Obataiye-Allah v. VA Clarke, et al, No. 7:2015cv00250 - Document 30 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/7/2015. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
clEnK' OFFIE U, - s C A n A o ,vAmK U T o N s Ds K,l E W iI : 'L7D I TH E UM TED STATES DI N STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI GI A CT R M RO AN O K E D I SI N VI O UHURU'SEK OU OBATM YE- U I M LM , SEP g8 2 1 25 JULA f. -U i D $ BY; CASE NO .7: 5CV00250 1 Pl nt f , ai i f M EM ORANDUM OPI ON M HAROLD CLARKE,:I AL , Dee n t) fnda ts. By: G l n E .Conr e ad Chi fU ni e St e D i t i tJudge e t d at s s r c Pli if Uhunf Se antf kou Obati - lh,a Vigi a i t pr e ng pr K , fl d t s a ye Ala r ni nma e oce di o ie hi . cvi rght a ton purua t 42 U. C.j1 i l i s ci s nt o S. 983. He alege t tofiil a Re Orin Stt l s ha fcas t d to ae Pds n ha vi a e hi c tt tonalrgh s by r f sng t pr de a co m odai f li o ve olt d s onsiu i i t e u i o ovi c m ton or ls lc os i olr nc De e nt ha wa ve s r c of pr e s a ha be n gr t a a t e nt e a e. f nda s ve i d e vie oc s nd ve e an ed n e e i oftm et r s xtnson i o e pond t pll i sc m pl nt The ha howe r pr de e de i o a ntc o ai . y ve, ve , ovi d vi nce n r s ns t pani smoi nf ritro u o yrle ( No 9 , n p an ifh srple wi a epo e o litY to o ne lc tr eif ECF . ) a d litf a e id t h de l r ton. Afe r vi w oft pa te 's isons t co tc l st pl ntf smoton caai tr e e he ri s ubm s i , he ur oncude hat ai if i m us bede e t nid. Pl i iffl d t saci i M a 2015. He c am st thei a lr ct e ,po k,daiy, antf ie hi ton n y l i ha s le gi o ggs r r a be fpr t . A sa f l roft Na i ofI lm r i i her e ve t Comm on Fa e nd e oduc s olowe he ton sa elg on, ec i s he r Di t de i ned t be co it ntwih hi r i ousdit r bei f . Dar pr t a ei l d i e, sg o nsse t s elgi e a y le s iy oduc s r ncude n t sdi t ml pl ntf wa st c t o diec Re Ori n of i l t pr dehi wih s tt t hi e , d ai if nt he our t r t d lo fc a s o ovi m t ubsiu e Obataiye-Allah v. VA Clarke, et al Doc. 30 f ie st tdo notc an dar pr t . Heas e t t te tng f ie sc ani daiy ood t m ha ont i iy oduc s s rs ha a i ood t m ont i ng r pr oduc s c us li di tve di c m f t or i s e c es a a l r c r a ton. H e al o t a es zm ges i s o or , n om as , n le gi e c i s c ompli t twhe he a dse tng daiy ie si t m e l pr de t hi he G t r es' ans ha n voi a i r t m n he a s ovi d o m, l a v . s ' Dockets.Justia.com C FRK . De e nt pr e e de t tpli ifha be n c i d a Re Oni snc M a 28, f nda s es nt vi nce ha antf s e onfne t d on i e y 201 Acc r ng t m e c lr or ,a t ttm e hewe g d 221pounds On Jme24 a a i 4. o di o di a ec ds t ha i , i he . t nd gan on De mbe 24,201 t i tt tonalphyscan is d a ditor rf pli ift r c ve no ce r 4, he nsiu i i i s ue e de or a ntf o e ei e g o d iyp o ucs( a e o lco eit lrn e. g s r ar r d t b s d n a t s no ea c ) On J anumy 6,201 a doc o e l t pl n if on li c 5, t r vauaed aitf ls ompl i t tsnc c l hood, ant ha i e hid e tng be a por ha c us d a r h a s li ofli tloa and eye . The doc o or r d ai ef nd k d a e as nd we lng zs lr t s t r de e I ST al r t ss f rpl ntf wih a f l u bas d on t t s r s t . On J nua y 1 