White v. Colvin, No. 7:2015cv00074 - Document 18 (W.D. Va. 2015)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/15/15. (eot)

Download PDF
CL S OFFI U.S. ST. URT ERK' CE DI K ATRM NOKE, VA FI LED 22T 15 2 1 25 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF V I N A CT RG ROANOKE DW I ON SI J A C. ULI D ucax DY; ' ' DE L E RI G . H I TA W TE, Ci lAc i No.7: 5CV000 vi ton 1 74 Pli if antf, M EM OR AN DUM O PI ON NI CA ROLY N W .COLV I , c i N A tng Com misone ofSocalSe u iy, si r i c rt By: Hon.Gln E. e Conr ad ChifUnie Stt DititJ e t d a es src udge De e nt f nda . Pli tf a n ifhassld t sa to c le ng t fna de ii n oft Com mi sone ofSocil e hi c in ha lngi he i l c so he si r a Se m'y de ngpli ifsc am f rs e e a s cliy i om ebe f unde t Soc a c i nyi antf l i o upplm nt l e trt nc t ne ks r he i l SecuiyAc,asn nde 42U. C.j1 # s Jlidito oft sc u'i purua t 42 t' t me d, t S. 381 . eq. trs cin hi ot ts s nt o 1 U. C. 1 8 ()3 , ih ic po ae j2 5 g o t So ilS c rt Ac, 2U. C. 40 () S. j 3 3 c () wh c n o rts 0 () f he ca e u iy t 4 S. j 5g . Asr lc e byt m e a a a pl nts itd byt pa tes t is snow be o et efe t d he mor nda nd r me ubm te he ri , he s ue f r he c u t r wh te t eCo s in r f a d cso i s p o tdb s b tn il v d n e o o r ae eh r ù mmiso e' m l e iin s u p re y u sa ta e i e c , r s' whe he t r i ' d ca e' o ne es iaer ma ngt c et t Co m iso rf f rhe t r he e s ' goo us 't c st t e ndi he as o he m s i ne or u t r c n ieain S e4 U. C. 4 5 g . o sd rto . e 2 S. j 0 ( ) Thepl n if Ria G. hie, sbor on Se e r1 1 aitf, t W t wa n pt mbe 2, 969. M s W hie e r ed aGED. . t nn Pl i ifha prorwo k e re easaho e pe .On Se e r 1 2011 M s W hieSl d antf s i r xpe i nc us kee r pt mbe 2, , . t e a a ia i f s e n pplc ton or uppl mentls t'y i o ebe t Shea lgedt ts be nmedia e a ecui nc m t neks. le ha he c s bld White v. Colvin Doc. 18 f a1f r o s tnta ganf le pl or 1 o ms f ubsa il i ' m oyme on J nua y 1 2001 d t bi a dio de ;pos u nt a r , , ue o polr s r r t tax tcsrs d s r e ; cdr fu h p re so ; a kij r c ng si he r fit e cu i rl i te s io d r a i el x; y e tn in b c nu y; o e t ma ve a t alr ; lonc l di t i hea t a l e;i t bl bo ls ome;snuspr e a de es i n ey. She asolc r f iur ni a e we yndr i obl ms; nd pr son/ nxit Dockets.Justia.com f ' ltrn ndedhe a i a in s ast r fec a a lged dia lt ons tdat ofAugus 22,2011 a e me r pplc to o o el t n le s biiy e e t . M s W hie no m ant nst ts ha r m ane dia e t t pr s nttm e. . t w i ai ha he s e i d s bl d o he e e i Pli tx sdam wasde e upon i ta c i r ton a r onsde aton. She t n ani i ni d niil onsde a i nd ec i r i he r uetda r evedad novohe rnga rviw be oea Ad ritai Law J eq se nd ec i ai nd e e f r n milsrtve udge.l a nn o ni da e Se e be 24,201 t La J pi on t d pt m r 3, he w udgea s dee