Weakley v. Laster, et al, No. 7:2014cv00657 - Document 92 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 8/31/2015. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
cl sOFFI u.: D8 K U ERK' CE , l m W .. AT ROANOKE,VA vI LED I THE UM TED STATES DI N STRI COURT CT FOR TI W ESTERN DI V STRI OF VI CT RGI A NI R O AN O K E DI SI N W O PAUL M YM OND W Em EY, AL 31 2 1 C 25 J A , D ULI DY: DE c CASE NO .7: 4CV00657 1 Pl nt f , ai i f M EM O R AND U M O PI O N NI SI LA STER , S By: G l n E .Conr e ad C hi fU ni e St e D i t c Judge e t d at s s ri t Dee f ndant . Pa Ra o W e kl y,a f de alim a epr e ng pr K ,fl d t sc vi rg sac in ul ym nd a e e r n t oc edi o ie hi i l i ht to u d rBi n v.Sx Un n wnNa dAg n s 4 3U. .3 8 3 5 9 ( 9 ) algngt a a tr n e ve s i k o me e t, 0 S 8 , 9 - 7 1 71, le i h t fe t de e ntprs o tc a a sg d li t t ge a po a i des t known rs he he f nda ion fi i l s i ne lm o he ner l pulton, pie iks f c d t r ,imae a tc e a ij r dhi a e hee n ts ta k d nd nu e m.Up n rv e o t r c r ,t c u tc n l d s o e iw f he e o d he o r o cu e t td fn a ti e tte t s mmayj d me t bae o W e k e ' fiu et p o ry e h u t ha ée d n s nild o u r u g n , s d n n ly s alr o r pel x a s a i sr tver m edi . dm ni t a i e es 1.Backzround W e kl y alege t f l ng s que a e l s he olowi e nce of e nt r l t t li cl m s He e e e ve s e aed o ls ai . nt r d f de a prs n on Se e be 26,2008,a t Unied St t s Penien i y i Col m a Fl i a e r l io ptm r t he t ae t tar n e n, ord (G Coe ll. W e klyt l t eitk o c r svea ra o st th fa e o h ri mae G USP lmaf a e od h n a e o e s e rl e s n ha e e r d t e n ts mi thn m hi i hewasasi d t t ge a populio a USP Colma Specfc ly, gh r m f sgne o he nerl ain t e n. i al W en e had c kly oope a e wih a horte i a Mghl vii e c i i ti li vi a vi e r t d t ut iis n y sbl rm nal ra nvol ng olnt Weakley v. Laster, et al pr s ga know n a t A r n Br he hood;he hi s fw a r m o e t ha m ur r d one of i on ng s he ya ot r m el s u r d o ve de e Doc. 92 t ga s m e r ;a he was wel lno n o f de a prs r fom pror t r s of he ng' mbe s nd l c wn m ng e r l ione s r i em i a c ai he ha s r d. The ofk e s verled t s i or ai n i W e kly' pr e e nc r er ton d e ve t r i hi nf m to n a e s es nt nce ivetg to rp r C R' ,b t a s r d hi ta h wo d b fne i g nea p p lto . n siain e o t TS ' u su e m h t e ul e i n e r l o u ai n ) Dockets.Justia.com . Twe y da l t ,t i ae e t r d W e kl y' c l ha d hi a c nt ys aer wo nm t s n e e a e s el, nde m opy ofhi own i a s nt ke s r eing f whih i ntfe W e l y asa i or nt a sr k hi num e oustm e wih a ce onu c de ii d ade n nf ma , nd tuc m r i s t mea pp al asmi ro j c.W e ke wa h s i l e f rte t n o hi rs ligij re . tl ie r i l be t n ly s o pt i d o r ame t f s e utn nu is d a az On De e be 29,2008,aut ii ta f red W e l y t aprs i Kent ky,known cm r hortes r nse r ade o ion n uc a USP Bi Sa y. Dlrng t it kepr s ,W e kly r lye hi f r aboutbeng hous d i s g nd