Kershner v. Wright et al, No. 7:2016cv00063 - Document 52 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/2/2016. (slt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OFFI U. . SX COURT S C: s DI AT ROANOIE, I VA FI ED I I TH E UN I D STATE S D I N TE STR I C O U RT CT FO R TH E W E STERN D I STR I O F W R G I I CT N A R O A N O K E DI I O N V SI TOBY KERSHNER, Pl ntf , ai if V. B. .W RI H T,e aI, A G t . D efendant s. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) DE2 25 2 1 26 J . U L CL EY ERK B ., h . = CLERK Ci lA c i N o.7: c 00063 vi t on 16- v- M EM OR AN D U M O PI I N N O By: H on. i hae F.U r M c l bans ki Uni e St e D i t i tJudge t d at s s r c To Ke s r aVigi ai aepr ce di pr x , ie a cvi rght compl nt by r hne , r ni nm t o e ng o fld i l i s ai purua t 42U. C.j1 3,nnmi vai c re tona a me c lsafa s itdwih s nt o S. 98 ng rous or ci l nd dia tf s ocae t Ri r lh Co rcin l n e (RNCC'.P an ifa g e t td f n a t v oae teEihh ve No' re to a Ce tr $ t ç ' litf r u s ha e e d n s i ltd h g t ) Am e e by f lngt pr e thi 9om a he i ae' a tc a f de i r t ndm nt aii o ot c m not r nm t s ta k nd or lbe a e i fe e t r s tnts i m e c lnee .D e e nt Ros Dulney,Ra helW els ndif r nce o e ula erous di a ds f nda s e a c l, Ch iteKig a d LiaPak (olciey,i dc l fn a t' fldamoinf rsl r rsi n , n s r s c le tv l ç ia Dee d n s' ie Me ) to o l mma y j d me ta g n ta Plitf f i dt e h us a albea mi srtv rme is ECFNo . u g n, r uig h t anif al o x a t v ia l d nitaie e d e . e s 34,42. trr e ngt r or t c tfndst tt M e c lDef nda sar e il d t Afe eviwi he ec d, he our i ha he di a e nt e ntte o s ummayj d me tb c u ePlitf d dno e h us a ia l a mi srtv rme isl r u g n e a s anif i t x a t valbe d nitaie e de . 1 p ryi e t ldt smmayj d me tftepla ig ,hedso r a dds lslemaeil o fl, A at s nie o u r u g n i h e dn st ic vey n ico t tras n i t r e a a yafd vt s o ta teei n g n ieds uea t a ymaeila t Fe R. v P. 6 a.Maeil at nd n fia is h w h th r s o e un ip t s o n tra fc. d. Ci. 5 () tra fcs a et ene es ay t esa ih t elme sofapa t sca eofa ton. Andes v.Li rvLobby.l ,477 U. r hos c s r o tbls he e nt ry' us ci ron bet nc. S. 2 2 2 (9 6 .A g n iedsueo maeila te it i,nve n terc r a dale s n beifrn e 4 , 48 1 8 ) e un ip t f tra fc xss f it iwig h e od n lrao a l nee c s Kershner v. Wright et al dr t egom i alghtmos fvor bl t t non- ng pa t ar a ona ef c-i rcoul rt r ave dit awn her n i t a a e o he movi ry, e s bl a tfhde d eun r c f t non- ova .I Themovi pa t ha t bur nofs or he m nt d. ng ry s he de howi - Sha i poi i outt t dititc tng ç t s, ntng t o he src om' t tt ei a a enc ofe d et s ha her s n bs e vienc o uppor t non t he movi pary' c e.'Celt x Cor v.Car t 477U. 317, ng t s as ' o e p. tet S. Doc. 52 3 5(9 6 .I temo a t aife ti b re te ten n- v n mu t e frhs ct fcsta d mo srt 2 1 8 ) f h v n stsis hs ud n,h n h o mo a t s st o t pe i a t h t e n tae k tee itn eo ag nun ds ueo fc frtil l a 3 2-4 A p ryi e ie t smmayj