a G le gy e t o ai if t olow p e he e t e uls a r 2 nd a n on J nua y 20,2015, antf r us t unde go t or r d al r t tng. Pl i ifno gai a r pli if ef ed o r he de e le gy esi antf w sa e t tbeng po d wih nee esi agans hi r i o belef . tt s ha i ke t dl s i t s elgi us i s On M a c 20,201 Dr Am one t is adie tve by e a lt a1 Vigi aDe rt e rh 5, . te s ued r c i m i o l r ni pa m nt ofCo r tonshe t a horte a pr de sc reci alh ut iis nd ovi r once ni dar pr t . The e a lsaed t t r ng iy oduc s m i t t ha onl i a e who r po ts y nm t s e r ympt m sc it ntwih at'e a lr t dar pr ucss d r ceve o onsse t l le gy o' iy od t houl e i u am e c ldi tor rf r dar s tt es The e li c t t ti eswho r po tahit y di a e de o iy ubsiut . mai ndi aed ha nmat e r sor ofpan,gas bl tng,and di hea wihoutot r s i , oai m , t he ympt oms s esi of a t u aler a e ugg tve r e l gy, r lkey l t e i olr nt r t r t n ale gi s h i a e s d mer l be a s d t a d i l acos nt e a , a he ha lr c; uc nm t s houl ey dvie o voi dar pr t a s d not be pr vi d a s c a dit r a c modai ns The e a l iy oduc s nd houl o de ny pe i l e a y c om to . m i i tuce pr de st r e ua e ale si G daiy' or r t e ur t tt ar ba e on nsr t d ovi r o e val t l xitng t no r ' de s o ns e ha hey e s d e de e ofat eal r t daiy. vi nc nl le gy o r I r po e t Dr A m one t s e ai, Re Ori s a f de e m i d t t pl n if ha no n es ns o . te' m l d lon t f t r ne ha ai t f d e tbls d m e c lne f a R dar ' or r The advie hi t the s d m a ge li sa ihe di a ed or no iy' de . y s d m ha houl na ls l t e i olr nt c ton by a di da r f . De e nt alo not t t ac or ng t acos nt e a ondii voi ng iy oods f nda s s e ha c di o pl i ifsm e c lr o d,he weghed 23 pounds on M a 26,201 t n poundsm or t n he antf di a ec r i 0 y 5- e e ha w e ghed be or t E da r 'o de w a r voke i f e he t no iy' r r s e d. 2 Pl ntf fld a e e ge ai if ie n m r ncy gre nc o Jm e 1 201 co ai ng t t he had a iva e n t 6, 5, mpl ni ha n ale g cr ac i a tri si a s a la o ofco t c e e Pl ntf sa e t tt co t lr i e ton fe nge tng m l m unt tage he s . ai if tt s ha he tage c e e wa ne t li be nson t plt a at he s s xt o ls a he ae nd lhough he ti d t s pa a et t a ea onl re o e r t he wo nd t y t bea ,he de l pe s l n e a a r h o hi c s. Thentr e who e m i d pli if he ns ve o d wole yes nd as n s he t ls xn ne antf i r pons t t s c n es e o he e ompl i snot t a e br ahi a no r ie r h,wih onl a s l ant ed ml bor d e t ng nd as d as t y mal amount of s li a ot bot e s a a i se e Be dr . Pl i if co pl ne of welng r md h ye , nd dm nitr d na yl antf m ai d ano he ale gi r c i o Jme 1 201 ' fe e mi ng pli ifon t s oc aso a nur e t r lr c ea ton n t 7, 5. A tr xn ni a ntf hi c i n, s not d smia s e i lr ympt s Pli ifwaspr de Be dr f tle days Afe a t r al r om . a ntf ovi d ne yl or lr e . tr hid le gy compl ntfo pl i ifon J 24,a nm s no e t tpli ifwasi no a ut dite s The ai ' m antf r une e t d ha antf n c e sr s . ntr e t n r e r d pl ntf f c r r vi w by t i tmtona physcin,who no e pl i i s ls he ef re ai if or ha t e e he nsi i l ia t d antY r us t t ef al o mder o de ed al r t tng. go r r le gy esi I r pons t de e nt e