Muhammad v. Unnamed Defendants, No. 7:2015cv00223 - Document 14 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/15/2015. (slt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
' . Muhammad!: Unnamed Defendants v. ! Doc. 14 / , :L ERKSoFFl u, . sm coUm cE s Dl AT RoAxou , vA FlEn u I lux INI STATESol Tm c' covR' x ' J TED s r r Fol tvus w sslx Rx m s' c' ol Rcl A rm r ?w xl ROAN OK E DI SI W ON . ABDUL HAM ZA W ALIM UHAM M AD, ) ) m ai if ntf, ) v. ) ) ) E. BARKS U ET AI. R. DAIE, , , ) ) Dee n t) fnda ts. ) J 15 2 1 UN 25 a . e uu ouo , sc BY : ' . . D , E CAS NO. : 5 0 2 E 7 1 CV0 2 3 M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI By: GlnE. nr d e Co a ChifUnie St esDititJudge e t d at src AbdulHn z W a iM u mmm a a Vigi a i ae pr e di pr K ,fl d tls cvi m a l l d, r ni nm t oc e ng o e li i l rg t a to pls a tt 4 U.. j1 8 ,algng t a p io o fcas a Re Ono S ae ih s cin t u n o 2 SC. 9 3 le i h t rs n fiil t d in tt r Prs ha fie t or ro pr de hi a dar re dita rcl sfe hi wihoutdue lon ve ald o de r ovi m ipfe e nd e asiid m t pr s . Upon r viw oft r co d, he c tfndst tt a ton m us be sl oce s e e he e r t our i ha he c i t lmmarl dimi s d iy s s e f f iur t e us q nita i r m e esbe or tlngt scvi aci n. or a l e o xha t dmi sr tve e di f e ii hi i l to I M uhn a ale s t ti M a ch 201 whie he wast mpor rl co i a Sus e 1 mm d l ge ha n r 5, l e a iy nfned t s x S ae P io C:I ',a d co prs rb d a p r n n d ipfe d e f rhm,t a d e sh s tt rs n S SP' ) o tr e cie ema e t ar re it o i o d rs i ongoi pr e wih c tpai a o he a ng obl ms t onsi ton nd t r bdom i li s s W hie a SI M uhn m a na s ue . l t SP, m d c i ontnued t r ceve hi pr a oved Comm on Fa e Ditm e l f r r lgi r as ns butw a o e i s e ppr r e as o e i ous e o , s pr de wih no dar s tt t t r pl e dar iems nor al i l d wih t t dit ovi d t n- iy ubsiues o e ac iy t m ly ncude t ha e . W hen M uha mad wa ta f re ba k t Re Oni on Aprl1 2015,he i edit l as d m s r ns e r d c o d on i 7, mm a ey ke f r ognii of t pe m ane non- i y di t pr s rbe by t SI doc or R e Oni s or ec ton he r nt da r e e c i d he SP t . d on' doc or s i t di t w oul ne t be a oved by a V i g ni De rm e of Cor ec i ns t a d he e d ed o ppr r i a pa t nt r to (& < VDOC' a mi srtr F o s r ie e ly e rf sd t p o ien n d iy s bsiue , n ' d nitao . o d evc mp o e s e u e o r vd o - ar u t ts a d ) t M uha a c mm d ompl i t t he wil l e weght wiho t s st tt e . M uha a a s ans ha l os i t ut he e tbsiut s mm d lo Dockets.Justia.com dico r d t tRe Ol o om ca s ha r c as i li t a li r s c iy lve wih m or s ve e ha d n il d e l ssed tm o lghe e m' e l t t e r ti tvelvi c tonswihoutprorno i eorahea i esrci i ng ondii t i tc rng. M thn a fl i o m a co ant a utt ditis a t c a sfc ton i s on l mm d ied nf r l mpli s bo he e sue nd he l s ii ai s ue Aprl23 a 26,201 butdi no r eve a r c ptf et r ç i nd 5, d t ec i e ei or ihe ompli . On Aprl29,201 ant i 5, Mth mma fld amoin f rp ei nayij n tv r l fr g i gt e ep o e .Thec u t ln d ie to o rlmi r n u ci e ei e rd n h s r blms e or co t e hi s nsm d s ubmi so a a cvi rght co anta is d ac to lflng or r a ong s i n s i l i s mpli nd s ue ondii na ii de , m ot r tlngs die tng hi t de o tae e usi n of a i sr tve r m e es a r quie he li , r c i m o m nsr t xha to dm nita i e