Kingsley v. Clarke, No. 7:2015cv00425 - Document 31 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/27/2016. (slt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK: OFFI u, . ST. M7 CE S DI 10t AT RoM oc , VA ' FI LED MAï 2? 2 1 25 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTER N DI RI T O F V I GI I ST C R N A ROANOKE DI SI VI ON JUm BK ED W AR D L.M N G SLEY , Pe ii r tt one , By: L RK M EM O R AND U M O PI O N NI H AROLD W .CLAQKE, R espondent . D , ERK C i lActi N o.7: cvvi on 15- 00425 V. DU H o M i hae F. bansd n. c l Ur l U ni e St esD i t i tJudge t d at src Edwar L.Ki l y,aVigi aprs rpr e di pr K ,fl ape ii f rawrtof d ngse r ni ione oc e ng o ied tton o i h be sc r usp rua t o2 U. C. 2 5 t c le g hi c n ito e trdb t Cic t a a o p u s n t 8 S. j 2 4 o haln e s o vcins n ee y he rui / Cou tfrt CiyofSt ntn.Repo ntfldamoi t dimis a Peitone r ponde r o he t au o s nde ie ton o s s , nd ii r es d, m n ng t ma trrpef diposton.Afe r vi wi t r c d,t c t s is st ki he te i or s ii tr e e ng he e or he our dim s e he pe ii astmebare . tton i r d. 1 . Th Cic t u t o t eCiyo S a no sn e c dP tto e o J n 9 20 9 t o j c e ruiCo r fr h t f tu tn e tn e eiin r n u e , 0 ,o b e t s x a p nerto ,nv oaino Vign aCo ej1 2 6 ., n a g a ae sxu l a tr o a e u l e tain i i lto f r ii d 8.- 72 a d g r v td e a b t y f e mi ,i vi ai o Vigi aCodej18. 67. Peii ra alduns ce sul t t Cour nor n olton f r ni 2- 3. ttone ppe e uc sf ly o he t ofAppe sofVigi a a t Supr m eCour ofVigi ar f edhi a alon Se e be 8, al r ni , nd he e t r ni e us s ppe pt m r 201 Pe ii rdoesnotcai t ha r quese r vi w by t Supr me Co toft Unie 0. ttone l m o ve e t d e e he e ur he t d St e . at s Pe ii rfld ape ii f awrtofha asc pusi t Cic tCour f rt Ciy of ttone ie tton or i be or n he r ui t o he t Kingsley v. Clarke St unt on De mbe 20, 1 andt tc utdim is d t pe ii n onJ 7, 2,a a on ce r 201 , ha ot' s s e he tto une 201 s Doc. 31 unimel fl d.N e ,Pe ii rfl d ape ii f rawrtofha a c puswih t Supr me i y e xt ttone ie tton o i be s or t he e Co tofVi gi a on J ur r ni anua y 11 201 Pe ii r c ai e i t s cond pe ii t t i e ala, r , 3. ttone l m d n he e tton ha , nt r i he wasde i d ç herg t couns ore f c i a ssa e o c prve t i ht o t el fe tve s it nc f ouns ldt ngt i ta -e e e ui he niilr viw Dockets.Justia.com c laea p oc e i un e M at zv. a 1 2 S. .1 0 ( 2 g 'whe tecrutc u t o ltrl r e dng d r ri ne Ry n, 3 Ct 3 9 201 ),' n h ic i o r q dimi s d hi frtpeii asuntmel The Supr m eCour ofVigi adim is t ha a s s e s is tton i y. e t r ni s s ed he be s pe ii n a s e svea untm ey on M a c 5 201 a Pe ii rfl d hi f der lpeii no tto s ucc s i nd i l r h , 3, nd ttone ie s e a tton e rirt a J l 2 , 01 .S eR. v. 2 4Ca e 3 d ( e cii gtep io mal o r ll a l h n uy 7 2 5 e Go j 25 ss ( ) d s rb n h rs n- ib x ue . e I. I Ha e sp tto slldt e j2 5 aes be tt ao ey a peid o lmiain.2 b a ei n ie md r 2 4 r u j c o n - e r ro f i tto 8 i U. C. 2 4 d ( )1 Ge aly, t i p ro b gn t r nfo ted t o wh c t j d me t S. j 2 4()1 . ner l hs ei d e is o u rm h ae n ih he u g n o c n ito b c me fn l 2 U .. . 