Young v. Clarke, No. 7:2015cv00390 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2015)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/17/2015. (tvt)

Download PDF
nlp- s ov l, U..Dl cour cE s sm AT ROANOKE, VA FI ED L I TH E UM TED STATES DI N STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF W R GI A CT NI R O A N O K E D I SI N W O , G R EG O RY LEO N Y O U N G , J 22 2 1 UL 25 ZUL I BY; -' ' L L C A SE N O .7: 5CV 00390 1 Pe ii ne t t o r, V. M EM O R AN D U M O PI O N M R AR O LD C LAR K E , By: Gl n E.C onrad e C hi fU nie St e Di t i tJudge e t d at s s r c R espondent . Gr gor Le Yo mg,aVigi ai t pr ee ngpr K ,fl d t speii n f awrtof e y on t r ni nma e oc di o e hi tto or i . habe c pus ptrua t 28U. C.j2254. Youngchalngest vai t ofhi c me n as or , ls nt o S. le he ldiy s onf me t u d raJ l 2 0 j g n i t Dmwil Cic tCo r whih c n itd h m o r b e y a d n e uy 0 4 ud me t n he le rui u t c o vce i f o b r n s ntnc d li t 60 yea si prs n. Afe r viw oft r c d,t c tf dst tt petton e e e lm o r n io tr e e he e or he our m ha he ii m 1 us besl rl d s s e a s c e sv , u s a t o2 U. C. 2 4 1 t l mma i imis d s u c sie p ru n t 8 S. j 2 4(9. y Cour rcodsi caet Yot prvi l fl aj225 peii c e ngt s me t e r ndi t hat mg e ousy ied 4 tton onc e he n j g n t a h c aln e h r . S e Yo mgv.Kel Cii Acin No 70 CV0 2 5 ( . ud me t h t e h le g s e e e t l vl to . :7 0 9 W D. v, Va Aug 7 2 0 ) Th c u td s se Yo n ' p tto wih p eu ie a d hsa p a wa . . , 0 7 . e o r imis d u g s eiin t rj d c , n i p e l s dim is f rf iur t pr e ut s s ed o al e o os c e. Pu s a t o j2 4 (9, fd r l ititc u t yc nsd ras c n o s c e svej2 4 ru n t 2 4 1 a e ea d src o r ma o i e e o d r u c s i 25 pe ii onl i pe ii rs c le s cii c rii to fom t Unied St t s Co tofAppe l tton y f ttone e tr s pe fc e tfcai n r he t a e ur as f rt eFo rh Cic i t t h camsi t ep tto me tc ranc iei. j2 4 ( )3 .Yomg s o h u t rut ha t e li n h eiin e e ti rtra 2 4 b ( ) t ' Young v. Clarke Doc. 2 c re tpei o i as b e ue to , al u d rtep o iiin i 2 U. C. 2 4 ( )a ans ur n tt n s u s q n ne f lng n e h r hbto n 8 S. j 2 4 b g i t i i a s cond ors c sve pe ii n. e uc es i tto 1 Un e Rue4b o teRue Go enn j 2 4 Ca e,te c u tma s mmaiy ds s a j2 5 d r l () f h ls v r ig 25 ss h o r y u rl imis 24 !eio tifiplil ap as9o tepeio a dayatc e ehi t t tt ptto e in te ie t rle 'tin tl t any p er m h tin n n tahd x bi ha he eiinr s o ntld o eif t l t s t m t dititc the src our. , Dockets.Justia.com . I h sc re tj2 5 peiin, t a srsta t e y ds o ee e d nc o f rnsc n i u rn 2 4 tto Yomg se t h tt wl ic v r d vie e f o e i n a yss's nal i ' uppo t a fndi t t he i ac ly im oc nt whi h s d, i tln, s r e as a rs i ng ha s ma l z e c houl n t r ev & t wa mec nim ' t cic mw e hi pr dtr l de a t of hi ha as cor cli s o E e y ga hn s ' o r t nt s oce la f ul s be pus am f pr ec ora m ic os ut i l s onduc a i f c i as it nc of co ms . l s ppor of t s de a t t nd nefe tve ssa e t el n u t hi f ul a pl e ,Yot r leson M c gci v.Pe ki ,569 U . r m nt mg e i oui n r ns S. - , 1 S.Ct 1 33 . 