m i d t tM s W hie i no lo t r ne ha . t s t diabld.TheLa J s e w udge f md t tpl i ifs f r fom s ve a s ve ei im e s i l ng ot ha antf ufe s r e r l e r mpar nt, ncudi b c p i sau po tiju rg t pp i ; e r ds a ewi hit r o c n e t h a t alr ; a k an, tt s s nty; ih hi an h a t ie s t so y f o g si e r fiu e h ve snuspr e s i t bl bowels nd om e acd r fux;de es i nnxit bipol rdior r a i oblm ; nia e y r ; i el pr son; e y; - a s de ; nd po ttal tcsr s d s r e .( 1 ) Be a s o te ei ar n s t çLa J d er ldt a s-rl i te s io d r TR 7 . c u e f h s mp ime t,h w u g ue h t ma M s W ht i d sbldf ra1 fh r s rlv n wo k.TR 26 .Ho v r t eLa J d e . ie s ia e o l o e pa t ee a t r ( ) we e, h w u g dee mi d t tpl ntf r t nss fcintfmctonalc pa iyf a lm ied r ngeofs de a y tr ne ha ai if eai ufi e L i a ct or i t a e nt r wo k.Th La J d ec rceie M s W ht ' rsd a f n to lc p ct a f lo : r e w u g haa trz d . ies e iu l u cina a a i s ol ws y Afe c r f lc i r ton oft e tr r c d,t t ri d fndst t tr a e u onsde a i he n ie e or he mde sgne i hat he cam a hast r i fmci lca ct t pe f m ar ngeofs de a y wo k li nt he esdual L tona pa iy o ror a e nt r r a d fn di 2 CFR 41 .6 ( Th cama t u db c p bl o sa dn / s ei e n 0 69 7 $. e li n wo l e a a e f tn ig ' wa li f 4 hotr i anor l8 hotrwor da sti f 6 hour i a nor 8 lcng or ls n ma l k y; itng or sn mal hol wor da lfi c ryi 1 poundsge nty a 20 pot occ sonaly; tr k y; itng/ a r ng 0 que l nd mds a i l o a i lypus ng/ lngwih t l cc sona l hi puli t he owere r m iis occ i l c i ng xte te ; asonaly lmbi r m psa sar , a i kne lng,c ouc ng,a so ng bu pr cl n nd t is balnc ng, ei r hi nd t opi t e uded fo rm ci bi l dde s r pe , s a f dsa c a i and s d a d c e r t d lm ng a r , o s or c fol nd r wlng; houl voi onc nta e e tr t vi a i ,wenes , z r ,a e r m ec dt mpe a u e .The xposle o br tons t s ha a ds nd xte ol e r t r s cama two l as rq iewokivovn o et t se j bi sr cin . li n u d lo e ur r n l ig p o wo tp o n tu to s ( 9 .Gi ns har sd l n cin l a ct , n a trc n i ei gplitc sa ea d TR1 ) ve uc e iua f n to a c pa i a d fe o sd rn an i g n y e a i aswela t si onyfom avoc tona e r, heLa J duc ton, l s e tm r a i l xpe tt w udgehel t tpl i ifr t i d ha antf e ans s t intf to lc pa iy f s ve a s c t s de a ywor r e e si i s g t a ufk e unci na a ct or e r l pe ik e nt r k ol s xitng n i nik nt nl e i t en to a e o o ( 27 .Ac o dngy t eLa J d eutmaeyc n l e l r n h ain l c n my. TR ) c r i l ,h w u g li tl o cud d mb 2 t tM s W hiei notdia e a t ts i note ild t s pplm e als cl y i m e ha . t s s bld, nd ha he s ntte o u e nt e tdt nco b n ft.S e2 C. R. 41 9 0 g . Th La J d eso n o wa a o tda t fn l e eis e 0 F. j 6.2 ( ) e w u g ' piin s d p e s he ia de ii n oft Comm iso rb t SocalSe t' yAdmi sr ton' Appe l Cot l Ha