Egan v. Gick et al, No. 7:2015cv00077 - Document 32 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/15/2015. (slt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Egan v. Gick et al Doc. 32 CLERK' OFFI U % DI O l S CE SX $ A X LED V TRFI 6 A A I THE I NI N J TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI T O F W R G I I C N A R O AN O K E DI SI N VI O ED W AR D JA M ES EG AN , J 15 2 1 UN 25 QJ U Y; D . co CL ERK C A SE N O .7: V 00077 15C Pl nt f , ai i f V. M EM ORANDUM OPI ON M KEVI GI C K , N CK, By:Gln E. n a e Co r d Chi fUnie St e Dit i Judge e t d at s s rct De e f ndants. t) Edwa d J m e Ega a Vig ri i ae pr e ng pr K ,fl t s cvi rght a tbn r n s n, r ila nm t oce di o ed hi i l i s c i ptrua t 42U. C.j1 3,ale ngt taf rpr e utra hi s r s rde i dEg ls nt o S. 98 lgi ha onne os c o nd s upe vio prve an oft rghtt a e s a sae co t By o ni n a or r e e e M a c 31 201 t co t he i o cc s tt ur. pi o nd de nt r d r h , 5, he ur ds s e te a to wi u p eu iea trEg n fie t c mpy wih t c u tsc n iin l imis d h cin t t rj d c fe a ald o o l t he o r' o dto a ho flng o de . Ega moved t va t t sdim is a r i t t t c e,bas d o e de e of ii r r n o ca e hi s s al nd ensa e he as e n vi nc m al de a . By opi on and or r e e e M a 1 i l ys ni de ntr d y 3,201 t c ur gr nt d t moton t 5, he o t a e he i o r isae ( No.1 ) v c td t e Ma c 31d s sa o d r c nsd r d Eg n' cams a d en tt ECF 9 , a ae h rh imis l r e, o i ee a s li , n sl rl d s s e t e a tmeb re a d lg l fi lu t e 28U. C.j1 5 b ( ) l mmai imis d h m s i - ard n e al rvoo s md r y y S. 91 A( )1. Ega t s itd s ve aladdii nalmotons a1ofwli h mus be de ed. n hen ubm te e r to i ,1 lc t ni Ega ha s itd t f l wi motons G tce a m oto plrua t Rul 60, n s ubm te he olo ng i : d i nd no i n zs nt o e 5 ' r ieai g h s j1 3 cams ( etrtn i 98 li ECF No 6 ,t tc y ag i t the c mpl d wi t .2 ) i ie' r ung ha . No ' o i e t he h c n iin lfl o d r( No 2 ) t to t rc ej dg , b s d o t c u tssl r o dto a ii r e ECF . 7 ;û in o e us u e' a e n he o r' lmmay ng mo ' dimis lofhi camsofe rnsc fa ( No.28) a wela dimis l ofpro c e ; s sa s li xti i rud ECF , s l s s sas ir as s t tc a moto ptr ua t Rul 60, de ndi r nsa e e ton t gr md t thi cli t i e nd no in ls nt o e ' ma ng ei tt m n 5 he ot ha s a m c n o b tmebard, e a eh i si t b et p ls ehssaec ur c s ( No 2 ) a d n n t e i - re b c us e s tl ma l o t u i tt o t a e ECF . 9 ; n l r l to f r p ei n r ijmcin' al n te c u tt o d r t e d fn a t Go so t û in o r l ay nt to , sc g h o r o r e h ee d n s l tp he mo mi ' i t Dockets.Justia.com b o k g o a c s t t Vign ac u t b sae rp e e ttv s'( No.3 )(mp ssi l c a e f c e s o he r ii o rs y tt s e r sn aie ' ECF 0 e ha i n odgi ) nal. None of Ega s s isons pr de i o ma i de o ta i t t c ts n' ubm s i ovi s nf r ton m nsr tng hat he our' dim is lofhi cli sastme bar d wase r ousorpr e sa ot rgr md on whi h t s sa s am i - re rone es nt ny he ot c he ca e s d be r nsa e t t a tve doc t Ega a j sa e no vai r a on r qui t s houl ei t t d o he c i ke . n lo t t s ld e s e dng he c tt r us is l fom de i ng li pe ng m o i nsi t sca e. See Bel v.Le nt l our o ec e t ef r c di ls ndi to n hi s ue ve ha , 6 F.d 5 7,5 5 (t Ci.2 1 ( tn t weletbihe prn i l ta E u iilr ln s 40 3 6 7 4h r 01 ) noig he l-sa ls d icpe h t ç d ca ui g gl al am os ne r c tt t a va i bass f a bi or pa talt moton. 640 F. a 575 one l t ve onsiue ld i or as ri iy i ' ' 3d t (uoi g Lie v v.Untd Sae ,51 U. 5 ,5 5 ( 9 4 Fial,be a e Eg n h sn q tn tk ie tts 0 S. 40 5 1 9 $. n l y c us a a o lkelhood o s c s on t m e is of hi t ryi t i ey cl m a i t t de enda s i i f uc e s he rt s mde l ng, mtm l ai ga ns he f nt n me i t i a to heh sn td mo s tdt a itro u o yij n tv rle o a y l d i n d n h s cin, a o e n kae h t ne lc tr nu cie eif f n dn s war ne S eW itrv. t rl s u c sDee eComcl I .5 5U. 7 20( 0 8 ra td. e n e Nau a Re o re fns t i.nc, 5 S. , 2 0 :. Fort r as saed,t c ur wils ma iy de t m oto . An a o it or r he e ons t t he o t l um rl ny he i ns ppr pra e de wile e t sda Ega m a a a t c ur' nzi wihi tzry da t t Unie St t l ntr hi y. n y ppe l he o ts lng t n lit ys o he t d aes Co tof Appea sf r t Fo t Cic t i he s de ie a s tsi s pr dm a r quie e s ur l o he urh r ui, f o sr s nd aife oce l e r m nt t r he e. The Cl r i die t t s nd c e oft s me or ndlm o ni a a co pa ng e k s r ced o e opi s hi m a l pi on nd c m nyi or rt pl i if de o antf. ENTER:Th s I d yo J n , 2015. i Y a fue Cli fUnied St t Dit tJ le t aes sdc udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