di s e r d t e 4 U. C. 1 9 e a.OnM a 1 , 01 ( No 4 , n d s b te amo inf r md r 2 S. j 9 7 () y 9 2 5 ECF . ) Muh mma u mitd to o e e i o tm e t c xt nson f i o ompl wih t c tona flng or r Tli m oton sa e t t y t he ondii l ii de . ls i t t s ha M uhn a r eved r s mm d ec i e pons st hi ilonnalc e o s rf ompli so M a 8,201 a c n now pr ee ant n y 5, nd a oc d t exha tli ad i sr i r medis o us ls m nitatve e e. 11 Th Prs n Liiain Reo m Ac ( t ', n oh rti g , r vie i 4 U. C. e io tg to f r t G A' mo g t e h n s p o d s n 2 S. TLl ) j1 9 ea t a ap io e c n o b ig acvla to c nc r i p io c n iinsu tlh h s 9 7 () h t rs n r a n t rn ii cin o e nng rs n o dto n i e a frte h u td a alb ea miitaie rme is P re v. sl,5 4 U..5 6 5 4 ( 0 2 . is x a se v ia l d n srt e de . o tr Nu se 3 S 1 , 2 2 0 ) v Thi e us i n r quie e a i t G l i a e s t , w he he t y i ve ge r l s xha to e r m nt pples o d l nm t uis a t r he nvol ne a c r lm s m e or pa tc a e s s . . . whe he t y alege e e s ve f r e or s e ot r i c l t nc s r i ul r pi ode , t r he l xc s i o c om he wr ng, a e n i t f m ofr le t i a es e i hi lws ti no a ia et ough t o ' nd ve f he or ' e if he nm t e ks n s a ui s t val bl hr he prs sgre nc pr e ngs JJ Fallet flow t r q rd pr durs oft prs s ion' iva e oce di . .. itr o ol he e uie oce e I he ion' ad i s tve r m e pr e s i l ng tm e lm is or t e us a 1l ve s of ad i s r tve m ni ka i e dy oc s , nc udi i i t , o xha t 1 e l m nit a i rviw i no G ope e usin'a wilba a i t sj 1 a ton.W oodf dv. e e s t ç r xha to ' nd l r n nmae' 983 ci pr or Ngo,548 U. 81 9 ( 0 6 . tW j r fi r t e ha s i a pae tfo t f c o t c mp an 'he S. , 0 2 0 ) i hee al e o x u t s p rn r m he a e f he o lit't l u 2 c tm a sl ma iy dim is t co a n on t t gr md. Ande s v.XYZ Core tonal our y l m rl s s he mpli t ha ' ot r on rci He 1 S r e . n .40 F.d6 4 68 ( t Ci. 0 5 . at e dc s I c, 7 3 7 , 2 4h r 2 0 ) h Opeai P o e u e (OP' 8 61i t wrte a mi taierme isp o e t eta r t r c d r G ' 6 . s he itn d isrtv e d e r c dl h t ng : ) r imae i t Vigna De a t n o Cor cin (t n t s n he r ii p rme t f re to s ç VDOC' mu t f lo t c mp y wih ' s ol w o o l tk ) j 1 9 ea . An imae mus frtatmp t rs le l sis e if r l by c mp ei a 9 7 ()1 n t t is te t o e ov l su s r o mal i l y o lt n ng i or a c nf m l ompl i f r f whi h he s d r ceve a r c pt I t i t doe no r c i a ant o m or c houl e i e ei . f he nma e s t e e ve r s ns t hi i or a c e po e o s nf m l ompl i wihi 15 da ,he m a fl a r gul r gre nc usng li ant t n ys y ie e a iva e, i ls r c pta e de et thea tm pt t i o m a co pli tpr e s A r ulrgreva m us e ei s vi nc ha te ed he nf r l m a n oc s . eg a i nce t befld wili 30 da oft oc ur e e ofwhi h t i a ec ie tln ys he c r nc c he nm t ompli . l t Leve 1r pons ans f he l es e t t r gul rg i va i nott hi s ts a to t i t m a a alf a Le 1 r s o he e a re nce s o s ai f c in, he nma e y ppe or vel 1 e pons , e a di s meisa c sd p ndn o t eis e Le l 1.Un r4 U.. j1 7 () a imae n n o n tn e e e ig n h su , ve 11 de 2 SC. 99 e a, n n t i ba r fom brng ng a prs c tonsc am i a f de a l wsltt i hehasfrtpr s nt d s red r i i ion ondii l i n e r l a ti mtl is e e e t tis t ough a1lvesoft a lbl prs gre ncepr edlr s W oodf d,548U . a ha s ue hr 1 e l he vaia e ion i va oc ze . or S. t 90. I i cea