zi he n a oce s a e ea d s ea s i e n ge r populton,bas on hi pas i e a tons wih t Ar n Br he hood a hi beng ne al ai ed s t nt r c i t he ya ot r nd s i i ntfe a a i or ntdutng t a s ul a USP Col ma De piet e rs f c or ,a t de i d s n nf ma i he s a t t e n. s t hes ik a t s nd he known pr s nce ofm a Ar n Br t r ee ny ya o he hood ga m e r a USP Bi Sa ng mbe s t g ndy,W e e wa akly s a sgne t t ge r lpo a i t r On J nua y 1 201 t i es9o a t rl i of s i d o he ne a pulton he e. a r 0, 0, wo nmat m no he m t t prs c m et W e kly' c l,sa he ion n o a e s e l tbbedhi m or t n 26tm e ,a l thi f de m e ha i s nd ef m or ad. W e kly wast r a trta f e t aprs i s hwe tVigila, wn a USP Le a e he e fe r nsen'd o ion n out s r ri kno s e, n rvi on J y 7,2010. Durng t i akes r e ng pr es a USP Le ,W e kly r a e al of r i ng ul i he nt c e ni oc s t e n e elt d l hi pr vi uspr e st CSI Ofi rLase 'a t ot rof e s. Theof e st d W en e s e o obl m o E S fce tr' nd wo he fc r l fc r ol kly nitz n he a ai t tte e we e Gbot s nheads and Odi ss i t gener lpopul ton atU SP Lee' ( r ha h r r t h ki ' Thid . Ame d.Co l 1 ,ECF No 2 . W e kly si t timae 9o t e e g o pswee n ng n mp . 3 . 5) a e ad ha n t s m h s r u r mo t er s i ef t a t k on hi a USP Bi Sa hos e ponsbl or he tac m t g ndy.Het d t ofi r t thçwasa r i ol he fce s ha fa d USP Le i t s fom t s g oupswoul ty t l lhi ,s he r ue t pr t tve c t e nma e r he e r d r o dl m o eq sed o eci usody. The om ce s s i t tt SHU wasover r r ad ha he c owde a t r wasno r d, nd he e oom f rhi t r . The o m he e y t d Mm t tU SP Le wa ç pe a , dif r ntfom ot rf r lUSP',a t tt y woul ol ha e s E cil' f e e r s ' he ede a s nd ha he d ' ESI 'i Laserstte a r nty r e st t Spe i hwesi tve Se vie oft BOP. The c t I S' n t ' il ppa e l efr o he cal tgai r c he our pr viusy dimis d al ilhns a ns t ohe ,lnkno USP Le ofk e sr f r nc i t c ant aRe e o l s se l a gai t he t r l wn e t r e e e ed n he ompli , r W e kly f iedt i ntf t m f pu pos ofa ompls ng s r ieofpr es . a e al o de iy he or r es cc ihi e vc oc s 2 A co di gt W e ey, OdnssaeE haebae q a irl iu g o pta i c nr le b te( y n c r n o akl iit r 1 t- sd u s-ei o s ru h t s o told y h Ar a a g Brteh o )a ds n e dg n s' (d l . oh r o d n kih a a g . I . 8) ' e n e t ot i t E ro l g aa tç' e k e ' s ft (d) W eakly agai r quesed pr ectvecusody,but i s nal u rn e 'W a ly s aey. I . pe y hi r q s wa de ed. s e ue t s ni On J y 10, ul 2010,i t sa tc d W ea e a sa nma e ta ke kly nd t bbedhi i t nec f l tm e .The m n he k otr i s a tc r wi l a lr m e a knie whi h W e kly m a ta ke s eded a ge t l f , c a e nage t m esl a y f o t m t d o te wa r m he o pr ve beng f rhe hn me A f we ksa trt a tc Lasert d W e kly t ton J y 9, e nt i u t r r d. ew e fe he ta k, t ol n e ha ul 201 he ha r eve a t e 0, d ec i d elphone c lfom a i t i or nt i t ge r lpo a i al r n nma e nf ma n he ne a pulton, ' saigt a G ht çho c le s weeg igt çh c -n' W e k e . (4 1 ) La trsi t a ttn h t ç ie s t alr ' r on o c e k i ' n lyS J. 2. se ad h t w . t edd ' t ikt e wo dg s fra t mu d r( e k e )s hed d td a yti a o t t e G in tl n h y ul o o a s o r e W a ly o in' o n lng b u' h h z l ' me s g . ( ) l J n a y 2 1 a t rte ta ser d W e ke t USP Tuc o i Arz n , sa e J n a u r 01 , uho i s r n fre A i a ly o s n n io a whih he i ntfesasa ls f ha n'prs n f r f de ali aeswho ha c c de ii ta e ve ' io o e r nm t ve oope a e wih 1 w r td t a e f re n .(d 6) n o c me t 1 . . W ea e s c am s a i tLase ha a co i a e pr e lalba kgr kly' l i gans t r ve mplc t d oc dtr c ound. W ea e kly sgne and da e hi i ta Bi ns c i d t d s nii l ve ompl i on J nua y 2,201 a m al d i t t Uzie ant a r 2, nd ie t o he lt d St t DititCour f r t Ditit ofAdz aes src t o he src ona,whi h r c i d a doc t d t pl adng on c e eve nd ke e hç e i J nua y 1 201 Tha i ta co aitdes rbe onl e nt a USP Colm a a USP Bi a r 0, 2. t nii l mpl n c i d y ve s t e n nd g Sandy a i ntsed t de e nt onl as ( l o unnn e e oye of t Fe r l nd de i he f nda s y G mer us nl m d mpl es he de a Bt e u o Pds n a d a e t a d s p r io so t eFe ea Bt e uo Ivetg to . ( mp . l a f o s n g n s n u e vs r f h d rl l a f n siains' Co l r r ' 1 ECF No 1) W e k e ma eo l ava u rfrnc t athr atc a US Le 'a d sae , . . a ly d ny g e ee e e o s id ta k t P e' n ttd t li i e t n e ls ntnt o m nd. On Fe u r 9,201 t Arzo ditit c t dimis d t i ta br a y 2, he i na src our s s e he niil c mplitwih u p eu ie b td dn tds s t ec s , n g v W e k e 3 d y t fl a o an to t rj d c , u i o imis h a e a d a e n ly 0 a s o ie n n e dc m nde ompli tt c r c c ran pl adi de i inci . a n o ore t e ti e ng fce es 3 Acc di t W ea e , Es o-alr'aeimae,sn to e b tea mi srto ,wh manan 1 or ng o kly c h tc les r n ts a cin d y h d nitain o itig l dsi ie o e oh rimae tru h te u e o voe c . (d.1 ) Th tr Rhek-n'menst Ke u s icpl v r te n ts lo g h s f iln e' I 9. e em c c i' a o d q e t n l ' r pr eci cusod ' 1 ot tve t y. d. ' 0n M a c 26,201 t Arz c tr c ve a doc ed W e ey' fr tnme rh 2, he i ona our e ei d nd ket akl s is nded c ompl n .4 W ea e na e La t ra a de e nti t he i oft c ait kly m d se s f nda n he ad ng he ompl i a i cai s ant nd n l m 1 a 1 , a l ed s t nta l t s m e f c sa i tLase a ar a s 2 nd 5 leg ubsa ily he n a t gans t r s le dy umm a d he e. The dze r 5 Arz nac u tds se t efrtn n e c mplitwih u p eu ieo Jme28 20 2, p n io o r imis d h is me d d o an to t rj d c n t , 1 uo fndi t tve wasi ope i t tsa e.W e kl y fl d a moton f r c i r to whih i ng ha , nue mpr r n ha tt n e ie i or e onsde a in, c t Co tgr nt d. I t or rvac tng t Jme 28,2012 dimi s lor r a r nsa i t he ur a e n he de a i he t s s a de nd ei t tng he c s ,h c u t imis dt efrtn n e c mplitwih u p eu iea d al we W e ke t a e t e o r ds se h is me d d o an t o t rj d c n lo d n ly o fl a s ond n e ie ec m nded c ompl i ,whih he di The Cout dim is d t t s ond n e ant c d. ' s s e ha