ng c so he s i ne y he i cui t nita i s a s mci. vi e use a1a ia e a nita i r m e es M s W hie ha no a a e t tzsc t xha t d 1 val bl dmi sr tve e di , . t s w ppe l d o li our. W hiepl i ifm a bedia e f c ran f msofe oy e , hec ucalf tzl l antf y s bl d or e ti or mpl m nt t r i ac t a de e mi ton i wheherpli ifwa dia ed f al f msofs t nta ganf le o e . t r na i s t antf s s bl or 1 or ubsa il i u mpl ym nt S e4 U. C. 1 2 () eeaef t ee n so p o fwhihmu tb c nsd rdi madng e 2 S. j 38 c a.Th r r ol lme t f r o c s e o i ee n l r s c a a ay i.The eee n sa esl rz da f lo :()o j cieme ia f csa u h n n l ss s lme t r l mmaie s olws 1 b e tv d c l a t nd ciia f i g ;2 t eo iinsa dc ncuso o te tn p y iin ; 3 s be tvee i nc lnc l md n s () h pn o n o l ins f raig h sca s ( ) u j ci vde e o p y ia mn ie tto o i ar n s a d s rb dt r u hacama t tsi n a d( ) f h sc l nf sains f mp ime t, s e cie h o g li n ' etmo y; n 4 s t cai ntsed a i voc tona hit y, e i ua s ls a a Vie v. nc 438 F. he l ma ' uc ton, a i l sor r sd l kil, nd ge. t k Fi h, 2d 1 5 ,1 5 - 0(t Ci. 9 ) Un e wo dv Riio f29 F.d8 0 8 ( t Ci. 9 2 . 1 7 1 9 6 4 h r 1 71 ; d r o . bc f, 8 2 5 , 51 4h r 1 6 ) W hiet is si t sca e a es m e tcl e t c ur i t bl t c l t tt l he s ue n hi s r o wha os , he o t s ma e o oncude ha he Comm iso rsf a dec son i s ppo td by s t tale de e. TheAdmils tveLa s i ne ' m l ii s u re ubsan i vi hc ri ka i w J udgef mdt ti a ton t he he r a mus ul ke ealpr e s M s W hie s fr fom ot ha n ddii o r a t nd c os l t oblm , . t ufe s ' r s ve als ve eps liti i ime s i l ng de es i a e y, - a dio de ,a e r e r ycla rc mpar nt, ncudi pr son, nxit bipolr s r r nd p s-ru tcsrs ds r e . ti a s si p an i sr sd l l to a c pa iy t eLa o tta mai te s io d rlYe,n s e sng litc e iua fmcin t a ct ,h w J udgei ntfe o y onewo k-ea e r src i wlih coul bef ry a s i e wih me a o de ii d nl r r lt d e titon zc d ail s ocatd t nt l r e to l y f n o al tto t wo kivovn o et t se j bi ku to s ( 1 ) moina d su din: i ain o r n lig n o wo tp o ns cin . TR 9 . mi l li r vi w oft e de er a e t pl ntf ps liti co to t La J n ls e e he vi nc elt d o ai irs yc larc ndii n, he w udgef mdt t ot ha j Undert goveni a nita i r ultons a s r i palme i c ace i d as o whi he r ng dmi srtve eg ai evee m . nt s har t' ze r r ne ch , sg iia t l t p ysc l rme tl blyt d b scwokatvt s Se 2 C. R. 41 .21 infcnl i s h ia o na a ii o o a i r ciii . e 0 F. j 69 . y mi t e 3 C M s W h t as e de esm ode a ed m c te wih r ga d t co e r ton, r it nc or . ie lo xpe nc rt i uli s t e r o nc ntai pe sse e, p c .( 1 ) Asn tdb t La J d e t i a s sme t sc nsse twi t efndn so a e TR 8. o e y he w u g ,h s se s n wa o itn t h i ig f h t saea e c p y hoo it whorviwe teme ia r c r i p an i sc s .