g ntfh h xse c f e ie ip t f a t o ra. d.t 2 2 . at s ntld o u r ud me ite t r or asawhol c dno ladar i tiroff tt fndi f voroft nonec d e oul t e atonal re ac o i n a he mova .W ila sv. i ,952 nt lim GrTm F.d8 0 S (t Ci. 9 1.i eet u p re se uain. .sno e o g t d fa asmmayj d me t 2 2 , 23 4h r 1 9 ) s r msp o td p c lto . i t n u, o eet u r u g n M h moin. En sv Na'As' o Bu . Ed c Ra i.n .5 F.d5 , 2(t Ci.1 9 ) A plitf c n o u ea to ' ni . tl sn f s & u . do Ic, 3 3 5 6 4h r 9 5 . anif n n t s ' rs o s t amoinfrs mmayj d me tt a ndo c re t c mplitc aln db t moinfrsmmay ep n e o to o u r u g n o me r orc a o an h l ge y he to o u r e j d me t Cla me v. De t, 5 F.d3 , 3 (t Ci. 0 ) u g n. o nh r Mc vi 5 5 3 24 3 6 4h r20 9. t Dockets.Justia.com The e usi n r quie e i m a t y a Sa i st a1i ae s t a xha to e r m nt s nda or nd çpple o l nm t uis boutprs ion 1f ( ' Po trv Nu se 5 4U. 51 , 2 , 3 ( 0 ) t o e e a sin d ma ds ie. ' re . s l, 3 S. 6 5 4 5 2 20 2 . i p r xh u to e n ) pr c ompla ewih a age y' de dlne a ot rc iialpr e alnze . W ood or v. z i nc t n nc s a i s nd he rtc oc dur l s' ' f d N o, 5 U. 81 9 ( 0 ) W h nap io p o i e a a miitaieg iv n ep o e u e te 48 S. , 0 20 6 . e rs n r v d s n d nsrtv re a c r c d r ,h i aem us fl agre nc r ii apa tc a c am a pur uei t oug ala ia elve s nm t t ie i va e a sng ri ulr l i nd s t hr h l va lbl e l o a p a t ç r p rye h us. d; x nv Pa e 2 F.d48 , 0 91(t Ci. 0 ) f p e l o l o el x a t' .Dio . g , 91 3 5 49 - 7h r 20 2 . p 'I çl nad nitai rme i no c i r dt ha be navalbl i aprs ne,hr no tAl mi srtve e dy s t önsde e o ve e ia e f io rt ough f ul ofhi own, pr nt fo a lnghi s l ofi.'M oor v. nne t,51 F.d 71 a t s was eve ed r m vaii m ef t' e Be te 7 3 7, 7 5( t Ci. 0 8 .çW l nprs no fcasp e e timae fo u igt a miitaie 2 4h r 2 0 ) t he io f il rv n n t s r m sn he d nsrtv g pr es ...t pr e st te sson pa rbe om e una ia e i r alt ' Ka v.S e 458 oc s , he oc s ha xit pe c s val bl n e iy. ' ba t pp, F.d6 8 6 4(t Ci. 0 ) A d fnd n h st b r e t p o ea imae sf i r t 3 7 , 8 7h r 20 6 . ee a t a he u d n o r v n n t' al e o u e h us a alb ea miitai r me is J n sv. c , 4 U. 1 9 21 ( 0 7 .On ea x a t v ia l d n srtve e d e . o e Bo k 5 9 S. 9 , 6 2 0 ) c de e an pr s nt e de e ofa f iur t e us,t btr e ofpr s fst t pli ift f nd t e e s vi nc al e o xha t he ld n oof hit o he antf o s how, apr ponde anc o t e de e, ha e usi n occ e orad i sr tver m e e by e r e f he vi nc t t xha to un'd m nitai e dis we et r mava lbl t ough no f ul oft pli if Se e. , ke v.Gr ve ,660 F. 1 ia e hr a t he antf . e. c.Tuc l o r 3d 249, 1 5 ( 0h Ci. 01 ) 2 4 1 t r 2 1. VDOC De a t n Op r tn Pr c d (E ' 8 6 1 ç fn e Gre a c P o e t e' p rme t e ai g o e me ç ' 6 .,l e d r iv n e r c dl , OP ) of r' pr dest a i sr tver medisf i ae t r ol c ovi he dm nitai e e or nm ts o es ve ompl i s a ala i sr tve ant , ppe dm nita i de s ons a c l ngepolc e a pr e es2 Thepr es pr de c r c i l ci i , nd hale ii s nd oc dur . oc s ovi s or e tona a i k r t sm e nst i ntf po e i lpr e sa i ne s a y,c r c t e pr e s i a dm ni ta or a o de iy t nta obl m nd, f ce s r or e t hos obl m n tm e y m a r A1 i s s a e gr e bl e pti s s a i l nne . 