ec t m nded c mplit t o t eu ieo Fe nlr 1 2 3 a alwe W e k e t fl at id n nd d o an wih u prj d c n b ay 2, 01 , nd lo d a ly o ie hr me e c mpan ,wh c h dd;ti s b sin wa sg d u d rpe at o pej r a d d td o o lit ih e i l s u miso s ine n e n ly f ru y n ae n l M a c 1 201 a doc e by t Cour on M a c 1 201 r h 2, 3, nd ketd he t r h 5, 3. I li t r n nde compl nt W e kl y as e td cli s 1 21 t r Bi ns r ga di n zs hid me d ai , a e s re am - mde ve , e r pg e n sa USP Col ma i Fl i USP Bi Sa i Ke uc a U SP Le i Vigi a The ve t t e n n orda, g ndy n nt ky, nd e n r ni. Arzo c tt n sl a iy dimi s d s ve a c am s a or r Bi ns c am s 11 17,1 i na our he lmm rl s s e e r l l i nd de ed ve l i , 9, a d2 t b sr e o fved fn a t,n l igLa tr Dee d n smo e on l f rd s s a n 0 o e ev d n ee d n s icudn se. fn a t v dj ity o imis l of t c he ompli t l De e be 201 t Arz an. n c m r 4, he iona c tde e t m o i t dimi s on our nid he ton o s s jlidcin lg omd ,b ts v rd t eKe mc y a d Vign acamsit t spaaea to t s ito a r t s u e ee h n k n r ii li n o wo e rt cins r a dta fn'd teUS Le p rin o t e c s ( ve scams 1 a 1 )t t i c u tm t n rnse e h P e o t f h a e Bi n li 7 nd 9 o h s o r s he o m os c t onve le f m whe eve wa pr pe .Thes c am sas e t ha S1 Ofi e La t rwas ri nt onz r nue s o r e li s r t t S fc r se 4 W e e di notsgn a daet s c akly d i nd t hi ompli . On t s me da ac r ng t c tr or aval e ant he a y, co di o our ec ds iabl onlne howeve ,t Arz i , r he iona c t doc t W ea e s spa ae peii unde t Fe r Tor Cli s Ac our keed kly' e r t tton r he deal t am t (TTCA',whc h sg e a d d td o Mac 1 ,2 2 Th tFTCA a to i c re ty pe dng b fr t t ' ih e in d n ae n rh 2 01 . a ) cin s urnl n i eoe he Arz dititc t W ea e v.UnknownPa is No. 1 CV- TUC- CB. iona src our: klv rte , 4:2- 022D 5 Thi frta s ls mende c ai h uded ale tonsconc r ng Lase ' i vementi W ea e si ta d ompl nt wl lga i e ni tr s nvol n kly' niil as i me t t ge r lpopulton a La trs fiur t rac t a i or ' t e sgn nt o he ne a ai nd se ' al e o e t o n nf mants elphone wa i be o e t rnng f r he Jl 1 ,2 0a sut ta Gho c l r'pa n dt Shek i'W ekly. (is Ame d. mp . -0 1 - 5 ECF uy 0 01 sa l,h tû t al s' ln e o ç c -n' a e Frt n Co l 9 1 , 4 1 , s e c No 8) .. 4 d lb rtl i ifrn t W e ke s sf t wh n h ( )rc ie a ph n me s g fo a eieaey ndfee t o n ly' a ey e e 1 e ev d o e sa e rm n i mae if r n t a Gho c l r wee g i t the k i ( e klyl'b tfie t a tt n t r o ma t h t t t al s r ong o c c -n' W n e ,' u ald o c o l s e p o e tW e ke ( am 1 )a ( )d r e W e l e p oe tv c so y d s t h ssa a a r tc n ly Cli 7 nd 2 el d ac y r tcie u td epie i tms s i l ci n lif nn n a dt efc t th wa p e i u l atc e a ohe i ttto ( am 1 ) rmia n o a t n h a t ha e s rv o sy ta k d t t r nsiuins Cli 9 . The c s i pr s nty be or t cour on La tr sm oton t dimi so ,i t ale nai , a e s e e l f e he t se ' i o s s r n he t r tve moinf rsl r u me t La trag e ta W e ke ' camss ul b ds se a tme to o l