f m t f e oft i talco pli and lt r s isons t tM uhn m a t s l r m he ac he nii m a nt ae ubm s i ha m d fl t s a ton be or he e use a ia e ad i sr tve r m e e as t hi cli s ied hi c i f e xha t d va lbl m nitai e di s o s am c e n ng li non- r di ta r c a sfc ton. I d,by hi o a s i n,he fld t s onc r i ls daiy e nd e l s ii a i ndee s wn dmi so ie hi cvi a ton l s t n a we k a trs itng hi i or a co ant a bef r he ha fl a i l c i e s ha e fe ubm ti s nf m l mpli s nd o e d ied r g lrg iv n e o a y a p at) M u a d' alg to sas d mo tae ta h h sno e ua re a c r n p e ls. h mma s le ain lo e nsr t h t e a t be n pr ve e f om ptr ui hi a i s r tve r m ed e . H e r ce ve tm e y r pons s t li e e nt d r ls ng s dm ni t a i e i s e i d i l es e o zs 1Thec u ta e j iiln tc o VDOC op rtn prc d r swhihaea ia l o i . o rtk s udca oie f eaig o e u e, c r valbe nlne 3 if r lc mp an s( t n 1 d y a trhefldt e 2a d t r afer, h h dt eo p rl t n o ma o lit wi 5 a s fe ie h m) n he e t e a h p o t y hi mi t fl atmel r gu a gre nc a o ie i y e l r iva e boutli di ta a uthi c a sfc to Be a e M lhn a 's e nd bo l s l s ii a i n. c us l mm d f ie t e us a lbl a zita i r m e esbe or flng t sac i hi c am sar bare al d o xha t vaia e dmilsr tve e di f e ii hi ton, s l i e rd fo rv e t e 4 U. C. 1 9 ea a dwil esl rl d s 's dwi u p eudc . rm e iw md r 2 S. j 9 7 () n l b l mma i iml e t t rj ie3 y s ho M uha a s s iso a s do not pr de a f t al ba i f t pr lmi r mm d' ubm s i ns lo ovi ac u s s or he e i na y ijl tverle h s e s Th p rys e i ap ei nayijmcinmu tma eace rs wi g nl i eif e e k . e a t e kng rlmi r nl to s k la ho n nc Gha he i lkey t s e d ont m e is hei lkey t s f rir pa a e hn m i t a e of E t s i l o ucc e t he rt ; s i l o ufe re r bl r n he bs nce prlmi ayr l f t a t eb ln eo e ui e tpsi h sf v r a d a ij n to i i t ep b i ei n r ei ; h t h aa c f q t s i n i a o ; n n n u cin s n h u lc e i itr s ' W itr v Nal a Re .De .Co ncl J c, 5 5 U. 7 2 ( 0 ) Gs un a n eet' ne . tr l s f u is . . 5 S. , 0 20 8 . t s ig l n l p ei nay ij n to b s d o l o ap si it o irpaa l h r i i c n itn wi 'he r lmi r nu cin a e ny n o sbl y f re rb e n m s n o sse t t t i h' f c ta ijmci r l fi G l e ta r iay rme y t a ma o l b a r d u n ace r a t h t nt tve ei s û' x ro dn r e d h t y ny e wade po la e al s howi t tt pl ntf i e il t s hr le .'I a 22. ng ha he ai if s ntted o uc ei f' d. t M lhn mad' m oto f r i e l ut r r le does no de onsr t t t he wil s f r l m s i n o nt roc o y ei f t m ta e ha l ufe ir pa a e hn m wiho pr re r bl r t ut ompt c t it r e i our n e v nton. Fis, snc he ha not ye exha t rt i e s t used 2 Muha d co ai t tofi il f ld t pr vi hi wih a r ceptf hi i or lc mma mpl ns ha tcas aie o o de m t e i or s nf ma ompli s ant wi i t b sn s d y , srq ie u d rtep o e u e.Thslc o arc i h snoberngo tej1 9 ea t n wo u ie s a s a e urd n e h r cd rs i a k f e ept a h ai n h 9 7 () anal i,howeve ,be us M uhammad a t t ther ei tmeyr po esand c d co i wih t r gua yss r ca e dmis ha ec ve i l es ns oul ntnue t he e lr gre ncepr s . iva oce s 3 The c rtalo notst tt c aitand a nde c ou s e ha he ompl n me d ompl nta ebot i onsse wih Ruls 1 a ai r h nc itnt t e 8 nd 20o teF d rl lso Ci l o e u e rg r igj i e o camsa dp ris Rue1 ()o teFe ea Rue f h e ea Rue f viPr c d