( 2425 . he tt g n y s c l gss e e d h d c l e o d n litc a e TR - ) Howe r i f mul tnga h hei a q si f t voc to le r' c i r ton,t ve , n or ai ypot tc l ue ton qr he ai na xpe ts onsde a i he Law J udgedi noti l a lm iai nsi t nnsofc d nc ude ny i tto n e once ta i pe ssenc o pa e, n r ton, r it e, r c but ise da k dt e p r t c nsd ro yt a M s W ht ç h udr c i o et t -tpj b n ta s e he x e to o i e nl h t . ie G o l e eve n o wo se o s isr cin . ( 5 ) l r s ns t t h poh tc lq e t n,hev c to l x r i e tse n tu to s' TR 0 . n e po e o he y t eia u si t o aina e pe td ni d ' o svea j bswhihh beiv dta panifc ul b e pe tdt p rbr t o g h n tdt t e rl o c e le e h t litf o d e x ce o el m,h u h e o e ha a1o t ej bsweet r d cinwo k'wl c wo dn t emir gua b e k , n whihwo l l fh o r t o u to r ' z h ul o p r t e lr y a s a d c u d p i rql et eG mply e. .oberg theea t ewok sai n' ( 5 - 2 .TheLa J d e e tr h t o e . t ih t r t h r tto . TR 1 5 ) i e ' w ug r le ont t si o oft voc tona e r i dee mi ngt tM s W hier t i s f e ei d he e tm ny he ai l xpe tn tr ni ha . t e ans ufkint f nci c pact f s ve als cfcwo k r e e si i sgni ntnlm be i t nq i na u tonal à iy or e r pe ii r ol s xitng n i fca l r n he to l e o o ( 28 . c n my. TR ) I W ak rv. we , 8 P.d47 5 ( t Ci.1 8 ) teUntd Sae Co r o Ap e l n le Bo n 8 9 2 , 0 4h r 9 9 ,h ie tts u t f p as f t Fourh Cicui co me e asf l ws: or he t r t m nt d olo Thepu pos ofbrngi i avoc tona e r i t a ss t ALJi detr i ng r e i ng n a i l xpe t s o s it he n e m ni whe he t r i wor a ia ei t na i le onomy whih tlspa tc a t r he e s k val bl n he tona c c li riulr cai ntc n pe f r . I o de f ravoc tona e r' opi on t ber lva tor l ma a r o m n r r o a i l xpe ts ni o ee n hepf l i mus beba e upon ac i ai n ofal ot re de e i t r c d, l u ,t t sd onsderto 1 he vi nc n he e or a i mus bei r s et pr pe h hei a quesi whi h f il s toutal nd t t n e pons o o r ypot tc l tons c à ry e 1 o cama tsi ar n s ( i to so te ) f li n ' mp i t. ct in mitd . me a I t i t ntc e, he c ti s m pl una et c l t tt La J n he ns a as t our s i y bl o onc ude ha he w udge pr ry ac ot t d ope l c m e f pli tf m ode a elmia i i c nta i pe sse ,a pac i hi q si ng of or a n ifs r t i t tons n once r ton, r it nce nd e n s ue toni t voc tona e r.Thevoc tona e pe ts ciialy obs r e t tt wor r ese sone he ai l xpe t a i l x r pe fc l e v d ha he k ol nvii d 4 ' f pli tf woul r quiet e o et bea t wor sa i on as t i d bassa t or a n if d e r he mpl ye o t he k t ton usane i nd o r m an on t k.Asama trofco on s ns ,i woul s e t tr pe ii wor aci t wo d e i as te mm e e t d e m ha e ttve k tviy ul beafece by mode aelm ia i i c enta i pe sse ,a pac Tli prncpl was f td r t i t tons n onc r ton, r itnce nd e. ls i i e r c l r cog ze by t Unie St t sCo tofAppe l f t Fourh Cic ti M as i v. e