Obataiye-Allah v. VA Clarke, et al, No. 7:2015cv00250 - Document 37 (W.D. Va. 2015)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/17/2015. (tvt)

Download PDF

clERrs oFFl Ua A RoA oK:,vA couW T cE s. s N nlm Fl LED SEP 12 2 1 25 I THE UNI N YED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STW CT OF W RGI A NI R O AN OK E DI SI N W O UH UR U 'SEK O U O BA TA n V - LA H , AL J A . ULI BY: ' L C CA SE N O .7: 5CV 00250 1 Pl nt f , ai i f V. M EM ORm UM OPI ON M HAROLD CLARKE, AL , :I Dee n t) fnda ts. By: G l n E . onr e C ad Chi fUni e St esD i t i tJudge e t d at src Plitf Uhmz S ko Ob tieAla no flshi mo inf ritroc t r rle ( an if t ' e u aay - lh w ie s to o n el uo y eif ECF No 3 ) sg da dd t do S p e r8 2 5 Asi li pdo s c moins hec mpli t a . 6 , ine n ae n e tmbe , 01 . n l s r u h to , o ans h t t de e ntprs n ofk il a Re Oni St t Prs n a e r f sng t ac omm oda ehi l t e he f nda i o f a s t d on ae io r e u i o c t s acos i ol r nce.Upon r vi oft r o d, heco twilde hi c r ntmoton. nt e a e ew he ec r t ur l ny s ure i Spect a l Oba aye- lh sa e t thi Comm o Fa eDitmea si l t ort e ik ly, t i Ala tt s ha s n r e l ncude wo hr e s r ngsofco t c e e e r d a s ei e c an o he f ie sc t i ng dar a e vi tage he s ve y ay nd om tm s ont i t r ood t m on a ni iy s wel. I r e da ,t prs r n s to be nsa s r e i t son t Comm on Fa e Di t l n ec nt ys he ion a hor f a nd e v d nma e he r e doubl po tons of co t e c s a e c me . Oba aye- lh as e t t t i he eas dar e ri tag hee e t a h al t i Ala s rs ha f t iy pr uc s he s f r a od t , uf e s bdomi lups t l he a dst s ie ,m ofk i l ha ad s d hi t na e. f voi he e t ms s t as ve vie m o do,he al ge y sa v a gr m o e a m or t r g f hi he g ofne ry sx f e le dl t r es nd ows r nd e mde weiht or s i ht al i e t a t n i he . nd e nc s By opi on a or r e er d Aug t8,201 t c tde e Oba a ye Ala s pdo ni nd de nt e us 5, he our ni d t i - l h' r Obataiye-Allah v. VA Clarke, et al Doc. 37 moton on t e is ,ba ed on de e nt 'evi nce i t r c d. On Augu t 1 201 i hes s ues s fnda s de n he e or s 4, 5, d fn n stld amo in f rsl r j dg n wih a d to a e ie c i s p o t Amo ee da t ie to o l mmay u me t t d ii n l vd n e n u p r. ng ot r t ngs def nda s e de e i c t s t tObat ye Alah we ghe 221 po he hi , e nt ' vi nc ndi a e ha ai - l i d unds on M a y 28 201 a 230 poundson M a 26,2015.I hi c r ntmoton,her porst the now weghs , 4 nd y n s ure i e t ha i Dockets.Justia.com ') 240 pot . De e n s e de ' a s i caest tt sm on h,Re Oni wilbe n s r i mds f nda t ' vi nc lo ndi t ha hi e t d on l gi e vng i aesho Com mon Fa e mea s The me f rt e meascal f s r i ofc t c e e nm t t r l. nu o hes l ls or e v ngs otage he s onl onc o t c pe w e k. y e r wi e r e Ba e on t i e de ,a f t r a ons saed i t Augu t 8 opi on,t c t sd l s vi nce nd or he e s z t t n he s ni he our c ude t t Oba aye M l h ha no de oncl s ha ti - a s t monsr t d a bass on whih he i e il d t t ta e i c s ntte o he e r di r r med he s ks Se W i e v. aur Res De .Cot l I ,555 U. 7,20 xtaor na y e y ee . e ntr N t al . f mci. nc. S. ( 0 8 (e ui n n oh rfco s as o n l l o o s c s o meisa d l l o 2 0 ) r q dng mo g t e a tr, h wig i i d f uc e s n rt n i i d ke ho ke ho ef e he l s t s fe irpaa eh r i a e c o p ei n r rle Ther or ,t courtwilisue an o u fr re rbl n m n bsn e f r l a y eig. mi a o it or rde nghi moton. ppr pra e de nyi s i The Clr i die t d t s nd c pi of t s m e a lm opi on a ac ompa ng ek s rce o e o es hi mor nd l ni nd c nyi or rt t pa te . de o he ri s ENTER:Thi lN R da ofSe e r 201 s y ptmbe, 5. Cli fUnie Stt Diti tJ le t d aes src udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.