Davis v. Raines et al, No. 7:2015cv00380 - Document 11 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/30/2015. (slt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CL ERKSOF I U. Di . FCE S STCOURi A R A O ,A T ONZ V FI LED I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT ' FoR THE W ES TERN DI TRI OF W RGI A S CT NI ROANOKE DW I O N SI SE 30 2 1 P 05 J uL . DL , ERK DU CL BY; GM W TH OM AS DAVI S , JR. , Pl ntf, ai if v . STEPHEN RAI NES,ET Al,, . Dee nts. fnda t) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) CASE NO.7: 15CV00380 - D U M EM ORANDUM OPI ON NI By:GlnE.Conr e ad Ch e Un td S a e DititJ g if ie t t s src ud e Ga y Thom a Davi,J . aVig ni i t pr e di pr K ,fl t scvi rg sa i r s s r, r i a nma e oc e ng o ed hi i l iht cton p s n t 4 U. C.j 1 8 ,algn t a apoieo l rwr n f ly dean d hm a d usd urua t o 2 S. 9 3 le ig h t l fke o g ul t ie i n e c e s i f c a i thi . By s pa a e or r t c twildie tt clr sofi e t a ss xce sve or e gans m e r t de , he our l r c he e k' fc o s it Da s i ac ompls ng s r i e on t sof r Upon r vi w oft r c d,t c tfndst t vi n c ihi e v c hi sce . e e he e or he our i ha Da s a tona c am sa ns ' he de e nt mus besl ma iy dim is d. vi' ddii l l i gai tot r f nda s t lm rl s s e I I bre ,Davi al gest ton M a 21 201 i a so e i Fr nkln Cot y,Vigi a n if s le ha y , 4, n t r n n i mt ri , St phe Rane ,a of dut He ly Cot y ofi e ,r c ze Da s fom pror e ountr . e n i s n f y rr mt fc r e ogni d vi r i nc e s Rane t d Da shi be ift ta ho ii sha o sa ng wa r nt f rDa sa a tmpt d t i s ol vi s le ha ut rte d utt ndi ra s o vi nd te e o de an Da s whe he l f t sor Rai s a lge y pr ve e Da s fom g ti i o hi ti vi n e t he t e. ne le dl e nt d vi r e tng nt s ve cl a t n fom goi ba k i o t sor a a one poit a l edl sn i Da s hi e nd he r ng c nt he t e, nd t n , leg y l mm ng vi' ha i a door Afe s m e sr e i vi a fr n m,Fr nkln Co mt ofi e s a rve nd n . tr o tuggl nvol ng ie r n i t y fc r r i d, Davis v. Raines et al a e nde D a s a pl c hi t r a r s . ppr he d vi , nd a ed m mde r e t1 Doc. 11 Da sbrug t sj198 acin,nami asdee nt Stphe Ranes He Count vi o ht hi 3 to ng fnda s e n i , my y, a Fr nkln Cot y. The c ur is a or ernotf ng Da st tli c nd n i mt o t s ued n d iyi vi ha ls ompl i f l t s t nnt aied o e j Acco di t Frnkln Comt Cic t Co tr co ds a ia e onlne Davi wa lt r c ged a r ng o a i t y r ui ur e r valbl i , ' s s ae har nd co ced ofpoi i orbr ndihi a fr a m and pos esi ofa frar a a c c e fl He i c r nty nvit ntng a s ng te r s son le m s onvit d eon. s ure l a tngtil waii ra. Dockets.Justia.com frh ce rj1983camsc e i co uc by e c dee anti vi ai ofhi consiui l o t la li onc m ng nd t a h fnd n olton s tttona tg saz gr t d li a opporuniy t fl a n e i ht td r e zm n t t o ie n m nded c ompl i , c heha do . ant whi h s ne Lieal c nsr e , h n n e c mplitalg ste f l wi g omd f rr le :() b r l o tu d t e me d d o an le e h ol ng r t s o eif 1 y o Ran sviltd sae lw i d tii Da i;( Rane t a ul sie a d u e e c sie ie oae tt a n eanng vs 2) i s mlwf ly ez d n s d x e sv fr ea an tDa i;()t He r Co n y S e ifsOfiec n o e Ran s wr n f la to ; o c g is v s 3 he n f u t h rf fc o d n d ie ' o g u cins ( ) te F a l Comt S rf s Ofi e n gi e ty al we Ran s a to a d fie t 4 h rnki t y heif n fc e lg nl lo d i e ' cins n ald o d si i lm t ra tr a d ()Rane c mmitd a s uta batr a an tDa i. Ran s icpl z hee fe; n 5 i s o te sa l nd tey g i s v s ie ne i s e mone a y dn a sfom t de e e ks t r m ge r he f ndan sf rt s aleg vi a i . t o he e l ed oltons l. I The c t i r quie t dimis a a ton or c am fl d by