Kiser v. SWVRJA, No. 7:2016cv00129 - Document 25 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 9/15/2016. (slt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CL :OFFI u.s. SI COURT ERK' CE Dl . ATDANML VA LE. FI ED L I THE UNI S N TED TATESDI CT COURT STRI FO R TH E W E STER N D ISTR ICT O F V I G I IA R N ROANOKE DW I ON SI S 15 2 1 EP 26 J I c. EM cI q UqA DUDL p BY; EPUTY cLE RI W KI CI SER, Pl nt f , ai i f Ci lAc i N o.7: c 00129 vi ton 16- v- M EM O R AN D UM O PI O N M SW VRJA, D ef endant . By: H on.Jacks L.K i e on sr Seni U ni St es D i ri Judge or ted at st ct liky Kie ,aVigi ai a epr ee ng pr K ,fld aci lrght aci n,na i t kc sr r ni nm t oc di o ie vi i s to m ng he So t wetVign aRe in lJ iAuhoiy(IW VRJ ' a t es l d fnd n .Pli tf u h s r ii go a al t rt G S A' s h o e ee a t anif ) c mpli t a j ipoiyp e e t me ia t si ga dte t n o h sHe t i C (1 ' o ans h t al lc rv n s d c l e tn n r ame t f i pai s $ t HCV' ) i ec i n a doe nota l hi t be a t sy bec us he t kes s i e m e c tons The nf to nd s low m o nz t a e a e zur di a i . SW VRJ fld am oto t dim is a Pl i ifr s nde wih am oton t n e t A ie ih o s s , nd antf e po d t i o m nd he co pl nt Afe r viwi t r c d,Igr tt m oto t a e plr ué t Rul 1 a m ai . tr e e ng he e or ' he i n o m nd zs nt o e 5 nd an de t SW VRJ Sm o i t dimisbe a e lbe al c t u d,Pl ntf salegai nssae ny he A' ton o s s c us , i r ly onsr e ai if l to tt p a sb ecamsf rrle .S e e:, i sv. r e , 0 U. 51 , 2 - (9 2 . lu il li o eif e e ..Hane Ken r 4 4 S. 9 5 0 21 1 7 ) çAqmu iiai c n o b hedla l t e j1 3o ar s nd a s p ro te r . 1 ( n cp lt n n t e l ib e md r 98 n epo e t u e ir h o y' y ' M o el De to S c S l .43 U.. 5 , 91( 9 8 .Th s t eS VRJ c n o beh l n lv. p' f o . ews, 6 S 6 8 6 1 7 ) u ,h W A a n t ed viai u l la l t e j1 3f rtea t o ise l y e .Ho ve,tlo a g v r i c ro sy ibe md r 98 o h cs f t mp o e s we r ç l c l o enng g bo is. . a bes ddr cl . . o mo eay d ca ao y o ijmcier l f e e. .h de . c n ue ie ty . fr n tr , e lrt r , r n l tv ei wh r . te e a ton t ti a l ged t be t c tt i c i ha s le o m ons iutonali pl m e sore ut a polc s a e e , m e nt xec es i y t t m nt Kiser v. SWVRJA Doc. 25 o di nce r ul ton,orde s on ofk i ly a ed a pr ul t d by t body' of i e s' r na , eg a i ci i t a l dopt nd om ga e hat s fc r . ' 1 . t6 0 Top o et tag ve n a e t y s ha al c l al u h rt ,sl bl f r d a 9 . r v ha o mme tl ni , uc s o a j i a t o iy i i e o t > c tt i na vi a i c m it d by is e pl ye s apl i ifm us s ons iuto l ol tons om te t m o e , a ntf t how t tt e iy' ha he ntt s polc w a t m o ng f c oft c tt tonalvi a i n. See e. , k Cnt v.Dods 454 i y s he vi or e he ons iu i ol t o . g. Pol y. on, Dockets.Justia.com U. 31 3 6( 98 ) s r i amoint ds s, panifmu tp a sbyalg ( ) h S. 2, 2 1 1 .To u vve to o imis a litf s lu il l e 1 t e e e se c o a o ca p lc o c so ( )t a i f il atiu a l t t emu cpa e tt a xitn e f n o il o iy r u t m,2 h t s ary trb tb e o h nii l n i nd y, ( pr maeyc usdt t ryi co tt i lvi ain.Se eR.J da e r lJ da v. 3) oxi tl a e he mde l ng nsi ona olto m es . , or n x e. or n J ks 1 F. 333,338(t Ci.199 .M t ci lpolcyc nbef ac on, 5 3d 4h r 4) mi pa i a oundi wrte or na es n itn di nc a r gul to , fr tvedecsonsofpolcy a ng of i l,orom iso by polc a ng nd e ai ns afimai ii i m ki fc as s i ns iym ki ofii l t tm a f tde i r t i fe e et t rght ofcii e .Ca trv. ori,1 F. fc a s ha nies lbe a e ndif r nc o he i s tz ns re M rs 64 3d 21 , 8( t Ci.1 9 ) 5 21 4h r 9 9 . Fis, anifalg sg n rlyi tea nd dc mplit t wa d r e tu ty sa's rt Pli tf le e e e al n h me e o an ,: s el d r sgj tt I i u f ha ngas i edior r The sae , G t me c lc ensf pli ifss ft '' or vi ezur s de . y ttdgj Due o dia onc r or antf aey.' Pl ntf i l d gre ncer s ns fom SW VRJ sa fde ngPli ifsr ques f r ai if ncude iva e po es r A t f nyi antf e t o co i r ton ofbeng at sy.Pl i ifr f r e t t Am e i nswih Dia ltesAc , nsde a i i nzt antf e e r d o he rca t s biii t 42 U. C.j1 31 e s (: S. 21 , t eg.