Egan v. Gick et al, No. 7:2015cv00077 - Document 40 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 8/4/2015. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OFFI E U. , DI COURT S C S SX AT 9tA?iKE, 0 .3 VA 1 r;.E9 iJ . At i 2 1 $ 25 I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR TH E W ESTER N D I STR I T O F W R G I I C N A ROANOKE DI SI N W O ED W AR D JAM ES E G AN , JULI (.' '4 r l C 'RK A - - ., t' . BV- CA SE N O .7: 15CV B0077 Pl ntf , ai if M EM ORANDUM OPI ON NI I N GI c K , CEVI CK, By: Gln E. nr d e Co a Chi fUnie St e Dit c Judge e t d at s srit De e f ndants. t) Edwa d J s Ega a Vig ri i a e pr e ng pr K ,fld t s ci lrg s aci n r nme n, r ila nm t oce di o e hi vi i ht to purua t 42U. C.j1 3,ale ngt taf me pr e utra hi s r s rde i dEga s nt o S. 98 lgi ha or r os c o nd s upe vio prve n oft rghtt a ce sa sa e c ur i M ar h 201 By opi on a or ren e e M ay 1 201 he i o c s t t o t n c 2. ni nd de t r d 3, 5, t c ts he our ummarl dimi s d Ega s cai as tm e ba r a l ga l f i o t r 28 iy s s e n' l ms i - red nd e ly rvol us mde U. C. j 1 5 b ( ) Eg n h s s b te rpe td moi n se n r i ttme t a S. 91 A()1 . a a u mitd e ae to s e kig ensae n nd r c i r to wlih mus be de e asl ccngm e i. e onsde ai n, lc t nid a li rt Ega frtague t thi j1 camsc no betmebar d be a e he i unde t n is r s ha s 983 li nn t i - re c us s r he dia lt ofi ionme ,s eVa.CodeAnn.j8. - a t co tdi nota ntag r an s biiy mprs nt e 012, nd he ur d ppoi uadi gt ltm f hi i t j 1 a ton. Tli apl n fisont f eoft a ia esaue . - ie or m n he 983 ci . l zs r me t al he ac he pplc bl ttts A pe s t r on mdera dia lt i e il d t a nt ntofa gua din g ltm onl i hei nn d s biiy s ntte o ppoi me r a d ie y f s me . a ap ryd fn n .S eVa Co eAn j8019 A) Eg ni t epan ifi t i j1 8 a to s a t ee da t e . d n. . - ( . a s h litf n hs 9 3 cin. Se ond,Ega ti t s c n res o how t thi s e ntmotons a a al i t sa e c t ha s ubs que i nd ppe s n he tt ours Egan v. Gick et al Doc. 40 t ld t sa u oflmia i . Thi a g e alo f l. Bec us Ega lne i M a c 201 ole he t t e i t tons s r um nt s ais a e n c w n rh 2 t tdee nt'agume shadr s td i dimis ofhi saeco tmoton,hi j 1 c us ha fnda s r nt eule n s sal s tt ur i s 983 a e o a to a c e a ta tme Na i v. ad n M d Ho eo Co r, 4F.d95 , 5 ( t Ci. f cin c nzd t h t i , sm W r e . . us f r.6 3 1 9 5 4h r 1 9 )(nb nc, n h st - e rfln p ro t e Va Co eAn .j8012 3 A)b g nt r n. 9 5 e a ) a d i wo y a iig eid md r . d n . - 4 4 e a o u Dockets.Justia.com Be a epli ifnee note us saeco trme e beor flngaj1 3 a ton,s ePas v. c us antf d xha t tt ur e dis f e ii 98 ci e tv Boad o Re e t o Saeo Fl.45 U. 4 6 5 2 ( 9 2 , h c u t i snor a o ta t e r f c n s f tt f a, 7 S. 9 , 0 1 8 ) t e o r fnd es n h t h nlm be ofa al a m o i f rr co i r ton t tEg c e t ptr ue i t sae co t l r ppe s nd tons o e nsde a i ha an hos o ls n he t t urs h da y efc o t nmnigo t lmiainp ro t e j8012 ( .Eg nd dn tfl hi a n fe t n he n f he i tto ei d md r . -43A) a i o ie s j 1 8 a t n a ans t ed fn nswihn t y a so tetme o a c u l Theeo e i wa 9 3 ci g i t h ee da t t i wo e r f h i f c r a. rf r , t s o p o el d s se a tmebard.l a y e n , a sj1 8 c mpan d e no saeacam r p ry imis d s i - re n n ve t Eg n' 9 3 o lit o s t tt li o wh c rle c n b g a td b ti c u t whih ha no j rs ito t o e t n t sae n ih eif a e rn e y h s o r, c s u id cin o v rm' he tt c u tsd s sa o d r Se Pllrv.M o r ,1 9 F.d 7 8 7 (t Ci.1 7 (mdngt a o r' imis l r e. e y e oe 2 3 2 , 31 4 h r 99 ) f i h t j ds ito frrv e o sae c u t u g n sle e cusv l wih s p do sae c u t a d u dcin o e iw f tt o r j d me t is x l i ey t u e r tt o rs n , ul maey wi t eUntdS ae S p e Co rl t tl, t h ie tts u rme u t. i h Be a e none ofEga sc r nts c us n' ure ubmisonssaesa gr und on whi h hei e il d t si t t ny o c s ntte o r i tt me oft scl e ca eorat r to oft dimi s lor r li m o i m us be de ed. ensa e nt hi os d s le ai n he s s a de , ls tons t ni An a oprae o de wile e t sda ppr i t r r l ntr hi y. The Cl r i diece t s nd c es of t s me o a lm opi on a a c e k s r t d o e opi hi m r nd l ni nd c ompa ng nyi o de t pl i if r r o antf. EN TER:Tli ls da ofAugus,201 y t 5. Cli fUnied St t Diti tJ e ze t aes src udg
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
