Casey v. Central Virginia Regional Jail et al, No. 7:2014cv00714 - Document 36 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 12/10/2015. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
6.é Apl VliV #:*' k. .i ONë#@@ * ' e ki T l ,& Fk IE; I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A ROANOKE DI SI W ON ADAM NI CHOLAS CASEY, Pl i if a nt f , V. CENTRAI VI NI REGI NAL , RGI A O JAI e a . L, t l, Dee f ndant . s IEC !' 2 5 ' 1 BYUL k I : L B D U Ci lAc i No.7: c 00714 vi ton 14-v- ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) M EM OR ANDUM OPT ON NI By: H on. ls n L.K i e Jac k o sr Seni Unie St e Dit i tJudge or t d at s s r c Adn N ihol sCa e aVigi ai aepr e ng pr K ,Gld aci lrght co pli m c a s y, r ni nm t oc edi o e vi i s m a nt Pls n t 4 U. C. 1 3.Plitf n me a d fn a t:h Ceta VignaRe in lJt t uat o 2 S. j 98 anif n s s ee d nste nrl rii go a al r CJ i' ; o me J i Su rn e d n Fly Ayo ;s dc l fc r' t he Un no al) fr r al peitn e t o d lr d ia Of es' s r k wn ' Me ; ot Ofk e s' a Or ng Count Thi m a tri pr e l bef r meum n Supernt nde Ayl ' t r '; nd a e y. s te s es nty o e i e nt or s moton t dim isa Pli i smotonst n e t c i o s s nd antY i o m nd he ompl i . Afe r vi wi t r c d, ant tr e e ng he e or I j a i pa tand de i pa themotonst a e gr ntSupe e ntAyl r sm oto t r nt n r ny n r t i o m nd, a dnt nde o' in o dim is a srket c efom t ac i doc t s s , nd ' i he as r he tve ke . t 1 . A. Plitf arv da teJio Fe rlr 2 , 01 , n tl a i a ezls ta V h d anif rie th al n b t y 2 2 3 a d od n ntk ire h t a a t ij e hsb c i ac ra cd n a u ay a e rir P an ife pli dG eehes ug t nurd i a k n a c ie t bo t e r a l . litf x ane ç r o h e wh te t n fo ( l co sa (l s ias' n tera o swh c ranme iainsh dbe n rame t r m d o tr nd h o ptl'a d h e s n y e ti dc to a e pr s rbedt li ,butt nur edi no t lPl ntf e c i o lm he s d t el ai ifhow t ob a npan m e c tons o t i i di a i . Casey v. Central Virginia Regional Jail et al Pli tf i r t e wee a trli a rva a uthow t obt n pa nm e c tonsa a n if nquied hr e ks fe zs ri l bo o ai i di a i nd Doc. 36 mus l r l r . St f e a ne t tt J i' docorha t e ua ePli ifbef ehecoul c e eaxe s a f xpli d ha he als t d o val t antf or d r c i m e cai .Afe Ii da ofnothea i a hi elefom m e c lsa f Pli if e e ve di tons tr lne ys rng nyt ng s r di a t f, antf fl d gre nc bec us hew a no r cevi me c c r t te thi ba k pai St f ie iva es a e s t e i ng di al a e o r a s c n. a f Dockets.Justia.com rs e ponde notng t tPli ifneve tl d ar q s f a a nt e wih t docor d, i ha antf r ie e pe t or n ppoi m nt t he t . M e c lsaf s he e li t s et doc o onc Pl i ifs it t r ue to M g c 25, di a t f c dul d lm o ù he t r e antf ubm ted he eq s n r h 201 3. Two da lt ro M a c 27,201 Pl ntf ha li a nt e wih t doc or ys ae n r h 3, ai if d zs ppoi m nt t he t . Plitf e pan dh sme ia hit r ,n ldn h sb c iju e a dp i h w hsb c ij r anif x li e i d c l so y icu ig i a k n ti s n an, o i a k nu y m a i difc tt ge i a o ofhi t bt kas i nm e ,a t thehee d s ehi t de t fi ul o t n nd ut s op- m sg nt nd ha de om t ng o hep wih a ons tofn ey.Thedoc ort d Pl i ifhewoul r c i Nur on,Na oxi l t n e nxit t ol antf d e eve ot pr n, Flxe a l a El vi t te tli ba k, i a n ey. e r l, nd a l o r a ls è pan, nd nxi t Atpilca lt ne da on M a c 28,201 Pl n ifwasgi n onl Nur o and Elvi. l l he xt y rh 3, aitf ve y ot n a l Pl i iffl d agde ncea utt m isng pr c i i ns a sà fs i t doc o pr s rbed antf ie va bo he s i es rpto , nd t f ad he t r e c i