924, 1 , 1 928 93436 ( 01 ) I M c i gn t Unie S ae S p e Cout edt a. s o n o a t l n o e e 2 3 . n ou g i,he td tts u rme t'h l h ta h wig f cua i n c nc ca s l a a ga e n e' s ve t way t ough whi h a prs rm a brng hi fr tpos- onvi ton c le hr c ione y i s is tc ci hal nge e na tre pr to o t esau eo lmiain i 2 U. C.j2 4 ( .TheM c z i Co r ve fe x iai n f h ttt f i tto s n 8 S. 2 4 * ouian u t a pl d is hodng b l t a pei o e ' i iil j2 4 p tto 1 3 S. Ct a 1 3 -4 p i t li n y o e tt n rs nta 25 ei n. 3 i i . t 9 33 ( ifrn itn iiil a a p tto sfo s c n o s c siepeiins. dfee taig n ta h be s ei n ' m e o d r uc e sv t o ) i r t Eve i Yot c d pe s de t c tt tt M coui n gae a acua i e e n f mg oul r ua he our ha he cci tw y t l nnoc nc nle s d be e e d t s e sve pe ii ,ho ve ,li ne y dic r d e de e i not l houl xt nde o ucc s i ttons we r ls wl s ove e vi nc s s cint t s uo e o uppor a col a e c am of a t l i e . Yo mg s is c rik aes of t or bl l i c ua nnoc nce t ubm t e tf t anays s i c tng t tt f r i s ints s a t Vigi a De rmentof Crm i J tc l i ndi a i ha wo o ensc ce it t he r ni pa t i nal usie Se vies f t fom c r c o md r ompa on of ha ds ndm ii s m pl t t Yot di not m ie t hand tng a es ha mg d t he prn ed not be nni tIHAVE a bomb,'wli h t r r ga t Am a Cox,t ban it e, gi ng < ' lc he obbe ve o nda he k t le . Young' e de e a s i c t t tt ha el r s vi nc lo ndi aes ha he ndwrtng o t no e wa pr pa ed by t ii n he t s e r he unkno wrt rofa sm ia no ei ve i a he bn r r wn ie i l r t nvol d n not r nk obbe y. Acc di t Young,t Co monwe 1h pr e ed e wines t si ony agans hi . or ng'o he m a t es nt ye t s e tm i t m M s Coxi ntfe Youngfom alne ofsxme a1weai tt . de i d r i up i n, 1 rng lobogga 'a s a s ,us ns' nd unglsesj t a t r bberdi whe he ha s he o d n nded Cox t r r no e. Anot reye wines e ,* .Ande s he obbe y t he t ss r on, pike Young outofa sx- n lne p a t pe s he s w si on t i e a he e e e t ba c d i ma i u s he r on a lp he c s nt r d he nk j s a e d o M r An e s n.Th d fns p e e tde d nc t a Yomg sfng r rn sweeno u t h a f . d ro e ee e r sn e vie e h t t ' i ep it r t 2 f ound o t fo o t no e a t ta herpe s sprnt wer f m d o t no e a on t n he r nt f he t nd ha not r on' i s e ot n he t nd he e r nc door oft ba l lg oft e wine se de e t tYo mg wast r r t nta e s he nk. n i ht he ye t s vi nc ha t he obbe , he a to le de e he now o f r ,s ddii na vi nc fe s howi t the di no pe s ly wrt t not us d t ng ha d t r ona l ie he e e o fi e t t lr i o gi ng t r r m one does not c tt e a ade t s rght n he ele nt vi he obbe y, onsiut n qua e howi of ng a m a i e e as ne s a y t cr lm ve hi def ul ofhi habe c am s See Sczup v. c l nnoc nc ce s r o ic l nt s a t s as l i . ll Deo 51 U. 29 ,3 7 ( 9 5 ( od n t a a t a i c nc t o e c me d ful r q ie l , 3 S. 8 2 1 9 ) h li g h t cu l l e e o v r o mo ea t e ur s s o n ta Eti mo elk l t a n t h tn ra o a l jlo wo l ha ec n itd' eiin r h wi g h t รป s r iey h n o t a o e s n b e t r u d v o v ce 'p tto e i r o t un eli gci ijlo sha rc ie s e ii, eibee ie eno p e e td a til. f he d ry n rme f t r d e ev d p cfc rla l vd nc t r sn e t ra) r As saed,Yot sc rnt j2254 peiin i a sco o s ce sve one Thus i i tt mg' ure tto s e nd r uc s i . ,t s b n'dfo r ve o teme i b ti c u tmd rj2 4 ( )wi u c riiain b teCo r a e r m e iw n h rt y h s o r t e 2 4 b t t etfc to y h u t s ho ofAppea s Bec us Young doe notde onsr t t the has obt ned s h c rii a i t l. a e s m tae ha ai uc e tfc ton, he c u twilds s t ep tto wi o tp eu iea s c sie An a p o raeo d rwile tr o r l imis h eiin t u rj d c s uc e sv . h p r p it r e l n e t s da hi y. The Clr i die t d t s nd co es oft s m e o a l opi on a ac ompa ng ek s r ce o e pi hi m r ndlm ni nd c nyi or rt pe ii ne . de o tto r ENTER:Thi :7 & da ofJ y,201 s y ul 5. Cli fU xie St t s D it i tJ le lt d a e s rc udge 3

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.