1 s ue r i va e xce s ue boutpolc e , oc dur ,a de i i i i s pr e es nd c sons 2I t a eore edt t im aeg iva epr dlr whent y e e t VDOC' c t andwhen nmaes r int o he n t re nc oce ze he ntr he S usody t y a eta fredt ot VDOC fciii . he r r nse r o her a ltes oft Vigi aPa ol Boa d;dicplna y he i pe lisa orpr e za e r s sa ea he r ni r e r s i i r arng nate nd/ oc dlr l ror ; t t nd f de alc tde ii ,lws a r gultons a ot rma tr be ndt VDOC' c r . e r our c sons a , nd e ai ; nd he te s yo he S ontol Be or s itng a r ul rgre nc t i a e m us m ake a good- aih ef o t o f e ubm ti eg a i va e, he nm t t f t fr t i or l r ol t is by s itng a i o ma c nf maly es ve he s ue ubm ti n nf r l ompl i f m,whi h i a l e i ant or c s vaiabl n housngl t .I siluns tsi ani t mus fl ar gulrg iva ewihi t ry c l nda i mis f tl a ifed, nma e t se e a re nc t n hit a e r da fom t da eoft oc ure eori de .Not bl r ul rgre nce t tdo notm e t ys r he t he c r nc nci nt a y, eg a iva s ha ' e tefln r q ie n so OP 8 6 1 lk ben fldlt, r rj ce a drt r e t t eimae h ii g e urme t f 6 .,ie ig ie ae ae ee td n eu n d o h n t wihi t wor ng da fom t daeofr ept3 A n i at m a a t n wo ki ys r he t ec i . nm e y ' ppea a i ake de i i by l n nt c s on s ndi t greva e a t i akede i i t ar ona o buds a wihi fve da of e ng he i nc nd he nt c son o egi l m m n t n i ys r c pt e ei . Pli iffl i o ma c a ntf ied nf r l ompli sa utt a tc on M a c 8,9, nd 11 201 a fl d ant bo he ta k rh a , 5, nd ie r gul rgreva eso M a c 11a 1 201 Ho ve , neoft s iso a r s ed e a i nc n r h nd 8, 5. we r no he ubm s i ns dd e s a lge y de i i m e ca ca e.Cons que l Pli iff ist e t ih t theptr ue le dl fcent di l r e nty, antf a l o sabls ha ts d a l ead i sr tyer m e e abo t m e c lc r wihi tlry da oft a tc ort t vaiabl m nitai e di s ut he di a a e t n lit ys he ta k ha a i sr tver m e e we enota ia e M or ove ,t ei nounwrte t pe a dm nitai e dis r va lbl . e r her s itn l cil s cr msa c s' xc p int 4 U.. j 1 9 ea t alw t camsa o tteme ia c r t iol tn e 'e e to o 2 SC. 9 7 () o l he li b u h d c l ae o o p o e d r g r ls o a yij re s san d.Ro sv Blk , U. ,1 6 S Ct 1 5 1 5 r c e , e ade s f n n u is u tie s . ae S. 3 . . 8 0, 8 5 ( 01 ) Ac od n l,h f u Me ia Dee d n s( s Dua e , c lW el, iteKig 2 6 . c r i gy te o r dc l fn a t Ro e ln y Ra he ls Chrsi n a dLiaPak )aee t ldt s n s r s r ni e o ummayj g n p ls a t o4 U. C. 1 9 e a, n t c s t r ud me t t u n t 2 S. j 9 7 () a d he a e r i di m i s a t t m . s s s ed s o he 3A copy oft hza de son i ke i t i ae' gre nc fl. he tke cii s pt n he nm t s iva e ie ' J ENTER :Thi 7 s da ofDe e be ,201 y cm r 6. / /- 'imr /. '# -r . + '' ' r . - z. U nie St t s Di t i tJ t d a e s rc u 4
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