2 4 () 1( .A c n ito b c me fna o c t e f o v cin e o s ia. 8 S C j 2 4 d ()A) o vcin e o s s l n e h 2 a albit o drc r ve i e h use .Untd Sae v Cly, 3 U. 5 2 5 4( 0 3 .The v i l y f ie t e iw s x a td ie tts . a 5 7 S. 2 , 2 2 0 ) a i one ye flngpe i i t l d whiea c c ' ç ope l fld a i to f rStt - ar ii rod s ole l onvits s pr ry ie pplcai n o ae p s-o v ci no oh rc l tr l e iw'i S e d n . 2 U. C. 2 4 ( )2 , e W al o tc n ito r t e ol ea rve 's ç n i g' 8 S. j 2 4 d ( ) s e l v. a p ' ' ' Khoi 5 2U. 5 5 5 8 6 ( 01 )(ic sngp o e dng t tq aiya c ltrl e iwl l, 6 S. 4 , 5 - 0 2 1 d susi r c e i s ha u lf s ol ea r ve t a ' . I ' . ' ' ' ' ' Peiine' j2 4p t ini t i l u de 2 4 () 1( .Pei o e' c h tto t o rs 2$ ei o s mtmey n r 2 4 d ()A) ft n rs o vcin t t i , be me tna o Dec m be 7,201 ' he t tm ee r d t s e r viw byt Supr m eCour ca s l n e r 0,w n he i xpie o e k e e he e t o teUni dSae .S eU. S p. . 1 4 )(tt a peln mus fl ap tto fram i fh t tts e S. u Ct R. 3 1 sai p la t t ie ei n o e ng i t o c rir r wi nnn t d y o tej d me t iga pe ld .Th r fr , tto e ha t i f e t ai t iey a s f h u g n ben p ae ) ee o e Peiin r d mtl o hi De e be 7,2011 t tm ey fl af de alha aspe ii cm r , o i l ie e r be tton. ' jTheone yerp ro o lmi to f rfl gaha e sp tto u d rj2 5 be i t rno telts o a eid fi t in o ii a n b a ei n n e 2 4 gns o u n h aet f i f urda e : o ts ( ted t o whc t j d me t c mef l ytec ncu ino drc rve o t A) h ae n ih he u g n bea i b h o lso f ie t e iw rhe na e r to oft tmef s ki s h r ew' xpiain he i or ee ng uc evi , ( ted t o whc tei dmett fl ga a l aincetdb Saeato i voain B) h ae n ih h mpe i n o ii n ppi to rae y tt cin n ilto n c oft Co tm ton o lwso t Unie Sttsi r he nsi i r a f he td ae s emove i t a iantw a pr ve e om flngby d, f he pplc s e nt d ii s h St eaci uc at ton; ( ted t o whihtec n tmto a rg t setdwa i tal rc nie b teS p e C) h ae n c h o si in lih asre s ni ly eog z d y h u rme i Cou ,i t rghtha be n ne yr ogniedbyt Su e Cou ta mader toa tvey a i bl t rt f he i s e wl ec z he prme r nd er ci l pplca e o ca e o colat alr e ; s s n l er eviw or ( ted t o whihtefc l rdc t o tecam o camspe e tdc udh v b e D) h ae n c h a ma pe iae f h li r li rs ne o l a e e n dic r d tr s ove e h ought exe cs ofd dii nc he r ie ue lge e. 28U.. j2 4 d () SC. 2 4()1. 2Peiin rddn t r u tmeiesu e sbscins( tru h( , t o e i o ag e i ln s nd r u eto B) lo g D) t z 2 Peii rfl hi frtsa eha aspe ii on De e be 20,2011 whi wa m o et n ttone ied s is tt be tton cm r , ch s r ha ayea a trhi c ci bec m efnal Ac or ngl t f r saut oflmiai ha r fe s onvi tons n i . c di y, he ede al t t e i t tons d ar a e r d by t tmePe ii rtl d hi frtsa eha aspe ii a sa u o y t lng i le dy xpie he i ttone se s is t t be tton, nd tt t r oli s n t osil.Se . ..M itrv. c 23 F.d6 3 6 5( t Ci. 0 0 (e o nzn t tsae o p sb e e ec, n e Be k, 0 3 6 , 6 4h r 2 0 ) r c g iig ha tt h b a p t in c n trvvea ara y e prdf d rl i tto speid . a e s ei o s n no e i n le d x ie e ea lmi in ro ) t a Eq tbl t lngi a ia e onl i ç hos r r i t nc whe e- d t cic sa es uia e oli s val bl y n ç e a e nsa es r ue o r um t nc t e e na t t pa t sown c xt r l o he ry' onduc - i woul beunc ci bl t . o cet lm iai n pe i t t d ons ona e o e r he i t to rod nf a an