enty e ni d he t d a e ur as or he t r ui n co Co vn 7 0F.d 6 2, 38( t Ci. 01 ) l i, 8 3 3 6 4h r 2 5 : I a ton,wea e wih ot rcic t t tan AI doesnota c n ddii gr e t he r uis ha J c ounttora f c am a ' lm iai nsi c e rto pe sse e, pa eby r titng t l i nts i t to n onc ntai n, r it nc and c esrc i he hypo he ialque to t smpl r utnet s ort kild wor 'W i c lv. t tc si n o i e, o i a ks ms le k. ns he Co ro S c S c, 31F.d 1 7 ,1 8 ( 1hCi. 01 )(onigt Thr , mm' f o . e .6 3 1 6 1 0 1 t r 2 1 i n he id S v nh, n Eih hCic is.AsMa cop it o tt ea l yt p ro m e e t a d g t rut) s i on s u ,h bit o e fr i smpl t s difr 9om t a lt t sa on t s Onl t lte lm iai n i e a ks fe s he biiy o ty a k. y he a tr i tto woul a ountf acli ntslmiai i c d cc or a ma ' i t ton n once r ton,pe sse e,o pa e. nta i r it nc r c l a 638. d. t Theis si t sca e a es wha cos be us t Admi sr tveLa J sue n hi s r ome t l e ca e he nita i w udge di not d a tmptt s lmepl i i sm ode a ei im e ti c nc nta i n, r it nce a pac unde te o ubsl antc r t mpar n n o e r to pe sse , nd e r abr d fndi ofi biiy t pe f r a hi ot rt n smpl t s ,a cr lm sa whi h t oa i ng na lt o r o m nyt ng he ha i e a ks icl t nce c he c t our Endsofen i ot rs i ls c u t c e a ac r lm sa ewhih waspr e i M as i t n he oc a e t iy as s nd icl tnc c es nt n c o. Ba e o sae e sgi n by M s W hie a t tm eofhe a i to f rbe ft , heLa s d n t tm nt ve . t t he i r pplcai n o ne is t w J eo e v a f l : udg bs r ed s olows W ihr ga d t c nc ntai n, r it nc orpa ,t ca ma ha m o r t t e r o o e r to pe sse e ci he li nt s de a e difc te . Thec am a as e t di c t wih ha i sr s o s hit yof fiuli s l i nt s red x uly t ndlng te s r , sor s c d li to a a tmpta me or pr e t tr nde he una e t uii a deai n nd te nd m y obl ms ha e r r bl o r c l pr vi aci . e a l e ous tons Howe r s a s s e s ge r l di rotf l w a ve , he lo t t d he ne aly d i olo r utne, he e or cha si r i lkey wotl no bot rhe ; t ts wa o i t r f e nge n outne i l ld t he r and ha he s a et w a c m ovi i e ie y,s t i a t nto f l s ke a w rte bl o t h es n ntr t us a n te i n, olow po n nd it n drcins a dc pa l o s mei sc mp ei ts ( iis4 a d 6 . ie to , n a be f o t me o lt aks Exhbt E n E) ng ( 1 1 .W liet c lt le st tt hi ce t t La J ea las atmptdt TR 8-9) ll he otr beive ha,o s rdi,he w udg t e t te e o a l et e de ei t r ofpl ntY sdek incesi co e r to pe sse e a pac , nayz he vi nc n e ms ai i i e i n nc ntai n, r itnc , nd e . t c r mus uli ae y c l t tt La J he ou t t tm tl oncude ha he w udge' e l i f l s t Si y bec us s vauaton el hor. mpl a e M s W liem a bea et m ant i a tnton f at hourmovi ,doesnotne es a ym e n . lt y bl o i an te i or wo e c s dl a t ts c n pe f m pr uci wor on a eihthourda fveda pe wee ba i .M or ove , ha he a ror od ton k n g y, y