Ball v. Dyer et al, No. 7:2016cv00156 - Document 10 (W.D. Va. 2016)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/16/2016. (tvt)

Download PDF
ct ' oF l us Dlmcou* zRxs FcE s A R N ïv T oA 6K ,A FI ED L I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COIRT CT T FO R TH E W ESTER N DI STRICT O F V I G I I R N A R O AN O K E D I SI N W O R EG I LD U I BA LL, NA TH J 15 2 1 Lh 06 JULA C BY: L , CA SE N O .7: 16f+ 00156 Pl ntf , ai i f M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI V. DYER,SUPERI NTENDANT CVRJ, By: G l n E .Conr e ad Chi fU ni e St esD i t i tJudge e t d at src c AL. , De e a t) f nd nts. Re na d Ket Ba l a V igi a i t pr ee ng pr K ,Gl d t s ci lrght a ton gi l ih l, r ni nma e oc di o e hi vi i s c i . pls a t t 4 U. C. j1 3 algn ta a j i nls p o i e hm wih a i o rc t u n o 2 S. r 98 , l i g h t al t e r v d d i t n nc re t e r m e c ton. Upon r viw oft c di a i e e he ompli ,t c ltfnds t tt ac i mus be sl ma iy a nt he otr i ha he ton t lm rl dim is d. s se Backeround Bal saest the i i r e aed a a pr ti de ane a t Ce r lVigi a Re onal l tt ha s nca c r t s e ral t i e t he nta r ni gi J i CGheJ l' i Or nge,Vigi a He alege t tdu i t eve ng pilpa saol 9: al t ' ' n a ai ) r ni. l s ha rng he ni l s r md 00 p. . o M a c 23, 201 Chdsi Furow , LPN, ha d Ba l a pa r cu s m n rh 6, tna r nde l pe p, uppps y edl co ani hi e ni dos oft media i pr s rbe f rhi c oni he c .Bal t ug nt i ng s ve ng e he c ton e c i d o s k c ada hes l ho ht t c us m e c ton i t c l d dif r nti col t n hi m e cai n us ly a he r hed di a i n he up ooke fe e n or ha s di to ua l ppea e r d. He as d Furow t c wha t m e c ton was a bot tm e s s d i wa t media i ke r wi e t he di ai , nd h i s he ai t s he c ton het k e r ni . Ba li sed mos oft media i n be or henotc a dif r n t se a oo ve y ght l nge t t he c to f e ied fe e t a t nd Ball v. Dyer et al Doc. 10 nlm b s t hi t l ne s o s ongue t t he di not nor a l e r e e w he t ki hi pr c i d ha d m ly xpe i nc n a ng s es r be m e cne. The e tr he fl d a r que t f m, sai t t Furow ha gi n li t wr di i r afe , ie e s or t tng ha r d ve lm he ong m e c ton a asdngf agle nc f m . di a i nd l or i va e or Dockets.Justia.com RK , W ihi 15 or20 mi e oft ki t m e c to Bal sa td ç xpe i nci dr nage tn nuts n ng he dia i n, l t re û re ng ai e al s v re czo i c ug r a to . Co l 7 ECF No.1) Cl s t min g t Balfld az t e e lq l nc o h e cin' mp . , d r '( . o e o d ih , l ie l i t r ques f m s ki m e c la tnto f a c nma e e t or ee ng di a te i n or ough,tg ne si hi c t a tt hi a 1 i ht s n s hes, nd t c ng 1 i o r' (d. Balas alg s t th s fe e n u e a tr tkn t me iain Fu r w ve. I ) l lo le e ha e u fr d a s a fe n ig he dc to ro ' dei r d t hi on M a ch 23,201 lve e o m r 6. Bals sFurow f ne i nc a f delbe ae i fe e et a s