Donohue v. Johnston et al, No. 7:2015cv00315 - Document 4 (W.D. Va. 2015)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/15/2015. (slt)

Download PDF

Donohue v. Johnston et al Doc. 4 CLERK: OF CEU.. SX COURFI S DI i AT ROANOKE, VA F/ LED I TH E IM TED STATES DI N J STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STW CT OF W RGI A NI ROANOKE DI SI VI ON JOH N DONOH UE, J 15 2 1 UN 2 25 J A ULI BY: D UD v RK K CASE N O.7: 15CV0031 5 Pl ntf , ai if V. M EM OR AND U M O PI O N NI J S. OHNS . J TON, & , c By GlnE. nr d : e Co a Chi fU ni e St e D i t i tJudge e t d at s s r c De e f ndant . s J Do hue aVig ni i ae pr ce di pr K ,tl t scvi aci cl mi t t ohn no , r i a nm t o e ng o sed hi i l ton, ai ng ha t ej d e pr s c tr a d p bi d fn e iv l di h sci n lp o e u in c lu e t h v h u g , o e uo , n u lc ee d r n ove n i rmia r s c to o ld d o a e hi wr ul c ce Li r ly c tui hi s iso ,t co tdoc e t m asa m ongf ly onvit d. be al onsr ng s ubm s i ns he ur ketd he ci lrght aci n ptrua t 42U. C. 1 8 . B e a e Donohue ha notpr pai t r uiie vi i s to ls nt o s e d he eq st S. j 9 31 c us . flng fe t c tasumes frpupos soft sopi on,t thei s e ngt pr e t f ii e , he our s , o r e hi ni ha s e ki o oce d q onna pa rs Upon r viw oft r c d,hec t i t tt a ton mus bes upe i. e e he e or t our fnds ha he c i t umm a iy dimi s d rl s s e wi u p eudc ba e o Do h ' p ircv l cin ta ha eb e d s s e a fio o . t t rj ie s d n no ues ro ii a to s h t v e n imis d s rv lus ho ThePrs Liiai Reor Ac of1 s tntal n nde t t f ma pa rs ion tg ton f m t 995 ubsa ily me d he q or upei sa e,28 U. C.j1915. The pur e oft Ac wa t r quie a1 prs ne ltga s s ng tmt S. pos he t s o e r 1 io r ii nt ui gove n e e ii o ofi i l t pa flng f e i f l et rt ough pr payme ort ough r m nt nttes r fc as o y ii e s n ul, ihe hr e nt hr i tl n s wi h l fo te ltg n ' imae tu ta c t . j1 1 ( ) S cin 1 5 g nsal t t ed r m h i a ts n t r s c omt me h i 9 5 b . e to 91 () dele t i t l e pa e me hod t prs ne swho ha Glr srkes'- t e prs ne s zis he nsalm nt ym nt t o io r ve llee ti ' hos i o r t w ho have ha t e pr vi c es o a a s di m i s d as f i ous m a i i ,or f r f lze t d hr e e ous as r ppe l s s e rvol , lc ous o ailr o saeacam, mls t etr esrke imaes o Gmmie td n e o s ro sp y ia ij r . tt li l e s h h e -ti r n t h ws t n n a g r f e iu h sc ln u y' i ' j1 1 () 9 5g . 1 Do o a s rst tAri eIIoft Consiui and 18U.SC. 1 3 ( no e itn saue p o ie tt ton n hue s e t ha tcl I he . j 3 7 a n xse t ttt) r vd j rs ito frtec u toa de shscams Hei mitke . u idcin o h o r t d rs i li . s sa n Dockets.Justia.com Do hue ha br no s ought s h a to o a al o t e or m o e pdor oc aso . Se uc c ins r ppe s n hr e r c i ns e Do o u v Hikl,Ca eNo 7 1 -v 0 3 ( . Va Ap i 2 ,2 4 ( im' a fio o n h e . n e s . :4 c - 01 8 W D. . rl 9 01 ) ds d s rv lus t e j1 5 B)1) Do o u v S il Ca eNo.7:4-v 0 51 ( . Va Ap i 2 ,2 4 md r 91 A( ( ); n h e . tl, s 1 c - 01 W D. . rl 9 01 ) ( im' a fio o u d rj 1 5 b () afr d f rra o ssae i t dsrc c u tNo. ds d s rv lus n e 91 A()1, fime o e s n ttd n he itit o r, 1 - 91 , 4h Ci. . 