r k ss e r t La J he w udge' r ol i oft sc ii a i s di no tke i oac ot t e s es uton hi rtc l s ue d t a nt c mt he mphasspl c by i a ed t v c to a e pe t nt ei ra c o pesse c , c , ndsa igo ts i tej b he o ain l x r o h mpo tn e f ritn e pa e a tyn n a k n h o s e vii d f M s W hie.Nordoe t La J n sone or . t s he w udge' opi o pr des s ni n ovi ound r as f t f c e ons or he a t t tpl i ifsr i lfm c i lc pa t a pu t t voc tona e r,i ude nor l ha antf esdua l tona a ciy, s t o he a i l xpe t ncl d ea wor r lt d e o i na lmiai ,d piet La J ge' fndi ofs ve ei i nt ba ed k-e ae m to l i t tons es t he w ud s i ng e r mpa nne s s on de e so n e y, - p dior r andpos-r ma i sr s dior r whi h ,by pr s i n, nxit bipol. s de , r ttml tc te s s de , c dei ton,r s ti sgnik a lmia i i me a a lt t do bascw o k a tviis Se 20 tnii e ul n i t nt i t tons n nt l biiy o i r ci te . e C. R. 41 .21a . F. j 69 () I i wels tldta,n aj dc t acam f rs ca s c rt be t ,h t s l et h t i du iai li o o il e u iy neks t e e ng Adm i sr tveLa J nita i w udgemus gver a onsf rt r s uton ofc ii li s i t ca e. Se t i es o he e ol i rtca s ues n he s e Ra f r v Covn 7 4F.d2 8 2 5(t Ci. 01 ) Hie v. we , 7 F.d5 , 9( t Ci. d o d i l i, 3 3 8 , 9 4h r 2 3 ; n s Bo n 8 2 2 6 5 4h r 1 8 ) Ar odv. e rtr , 6 F. 25 , 9(t Ci.1 7 ) ec u t o ld st a t fn l 9 9 ; n l S cea y 5 7 2d 8 25 4h r 9 7 .Th o r c ncu e h the ia de ii n oft Comm iso rdoe no e an t dic e nc be we n t i par e sa c so he s i ne s t xpl i he s r pa y t e he m im nt nd lmiai nsf md byt La J i t to ot he w udget e s,a t c c a hy t tca quesi putby t La o xit nd he nli l po he i l ton he w J udget t voc tona e pe t Thec t oncudest tpl ntf sca e mus ber ma d f o he ai l x r. our c l ha ai if s t e nde or f rhe de l u t r veopme a co i ai n,c nsse wih t sopi o Se Ra or v.Col n, nt nd nsderto o it nt t hi ni n. e df d vi s aa 296. upr t On a a t t sc tpli tf a guest t fna de ii n oft Co misone ppe l o hi our, a n if r hat he i l c so he m s i r s dberves M s W hiepoi so t ta t tmeoft a nitai he rngonJ y houl e red. . t nt ut ha ihe i he dmi srtve ai ul 22, 3,s ha ar a unde go a o t pa di e l to by Dr Robe t St phe on,a 201 he d le dy r ne n rho e c vauai n . r B. e ns nd t tDr St phe on' r po twaspe i She as pr pos dt s ha . e ns s e r nd ng. lo o e o ubmi acons ttve t ula i ps hol ca e l ton fom Dr Pa l S. s ne r yc ogi l va ua i r . me a Te s a .TheAdmi sr tveLa J nita i w udgea e d t gr e o r c i a dc n i e t t c n uttv rpo t o ete b c mea albl.( 3 ) M s e eve n o sd r he wo o s l ie e rs nc h y e a v i e TR 3 . . a a W hiee nm al s bmit t r porst t Ad i sr tveLa J t ve ly u ted he e t o he m nitai w udge a t La J , nd he w udge r f r nc boh r porsi M sopi on.TheLaw J e e e ed t e t n ni udgede e mi d t gi bot r pp t l s r t r ne o ve h e rs es e we g be us t opi onsr nde e byt co ula swe es i t bei onsse wih i ht ca e he ni e r d he ns t nt r a d o nc it nt t o j cieciia sndn sa doh rme ia e i e eo r c r .