denc pli ifco i n es e o f nda s' vi e, antf ntnuest i itt the i a lr ct daiy o nss ha s le gi o r f oods a ha de o d da k cr l a ot hi e fom goi wihouts tt e f ie s nd s velpe r ices r md s yes ' r ng t ubsiut ood t m . He sa est thei ne dy sx f e a tn i hest l and hi nor alwei i 262 pot . tt ha s a i e t nd e nc al s m ght s mds Be a s itro uo yij n tv r l fi a e ta r iay rme y,hepa t s e i t e c u e n el c tr n u cie ei s n xr o dn r e d t ry e kng h e p ei n r ijmcinmus ma ace rs o n th th i l eyt s c e d o temeis t t rlmiay n t to t ke la h wig l a e s i l o u c e n h rt,ha t k he i lkey t s f r ir pa a e ha m i t a e e ofpr i i r r le ,t tt ba a e of s i l o ufe re r bl r n he bs nc elm na y e if ha he l nc e ute tp i hi fvo ; ndta a ijmcin i i tep bi i tr s 'W itrv. tla Re . q i s is n s a r a h t n nl to s n h u lc ne et' n e Nat l s i r De . t i.I - 5 5 U. .7 2 ( 0 ) Ea h o t e ef t fco smu tb stsid 1 Re 1 f Comcl nc, 5 S , 0 2 08. c f h s ol a tr s e aife . a r Tnzh Abo Oba I v.FEC,575F. 3 347 ( h Ci.2009) va t on ot rMr mds t ut ma. nc. 3d 42, 4t r , caed he ot , 1 Plitf rq ssatmp rr rsri ngodrad apei ny ijncin. Te oayrsriig anif euet e oay etani re n rl a nu t mi o mp rr etann or r a e is onl r r l whe t mova pr st the wils f iptr i r i i notgrntd befr t de s r sued y a ey, n he nt ove ha l ufer l ty f elef s a e o e he a v rep ryc udb n tte a dh v o p ru iyt r so . S eF d R. v. 6 09.Su ha od rwo d d es at o l e oi d n a e p o tnt o ep nd e e . Ci P. 5 i c n re ul o l ls t i s c tmea ahern o aprl nay ij n to c udbearn e Asi i ce rfo t o te ny at mtl u h i s aig n ei r nu cin o l mi ra g d. t s la rm he ust ta panifi n te t ldt apeh iayijncin t c u tid n b ssu o whc t grn hi atmp rr h t litf s o nie o rlnn r nu to ,he o r fn s o a i p n ih o a t m e oay t r s ni o de . e kai ng r r 5 9 U. 1 8 ( 01 ) r isae i rlva tpa tb 6 7 F.d 3 5 3 5 ( t Ci.2 0 ( ing 5 S. 0 9 2 0 , en ttd n ee n r y 0 3 5 , 5 4h r 01 ) ct i W itr 5 5U. a 2 ) n e, 5 S. t 0 . P an iff ist d mo taea y irp r beij r t t wi s fri t ec u t o sno litf al o e nsrt n re a a l nu y ha he l ufe f h o r d e t l o de def nda s i e a ey t pr vi no iy f r r e nt mm dit l o o de ndar ood s tt t . He has not pr s ntd ubsiues ee e e de e e t bls vi nc sa iMng t the ha a t'e a lr t daiy pr uc s ort the c ha s l le gy o r od t u ha nnnotvolmt rl t a iy a d m os,i notal c ac w11 dar pr ucs.Theevi ncea s doe nots voi t f l, ont t 11 iy od t de lo s uppo tpl i i s r nntc i itnc t t he i sa vng wihout r e vi s tmt f nsse e ha s tr i t ec i ng ubsi e ood ie s f t dar pr tm or he iy oduct s i ude i li mea s W ihou pr t the wils f rir pa a ehn m,hei no e ild t t ncl d n zs l. t t oof ha l ufe re r bl r s t ntte o he pr lmi r r le he s ks. Acc di y,t c twilde hi m o i n. An a opra eor r ei na y ei f ee or ngl he our l ny s to ppr i t de wilis t sda l s ue hi y. The Clr i die t d t s nd co e of t s m e a lm opi on a ac ompa ng ek s r ce o e pis hi mor nd l ni nd c nyi o de t t pa tes r r o he ri . EN TER : Tli - N da o Se e r zs 1 y f pt mbe , 2015. Chi Unie Stt Diti tJ ef t d aes src udge 4
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