6 2 4 Do h v Coln , vl to No 7:4-v 1 7( . Va 4 6 5 ( t r Aug 2 , 01 :; no ue . l s CiiAcin . 1 c - 5 W D. . i 2 4 ( im' a fioo u e j1 1 A( )1) Ac o dn l Do h ma p o e dL f r 01 ) ds d s rv lus nd r 9 5 b ( ). c r igy, no ue y r c e q o ma p u rs( to t rpa me t ftefln fe o l i h s wsta h f c si n n d n e o a pei wih u p e y n o h ii g e ) ny f e ho h t e a e mmie t a g r f s ro p sc lij r rltd t hi c re tcams j1 5 g . Do o uesalg to f i t eius hy ia n u y eae o s u rn li . 91 ( ) n h ' le ains al o s how t tt pa t c ha he s onduc of whi h he c t c ompl i i t s a ton ha pl ce hi i i ne ans n hi c i s a d m n mmi nt da rofphysc hn m. nge ial r Be a s t erc r srte tta Do o u ha a latt reGti s'md rj1 5 g a d c u e h e o d el c h t n h e s t e s h e t rke 't e 91 ( ) n s hasnotde onsr t t the i i i i ntda rofphysc ha m,t co tde e Donohue m taed ha s n mm ne nge i al r he ur ni s t o potniy t p o e d L f r p u e i a d ds s e t e c mplitwi u p eu ie he p ru t o r c e q o ma a p rs n imis s h o an t t rj d c ho t e j 1 5 g . An ap r pdat or rwilis t sday md r 91 ()2 p o e de l s ue hi . TheClr i die t d t s nd c pi oft sm e or ndlm o ni n a a ompa ng e k s r c e o e o es hi m a l pi o nd cc nyi or rt pl ntf. de o ai if ExTsR:Thst i6 d yo Jme 2 5 a f t , 01 . Chi fUnie Stt DititJ e t d a es src udge 2 M or ve,Do hu ' c r ntca a elgal hi ous I esenc hi c eo r no e s ure 1hns r e ly vol . n s e, s ompl nta tmpt t ove t n ai te s o rur hi c i nalconvito t ough mea ofa cvi acin a i tt pa tci nt a til I i wel e tbls d, s rmi cin hr ns i l to gans he ri pa s t ra. t s l sa ihe ho vrta dtt pio es( y us o yhbescr s(rsmia sae rme e whe t yse t ivldt wee,htsae rsn r mal e nl a a opu o i lr tt) e dis n he ek o n aiae s ted rto o t i c n e n, wh te dr cl o Rn ie tytr u haj dca d tr naln ta n c sai h u ain f her o ln me t' eh r ie t r idrcl h o g u iil eemi to h t e e srl ' y y i le teu lwf le so teSaesc so y' W i n o v. to ,5 4 U..7 ,81( 05. F rh r r,h mpis h na un s f h tt' utd . l s n Dos n 4 S 4 20 ) u temoe te ' ki c u td cie t c ns eDo o ess b sin a ah b a c r sp tto u e 2 U. C.j2 4,b cu ei o r el s o o t n nl n hu ' u miso s a e s opu eiin nd r 8 S. 25 e a s t ofr n go n o whc t sg ett t u hap tto c ul bed e dtn l t e 28U. C. 2 4 ( fes o ru d n ih o u g s ha s c ei n o d eme h ey md r i S. j 2 4 *.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.