Sheppard v. Commonwealth of Virginia et al, No. 7:2015cv00598 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2015)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/9/2015. (tvt)

Download PDF

nl S OFFI U.. sm Cour FRK' CE S Dl AT RoANou , vA FIED L I TH E UM TED STATES DI N STRI COURT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STW CT OF W RGI A NI RO AN O K E D I SION W LL O Y D W A YN E SH EPPA R D , ï2 2! 2 1 V 25 JULA C. I BY: D CA SE N O .7: 15CV 00598 Pe ii ner tto , V. M EM O R AN D UM O PI O N NI COM M ONW EALTH OF VI RGI A, M W K , By:GlnE. nr d e Co a C hi fU nie St e D i t c Judge e t d at s s ri t Re ponde s s nt . Ll W a oyd yne She r a Vigi a i t pr e ng pr K ,fl d a pl di tte ppa d, r ni nma e oce di o ie ea ng ild: G i e ofAppe l' I a a sfom li s iso a sa ec tr or a ia e orlnet t l c Not a o' t ppe r r ls ubm s i n nd t t our ec ds val bl li ha She r fldapeii f ram i ofa t li ce t rVa CodeAnn.j1 2- 10i t ppad ie tton o t cua nno nce mde . 9. 327. n he M on gome y Comt Cic t Cour, s e ng r le fom hi 2009 c ci f a a t t r t y r ui t e ki ei f r s onvi ton or ggr va ed malci woundi i ous ng. Afe t cr ui c r de e hi peii n, She r a tr he ic t ou t ni d s tto ppa d ppeaed t t l o he Su e Cour ofVigi a whih r f s d t a a by or rdaed Oc o r30,201 Be a e pr me t r l , c e u e he ppe l de t t be 5. c us She r s c r nt s iso i t s c t i i es e e, c le ng t vai t of hi ppa d' ur e ubm s i n n hi our s, n s nc hal ngi he ldiy s c eme n t e asaec u tu me tt i c u t o tu da d c ee hi s b sin a a o me t md r tt o r j dg n ,hs o r c nsr e nd o k td s u miso s p tto frawr o h be sc pu , u s a t o28U. C. 2 4.Th c u t id , o v r t t ei n o i i f a a o s p ru n t t S. j 25 e o r fn s h we e ,ha t peii mus bes mn iy dimi s d.1 he tton t um rl s s e Lo rfd r lc u t,lk t i o e d n th v j rs ito t rve t ej d me t o we e ea o rs ie hs n , o o a e u idcin o e iw h u g n s f saec u t o a p a .Pllrv. o r ,1 9 F.d 7 ,7 ( t Ci.1 9 ) S eas Ditito tt o rs n p e l y e M o e 2 3 28 31 4h r 9 7 . e lo src f Sheppard v. Commonwealth of Virginia et al Doc. 2 CoumbaCtAp . Fed n 4 0U. 4 2 4 2 8 ( 9 3 ; o e v Fi. s Co.26 U. l i . p v. lma , 6 S. 6 , 8 - 6 1 8 ) Ro k r . d Tnlt , 3 S. 41 ,41 - 6 (9 3 . J rs i o fra p lae rv e o saec u t u me t le e lsv l 3 5 1 1 2 ) u iddin o p elt e iw f tt o r j dg n s is xcu iey 1 Un e Rue4 b o teRue Go enn j22 4 Ca e,te c m'ma sl rl ds s aû2 4 d r l () f h ls v r ig 5 ss h o t y ' mmai imis y 25 p tto Rifipanya per *o tep tt n a da yatc e e hiist th p t in ri no e tldt rle eiin ll t lil p as m h eii n n ta h d x bt ha te eio e s t nie o eif o t t i t dititcomt' n he src ' Dockets.Justia.com 1. . wih s ror sa e c rs a uli ae y,wih t Unie St t Supr t upe i t t ou t nd, tm tl t he t d aes eme Cour. Pl e , 1 t ylr 29 F.d a 7 ;2 U. C.5 25 Th rf r ,t te e tn ta S p r s e dr c a pelt 3 t 31 8 S. 1 7. eeo e o h xe t h t he pad e ks ie t p l e a r viw by t s c toft sae c t' de ii ns r ga di hi pe ii n f r a m i of ac u l e e hi our he t t ours c so e r ng s tto o t ta imoc nce hi a ton m us bedimis d. r e , s ci t s se Thsc u t o sha ej rs ito t rve t ev ldt o a i maesc nf me t nd r i o r d e v u idcin o e iw h ai i f n n t ' o me n u e y asaec u t u g n tr u h ha a c r u rv e p u n t 28U. C.j2 4. P ye ,1 9 tt o r j d me t h o g be s o p s e iw ms a t o S. 25 l lr 2 F.da 7 2 Fo ti r a o ,h c u t o tu dS e pad' s b sin a aj2 4peiin.As 3 t 3 . r h s e s n te o r c ns e h p r s u miso s 25 t o r t s h,howe r t pe ii sa e no gr uc ve , he tton tt s ound f r le . She r i notc i d ptr uan t t or ei f ppa d s onfne ls t o he saec u t u g n sd n i h speiin f rawrto a ta imo e c .Rah r h i c ni e tt o r j d me t e yng i t o o t i f cu l r c n e t e , e s o fn d pts n t teci na j d me to t eM o t o r Comt Cic i Co r. Tot ee tn t t t ua t o h rmi l u g n f h n g mey t y rut u t r h x e t ha h n w s e st c aln eteci n l u g n , sc re tpeiin i s c e sve Pms n t e o e k o h le g h rmia j d me t hi u rn tto s u c si . ua t o j2 4 09,a fd r ldsdc c u tma c nsd ra s c n o s c e sv j2 4 pei o o l i 24 e e a it t o r y o i e e o d r u c sie 25 tt n ny f i peii ttoners m es s cik c rik ai n fo t Unied St t Co tofAppeas f t Fourh ec pe t e tt to r m he t aes ur l or he t Cic t h ttecamsi t ep t in me tc ran ciei. j2 4 b () Co r r c r sid c t ruit a h li n h ei o e e ti rtra 2 4()3 . u t e o d n iae t ta S e p r p e iu l fld aj2 5 p tto c n e n tes mej d me t Cii AcinNo. h t h p ad r vo sy e 2 4 eiin o c mi g h a u g n, vl to 7: 1 0 4 ,wh c te c u td n e wi p eudc . S p r s a pe lwa t u c sf l 1 CV0 5 0 ih h o r e id t rj ie he pad' p a s ms c e su. h Be us She r does not de onsr t t t he has obti d ce tfc ton by t Cour of ca e ppa d m ta e ha a ne rii a i he t Ap ast pt s ls c re tj2 4 peiin te c u tmu td s s i wi u p eudc a pe l o l ue l u rn 25 tto , h o r s imis t t t rj ie s r i ho s ce sve An a o t or rwile ert sda uc s i . ppr pda e de l nt hi y. The Clr i diece t s nd c es oft s me or ndlm opi on a a compa ng e k s r t d o e opi hi m a z ni nd c nyi or rt pe ii ne . de o tto r ENTER:w y mbe, 01 s 9*1 da ofxove r 2 5. Chi Unie Stt sDititJ ef t d a e src udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.