( 2 ) be tv l c l ig n t e dc l v d nc f e o d TR 6 . n Pl i ifnow m ant i t tt r po t fo Dr S e ns n a Dr Te s a c e ry antf i ans ha he e rs r m . t phe o nd . s ne r l a l e t bls t ts i dia e f a 1f msofs tntalganf le oy e .Dr Stphe o sa ih ha he s s bl d or 1 or ubsa i i u mpl m nt . e ns n f l dt tM s W hiec dpe f r lg e wo k a tviy,butt ts woul ber quie t om ha . t oul ro m i ht r r ci t ha he d e rd o ee t he l gsdui t wor da i or rt co r e m ai he l re r m iis Ba e lva e r e t ng he k y n de o ntol de n r owe xte te . s d onhe r viw ofpl ntf sm e ca hit y,a welashe own c i c le l ton, . s nea re e ai if di l sor s l r lni a vaua i Dr Te s r da n s drc re t s v r mao d p e sv d s r e , e rlz dn xeyds r e, n pn c ig o e e u rn , e ee j r e r sie io d r g neaie n it io d r a d ni dior rwih a a s de t gor phobi Sheas e s d M s W hie' GAF a be we n 45 a 48. Dr Tes ne r a. s se . t s s t e nd 2 . s a ofe e t f l ng O nc i la s s me : f r d he olowi tona s e s nt M s W liei a et unde sml a f l smpl i t ci ns Ate in a . zt s bl o r t d nd olow i e nsm to . tnto nd c e to a ea uaef s tpe i buts c nnotm ant i f usf r onc nkai n r deq t or hor rods he n i an oc o mor t af w ho sa atme.Soc a fmc i lngi m a ke y i pa r d a s e han e ur t i i l L tozi s r dl m ie nd he i no a et wo k wih t publc o ge aong wih s r or orc wor r . s t bl o r t he i r tl t upe ds s o- ke s Sheha t e c a er gea tc i whih s ca be m eco ba i He s mpr dit bl a ta ks n c he n co m tve. r a lt t co wih a i r a e s r s i ve y poora ne sr s s m a l a biiy o pe t ny nc e s d t e s s r nd w tes or y e d 2 , Th go a assme to fn to ig, rGAF i usdt rpo theciiin sj ( e to-j s bets e lb l ses n f u cinn o , s e o e r t l ca uj n jt u jc' n pn w ove allve ofôm ci ng. A GAF s or bewe n 41 a 50 i i c tve ofs rous s m pt s ora s ro rl e l toni c e t e nd s ndia i ei y om ny e ius i r nti s ilocc tona, s hoolinci ng.Ame ianPs hiti Asocain, a osi a St tsial mpaime n oca, upai lor c fl toni rc yc arc s ito Dign tc nd aitc Ma u l f na Diod r 48(t e .e t e . 0 0 . n a o Me tl s res 4h d tx rv 2 0 ) t de ompens ton. a eofpa c,a e y a f a f l s i publcpl e ,s o c ai Bec us ni nxit nd e r une s n i ac s he i e c e t ha fe ntwor a e es i s i a et la he hom ea a l s xpe t d o ve r que k bs nc , f he s bl o e ve r t l. ( 7 0. TR 9 ) Thec t le st tt La J our bei ve ha he w udgeofe e ar a o bl a s s e oft r porsof f r d e s na e s es m nt he e t Dr Stphe on a Dr Tes ne r andt tt s sudi do note t bls t tpl n ifi dia ed . e ns nd . s a , ha he e t es sa ih ha aitf s s bl wihi t men ng oft Soc a Se udt Ac. Dr Stphe on di noto e ves ve e e ma a t n he ni he i l c y t . e ns d bs r e r de t tetmeo li e n n to .