Johnson v. Southwestern Virginia Regional Jail, No. 7:2015cv00431 - Document 17 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/8/2015. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OFFI U. DI COURT : CE S. ST. > ROANOKE, J' VA FT L LLD sEF 23 2 1 25 I TI E U NI N I TED STA TES D I STR I C O UR T CT FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STR I T O F V I GI I C R N A RO A N O K E D I SI N W O R O BER T LEE JO H NSO N ,JR . , ) ) Pl ntf , ai if ) V. ) ) SOUTHW ES TERN VI M A REGI RGI ONAL) J L M EDI M CAL STAFF, AL. c . ) ) De e a t) f nd nts. ) JOLA - D ' L C I . 2 BY: . , , D u, E CA SE N O .7: V00431 15C M EM O R AN DU M O PI I N N O By: H on.G l n E.C onr e ad C hi fU nie St e Di t i Judge e t d at s s r ct Robe tLeeJ hns J .aVigni i ae pr ee ng Dr K ,fld t scvi dg sa ton r o on, r, r i a nm t oc di o ie hi i l ht c i t 42U. C.j1 agans t So hwetm Vigi aRe o lJ i me c saflrgadi mder S. 983 i the ut se r ni gina al dial t t e r ng te t ntofhi b o n' .1 J l on hasalo m o d t a e t a t a tona ca ms i a me s r ke f oot o ms s ve o m nd o dd wo ddii l li a an t h j i, e a dn me ia c r r c i e a trh s fee as iur a alg d g is t e al rg r i g d c l ae e ev d fe e u fr d ez e nd le e m ic c ai n o hi t r ofc i m e .Theco t l g a t snme m e ,wlih doesnot s alulto f s e m onfne nt ur wil ' nt hi r nd nt zc i e tf a ya iina d fnd n t) Gl c u t h lrv e . . c mp an i acv l dini d niy n ddto l e e a ts. ç- o r s al e iw . a o lit n ii a o n -he wli aprs rs ksr dr s fom agove n e ale iyorofi e ore pl zch ione ee e e s r r m nt ntt fc r m oyeeofa g v mme tle tt ,'a ço nrv e t ec t's al d niyc g ia l camso d s s o e n a n iyg ' nd t q e iw,h alt h li e tf o nz be li r imis l g t t co pl nt ora pori n oft c he m ai , ny to he ompli ,i t c ant f he ompl i ...i fi o , ai i ,or ant s rvol us m lcous fist saeacam u nwhihrle ma b g a td. .'28U.. j1 5 a-b ( ) Up n al o tt li po c eif y e rn e . . ' SC. 91 A()( )1 . o r viw ofJ e e ohns sc on' ompl i a n nde t c tc ude t theha no l lbassf a ant s me d, he our oncl s ha s ega i or j 1 cam a i tt de e ntheha na a t r f e wildimistlsc ewiho 983 li gans he f nda s med nd,he eor, l s s li as t ut Johnson v. Southwestern Virginia Regional Jail P eu ie rj d c . Doc. 17 Se ton 1 pe misa agg i vedpa t t fl a cvi a ton agans ape s f a tons c i 983 r t n re ry o ie i l c i i t r on or c i tke unde col ofsa e1w t tvi a e li c tt i na rg s SeeCoope v.Shee n,735 a n r or t t a ha olt d ls onsiuto l i ht . r ha 1 Pl ntf fl t s cvi a ton i t Unied Stt DititCou f t Ea tm Diti ofVigi a. ai if ied hi i l ci n he t aes src rt or he se srct r ni Be a s t camsao ewi nt j rsito o ti c uth we e,h c s wa ta fre h r . c u e he li r s t he u idcin fhs o r, o v rte a e s rnserd ee hi Dockets.Justia.com F.d1 3, 5 (t Ci. 1 ) Assae , o ns n' i ta c mp an a dn n me t n mete 3 5 1 8 4 h r 20 3 . ttd J h o s niil o lit n me d n s n h j i' t dc l tf'a t o l d fnd n t a1 scams Hec n t e ali aj1 3cam als t ia sa f s he n y ee a t o 1hi li . a no prv i n 98 li me ' a an tti g o po j i e l y e o t ej i is l, snet e o te ee tte q ai sa g is h s r u f al mp o e s r h al tef a ih r f h s n i s u lfe i G e s n' u j c t s iu de j 1 8 .S ePrv l Re o 2 3F.d8 , 0 W L 2 5 , t*1 t ro 's b e t o ut n r 9 3 e e a v. n , 0 3 21 20 0 p 0 91 a ( t Ci. a .1 , 0 0 (mp bih d (uoigW i v. ilia De to S aePoie 4 U. 4h r J n 3 2 0 ) t u ls e ) q tn l M cl n p' f tt lc , 91 S. l R 58 71( 9 9 ( d n t a saea disa e ce aen t ro u d rj 1 8 ) M c vv. , 1 8 ) fn i g h t tt n t g n is r o pes ns n e 9 3 ; co Ch spe k Cor ci n lCe tr 7 8F. u p. 9 , 9 -4 ( D. .1 9 )(id n j in ta e a a e re to a ne , 8 S p 8 0 8 3 9 E. Va 9 2 fn i g al o p ro f