one dos ofElvi a ni hta t e dos ofNe otn dtrng t da e a l t g nd hr e es ur i li he y. Plitf twi ap sca ' a ssa t anifme t hy iin s sitn CPA' o Ap i4, 01 , n d ma d d h ' n rl 2 3 a d e n e ) pr c i i f Na oxi a Flxe a la abo t es rptons or pr n nd e r l nd tom bunk a sgnme . ThePA gr nt d s i nt a e Pl ntf sr s f t t pr c i i nsbutwoul notco i rmodiyi Pli if sblnk ai if eque t or he wo es rpto d nsde f ng antf l as i e .Pl ntf fl gre nc r ue tng abotom bunk orat bunk wih al dde , sgnm nt ai if ied iva es eq si t op t a r but saf e ai d t tt m e ca de rm e ha nota ove abotom- mk à sg e andt t t f xpl ne ha he di l pa t nt d ppr d t bl s i nm nt ha t J i di nothavebunkswih ldde s Pl ntf alo fl d gre he al d t a r . ai if s ie ivanc a es boutha ng t pa vi ö y c yment f me c a nt e sa te t nt . opa s or di al ppoi m nt nd r a me s Pl i iff t rc antf urhe ompl i t tm os ofhi f a t J i wa awa i bl be a ei ans ha t s ood t he a l s l ys nedi e c us t wasdre ou by t wn mi ta .Pl ntf ompl i d t saf boutt f i d t he r ng r ys ai ifc ane o t fa t he ood,a afe t nd tr he . wa mi tayswe etuned do Pl i ifwa ups tbe us hebei ve t r wm als t t r ng r r tl wn, antf s e ca e le d he e s ' k ha i ba t i c d ha gr cera oul ve own i t f n he ood. Pl ntf as c ai if lo ompli d t ther c i d r l rmik a ne ha e e ve egu a l i t ad ofçvin i D m ik. nse i tm n l' ' 2 Pl i ifal gest tSupe i e antf le ha rntndentAyl wa r s or s e ponsbl ,a t J i' c i e s he a ls omm a ng ndi K . ofi e f t tani s r son, nd c fc r or he r i ng, upe vii a onduc ofJ lsa f He s ksda a sf al ge t ai t f. ee m ge or le d vi a i oft Ei h a Fouree h Amendme sa va i sa el ws oltons he ght nd t nt nt nd rous t t a . B. I adocl e a tc d t t c n lm nt ta he o he ompl i ,Pli iff t ral gest tofi e s team e ant antf urhe le ha fc r ' r t nt ofhi wasdir s tul Pl i ife a nst thewaswor ng outa doi pus upsi hi m se pecf . antf xpli ha ki nd ng h- n s c l o Ap i2 , 1 , e hi ba kt n o ta dsa tdlcdn u o lm ( 'c u ig el n rl 9 20 3 wh n s c û t u n tre o l g p n 1 , ' a sn we i ) ç x rmep i .' Pli t fc mp an dt Ofie Dos n, og vePlitf ame ia r q e t t te anl ' ani o lie o fc r to wh a an if d c l e u s e j f f r a of e e t dei ri t m e da saf rgh a y.Pl i ifwr t on t f o m nd f r d o lve t o di l t f i t wa antf o e he onn,ç y bac çM k i lc n u d et t emu ces a msa ev r itns (iq In e me ia atnin AS 1 s o kig p u o h s l p s r ey ne e sc . e d d c l te to AP. as c nn tst(n q. . a n tg tu o d wn o fmybmkb c u eIh veatpbmk. lo n o i a d . c n o e p r o f l eas a o l ' ' Pli ifga Ofi e Doton t f m ,a a s etme lt rt tda Ofi rDo s n t d antf ve fc r s he or nd t om i a e ha y, fce t o ol Pl i ifheco d m e tm e c lsa fdurngpilc l f hour lt r antf ul e di a t f i l a l our s ae. M e ca saf a s s Pl i ifdurngpilcala de e ne Pl ntf c d wai lntl di l t f s es ed antf i l l nd t nni d ai if oul tl i t ne da t m e twih t docor Pl ntf r f s d t r tln t hi c l,a s c iy sa f he xt y o e t he t . ai if e u e o e lr o s el nd e urt tf e c td hi t as gr ton c l s ore m o e ega i el. Pli ifc pl i t ts c iy sa fwoul nota sgn Pl i ift abotom bl on t antf om ans ha e urt t f d si antf o t mk he omdfo ro t J i, ov t sa dn me ia safsr f s l oo d rab to b mkpa sa t lo f he aln t h tn ig d c l tf eu a t r e o tm l s s me c l V ce s r Cons que l Pl ntf i upstt tscliysafma Pli ifwakup dialy s ay. e nty, ai if s e ha y trt tf de antf l a down sa r , i b i o a outofat bunk,a di notàlow hi e e i prvieg , nd t is clm nt nd op nd d l m xc ptonal i l es