Clehm v. BAE Systems Ordinance Systems, Inc. et al, No. 7:2016cv00012 - Document 204 (W.D. Va. 2018)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 08/19/2018. (aab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OFFI U.S.DI .COURT S CE ST AT ROANOKE,VA FIED L I TH E UN I D STATES D ISTRI CO U RT N TE CT FO R T H E W EST ERN D ISTRICT O F W RGI I N A RO AN O U DI VISI N O A( 2 û 2 1 5 8 J q c. ' E CL U L Y ERK BY: c CARI A A .CLE H M , Pl ntf, ai if Ci lActon N o.7:6- vvi i 1 c 00012 V. Bu S STEM S O RD N AN CE Y S S EM S,I C .p1ala Y T N , , . By: H on.M i chaelF.U r bansl d Chi fUn t d St t sDit tJ e ie a e sdc udge D ee f ndant . s M EM O RAN D U M OPI IO N N Folwi e tyofs mma yj d me i isfvo ,d fnd ntBAE S tms l ng n r u r u g nt n t a r e e a o yse Or dnanceSyse s l .fl d m otonsf an a a d ofc t and ator y' f e . Pli if tm , nc ie i or w r os s t ne s e sl a ntf Ca l Clh o pos sbo. moéo . c r r fre tks mot t Untd S ae ra e m p e t h ns The ou t e er d le e i o ie tt s ons Ma ita eJ g Ro r S. zo f zr po ta r c gsr t ud e be t Ba u o e r nd e omme a n, uru n t 28U.. j nd do p s a t o SC. 6 6q 1 7)a ( () Thema itaej g is e ar po to Ma 9 2 8 r c mme dig 3 $() nd 1 3 . $ gsr t ud e su d e r n y , 01 , e o n n t tBAE' m oton f al ne sf esbe de e a t tism odon f c t begr ed i ha S i oz toz y' e nid nd ha t or oss ant n pat Clh fld atmeyobe to t t erpot. r. e m le i l jcin o h e t Thef c o Clhm' obe to i nots muc a ye r rma b t ma iva e o us f e s jcin s o h n r o de y he gs t jdg .n fc, e m tk snois wiht maitaej g ' lg la lsso u e l atClh a e sue t he gstt ud es e a nayi r com put tons a s des rbe t r por asf hoz a i , nd he c i s he e t ' ough' a T lr s d.' t ki t ' nd f -ea one 'Ra her n wel Clehm v. BAE Systems Ordinance Systems, Inc. et al Doc. 204 h rl t dobe to Clh a k t ec u tt sa a ya r ofc t pe diga a. e i e jcin, e m s s h o r o ty n wa d oss n n ppe l mi 1Co n I, lgn asut ndb teya an t ee d n l su Tik u idvd al,ssi p n iga dsto jt til u t 1al ig sala atr g is d fn a t o h a , o sn iiu l i tl e dn n e fruy ra e n y l a t d ge . s o ama s Dockets.Justia.com Bec us s ha notpt de a a e he s ovi d dequat t a on f t c tt sa a a t ofc t e e s ot he our o t y n wa d oss ort d eo de yt èa t t c mme e b t ma ita ej g ,hec uz wi ADOPT e uc r n l wad e o nd d y he gst t ud e t o t l a t t ma itaejdg ' rpot a tc mme a i ise ie y OVERRULE Clhm' he gstt u es e t nd e o nd ton n t ntt t, e s ob e éon, n a t BAE $ ,6 .0i c ssund t2 U. C. 1 2 jc a d wad 70 83 n o t e 8 S. j 9 0. 1 . A pat ma ç e v a fl s e ii, itn o e to t ama itaejdg ' ty y f r e nd i p cfc wtte bjci ns o gsl t u es s e pt opos d fndi a t com m e e i ngs nd e ndaéonswihi f t en da ofbeng s r ed wih acopy t n oute ys i ev t oft z p t' TGD 1 1FM v. u Ex ha e l c, 8F. up 3 5 0 5 3 ( . . he e oz. W ' 05 So nd c n n .8 S p. d 8 , 8 W D Va 20 5 (in 28U. C. 6 q 1)f hedit tc r mus d traned no oa . 1 ) ct g i S. j 36 $().f x' sdc out t eeni e v ny p rin oft ma ita ej g ' rpot a d r c o to he gsr t ud es e t n e omme ai t whih ap o ro e do nd t o c r pe bjc n on h sbe n ma e'l Bu , fapat d sno m a eap o robe ton t dstc c ur i no a e d . d. t i ry oe t k r pe jci , he itit o t s t ' oblga e t i i t d o ndepende l r viw t r om m e don.Se Thom asv. n,474 U . 