rp r osso j1 8 ) Th r f r, o n o scamsa ans t ej i' me ia safa a e s n o u p : f 9 3 . e eo e J h s n' li g i t h als d c l tf s g o p, sheha c e tyi e tle te mus b s mmaiyds se wi u p eu iet e ru a s r n l d ni d h m, t e u rl imis d t t rj d c md r ho o i e de l s ue hi j1 1 A( )1 a lg lyio o . An appr prat or rwili s t sday 9 5 b ( ) s e al v lus2 . Thec e k wils nd ac o t so ni a t ac ompa ng or t pl i i lr l e opy f hi pi on nd he c nyi der o antE ENTER:Tli V D da o Se tmb r2 5 l s 1 y f pe e 01 . Cli fUnie St t DititJ le td aes src udge 2 I a e nt i doesnota rt tJ hns n, ale tonspr deabassf a cai acinabl unde n ny ve , t ' ppea ha o o s lgai ovi i or ny l m to e r j1 8 a anta yo a t i tme Hi s red tisa o th me c le auaina dte t n h r cie a te 9 3 g is n ne t hs i . s pas eal b u te dia v l to n rame t e e ev d th j is g et, th mo tp sil camso me ia n gie eo mapa tc b t d niidsaf mbes Mee al u g ss a te s, o sbe li f dc l e l nc r lrcie y mie tfe tf me r. r g ne l e c i n tato a eu e j1 8 .S eEsel v Ga le 2 U.. 7 1 2( 9 6 (odigo l d l rt gi n e s o cin bl nd r 9 3 e tle . mbe 4 9 S 9 , 0 1 7 ) h l n ny ei ae g be idfee c t a imaess ro sme ia ne d voae t Eihh Ame d n) W e b v. miulh 2 1F. n ifrn e o n n t' eiu dc l e s ilts he g t n me t; b Ha d l , 8 a Ap x 1 9 1 6 (t Ci.2 08 Cpu smpy,n gie tme ia da no e o ke t n,wi u mo e d no p' 5 , 6 4h r 0 ) t i l e lg n dc l ig ss r ame t t t r, o t ho c nttt d l rt idfee c .) I J l o st r cam,h se mo eay d ma e bae o aj i saf o siue ei ae n ifrn en. n omsn' hid li e eks n tr a g s s d n al tf be me mbersacinst tha alege yca edJ ont bewr uly è medpa thi pr rr ea eda e Un i a ' to ha ve l dl us ohns o ongf l onf s s ope el s t . tl cour ha hedt J on' tr ofc i m e thasbee mic c aed,howe r he c nnots ekdama on t t t s l hat ohns s e m onfne n n s alult ve, a e ges ha is ea ans a yo t e j1 8 . S eWi is nv Dosn, 4 U..7 ,8 ( 0 )C( saep io r j1 3 su g i t n ne md r 9 3 e l n o . to 5 4 S 4 1 20 5 A1 tt rsne' 98 k s ato i b re (b e tp iriv ld to l n matrterle sug t( a g so e ui berle n matrt cin s ar d a sn ro n aiain - o te h eif o h d ma e r q t l eig, o te he a tye o tepio e' si(tt cndc la igt cn ito o itra'rsnpoed ls-i scesi ta a t fh rsnrs ut sae o u tedn o o vcin rnen l io rce hgl f u cs n ht p ato wo l n c sai d mo taeteiv l i o c n ie n o isd rto '. cln ud e e srl e nsrt h n ai t f o fn me t r t uain.) y dy ' To t exentt tJ hns n ma wih t s e hi r las 9o conf me ,bas d on hi alegain t the he t ha o o y s o e k s ee e m me nt e s l to ha di no r eve c e tf tme s r d on t s ntnc ,hi pr rc s ofl laci i apeiin f awrtof d t ec i r di or i e ve wo e e es s ope oure ega ton s tto or i ha e sc pu a dno acvl ih sato u d r91 8 .Se P esrv Ro rz e ,41 U. 4 5( 9 3;To dv. b a o s n t iirg t cin n e 9 3 e rie . d iu z 1 S. 7 1 7 ) d Bak r ie 7l F.d7 (t Ci.1 8 ) Jh s nma se h be sc ru rle i ti fd rlc u to l a trh s evl , 2 2 0 4h r 9 3 . o n o y ek a a op s eif n hs e ea o r ny fe e l h se h u tda albesaec u t e de .L=; e as 2 U.. j2 4 (e adnge h usinrq le n) a x a se v i l tt o r rme is d.s e lo 8 SC. 25 09 rg r i x a to e urme t. a J ns n' s oh o s ubmisonsdonots s t theha fl a ha asco puspetton r ii hi s t e cac ai si ugge t ha s ied ny be r ii asng s enenc lulton cl i t sa ecou t--et ri t cic tc twhe ehe wasc ced ori t Supr me Cou tofVigi a. ahns n he tt rs ihe n he r ui our r onvit n he e r r ni Be us i t a ar t t he has a lbl sae c tr medi by whi t c le t l h of hi ca e t hus ppe s ha vaia e tt our e es ch o halnge he engt s c n e n,hi c u t ln t o tu hi c re t u miso a aj2 4p tto o sn me tt s o r wi o c nsr e s urn s b sin s 25 eiin. l 2
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