rousm e c lnee l ue r or glge e nd or i r t ndif r nc o e i di a d i vo ai no hi c n t uina rg t.Heas s st ej i a to iya dt ej i s p rne a t n ilto f s o si to l ih s t lo ue h al uh rt n h al u e itnd n , s e ngm one a y dn a f hi pa n a s f rng. e ki t r m ges or s i nd ufe i Di scuss on i Und r28U. C.j1 5 b () te c u ti rq ie t r ve p io e c mp an sf r e S. 91 A( )1 , h o r s e ur d o e iw rs n r o lit o c omplanc wih t ba i r e ofpl adi and d i t sr viw,m us et ri ntf a c am i e t he sc ul s e ng, urng hi e e t ihe de iy l i i t c n he ompl i on wlih r le m a be gr nt d ors ma iy dimist co ai . A vi bl ant lc e if y a e um rl s s he mpl nt a e c ompl i mus a l e te ant t leg tnough f t t sa e a c am t r le t t i pl usbl on is f c ' acs o tt l i o e if ha s a i e t a e. ' Gira tn v J l o ,5 F.d 29 ,3 2 ( t Ci.2 0 )( l At.Co .v Two l,5 0 arn a o . oms n 21 3 8 0 4h r 0 8 Bel l p . mby 5 U. 5 4, 7 ( 0 ) S. 4 5 0 20 7 . A gove n e ofk i vi a e t c tm to lrght ofa pr til deai e whe s r m nt f al olt s he onsi i na i s e ra t ne n he kno of but dir ar a s do rs of ha m t t deai e. Se Pa s e r l Lee v. ws seg ds e us ik r o he t ne l e ni h x e . Clvea d 3 2 F.d 29 3 2 (t Ci. 0 ) (iig Fa rv.Brn a 51 U..8 ,8 7 e ln , 7 3 4, 0 4h r20 4 ctn nne e n n, 1 S 25 3 ( 9 4 ç-' b la l u d rt i sa ad t eo fca mu tb t bea r o fcsfo whc 1 9 $. lf o e ib e n e h s tnd r , t fiil s oh wae f a t r m ih gj h t i ee ecoll be dawn t tas bsa ilrs ofs roushn m e ss a (l mus alo he nfrnc zd r ha u tnta ik ei r xit, nd she t s 1 Cli conc r i c f m e condii i ed u n pr ti de ane sa et bee uatdunde t ams e n ng on me nt tons mpos po eral t i e r o val e r he Du Prc s Clu e rte ta u d rt EihhAme d n .Bel W ots , 41U. 5 0 5 55 8(9 9 .Du e o es a s ,ah r h n n e he g t n me t lv. l h 4 i S. 2 , 3 -3 1 7 ) e pocs p o cie p ns n o a d tie beoe po e aj dcto o g i h s b e a c mpihe . Asa r es r srb s u ihme t f ean e fr rp r du iain f ul a e n c o ls d t pr tc ma tr ho ve ,t cont soft DuePr s Clus i t prs c e tnd t be c t i wih acial te , we r he our he oce s a e n he ion ontxt e o oexensve t t s tntve c tmtona prncplsco t ha a i vi t Ei h Ame he ubsa i onsi i l i i e urs ve ppled a he ght ndmentt c ced i ts. Se o onvit nmae e Hi v Nio e , 7 F.d9 7 9 -2(t Ci. 9 2 . l . c d mus 9 9 2 8 , 919 4h r 1 9 ) l d a t if rn e''1 .(u tn Fn me,51 U. a 8 7 .Rti n te o g t a teo fc r 1 rw he r ee c .' d q o ig r r 1 S. t 3 ) l s o n u h h t h fie l l s o l ha erc g ie r s b tn il ik o h r ; s e a t al mu t a ep r ev dters . h u d v e o n z d a u sa ta rs f n mj gh q cu ly s h v ec i e h ik' ' I M e ene i nc orm e c lm al a tce doe notrs t a c tt tonallve . Ese l 429 d. r glge e dia pr c i s ie o onsiu i e l t le, U. a 1 1 S. t 05- 06. Unde t sa yss Ba lsc r hi nal i, l' ompli doesnotsa ea c nsiutonalc am a ns a ne ant