thepa t a dg o sij siewo drs t'Ro ev. e 3 9F.d2 , 4 ( t Ci. g is t ry n r s n u tc ul eul. us Le , 3 3 38 2 6 4h r ' 2 0 )(nb nc (n en lq oainmakso te )(iigHa sv Huc i o , 09F.d3 , 0 3 e a ) itr a u tto r mitd ctn ni . thns n 2 3 25 3 0( t Ci. 0 0 3 4h r 2 0 :.Th s ap tto e mus h veç e np runghi rg t dlg n l, n .. u , eiin r t a t e u s i s ih s iie ty a d . b s ome e r di r cic sa soodi hi wa 'o pr ve tm ey flng. Hola v. orda xtaor na y r um t nce t n s y't e nt i l i lnd Fl i , 5 0U. 6 , 4 - 0( 01 ) 6 S. 31 6 9 5 2 0 . Pe ii rslc ofknowl dgea ttone ' a k e boutl alpr es ort sa t o y de dlnef f de a eg oc s he ttz r a i or e r l t habe r le do nots as e if es uppo tgr ntng s h e r r na y r le Ha rs 209F. a 330. r a i uc xtao di r e if ri , 3d t Furhem or t c tdoe nottnd a e r r na y c r um sa ei t sr co dt tpr ve e t r e, he our s s ny xtao di r ic tnc n hi e r ha e nt d Peiin rfo sl g atmeypeiin.Se . ..UntdS ae v. o a 3 4F.d5 7 51 (t tto e r m i i l tto n e ec, ie tts S s , 6 3 0 , 2 4h Ci. 0 4 ( oi p oK sau a din rnc o t 1w d e n tusiye ui bl tli ) r 2 0 ) n t r tts n g o a e f he a o s o j tf q t e o l ; ng a ng Tu arv J h s n,1 ?F.d39 , 9 ( t Ci.1 9 )( tn ta u fmi aiywihtelw d e n e . o n o 7 3 0 3 2 5h r 9 9 noig h t n n l rt t h a u i t i iea yo p o sau d e n ttl lmiainsp ro ) M o e ve, t in rfist o l trc r r t tt s o s o o li tto ei d . ro r Pei o e al o l t esa ih i t sc et tt M a tne e e i a i t e us a untm ey fl d f de a t bls n hi as ha he ri z xc ptàn pples o xc e n i l ie e r l pe ii The Supr m e Cour i M a i z hel t ti f ec i a s s a ofco e G ti ta tton. e t n rtne d ha ne f tve s it nce uns l ' nii l a r viw c lt r lpr ee ngsma esa ih ca ef aprs rspr dtr lde a tofac am e e ola e a oc di y t bls us or ione ' oce la f ul li o i efciea ssa c a til' 1 2S. . t1 5 Alh u h Ma t zc n en daj dcal f n fe t sitn e t ra. 3 Ct a 31 . t o g ri o c r e u iil v ' ne y- c a td pr e alde a tdoc rne,i di no e e t a ar ad e r f de allm iai r fe oc dur f ul ti t d t xt nd o n le y- xpied e r i t tons pe i fxed by saut . Se e. ,Couc v.W oods No.3: 3c 46,201 U. Dit LEXI rod i t t e e. c. h on, 1 v1 3 S. s. S 1 8 , t* - , 01 W L 5 3 5 3 a * ( D. . v 5 2 3 (olcigc s sf rt t 5 461 a 5 6 2 3 9 3 4 , t 2 E. Va No . , 01 ) c le tn a e o ha p o sto ) Ac o dn l, tto e fldtefd rl b a p tto b y n t o ey a r po iin . c r igy Pei n r ie h e ea ha e s ei n e o d he n - e z i i sa u eoflm iai , ttone i note ild t e t et lng,a t peii n m us be ttt i t tons Pe ii r s ntte o quiabl oli nd he tto t di m i s d. s se 11 1. Fort f eg ng r a ons t co tgr nt Re ponde ' m o i t dimisa dimis s he or oi e s , he ur a s s nts ton o s s nd s s e t pe ii f awrtofha asc he tton or i be opus Bas d upon t c tsfndi t tPeii rha no . e he our' i ng ha ttone s t m a t r quiie s t i s de he e st ubsantal howi o ade alofac tt i lrghtasr quie by 28 ng f ni ons iutona i e rd U. C. 2 5 /)a Slc v. c n e, 2 U. 4 , 4 (0 0 , c ri c t o a e lblt S. j 2 3 nd a k M Da il 5 9 S. 73 48 2 0 ) a e ti ae f pp aa i y f i i de e s ni d. ENT ER om :Thi * 1 da o M a 201 s y f y, 6. f f* Y V f. > Unie St t Diti J t d aes srct udge 4 '
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