( 7 9 .Peha smo ei ra ty Dr S e he s nn tdt a h i f l x miain TR 7 ) r p r mpo tnl , . tp n o oe h t s M s W hiewa no e . t s t ngag ng i teame r gi e f rhe e m a ot rt n f t us ofa i n r t nt e m ns o r de , he ha or he e dl ei.( 7 7 .Dr Te s e rrpo tdta M s W hi wa n t e evn te t n f rhe irtc TR 7 ) . sn a e re h t . t s o r c i ig r ame t o r z e p y l arca de to a p o lmsa tetmeo t eciia e auain.( 7 0 .Th c u t s cl ti n moin l r be t h i f h llc l v l to TR 9 ) e o r i r a s not t ta t tme ofhi o t pa di e m i ton,Dr St phe on s c fc l not d t t lo es ha t he i s rho e c xn na i . e ns pe iialy e ha panifma ie tdG oe i e c o sg iia td prsin o n it . ( 7 9 .S ae litf nf se t v d n e f in fc n e e so r nxey' TR 7 ) ttd n ' s cnc l t co tbe ivest tt La J uc i ty, he ur le ha he w udgem i r as bl i e pr tt r po t ofDr ght e ona y ntr e he e rs . S e ns a Dr Te s a s a t i c t t tpli ifsph i a a e o i pr e s t phe on nd . s ne r o s o ndi a e ha antf ysc l nd m tonal oblm aes be t or a o beme ia c n r lh o g a p o raete t n me s e , n ta te r u j c t e s na l d c l o to tr u h p r p it rame t am s a d h t h e de edoesnots vi nc uppor t noto t tpl i ifse ma a e o i difc tesco d t he i n ha antf de nd m tonal fi uli ul r as bl bee pe t d t r ul i a c ntnuouspe i ofdi a lt ofno l s t n 1 m o hs e ona y x c e o es t n o i rod s biiy t e s ha 2 nt , asi rquiedfre tte n t s e ntlsc iyi omebe f Se 42U. C.j s e r o nilme t o upplme a e m t nc neks. e S. 1 2 ()3 ( .On ea an,h c u t eiv sta t ec ia a dds stv is ei M s 38 ca ()A) c g i t e o r b le e h t h dtc l n ipo i e su n . i W lie' c et m son t a s s m e tofhe vocai nala pt biiy. lt s as u he s e s n r to da a lt Fo t r as saed, heco tc l st r i çg c us 'f r m a o tlsc s r he e ons t t t ur onc ude he e s tood a e' or e nd f li a e t t Comm isone f f t rde l o he s i r or urhe veopme a c i r to l t Comm isone i t bl nt nd onsde ai n. f he s i r s ma e 8 t de i t sc e i pl ntf sf voron t ba i oft e si r or t Co mi so rwil o c de hi as n ai if a he ss he xitng ec d, he m s i ne l c onduc as e nt ladmi sr tvehe rng,a whih a c t uppl me a nitai ai t c ompr he i hy t tca quesi e nsve po he i l ton c n beputt aqua ii voc tona e r.Upon r ma bo h sde wilbea l d t pr s nt a o lfed a i l xpe t e nd, t i s l lowe o e e a dto a e d n ea dagu n .Ana p o raej d me ta do d rwil ee tr dt sd y. d iin l vie c n r me t p rp it u g n n r e lb ne e hi a TheClr i die t d t s ndce tfe c e oft sopi o t a 1c m s lofr co d. ek s r c e o e rii d opi s hi ni n o 1 ot e e r DATED : s Thi I& % d yo Oco e , 0 5 a f tb r 2 1 . 6 Chi fUnie Stt DititJ e t d a es src udge 9

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.