lkenotusng s cziy r sr i sdtrng tans r orwe rng s i c o hi duet hi bac i i e trt e tant ti r po t a i pecsc l t ng, o s k pa n. i 3 Dt ng a es re m o fom a uppe l ve oft J lt al rl l Pl ntf ui n co td ve r n r e l he ai o owe eve , ai if e le ed sg fca ba k pai a l i on t too a t botom ofa s tofsar .Ofi r xpei nc i nii nt c n nd a d he l r t he t e t is fce Doton had awhe l ha rbr s e c i oughtt Pl i if r quese m e ca as itnc f rPl i if a ha o antf , e t d di l s sa e o antf, nd d i nd Pli tf br a n if oughtl t med c de rmen .Pl n ifr c i d pr c i i f randpan a o he i al pa t t aitf e e ve es rptons o m us l r l r . c e e axe s Durng a he i t nc Li u e tAke sbr i not r nsa e, e t nan r oughtPl i ifawhe c ra t d antf elhai nd ol ofke st tPl i ifhadt bet ke t hi s gr ga i celi t ad oft t cas ii a i t r ha antf o a n o s e e ton l nse o he l sfc ton ofk e ' ofi e.Be or Pl i ifwa f l s t d i t whe c i,Lt Ake sbe n pus nghi t r s fc f e antf s uly eae n he elhar . r ga hi m a t whe l hardown t hal.Pl i ifbe n yeli ve y l udl f t cas ii a i nd he ec i he l antf ga lng r o y or he l sfc ton ofi e t hep hi a be n t çsr i e o 'M sbod i t whee c i. I r s ns t fc r o l m nd ga o ttaght n ut' y n he l har n e po e o Plitf s d nmo mè ta dy l n , . e sp le b c o Plitf jl u twhc anifs ud e ve n n el g LtAk r uld a k n anifs l i, ih i mps c o fpl ntf br a hi t o as c ' Pl i ife ai edt Lt Ake st thi s n ut f ai ifs e t ng l r e ond. antf xcl m f ' o . r ha s udde mo e n wa fo amusl c n , ndLtAk r rla e Plitf j mps i.W h nt e v me t s r m ce r mp a . es ee s d anifs u ut e h c a st a i ofà e as d Pli ifwha wa wr wih hi , .Ake si e e and s d, l s ik ton tc r ke a ntf t s ong t m Lt r nt nupt d ai ç t ng, i sne. The cas i a i ofi e t n i t ctd t es ri ofi e st put s hi he s No ' ' l sfc ton fc r he nsnz e he cp tng fc r o Pli ifi ag ot foorcel Pli ifwasta f r e outoft J i t ne da antf n ' mdr l. antf r nse r d he a l he xt y. II. Pli ifsfr tm oto t a e s e t dim isOr ngeCol y fom t l ws ta t antf is i n o m nd e ks o s s a mt ' he a ui nd o r r nn ede enda ç e c lOfi e s' ç e m f nt ç di a fc r 'as ç M unknown M e ca Ofi e s' Pl ntf s co di l fc r .' ai ifs e nd mo int a n s e st j i s v rld fn a t: n kDy r wh rp a e d fn a tAyo a to o me d e k o o n e ea ee d ns Frn e, o e lc d ee d n lr s Supe e nti J 2015;J i o fc r Ca an Ryde a Ofi rDods n;a t Ce r l dnt nde n une al fi e s pt i r nd fce o nd he nta Vign aRe ina J i Au h rt Cç to i ' .Plitf d e n t l g n w fcsa o the e r ii go l al t o iy Auh rt ' an if o s o al e e a t b u t s y) e pr e de e nt . opos d f nda s 4 Fe e a Ru eo Cii Pr c d r 1 () 1 p r t ap ryt n n isp e dngo c a a d r l l f v l o e u e 5 a( ) emis a t o me d t la i n e s m a trofc s wihi 21da ofs r i t pl adi orG ft pl a ng i onet whi h a te our e t n ys e v ng he e ng t he e di s i o c r s i pladi i r r d, daysafe s r c ofar ponsvepl ad ng o 21da a tr e ponsve e ng s equie 21 tr e vie es i e i r ys fe sr iùo amo int e Rul 1 ( ) () o ( whih ve i e rir' I ap rys e st a n e vc f to md r e 2 b ,e , r 9, c e r s a l . f a t e k o me d e' ispl di i a lot rca es i m a onl do s wih t c tsl a ort o t ea hgs n l he s , t y y o t he our' e ve he pposngpa t s i ry' wrte c n e t1A c u t h udfe l gvela ewh nj sies r q ie a e ts mer m o itn o s n . o r s o l r ey i e v e u tc o e ur s bsn o e s n i uc a t ç h s mduedely, d f ih ordiaor m otveon t pa toft mova ,r peaed f iur t s a ba at lt y i he r he nt e t al e o cled t e ce b a n me t p e iusy al we u uep eu iet t o