1 nty e e he ec nda e Ar S. 40, 1 0 (9 5 (1 d sno a pe rt tCon r s i e e t r q ied sdc c r r ve o a 5 1 8 ) T t oe t p a ha g e s ntnd d o e u t it t ou t e iw f < m a i tat ' f ctz lorl ga concusons unde a de novo ora ot rsanda d when ne t r g sr es a ta e l l i , r ny he t r ihe p ryo et t tos fndn . I a ii ,hecititc r T ya cptrjc, r at bjcs o h e i igs' n ddton t t rc ou tt c e ,eeto ). s ma m odiy t r om m e f he ec nded diposton; e i fzt te de ;orr t n t m a tr t tn s ii r ceve lrhe vi nce e ur he te o le ma itaej g wihi tuci . Fe . Ci P. 21 39 c o d28U. C. 6 6 $() gsrt ud e t nsr tons' d R. v. 7 4 )a c r ' $( S. j 3 9 1. I 1. Th p i r pu p eofClh ' o e t t t ma ita ej g ' r po ta e rma y r os e m s bjci o he g sr t ud es e r nd on r c m e i i t s k a sa ofany a t ofc t pe ng a e om ndaton s o ee ty wa d oss ndi ppea.Theciti tc t l lsrc our ha dic e i t pr ee wih t xa i ofc t ort defrr i on as es m e ofcos s s s r ton o oc d t a ton os s o e ulng s s nt t untlafe t a a spr es .S n lt v.D e 7 ofCor ec i i t r he ppe l oc s i e on t r tonalEduca don,N o. 10 CV0 0 4 2 0 W L 2 2 9 9 a * ( D. . t 3 2 0 )(iai ot te ) Rul :3 0 0 , 0 3 2 9 03 , t 1 W. Va Oc . , 0 3 cttons nitd . e 5 d c e t sap e u tn i fvo ofa a t ofc t t t p e c n pat fn t 4() r ae t s mpto n a z n wa d oss o he r v g ry T he i o dnayc re'Te uev. l e , 5F. 9 ,9 6( t Ci.1 9 ) ffn ac s wheet e r i r ou s . a ? Bat r 3 3d 78 9 4 h t 9 4 .f j a e r h k g dsrc c u tfesta a rain fo ti g nea rl i a r êae t c zt tj tY itit o z e l h t berto r m ls e rl ue s pp opit,he ol mus usi z r isd csonb friuaigs meg odra o frdongs ' 1 .(uoi Oa Hal & t eii y at ltn o o e s n o i o.' d q tng k lCa c 7 Go Co. O1 Do nni Friht ne I .8 F.d 2 1 2 ( h Ci. 9 0 ) s eas wn v. d r i on e Li nc, 99 2 9 , 96 4t r 1 9 )9 e lo Ha nwhaAzde ,l v.C&D Zodi ,l , o.6:2- l nc. ac nc.N 1 CV 00023,2015 W L 1 417058,a *7 t ( D. . r 27 2 59 e v. m i n I 'Co . 1 6F.d 4 2 4 ( . Ci. W. Va Ma . , 01 ) Ch r Cha o nt l , 8 3 4 , 46 4t r h 1 99 . 9 ) H e e t onl r s Cl hm pr de f he r que tt sa a a d ofcos si r , he y ea on e ovi s or r e s o t y ny war t s he a s r i t tsa ng c t pe ng a a T be t pr c e oft sCout i t r s e ton ha tyi os s ndi ppe l r has en he a dc hi t n he pa t' . Obj ECF No.1 3, t J . t sp o i n,s ctsW ak rv. - l a s. Pls . ' ' , 9 a ! 1 For hi r poséo he ie le Mod u-fr f Home , s LLC, 71 c 0 7 , 01 W L 2 5 1 ( D. . y3 , 1 ) W ake, No. :2 v0 4 0 2 4 4 01 8 W. Va Ma 0 20 4 . l r howe r ofe sno a l i on t sis M or r i wa i adif e pr edur lposat ve , f r nayss hi s ue. eove , t s n fer nt oc a t e t n t ei tntc s- a t tmet bi ofc t wa fld t c u tss ha h nsa a e t he i he l oss s i , he o r' umma yj g nt l e r ud me r i wasa t ady penci on a a a t Four h Cic t I a e nt W ake doesnot ulng le lng ppe l t he t r ui. n ny ve , l r s ugges i i t pr ctc oftascour t sa a a r ofc t pe ng a a . t t s he a ie li t o t y n wa d oss ndi ppe l Cl ehm ofe sno ot rr s why t cour s d e z ie isdic e i t s a a fr he ea on he t houl xe c s t s r ton o ty nzi on t em otons a t c tfndsno good r s f doi s I e t z i lng ' hes i , nd he our i ea on or ng o. nde d, he e s good r a on no t sa a a r ofc t i t sc s .f ih pr ptt xa es 1 o t y n wa d oss n hi a e V t om a don,a a ny ppea l fom t a r ofcos sc d f asbl be c oldat wih t pe ng a r he wa d t oul e i y ons i ed t he ndi ppea on t l he meis t r b e ha i gj iil fiinc . Sn et n, 0 3N L 2 9 0 , t* (i g rt,he e y n ncn udca e fce y' i lo 2 0 V. 2 9 39 a 2 cdn ' ' La ham -'l Pe t e v. FuesCo. 