Shine v. Clarke, No. 7:2016cv00258 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 8/29/2016. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
clEax' OFFI U. . SI GOURT - : CE S DI AT> Oc , A V FL D Ié At 20 2 1 s 26 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT FO R TH E W E STER N DI STR I T O F V I G I I C R N A R OA N O K E D I I O N V SI R I AR D SH I E, CH N Pett oner, ii J ULI , DLR CLERK BY: W CL ERK C i lA c i No.7: 6- v- 258 vi t on 1 c 00 M EM O M N DU M O PI O N M HAROLD YV.CLARKE, BY: R espondent . H o M i hae F. rbans n. c l U ki U ni e St e D i t i tJudge t d at s s r c Ri z Shi aVigi ai aepr e ngpr K , ied apeii n f a wrtofha as cha d ne, r ni nm t oce di o fl tto or i be c r u , u s a t o2 U. C. 2 4,oc aln et u g n e trdb t eCic i Co r fr o p s p ru n t 8 S. j 25 t h lç g hej d me t n ee y h r ut u to t CiyofLy hbur Thi m a tri bef r t c tf pr lmi r r vi w, zs ntt Rul 4 he t nc g. s te s o e he our or e i na y e e plr ua o e o t Rue Go en n j2 5 Ca e .Afe rv e n t er c r ,h c u t imis st f he ls v r i g 2 4 s s tr e iwig h e o d te o r d s se he pe iin a tm ebared, tto s i r 1. On Aug t28,201 t Cic tCour f t CiyofLync g s nt nc d Shi t us 3, he r ui t or he t hbur e e e ne o f te yea s i a c r ton f t co c i ofditi i c ai Shi spr ry-ie oure n r ' nc r e a i or wo nvitons srbutng oc ne. ne' ope l fl d a alt t Cour ofAppe l o Vigi awa de e on M a c 1 201 Appel t c ms ldi ppe o he t a s f r ni s ni d r h 3, 4. la e ot e d notpr ry pe f c a a a t t Supr m eCour ofVigi a.On J nua y 8 201 Sli fld ope l re t n ppe l o he e t r ni a r , 5, lne ie apeii n f ra wrtofha a c puswih t Supr m eCour o Vigi a, c de edt tto o i be s or t he e t f r ni whi h ni he pe ii on J y 6,201 tton ul 5. Shine v. Clarke Doc. 4 Shi fl t i tntpeii onM a 22,201 SeeR. v.2254Ca e 3( ne ied he nsa tton y 6. Go s s d) ( e ci igt p io - i o nl l Thec u t o i o l fldt ep tto a v sd S ie d srbn he rs n mal x l . b e o r c ndt nal ie h eiin, d ie hn i y t thep tto a p a e t b t i l fld, ndp o d dhm t eo p ru iyt e panwh ha t ei n p e r d o e mtmey ie a r vie i à p o tnt o x li y i Dockets.Justia.com t c ts d c i ri tm ey tl d.Shi e ansi r pons t thi a lt com s l he our houl onsde t i l ie ne xpl i n es e ha s ppela e t e wa i feci f rf ii t pe f c t a al o t Supr m eCour ofVigi a. s ne f tve o alng o r e t he ppe t he e t r ni I I. Ha e sp tto ssldt e j2 5 aes be t oao ey a p ro o l tto 2 b a eiin e md r 2 4 r u j c t n - e r ei d f i ain. 8 mi U .S. j22 4() 1. Thea i a epe i f t i t ntpeii n bega t nm fom t da e pplc bl rod or he nsa tto n o r he t C. 4 d ()1 O Whiht ej g n o c n ito b c metn 1 2 U.. j2 4 ( )1( ; e Uni d n c h ud me t f o vcin e