p sn p ryby t ekin is y me d n s rv o l lo d, nd rj dc o he p o ig a t r vit e ofal wml e oft n ndm e o f tlt oft n e ru lo c he me nt r u iiy he m ndme .... Fom a v.Da s 371 nt ' ' n vi, U. 1 , 8 ( 9 2 (iigFe . Ci P. 5a (). S. 78 1 2 1 6 ) ctn d R. v. 1 ( )2 ) Th c u t tas c nsd rtemo es e i j i d rp o iinso Ru e 1 ()a d e o r mus lo o ie h r p cl o n e r vso f ls 9 a n k 2 ()whe ap an ifflsamoint n n ta s e st j i a d to a dee d n s Hi o v 0a n litf ie to o me d h t e k o on d ii n l fn a t. ns n . No e t n. C.I c, 9F.d 6 1 6 8(t Ci. 01.Thep o o e d f n a t mus ha e m s Fi S. . n .23 3 1 , 1 4 h r 20 ) rp sd ee d ns t v adghtt r le ms e td agans t m ,ç rsng o oft s ta a ton,oc u r nc ,ors de o e if s re i t he s ii ut he nme r ns c i a c re e e s o ta s cinso o c re c s,'a t ecamsmu ts r s meS u si no 1w o f c f rn a to r c u rn e lq' nd h li s hae o i e to f a r a t q c mmo t'a1d fn a t.Fe . Ci P. 0 a () o n o' l ee d ns d R. v. 2 ()2 . Thefr tm oton t a nd i g a ed i pa ta t dim isng Or ngeCount fom t is i o me s r nt n r s o s s i a y r he s t butt m o i nst n nd a eot r s de e asf tl W he he adef nda i na ui, he to o me r he wie nid uie. t r e nt s med R e c lOfi r 'orl M di a fce s' t unkno M e c lofi e s' sofno c e nce Cole tve wn di a . fc r 'i ons que . l c i de e nt ,lkede e nt S e c Ofke s'a Eot rUnknown Ofi r 'a e no pe mitd f nda s i f nda s i dial f r ' nd ç he M fce s' r t r te i a a to va4 U.. j1 3.S e eg, r u o v M o z n No 19 c 6 1 ,1 91U.. n n cin i 2 SC. 98 e . ..Fec s n . r a , . :0 v0 3 8 9 S Dit LEXI 8 9 , t* - ,1 91W L 1 5 5 , t*1( D. Y. u e2 ,1 91 (o cu igta a s. S 2 5 a 24 9 1 7 9 a S. N. J n 0 9 ) c n l dn h t 1No dee nthasc e ed. fnda ons nt 5 R . g o p o p ro ne,i G dc l tf, i n t ç es n'o p r os so j 1 8 ) Alo r u f es n l l me ia sa f's o a ç ro 'f r u p e f 9 3 . s , ke ' p Pli tf hasbçe r l a edf o i r e ai n, wa no i a ce a e a t J i durngDye ' a n if n e e s ' m nca c r to he s t nc r r t d t he a l i r rs tr a Supe i e nt a t r i no e c ai t tPli tf wilc mi ac i orvi a ea em s rnt nde , nd he e s xpe t ton ha a n if l om t rme olt t r ofs r ie r l s t wa r nthi r i a c r ton a t J lunderDyerss r son. em upe v s d eea e o r a s e-nc r e a i t hç ai ' upe vii S e eg, A. Lv ns 4 U. 9 ,1 1 1 ( 9 3 .Th r fr ,heei n b sst j i Dy ra e . ..L. v. o , 61 S. 5 1 - 2 1 8 ) ee o e t r s o a i o on e s adef nda i e t ra ofk i ori vi lc pa iy. e nt n ihe n t al ndi dua a ct Alh u h Pli t fse la et j i teAuho i a an w à fn a t h f ist alg t o g ani e ks e v o on h t rt s e ee d n , e al o le e f y a f c sag ns t spr e e iy.Eve i a c am ofm t ci lla iiy co d bet rtr d ny a t ai t hi opos d ntt n f li mi pa ib lt ul o tle . fom Pl i ifsflngs hef l t de onsr t a c us f r le . SeeBd.oft Cn v. r antf ii , ais o m ta e ny a e or e if he t Co r v. o 5 U. 2 7, 03( 9 7 (e u i t i s j 1 8 la iiyo a mm's Br wn, 20 S. 9 4 1 9 ) r f sng o mpo e 9 3 iblt n mu ii l yt e ate r o rs o d a s p ro ) M o lv. p' o So . r s, 3 U.. ncpai md r h o y f e p n e t u eir; nel De t f c Se v .4 6 S t 6 8 6 4 ( 9 8 ( e n mu iia j 1 8 la ii ) Plitf c n o rl o rn s c lto 5 , 9 1 7 ) d fnig ncp l 9 3 iblt . anif n n t ey n n k pe u ain, y l be s a c l i t sa ea aci na ec am . See e. , lAt.Cor v.Twombl 550 a l, nd oncusons o tt n to bl l i . :.Bel l p. v, U.. 4 , 5 ( 0 7 . S5455 20) Plitf n nd n st j i Ox c r Ry e a dDo o aeas f tl.Plitf anips me me t o on es d r n ds n r lo uie an if c ompl i t tCa an Rydert dhi he c d no ge abo t ans ha pt i ol m oul t t tom bunk