8 3F. 1 2 1 3 - 1 (t Ci. 9 7 , e v. n i il t olum S. l l , 1 2d 3 7, 3 0 3 4 h z 1 8 ) Re d Helh& Hu nS l .7 4F. 1 70 1 7 (t Ci.1 8 ) a dW rg v.a k o 5 2 at ma evs, 7 2d 2 , 2 7 4h t 9 5, n iht J c s n, 2 F.d9 5 95 (t Ci. 9 5) 2 5 , 7 4h z 1 7 ). Clhm,rutofa a nd n eofc u i , as o e t t sve a ot rf l sfo e ç o n bu a c a ton' lo bjcs o e r l he i i r m ' ncng t maitaej g ' tpot,ncudngt tBAE i t ptv in pat a asae ntt t he gstt ud es e ti l i ha s he e al g ty nd ttme ha i t ealg d i Cou 1 oft S c ndAm e e Co li aec ncus r ,<to t e h l a ons n nt 1 he e o e nd d mp ant r o l o y fj h g e tnts h lng a ei c i r d afc lfndn ' . Obj ECF No 1 , t 2 Th s x e uc a u g s onsde e a ma i ip'Pls . ' , . 3 a ! . ee o e to lc mei a war ntn f rhe ds usi n fo t c r. bjci ns a k rt nd ra o u t r ic so r m he ou t Clhm as o e t t t maitaej g ' hndngta q e do i t sc s wee e lo bjcs o he gstt ud es i h t u s ns n hi ae r no co eordfkut I . t 3 Fiefc o si or t c ur' de ii t de ya a r o t ls if l. d a ! . v a t r nf m he o ts cson o n n wa d f c t:()r s on c b t p e in pa t; 2 t eu uc e su pa t i bl yt pa t oss 1 nic du t y he r val g ty () h ns c sf l rfs na ii o y he i t c t;()t e e sve s oft c t i apa t ulzc s ;4 t l ltdvaueoft e oss 3 he xc s i ne s he oss n ri a a e () he i ie l c n h p e in pa t' v co y a ()t eco e s a dfiut oft is sde i d. l v. r w l g rys it r ; nd 5 h l s ne s nd ifc ly he sue cde Els i i Grnt z onLLP, 3 F. p' 2 2, 3 (t Ci. 01 )(ii Che , 8 F.da 4 6. a Tho nt 4 4 Ap x 3 2 5 4. r2 1 ct h ng r 1 6 3 t 4 ) A c s ' cos ne si fud e no bywhehe o p ryce t pzval o za t t a es l e s s j g d t t r ne a t la l e is ve no he , y butby t r hne e ofpe ce i r quie t r c ze sf t ough a or m r lva he e m nt r pton e t d o e ogni , it hr nd gani e ee nt e de e,a by t difc t ofdice ni t 1 w oft c e.: rhu.v.PetD ' ,N o. vi nc nd he fi uly s r ng he a he as 'A t r 6:1 CV- 0 4 , 0 3W L 6 2 7 2 a * ( D. . c 2 2 3 9 . ne Co . MAC 1- 0 0 2 2 1 2 8 3 t 3 W. Va De . , 01 ) Va Pa l v. Pa l , 0 F. D . 6 2 7 ( . . . 0 ) Clh o fr no s por f h ragt nt ne Co.2 3 R. 23 , 3 W D Va 2 01. e m fe s up t oz e r z me t tt i s spr ent d i t sc s we e s fc e l cos a difc tt wa r nta ha he s ue es e n hi a e z ufii nty l e nd fi ul o r a z duc i orde a ofc t.Rat r s sat sm pl t s i e t a a t c ts e ton nil oss he , he t es i y hat he nt nds o ppe l he our' s mmay j g ntnzig. e m c na pe lt td cso a amatrofrg ;e e csn u t ud me l Clh a p a ha e ii n s te iht x r ii g n 4 t trghtdoesnotm a t ca ecl e a difc t how e t Eve i t ca ewascos a ha i ke he s os nd fiul, ve . n f he s l e nd dii t t sf c or aonei nots f e t de c t .Va Pane Co . 203 F. D .a 238. fkul, hi a t l s ufki nt o ny oss . l , R. t l s r,hec t fn n e r wih t m a itaej g ' a lssa wil c e n ho t t ou t i ds o ror t he gsr t ud es nay i nd la c pt hi r omm e don a a z c t i BAE' fvozi t a s ec nda nd wa d oss n S a n he mountof$7, 30. 068. 1 . 11 Fo t s r a o , h c u t l ADOPT t ma itaej g ' r po ta r he e e s ns t e o r wil he gsr t ud es e r nd rc mme ain ( No 1 2,OVERRULE Clh so e to ( No 1 3, e o nd to ECF . 9 ) e m' bjcins ECF . 9 ) DENY BAE' mot f rat r y ' e s( No. 7 ) a GRANT i pa tBAE' S i o to ne s f e ECF on 1 6 , nd n r S mod f rc ss( No. 7 ) on o o t ECF 1 5. An appr i t O r rv,lbe e e ed t sda opra e de i l ntz hi y. E trd JT - / -M /& nee: R Q ) % M iha F. ba ki c el Ur ns Che Unie S ae Ditit u e if td tt s stc l dg 5
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