a pds r agans a our s e r d o s s ny ci l i ie one i t gove n e ale iy orofi ri t c tde e m i st aci n orcli i fi ous m a ii us r m nt ntt fce f he our t r ne he to a m s rvol , lc o , o fist saeacam u nwhihr l fma beg a td.2 U. C. 1 5 b ( ) I o d rt r al o tt li po c ei y r ne 8 S. j 91 A( )1. n r e o e saea cam i a y fd r lcvla to ,t p an ifst a ta alg to smus bee o g t tt li n n e e a ii cin he litf' t ct l le ain m z t nuh o r ie a rg t r le a as i ht o e if bove t s cultve l ve s't one t ti l a i e on is f ce' r t r he pe a i e l' o ha s l usbl pl t a s' ahe ta meey E o ev b e' BelAt.Co v.Two l 5 0 U. 5 4 5 0 ( 0 ) Se to h n rl ç nc i a l. l l m. c ' mby, 5 S. 4 , 7 20 7 . cin 1 pe mis a a ive pa t t fl a cvi a ton a i ta pe s f a tons t ke unde 983 r t n ggre d ry o ie i l c i gans ron or ci a n r col of sa e 1w t tvi a e hi rght t rt Co tt i o l ws oft Unied Stt . or t t a ha olt d s i s mde he nsiuton r a he t a es Co p rv. h e n 7 5F.d 1 3 1 8(t Ci. 01 ) o e S e ha , 3 3 5 , 5 4 h r 2 3 . Se ton 1 w ilnots c i 983 l uppor a c am ba ed o a r pondea s ro t or ofla lt t li s n es t upe i r he y ibiiy. M o l v De t fS ca S r ie , 3 U. 6 8 6 4 ( 9 8 .Toi o e1 8 la iiyu o a nel . p'o o il e vc s 4 6 S. 5 , 9 1 7 ) mp s 9 3 ib l p n t mlni i iy o is age i s f a mt cpale o e' a tons Eofk i lpo iy mus be Ehe l cpalt r t nc e or mi i mpl ye s c i , l t à lc t t m o ng f c oft c tt tona vi a i i or rt e t bls t la lt ofa go r e vi or e he onsiui l olton' n de o sa ih he i biiy ve nm nt b d t e j 1 8 . Pok v.Do s n 4 4 U. 31 3 ( 9 )( u tn Mo l,4 6 U. a o y md r 9 3' l ' d o , 5 S. 2, 26 1 81 q oi g nel 3 S. t 6 4 . Se Riz v.Go d ,4 3 U. 3 2,3 0 3 7 ( 9 6 ( o dn g nea alg to o 9) e zo o e 2 S. 6 7 - 7 1 7 ) h l ig e r l l ain f e a miitaiene lg n e fist saea c nsi to a cam c g z bl u d rj 1 8 ) Da i d nsrtv gi e c al o tt o tt in l li o nia e n e 9 3 . vs u doe notsae f c s i c tng t tRa ne a t d a he d d plrua tt an polc or c t of s t t a t ndi a i ha i s c e s i zs n o y i y usom et rHe y Cot y,Fr nkln Co mt ort i r s c i s rf de rm e s Ac or ngl ihe nr mt n i t y, her e pe tve he ifs pa t nt . c di y, Da shasnotsaed ac am t tet rt c mte o t i 1w e o c m e e ii m a behed vi tt l i ha ihe he ot is r he r a nf r e nt nttes y l la et rj 1 f Rane 'a to a i tDa s ibl mde 983 or i s cins gans vi. Da sa s f ulst co mtesa t i 1 e o ce nte ii sf rf ii t dici i vi lo a t he t i nd her aw nf r me ntte o alng o s plne Ra ne f t aci Da sc le s Da sha no co tt i lrght howe r t ha a i s or he tons vi halnge . vi s nsi ona i , m ve , o ve ny ot rpe s i si td orpr e ut d f a ofe e SeeLi R. v.Riha d D. 410 U. he r on nve tgae os c e or ny f ns . nda S. c r , S. 61 ,6 9( 9 3 (i dn idv d l sn c n ttto a rg trgadn ci na pr s c to o 4 1 1 7 ) fn ig n iiua ha o o siuin l ih e r ig rmi l o e ui n r n n p o e u ino a t e p ro ) o - r s c to f noh r e s n . 11 1. Fort r s saed,t co tdim is Da s'c am s a i tHem' Cot y a t he ea ons tt he ur s s es vi l i gans y mt nd he He r Cot y Sherf De rm e a ag ns Fr nkln Count a t Fr nkln Cot y ny mt ifs pa t nt nd ai t n i y nd he a i mt S rY sDe rme t p ru n t j 1 5 b ( ) f rfi r t saeacam. Thsa to wi g hei pat n , u s a t o 91 A( )1, o al e o tt li u i cin l o l f wa d o y ast Da s c am sa i tDe e ntRane . The Clr i die t d t s nd c pis or r nl o vi' l i gans f nda i s ek s r ce o e o e oft i m e a um opi o a a o pa ng o de t pl ntf. l s mor nd z ni n nd cc m nyi r r o ai if y Re Y . ENTER:Thi 3*Y da of le 'r Ie t ,201 s yt . 5. Chi fU nie St t sD i t i tJ e t d a e sr c udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