a sgnme be us none si nt ca e we ea lbl a be aus hewr et f l ng r pons t Pl i ifsgre r vaia e nd c e ot he olowi es e o antf ivanc e: l a e m egs a e a o d a or ng t t Re omm e d Dit r nm t l r ppr ve cc di o he c nde ea y Alo n e ( lwa c s RDA)f rmae a e 2 -5 y a sod Th imaeme lta s o ls g s 5 0 e r l . e n t a T y aetk n o fo t h ae ( e t eei ah tme l co e f o c r b a r a e f f he e td wh n h r s o a) ls d o d a t y n i t we rng gl nma e a i oves a a hai ne .I i t n diecl ha d t you t nd r t t s he r ty nde o he imae Do (i)t t h g von o i mae ,i i i o sbl a d n t n t. sc o he ih lme f n t s t s mp si e n o e ctd t ha you a ta sr i f o t s r i lne i t kic n. As xpe e o nd r y taght r m he e v ng i n he t he f r yo mus l s m,o l o ie m e ca sa fc o ur c e pas tr nst di l t f nnno m i e pr c i i nsi t t es rpto f t y a e nee d. The e or i i ne s a y f you t r ques t s a Doc or he r de r f e, t s ce s r or o e t o ee t orPhysc a As it nton a i t r ques f m . Ha yo r ue t d t be ii ns ssn n nma e e t or ve u eq se o j n? The e a e a s esa ihed c ie i f i t s t t r ques a boto ee r r lo t bls rt ra or nma e ha e t tm bt The Doc or or Physc a As it nt wil r vi w your ne ds f r t s mk. t ii ns ssa l e e e o hi 6 r ue ta s Ha you r ue t d on a i ae r que tf m t be e l t eq s lo, ve eq se n nm t e s or o va uaed? Asf t rde ofolri ae ta por ve c e notbei t yo lli orup or he i z nm t r ns t hil s ng o ur icng t your sanda d,o l ve ces a e s r ce and i pece on a r gu a bass o t r tr hi l r e vi d ns t d e lr i. Ve c e r pais a e ma a ne hi l e r r de s eded. t Ofi r a i ae s f t beng a wih fce nd nm t a e y i prort I cosng,Iwa t ad s you l tt ear ce t n i onveze s i iy. n l i nt o vie ha her e rai nc zi nce t be e c e a a i r er t i i dua . Alo,t Ulie St t M a s l o xpe t d s n nca c aed nd vi l s he lt d aes r ha Se vie c r c onduc s a ye ry i pe i o our f iiy a a ovesotr f iiy t a l ns cton f ac lt nd ppr l ac lt t bei c o n ompla oft i r uie e st hous t i i t s ince her eq r m nt o e her nma e . Pl i iff ist s c f ac am a ns Ca an Ryde ,a no f r lcai upon whi r le antf a l o pe iy l i gai t pt i r nd ede a l m ch ei f m a be gr nt i e de fom Ca an Ryde ' alege sa e nt . See e. ,De av. y, y a ed s vi nt r pt i r s l d t t me s . g. paol Ra No. 1 c 0 3 , 3U. Dit LEXI 1 71 2 * 3 2 3W L 4 51 3 , t* ( . Va J y 7:2 v 01 9 201 S. s. S 1 8 , 2 , 01 4 2 6 a 8 W D. . ul 2 , 01 )(W s peirsa trt -a td n a o ag iva c f lsfrs o t etb ihig j1 8 2 2 3 $ u ro ' fe-hefc e il f re n e al a h r of sa ls n 9 3 la l y-) ibit ' . i ' Asf Ofke Dods Pl i ifas d Ofke Dods n f rm e c la ssa e o Aprl or f r on, antf ke f r o o di a s it nc n i 29,201 be aus hi ba mus l ssa t t c nmp whiewo ki outi hi c l. Of e 3, c e s ck c e t red o r l r ng n s e l fc r Dods ga Pl i ifar ques f on ve antf e t onu, c Pli ifc whih a ntf ompl t a ga ba k t Ofi e eed nd ve c o fc r N Do o Thef r r a ,t yb c i lc n u d et temu ces a msa ev r i tn e(iq ds n. om e d ç a k s o kig p u o h s l p s r ey ne s sc . M Ine d m e ca a tnton ASAP. la s c e di l te i lo nnnotst Furhe ,Ic nno ge up ordown of my bunk i. t r n t t f be a e Iha at bunk. Durng a he i e a ton, t e Doton ha awheec i c us ve op ' ' i not r nt r c i Ofk r s d lhar br ug t Pl ntf s hedi no ha t wak i pan and ha Pli ifdei r d t t m e ca o ht o ai if o d t ve o l n i d a ntf lve e o he di l de me f te m e . pm nt or r at nt N o r i t co pl ntd Pl i ife an how Ofk e Dods kne ofor whe e n he m ai oes antf xpl i l r on w r c e sy dir gar d a s t nta