t t o tt i l i gai t nyo . Hi al ga i do not s s le tons uppor a r s na e i e e e t t Ntr e Furow kne t c ts d t ea o bl nf r nc ha ls r w he rlhe m e c to i t c wa no Ba ls pr s rbed me c ton or t t s lne t me c ton di a in n he up s t l' e c i di a i ha he c w he di a i pos d a s t nta rs ofhn m t Ba l Att m os,Bals c e ubsa i l ik r o l. he t l' ompl i pr s nt a cai t t ant e e s l m ha Furow ne i nty f l d t f l t sa r of ca e r quie of ntres t dipe e r glge l aie o olow he t nda d r e rd ls - o s ns m e ca in t pa int aspr s rbe by t i physc a . Suc al ga i ofm e e y neg i nt di to o te s e ci d her ii ns h le tons rl lge co nduc by t ntr e do noti ia e a c tt to ly pr eced rg a ar no a tona e t he ts mplc t ny onsiui nal ot t i ht nd e t c i bl t e j1 8 md r 9 3. Bal as s e t e j i a t o y a d ji s p rne d n ,but doe no sae a f c s l lo u s h al u h dt n al u e itn a t s t tt ny a t . wha s ve c meci t ede e nt o t rpolcist t media i i de . Se M o l toe r ol tng hes f nda s r hei i e o he c ton nci nt e nel v.Ne Yo k Civ De t o S ca S r ie ,43 U..6 8 6 0 ( 9 ) ( c lg v r i g w r t p . f o il e vc s 6 S 5 , 9 1 78 t a o e nn to b d e . . a bes e drcl t e 5 98 frmo eay d caaoy, rij n tv rle wh r o is . c n u d ie ty md r 1 3 o n tr , e lrtr o nu cie eif e e . . . t a i t ti al ge t be t onsiu ina i e nt bre u esa polcy sae e , he cton ha s le d o mc tt to l mpl me s xec t i t tm nt o dna c , e lto ,o d cso o tcal a o t d a d p o l ae b t a b d ' o fc r' r i n e r > ain r e iin fi il d p e n r mu g td y h t o y s fie s). y l a iin,hes peitn a twa lwf ly e t ld t rl o t en resme ia j d me ti n ddto t u rne d n s a ul n i e o ey n h u s ' d c l u g n n t mater r ae t Bal' c zs ofme c lte t ntShac v.Smih,71F. 1 1 ( h Ci. t s eltd o ls olre dia rame , lka t 3d 62, 67 4t r 1 9 ) a d c n o b v c do l la l frt en resa to s S eAs co t I b l 5 6U. 9 5 , n n n t e ia usy ib e o h u s ' cin . e h r f v. g a, 5 S. 6 2 6 6( 0 9 . 6,7 20) Fo t e sae r a o s t e c u tsl rl d s se Bals j1 3 cams wih u r h ttd e s n , h o r l mmaiy imis s l' 98 li to t p eu ie u de j 1 5 b ()f rfiu e t sae a cam. M o e v r b c us Balsae no rj dc n r 91 A( )1 o alr o tt li ro e , e a e l tts a to a l j 1 8 cam, h c u t e ln st e ecs s p lme tl mid ci no e h srlt d cin b e 9 3 li t e o r d cie o x r ie u p e n a j s ito v r i eae sae1w cams s e2 U.. j1 6 ()3 , ndwi sl rl ds s t ee tr c s wih u tt a li , e 8 SC. 3 7c ( ) a ll l mmaiy imis h n ie a e to t p eudc .Ana p o raeo d rwils u ti d y. rj ie p r p it r e l is e l s a l ' The Clr i die t d t s nd c pi of t s me o andlm opi on a ac ompa ng ek s rce o e o es hi m r z ni nd c nyi or rt pli if de o antf . N ENTER:Thi t dyo Jme 2 6 s G a f t , 01 . Chi fUnied St t D i ti tJ e t a es sr c udge 4

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.