<ADA' i hi g iva e.Nonehees,safde edhi r quet sai ' n s re nc ) t l s tf ni s e s, ttng, Eà ou w e e de ed f r s z ze ,' nd, ç w e e de ed f rm e c lc e nsf your sr r ni o ei tr s ' a çYou r ni o di a onc r or S f t ... a e y. ' ' Til 1 oft ADA pr de t tG quaii i vi ua wih adia lt s l by te 1 he ovi s ha i no lfed ndi d l t s biiy hal, r as ofs h dia lt bee l df o pa tcpai n i orbede e t be isoft e on uc s biiy, xcude ' m rii to n r nid he neft he sr ie , r rms o a tvte o apu l e t y o b s be tdt ds rmi to b a s h e vc s p oga , r ciiis f bi ni , r e u j ce o ic i nain y ny uc c t e iy.'42U. C.j1 32.A i lfe i vi lwih adia lt 'sdefne asça ntt ' S. 21 t iid ndi dua t sbiiy'i i d ln qua i vi lwih adi a lt who,wih orwiho r a ona emodi ato t nzes polc e , ndi dua t s biiy t t ut e s bl fc i ns o l , ii s or . pr c i s ... t pr vi i ofa lar a ds a s r i e ,m e s t e s nt a e i biiy a tce or he o s on uxii y i nd e v c s et he s e i l lgi lt r qui e e sf t r c i ofs r i e ort pa tc pa i i pr r m sora tvii spr vi d by e r m nt or he e e pt e v c s he ri i ton n og n c i te o de apublce iy.'1 a j 1 312) Til 1 oft ADA doesa yt saeprs andt i i ntt ' d. t 21 ( . te 1 he ppl o tt ions her i ts Se eg.Pa. p' ofCor.v.Yekev,524U. 206,21 ( ) nmae . es . , De t r s S. 0 1988 . 2 Tosaeacam u d rTil 1 o t ADA, mihmu ts o ( ) h th i aq l d tt li n e te 1 f he S t s h w 1 t a e s uai se i iiu l t ads bl y;2 t a hewa d nidpm iiaini o d n e b n ft o t e ndvd a wi ia ii () h t h t see cp to n, r e id e e s f h s l c s p o rmso a tvi e o teS VRJ o wa oh r s ds rmiae a ans; n ( ) ewie , r g n r ci t s f h W i A, r s te wie ici n t d g i t a d 3 t de alordici nain wasbec us ofhi dia lt 42U. C.j 1 32.He e Plitf he ni srmi to a e s sbiiy. S. 21 r , anif e anst the s f r fom s itr st ta ef ly c r ld by m e c ton a t thewas xpl i ha ufe s r ez le ha r ul ontole di a i nd ha de e t c nc t beatusybe us ofhi te t d m e c lco ton. Ac or ngl t ni d he ha e o r t ca e s rae di a ndii c di y, he m o i t dimism us be de ed f rt sc am . ton o s s t ni o hi l i Se nd, antf alege t thi HCV i eci nsGc n' bec ke o te t d duet co Pl i if l s ha s nf to da t hec d r r a e o S VRJ Po iy kn (n qg)c n' g t epf ri. Plitf nf r dj i safh w hs W A lc ma ig a d l a t e h l o t' anifi o me al tf o i ' p i aeph sca b le dhsHCV lv l ç dra h dad n eo slve'a dalg st t al rv t y iin eive i e es G e c e a g r u e l n le e ha j i ha ' polc doe no a l H CV t s i des t hi r ue t . Li r ly c t i t a l ga i ns iy s t low e tng pie s eq s s be a l ons nlng he le to , ' Pli ifhasalege t tt SW VRJ hasapolc ofr f sngt m onioror'ea hi HCV, antf l d ha he A iy e u i o t t t s r whihi asro sme ia n e .S e e:, k v. h e e 5 5F.d2 5 2 ( t Ci. 0 8 .A c s e iu dc l e d e . ..1 o S rv , 3 3 2 , 41 4h r 2 0 ) polc t r us t tng orte t e f Gda r 'l ve sofHCV c d e i y o ef e esi r am nt or t nge ous' e l oul xpos Pli ift a e antf o s t nta rs o s roushn m .Cons quen l t c ubsa il ik f e i r e ty, he ompli plusbl s ant a i y ugge t a Ei h ss n ght Ame m e ca m ofdelber t i f e e et as rousm e ca nee Se eg. Eselev. nd nt li i ae ndif r nc o e i di l d. e. . , t l Gn e 4 U. 9 ,1 4( 9 6 . mbl, 29 S. 7 0 1 7 ) Fort f e ng r a ons 1gr ntPl i i fsm o i t a end a de t m o i n t he or goi e s , a a ntf ton o m nd ny he t o o d s is Pur ua t Stndi Or r201 6, he SW VRJ s l fl amoton f ml ma y im s . s nt o a ng de 3- t A hal ie i or m r j udgme wihi f t tveda . nt t n ory-i ys ENTER: i l Wd yo S pe r2 6 Ths g a f e tmbe, 01 . V .. t 7 . k . X ' . , ' Se rU nied St t D l ti tJ t a es sr c udge 3 '
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