rs ofha m duet Pli ifsba k s m s See eg.Pa rs e kls l s e de ubsa i l ik r o antf c pas . . . , rih e r lLe v. e ea d 3 2F.d2 4 3 3( t oi. 0 4 ; i ir Be r , 9 F. 8 8 8 x e. e Clv ln , 7 3 9 , 0 4h r 2 0 ) M l e v. o n 8 6 2d 4 , 51 t 5 ( t Ci.1 9 ) Ev n i af u - o rd lyframe c l vau to c u db at u e t 2 4h r 9 0 . e f o rh u ea o dia e lain o l e tdb td o Ofk e Dods on Aprl29,201 Pli iff l t esa ih a r s tng s bsa i lha m. Se . t r on i 3, antf ais o t bls ny e uli u t nta r e eg, e bv. miulh 2 F. p' 1 9 1 6(t Ci 20 8 .Plitf as fist d s rb ..W b Hn d la , 81 Ap x 5 , 6 4h r 0 ) an if lo al o e cie as dousm e c lne be a et PA whoe l t Pl i ifon Aprl29, 3, f re a e di a ed c us he vauaed antf i 201 de e r d ny te t e a f rhere ua i untlt ne d Durngt s cond e s o adif r nt r am nt nd u t val ton i he xt ay. i he e piode n fe e da Pl i ifcola ed a t botom oft sa r , nd Ofi e Dods n ha awheec i br y, antf lps t he t he tij a fc r o d lhar ought t Pli ifs Pli tf c d ge t t medialde rm e tf te t e wihouthavi t wa k o antf o a n if oul t o he c pa t n or r am nt t ng o l i pan.Ac di y,t n pd e si vi Ofk e sRyde a Dods a ede e asf tl n i cor ngl he me m nt nvol ng l r r nd on r ni d uie. 11 1. 1mus dim isa a ton orcli fl d by a i a ei Idee mi t tt a ton o cai t s s n ci am ie n nm t f t r ne ha he ci r l m i fioo so fist saeacam o whc rle ma b ga td.S e2 U. C. j1 1 ()2 , s rv lu r al o tt li n ih eif # e Tne e 8 S. j 9 5e() 1 5 b () 4 U. C. 1 9 ec .Th Ertsa d r i ld scamsba e u o ç n 91 A()1 ; 2 S. j 9 7 () ' e s tn ad ncu e li sd p n t a i s a y m e il sl alt ol 'çcai sofi rnge ndiput bl rtes eg he y 'tl m nfi mentofal gali e es whih cea l e nt r t c l ry doe no e s,' cli wher t Sact c e to a ece ryba ee s' Netkev. s t xit'or ams e he G tz ontnins r lal s ls.' iz f al W ila , 9 U. 31 , 27( 9 9 .Th s c ndsa d r i t efmiirsa d r f ramoint lims 4 0 S. 9 3 1 8 ) e e o tn ad s h n la tn ad o to o ds s t e Fe e a Rul o Ci l o e u e1 ( )6 , c e tn ap an ifsfc lalg to s imis md r d r l e f viPr c d r 2 b ( ) a c p ig litf a ma le ai n a t e.A c s nz ompli nee E s ta pl n sa e toft cài s a nt ds 1 hor nd ai t t men a he l m howi t tt pl de i ng ha he ea r s e tte t r l f a ds fkin ila ma alg to . .oriearg t orle a o te n i d o ei ' n u t e t dl c l le ains . t as ih t eif b ve h l e l s c ltvelv l..' BelAt. m . Two l, 5 U. 5 4, 5 ( 0 7 (nena q o ain pe uai e e . . l lCo v. mby 5 0 S. 4 5 5 2 0 ) itr l u tto ' makso te ) A plitY sb ssf rr le Se u rsmo et a lb l a c n l i n . .' r mitd . ani a i o eif t q ie r h n a es nd o cuso s . . r ' I .Th r fr , p an ifmu tG l g fcss fce tt saea1 h ee n so (h )cam. d e eo e a litf s ç l e a t ufiin o tt 1t e lme t f t e li ' ae ' Ba sv. I Du n d Ne u s& Co.3 4F.d7 , 6 ( t Ci. 0 3 . s E.. po t e mo r , 2 3 61 7 5 4h r 2 0 )2 2Dee mi ngwhehe ac tr ni t r ompli saesaplusbl cam f r i i 1 c ex -pe t t s t tr uies ant tt a i e li or elef s ç ont ts cik ak ha eq r a terviwi c u toda o isudca e p re c a dc mmo sn e' As co v.q a. 5 U.. 6 , 7 -9 h e e ng o r t rw n t j iil x ein e n o n e s . h r h l b l5 6 S 6 2 6 87 ' ( 0 4 Th s ac u tce nn ac mpli u d rRue1 ()6 cnie tf pla ig ta aeno e tt dt a 20 9. u , o r sr e ig o ant n e l 2b () a d niy e dn s h t r t nil o n e m s mp i no tuhb c us te c n ito nomo et a lb l a d c n l in ,J .Al o g 1l e al c n tu su to f r t e a e h y o ss f r h n a e s n o cuso s . t u h i r l o sr e T h b y I . V A. Pli iff l t de c i a i vi a ton by Supe e ntAyl t tvi aed antf ais o s rbe ny ndi dual c i dnt nde or