alo ce 9o M uha d' s s inst the ha ,once a n,tld a f de a lws tbeor t s s lar m mma s ubmiso ha s gai ie e r l a ui f e c mpl n wi tee h usinrq rme t i 4 U. C. 1 9 ea.Thsd fce c p o ie a oh rg omd fr o yig t h x a to e uie ns n 2 S. j 9 7 () i e in y r vd s n te rt s o h dimis loft sacin. s s a hi to 3
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