n i a. 8 SC. 2 4 d ( )A) s e t 2 e S ae v. a 5 7U. 5 2 5 4( 0 3 ( odngac n ito b c me fn l n ete tts Cly, 3 S. 2 , 2 2 0 ) h li o vcin e o s i a o c h a i bit o dr c r ve i e ha td .Th o - e rfl gp ro i tle whl ac n its val l y f ie t e iw s x use ) e ney a ii e id s o ld ie o v c' a i n t ope l tl d a ia i f rStt pos E pr ry se pplc ton o ae tconviton oro he c lt r lr yi w'i ç ndi ' 28 ci t r olae a e e ' s ç pe ng. ' U. C. 2 4 d () s eW al Kh l, S. j 2 4()2 ; e lv. o i U. S. ,1 S. .1 7 ,1 8 - 9( 01 ) 31 Ct 2 8 2 8 8 2 1 ( ic sn p o e dng ta q aiya c laea r ve . ds usig r c e i s h t u lf s o ltrl e iw) S i ' j2 4p tto i u tmeyun e j2 4 ( )1( .S i ' c n cinb c me hnes 25 eiin s ni l d r 2 4 d ()A) hnes o vito e n fna i Aprl201 whe t tm ee r d f Shi t no ea a a fo t Cou tofAppe l l ln i 4 n he i xpie or ne o t n ppe l r m he r as o Vigni t t eS p e Co r o Vigni.S eVa S p. . 5 1 ()(ttn al p a f r i a o h u rme u t f r i a e . u CtR. :4 a saig ra pe l 1Theoneyerp ro o l tt nfrtl ah b a peio t e j2 4b gn t r no telts o a eid fi ai o ii a e s tin md r 25 e is p u n h aet f mi o ng t f dat : our es ( ted t o whc tej g n b c mef l tec n lso o diet e e o tee piaino te A)h ae n ih h ud me t t a ma by h o cu in f rc rviw r h x rt fh o tmef s e ng s h rviw; i or e ki uc e e ( ted t o whihtei dme tofl ga a piaince tdb S aeato i voaino te B) h ae n c h mpe i n t ii n p lcto rae y tt cin n ilto fh n Consi in orlwsoft Unied S ae i r moved,i t a i ntwaspr ve ed9o flngby s h tt o m a he t t ts s e f he pplca e nt m ii uc St ea ton; at ci ( t d t o whihtec nsi o a rg t setdwa iial rc g ie b teS p e Cou ite C)he ae n c h o tt n lih a sri s nt l e o nz d y h u r me tt fh mi i y rghtha bee ne yr ogniedbyt Supr Cour a madertoa tvey a ia et c e on ' i s n wl ec z he eme t nd er ci l pplc bl o as s cola er r ew'or l t al evi , ( ted t o whc t fcu l rdct o tecam o camspe e tdc udha eb e dso ee D)h ae n ih he a ta p e iae fh li r li rsne o l v e n ic v rd t ought exe cs ofd dii nce. hr he r ie ue lge 28U.. . 2 4 d( ) SC j 2 4()1. 2P tin rddno ag etmeiesu e sbscin ( tru h( eio e i t ru i ln s nd r u eto s B) ho g D) t . 2 fom t Cour ofAppe si al wedonl i t a la fl sano i ofa r he t al s lo y f he ppe lnt ie tce ppea wihi t ry l t n hit d y o tefn lud me t.Afe alwigf <tet ligo t ep ro whl tesaeha a a s f h i a j g n ) tr lo n o h oln f h e id ie h tt be s pr e ng wa pe ng,Shi wa r quiedt 5l hi f de alha aspeii by Oc o r201 oc edi s ndi ne s e r o e s e r be tton t be 5, buthedi no fl t peii untlM a 201 d t se he tton i y 6. Equia et lng i a ia e o y i Ghos r r i t nc whe e- d t cic sa e t bl oli s val bl nl n G e a e nsa es r ue o r um tnc s t e ena t t pa t so conduc - i woul beunc ns ona et e o cet lm iai n pe i xt r l o he ry' wn t t d o ci bl o nf r he i t to rod a ans t ep rya dg os ij tc wo l r s l. Ro s v. e 3 9F.d2 8 2 6(t Ci. g i t h a t n r s nusie ud e ut' u e Le , 3 3 3 , 4 4h r ' 2 0 )(nb n )(ne n lq tto makso te )(iigHa i v Hu c i o , 0 F.d3 , 0 3 e a c itr a uoain r mitd ctn n s . thns n 2 9 3 25 3 0(t Ci, 0 ).Th s apei o rmu th v G e np rungh srg sdlg nl a d. . 3 4 h r 20 0) u , t ine s a e l e u s i i iht iie t n . t b y, s ee r or nar cr umsa esood i hi wa ' o pr ve tm ey flng.Hola v.Fl rda om xta di y ic tnc t n s y't e nt i l ii l nd oi , 5 0U.. 31 6 9( 01 ) 6 S 6 , 4 2 0. Shi slck ofknowl dge a tl lpr s ort sa t o y de dlnef f r lha a ne' a e bou ega oce s he t tz r a i or ede a be s t r le doesnots ei f uppor g a i s h e r r na y r if Ha s 209F. a 330. Furher e, t r ntng uc xtao di r ele . ni , 3d t t mor t c tdoesnotfnd a e r or nar cr lmsa si t sr or t tpr ve e Shi fom he our i ny xta di y icl tnce n hi ec d ha e nt d ne r flng atmel pe ii n a trt Supr m eCour ofVigi adimi s d hi habe spe ii n. See ii i y tto fe he e t r ni s s e s a tto . eg, ie S ae v. o a 3 4F.d5 7 51 (t Ci. 0 ) ( o igt a p o. sau a d ..Untd tts S s , 6 3 0 , 2 4h r 20 4 n tn h t r z tt s n t in rn eo t lw d e n t u t ye ui betli ) Tlne v. o n o 1 7F.d39 , 9 g o a c f he a o s o j si q t l ol ; u r J h s n, 7 3 0 3 2 f a ng ( t Ci.1 9 )( tn t t n a laiywi t 1w d et i iea yo p oK sat d e no 5h r 9 9 noig ha u f miirt t he a u o l trc r r ttz o s t h l s t llmiatonspe i .Aec di y,Shi fldhi fde a ha a peiinmor t noneye r ol i t i rod) or ngl ne ie s e r l be s tto e ha a a trt ej d me t c mefna, hnei no e tte t e utb etlig, n tepeiinmu t fe h u g n be a i l S i s t n i d o q i l ol a d h tto s l a n bedimisd.SeeHilv. a on,277F. 701 707(t Ci. 2)(ec zi adititc t s se l Br xt 3d , 4h r 200 r ogni ng src our ma sl rl ds s aj2254peiin i apeii rfist ma t rquiies ngof y lmmaiy imis tto f ttone al o ke he e st howi tm ei s a trt co tnotfespe ii rt tt petton a a suntm e yand a l a i lne s fe he ur ii ttone ha he ii ppe r i l lows n o po t t t p o d a y ag me ta de d n e. p rt y o rvie n r u n n vie c ) mi 11 1. Fort f eg ng r as ,t c tdim is t peii f awrtofha sc pusas he or oi e ons he our s s es he tton or i bea or tm eba r d. Ba e upon t c tsfndi t tShi ha notm a t r quiie s t nta i re sd he our' i ng ha ne s de he e st ubsa il s wi o ad n a o ac n tmto a rg ta r q ie b 28U. C. 2 5 () ac riiaeo ho ng f e il f o si in l ih s e urd y S. j 2 3 c, et c t f f a aa lt i de le ppe lbiiy s ri d. ENTER:Tli ts da ofAug t 2016. y us, / +/- 4 J e.K Unie Stt sDitit dg t d ae src 4 '
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