ha ol t PlitT sfd r l' h sa to a l v aj 1 8 Se . ..As co t I b l 5 6U. 6 2 6 6 an i e e a tg t cin b e i 9 3. e eg, h r f v. q a, 5 S. 6 , 7 i * . ( 0 9 .Plitc scamsa o tE arig s pe vso a dc n u t' r e trl c n l o ya d 2 0 ) an i li b u Eril , u r iin, n o d c'a e n iey o cus r n t n fi t stsyt eee n so s c camse e i t e weea s l a ans a a p o rae alo aif h lme t f u h li v n f h y r sevd g i t n p r p it de e f ndant Se e. ,M one l 436 U. a 694.Pli ifdoe no a lge asngl f c s wi t t . es g. l, S. t a ntf s t le i e a t ho ng ha Supe i e ntAyl rha an i ve e wih orknowl rnt nde o d y nvol m nt t edgeofPl i if sc antf ompl nt a ai s bouta housng m sgnmen ,alege bac pan, e c tons a ey,f i si t l d k i m di a i , nxi t ood,ora hi ele nyt ng s . Tot e e Pli ifs c aest tapolc orc t c eae i e nt d, he xt nt antf pe ult ha i y usom r td, mpl me e or pe pe u t d by Supe i e ntAyl ca e t ba e ofli vmi usco ait ,hef ist s ae r t ae rnt nde or us d he s s ls o mpl n s al o tt acli . Pli iff ist s fce l al geSu rnt nde Ayl ha acualorc t ci am antf al o ufi inty le pe i e nt or d t onsm tve knowldget tas di t wa e e ha ubor na e s ngage i co d n nduc t tpos 1ape va i a unr % ona e t ha ed $ r sve nd e bl rs 'o c nsi to a ij r t p o elk t ePlitf; u rn e d n Ay o ' r s o s t t a ik' f o tt in ln u y o e pl ie h an if S peitn e t lrs e p n e o h t u knowl dgewass i qua east s e o nade t o how ç lbe a ei f e e t ort cta ho ia i n o t s i r t ndif r nce o a i ut rz to f he de a lged ofe i pr tc ';a t tt r wasan G fima i ca a lnk'be we n le f nsve ac ies' nd ha he e t fr tve us l i ' t e a S peitn e t l rsalg di a to a d ap riu a c n ttto a ij r Plitf ha u rn e d n Ay o ' le e n cin n a t lr o siui n l nu y anif d c s fee S e eg . a v. to , 3F.d7 , 9 ( t Ci.1 9 ) u frd. e s ..Sh w Sr ud 1 3 91 7 9 4h r 9 4 . The ei no bassf hol ng Su rnt nde Ayl la ef Pli tf' dis tsaci r s i or di pe i e nt or ibl or a n ifs s a if ton wih a m e c c r orbei c r d c t ny di al a e ng ha ge opay e sf rs r i es Se ea. Boblt v. m nt o e v c . m . , e t Ange one l , poK c mpansHan sv Ken r 4 4U.. 9 5 021( 9 2 , d n tata a imaesa v ct, u s ne r o lit, ie . re, 0 S 51 , 2 - 1 7 ) I o o c s n n t' d o ae s a po t d vlpnjsa oyadcntmto a camsn t lal rie i acmpan.Serrc v. rol17F.d2 , e eo i tmtr n o si in l li o cery asd n o lit e B o k Carl, 0 3 41 2 3(t Cm 1 9 )Gu t , .c n u n )Be u et . t o Ha o 7 5F.d 1 7 ,1 7 (t Ci.1 8 ) se 4 4h 9 7 ti J, o c ni g; a d t v Ci f motn, 7 2 2 4 2 8 4h r 9 5 ;e g y as Go d nv Le k ,5 4F.d 1 4 ,1 51( t Ci.1 7 )(eo iigta adititc m'i n t x ce t lo r o . e e 7 2 1 7 1 4h r 9 8 rc r zn h t src o ts o e petd o as meter eo a vo aefrap oK panif. su h ol f d ct o r litf) 9 7F. u p 8 8 81 ( . Va 1 9 )(cor cin o scasa ee t ldt rl o t e 5 S p . 0 , 3 W D. . 9 7 s re to s f il r n i e o ey n h ç t . ' e p rieo terisi to sme ia saf. .'(i n M i irv. on, 9 F.d 8 8 8 4- 5 x e t f h i n t u in' d c l tf . . ct g l e Be r 8 6 2 4 , 5 5 s t ' i t (t Ci. 9 0 .Ani maeh sG c n ttto a rg tt fe me c l a e'a ii wel 4h r 1 9 :) n t a d o siuin l ih o r e dia c r , nd t s l no ' s tl t ti m a e ma bec r d c yme sf rm e c ls r c .Bo e tv.Ang one,9 e ted ha n t s y ha ge opa nt o di a e vies blt el 42 F. u p. 1 25 ( . Va 1 9 )( tngplitY sc n e to t a t sar s l o t epoiy S p 25 , 4 W D. . 