r, e adn ond r f li n a t . l 8a f h d r l ls e ofCiiP o e ueo l alwsaplitf t ji et r( sid pe d n o a atmaiecams a ma ycamsa i vl r c d r ny lo anif o on i l n e n e t r s le t li , s n li st he a v ha a an ta o po igpay ' Rue2 o teFe ea Rue o CiiPrc d r alwstej i e o s v rl a t s s g is n p sn r ' l 0 fh d rl ls f vl o e ue lo h ond r f e ea p ri e o yi t camsao eo to t smeta a to o o c re c , rsre tee la c nanaq eto o fc o nl fhe li rs u fhe a rnscin r c urn e o eis h rot nd o ti u sin f a t r lw c mmo t alh d fn a t.S e6 Wrgh, le a Ka e F d rl r ciea dPr c d r j1 8 (de . a o n o 1te ee d ns e A i tMilr nd n , e ea P a tc n o e u e 5 3 3 d 1 9 )(oigta t e Rue 1 ()a 20 i tecamsaieo to dfee tta ato sa d no iv v al 9 8 n tn h t md r ls 8a nd ,f h li rs u f ifrn rnscin nd o t n ole l dee d nsj id rs ul n tb alwe ) Un e te erls ç plitf ma na mo eta o ed fn a ti a fn a t,on e ho d o e lo d . d r h s ue,& anif y me r h n n ee d n n a muli e cai lws tonl i t cli agai taldeenda s m's outoft s me i i ntor i de s a tpl l m a ui y f he ams ns 1 f nt o e he a ncde nci nt nd i vea c nvol omm o f c u orl lq sin. Gr n v. nni No.06n a t al ega ue to ' ee De ng, ' 3298,2009 U. Dit LEXI 1 S. s. S 5738,2009 W L48 4 7 a * (7 Ka . b. , 0 9 .Theep o e u a rlsa pl wihe u lfr et p os p io e c ss 4 5 , t 2 1. n Fe 26 2 0 ) s r cd rl ue p y t q a oc o r e rs n r ae . I d e , ljq iiga h rn ei p io e s t t t fdea r lsrg r n j id ro p risa dcamsp e e s n e d Rre urn d ee c n rs n r ui o he e rl ue e adig on e f ate n li rv nt s th sr of rs ( mulpecam, lped fn a t s ip o u es.' L.(u t Ge rev. mi 5 7F.d te ot mo as a t l li mut l ee d n) ut r d c ll' d q oi o a S t 0 3 i i ' . ng h, 6 5 6 7 (t Ci.2 0 ) I Muh mma i dsaife wih te rs l atrh h s e h use a mi srtv 0 , 0 7h r 0 7 . f a d s istsid t h eut fe e a x a td d nitaie s rme iso hsde a ca sfc to cams ds sa wi o tp eu ieo ti a t n la e hm 9e t liae e de n i it nd lsiiain li , imisl t u rj dc f hs ci e v s i e o ig t h o t t eis s H ei a s d,ho e r t e tr t ta ne cvi rght c pl nthe flsc ple wih Rul 18 hes s ue . s dvie w ve , o nsle ha ny w i l i s om ai ie om is t es a d20a d e n tmp o el onu rltdcamso p risi tesmelws i. n nd o s o i r p ryj i neae li r at n h a a ut e . 4 a ia e ad i sr tve r m e e ,he c nnots y t tt s r m e e wilno r s ti c r to val bl m nita i e di s n a ha he e e di s l t e ul n oreci n o t ev r is ssae i tecvi a to . S c nd h meey c mpli t a wih u ijmcie f h e y sue ttd n h i l ci n e o , e rl o ans h t t o t n t tv r le or rng non- r s tt esa r cl sfcai n pr ee ngs he ma l e we g and be ei f de i daiy ubsiut nd e asii to oc di , y os i ht ho e t r t pecfed r src i co to . The co t c nno fnd t t t s c er us d mde ms ii e titve ndii ns ur n t i ha he e onc ns co tmt i i nt i pa a ehn m worhy oft r quesed i e l ut y r le . Ac r ngl nsi e mm ne , ae r bl r t he e t nt roc or ei f co di y, t c u t l d n h smo inf rap ei n r ij ncin. An a p o raeo d rwil su t s he o r wil e y i to o r l ay nu to mi p r p it r e l is e hi da y. The Clr i die t d t s nd c pi of t s m e a l o ni n a a ompa ng ek s rce o e o es hi mor ndlm pi o nd cc nyi o de t pl ntf. r r o ai if ExrsR:T s t N d yo J n , 01 . r hi B a f u e 2 s Cli Unie Stt sDititJ lef t d a e src udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