9 6 noi an i o tnin h tt eu t f h l a c r ga di medi lco ym e s hei o tn f c t c e r ng ca pa nt, s fe or ed o hoos be we n ne es a yt l re a e t e c s r oieti s nd a e u t me ia c r'fie t saeacam f rvilto o h sc n tmto a rg t) apd 1 d q ae dc l a e' ald o tt li o oain f i o si in l ih s, f , 21 F.d6 7(t Ci. 9 7 .Pli t salg to s o t a a wa no d n e me ia te t n 3 9 4h r 1 9 ) ani le ains h w h t. s t e id dc lr ame t Y he bec us ofa i biiy t pa .3 a e ny na lt o y Nordoe Pli tY sdi s ts a ton wiht t mper mr q lt orpori sz ofhi s ani s a if c i t he e a e, uaiy, ton ie s f o o d ikssaea ya t n becam o d srb a y ij r o c n tmto a dme so s o d r rn tt n ci a l li r e cie n nu y f o si in l i n in . o S e ec, o e v Ch p n, 2U. 3 7 3 7( 9 ) He d ro v. r il , 0 U. Dit e . ..Rh d s . a ma 4$ S. 3 , 4 1 81; n e s n Vicla 20 7 S. s. i LEXI 7 2 7 a * 6 2 0 W L 2 81 2 , t* ( . Va Se . , 0 )( n a , . S 0 0 ,t 2 , 0 7 7 7 2 a 7 W D. . pt21 20 7 Co r d J) ( n u ls d .Ac o d n l,S p rne d n Ayo i e tte t q ai di mi , n h s u p b ihe ) c r i gy u eitn e t lr s nild o u lfe mmt t a d i y moton t dim isi gr nt d. i o s s s a e B. Ther m ani de e nt - i e c Ofi e s'Rot rUnknown Ofi e s' a t J l e i ng f nda s s di al fc r y' he M fc r y' nd he ai - a eno p o e d fn a t t a a to p ru n t 4 U. C. 1 8 S e eg, il r t r p r ee d n s o n cin u s a t o 2 S. j 9 3. e e ..W lv. M ihia De to S aePoie 4 U. 5 , 0( 9 9 ; r v l Re o 5 F. u p. d3 7 31 c a n p' f tt lc , 91 S. 8 7 1 8 ) P e a v. n , 7 S p 2 0 , 0 ( D. . 9 9 (tT) eP e mo tRe ina J i i n t R es n, a dt ee o en tn na l t E. Va 1 9 ) ç h id n go l als o a p ro ' n h r fr o me be o ( ' 3Alho Pli ifcts 1 U .S. j 4 6 401 ()a 4 48a( )A)B)i(i a d( 1 2 a b ss t ugh antf ie 8 C. j 00 3d, nd 0 ()4( ( ( i) n 1 /4) s a e ) 9( frwh h so l n t v t pa cpy nsfrme iasrie, t n t ri peld steJifo c rig o y e h ud o hae o 4 o ame t o dclevcsnohig heen rcu e h alrm hagn af ef me ca s r c .Addil l Pl ntf f ist e tbls t theha aprvaec eofaci l rt e e or di l e vies tonaly, ai if al o sa ih ha s i t aus ton mde hos sa e .Se. ..Tra wa v. uom No. 0 CV- 0 4 A@' 2 2U. DitLEXI 1 8 2 , t* - , 01 tmts e eg, e d y Vo tt 1 - 0 0 2 ) 01 S. s. S 4 8 8 a 2021 2 2 , WL49 9 4, t* ( . N. S p. 7 2 2 . 5 41 a 7 W D. Y. e t2 , 01 ) 10 s iun e 4 U. C. 1 8 .) afdt pat n r v' L p r, 0 F.d8 (t Ci. 0 0 , ut d r 2 S. j 9 3' , f q r a d e d q a t2 3 3 21 4h r 2 0 ) 5 rp re i f l-e t o ma a 2 00U. Ap LEXI 46 , t* 20 0W L 2 5 , t*1(û'e e o td n ultx f r t t 0 S. p. S 5 a 3, 0 0 91 a çf -h c ta s pr ry de e m i d t tt Pidm on Re o lJ li nota d r on'a i t r f e our lo ope l t r ne ha he e t gi na ai s pe s nd s he e or n tn na l t s it e 91 3( ' ; e g s n, 19 c 0 31 ,1 91U. Dit LEM S o me be o ut md r 98 .' F r u o No. :0 v 6 8 9 1) S. s. 8 5 a * - ,1 91W L 1 5 5 , t*1(o cu igt t g o p o pes r l l eS dc l 29 , t 2 4 9 1 7 9 a c n l dn ha a ru f rome,i s ia k me sn f' sn t ç e s n' o p mo e o j 1 8 ) Ac o dn l camsa an t h s d fnd n s tfl i o a s ro 'f r u s s f 9 3 . c r igy, li g is t e e ee a t ' p aeds se p ru n t 28U.. j1 5 b ( ) r imisd u s a t o SC. 91 A( )1. V. Fort f eg ng r as ,Igr nti par a de i pa t antf smotonst n e he or oi e ons a n t nd ny n r Pl i if i o m nd; t y m' gr nt d ast d s isng a ca m agans Or ng Comt a t y a e de e i a 1 he e a e o im s i ny li i t a e t y, nd he r ni d n 1 o he r pe t Supe i e t r es c s. rnt nden Ayl ' moton t dim isi g a e and Ide net e r s t ors i o s s s r nt d, di o xe cie s p lme tl u id ci no ra y saelw cam, uru n t 28U.. j1 6 ()3 . u p e n a j rs ito ve n tt a li p s a t o SC. 3 7 c( ) ENTER : s Thi da ofDe mbe ,201 y ce r 5. ( . ö Se ' Unie St t ititJ or t d aes sr c udge 11
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