mmayj dg n . se r u s h t n ly s li ho d e imisd s i ba r t red mder t a i bl sa ut of lmia i or ba ed on W e kl y' f im e t e us he pplca e tt e i t tons s n e s al o xha t a miitai rme is o ta La tr i e tte t sz r j d me t o t è g o n o d n srtve e de , r h t se s n ild o l mmay u g n n h r u d f qualfed i lniy. W e ey ha r s i mm l t m s e ponde t t e a glme s madng t m a tr rpe f d o hes r l nt , l he te i or di pos ton. s ii 1 D i c s on . s us i A . St andards ofR e e vi w A m oton t d s ist sst l ga s fc e y ofa c i o im s e t he e l ufii nc ompli . See e. ,Be lAt.Cor ant , g. l l p. v. mby, 5 U. 5 4, 5 - 3( 0 7 .A c mplitn e sas o ta dp an sae n o t Two l 5 3 S. 4 5 3 6 2 0 ) o an e d h r n li ttme t f he cam s o n t a tepla e i e tte t r le a d s fkin ûta tll l g to . .or ie li h wi g h t h e d r s n ild o eif n u t e t çl cl al ains . t as g n e a rghtt r le a i o ei f bove t s ultve l ve ....' a f c a bass f r r le ç e r m o e t n he pec a i e l '; a m l i o ei f G quies r ha r lb l a c n l i n a es nd o cuso s Two l 5 0 U. a 5 5 (ne lq oain makso te ) mby, 5 S. t 5 itma u tto r mitd . Theeo e panifmus G le efcss fiin t saealheee nso (h jcam. Ba sv rf r , lit f t l lg a t u fce t o tt l t lme t f te li ' s . a ' E.. p n d Ne u s& Co.3 4F.d7 , 6 ( t Ci. 0 ) IDu o t e mo r , 2 3 61 7 5 4h r 20 3 . A c ts d gr ts our houl an ummayj me Gi t mova s r udg nt Gf he nt howst tt r i no ge ne ha hee s nui d s u ea t a ymae ilf c a d temo a ti e t ldt j d me ta amatro lm ' Fe . ip t s o n tra a t n h v n s ni e o u g n s t te f a ' d R. v. 5 () 1 t maeil y .. ( lz ds ue o e fcsta mih a fc t o t o Ci P. 6a . 1 o trai . o ly ip ts v r a t h t g t fe t he uc me As t l o t s i t e te g v m ig lw wilp o el p e l et e e ty o sl r j g n . f he ut md r h o e n a l r p ry r cud h nr f l mmay ud me t' ' s e t lge ne, An e s n v Lie t Lo b I . 4 7 U. 2 2,2 8 ( 9 6 . The diput m us be Gç nui ' d ro . b ry b y. nc, 7 S. 4 4 1 8 ) t a i,i te e i e c i s c t tar a o bejzy c ud r tr av r itf rt eno mo ig h t s f h v d n e s u h ha e s na l l o l eun e dc o h n vn r pa t ' J. ûnrviwi t e de ,t c tmus d a a1ras bl i ee esi fvorof ry. . t e e ng he vi nce he our '1 l L t r w 1 e ona e nfrnc n a t no ovi pa t a m a not m a c e biiy de e mi to or wegh t e denc ' he nm ng ry nd y ke r di lt tr nai ns i he vi e. ' W iln v Sa ls I c,3 2 F.d 6 2 6 7 (t Ci.20 4 (iai n o te ) GAjv rle l ms . tpe . n . 7 3 6 , 6 4h r 0 ) ctto mitd . : eiid i ( c mpan i t ee ui ln o a o p sn afd vtf rsl r j dg n p r s s wh n t o lit s h q vae t f n p o ig f a i o l mmay u me t u po e , e he al gai co a ne t r i ar ba e on pe s le tons nt i d he en e s d r onalkno ldge. W ilams v.Grfi 95 F. we ' ' li ifn, 2 2d 8 , 2 (t Ci.1 91 (ii Da i v. h a n c ,6 0F.d 45 , 6 (t Ci.1 7 :.W h n 20 8 3 4h r 9 ) ct ng v s Zn rd ik 0 2 8 4 0 4 h r 9 9 e t opposng a fda t a t ve i d c he i fi vis nd he rse ompl i G e e c i tng ve sons of t f c s ant G s nt ov c i pr ri he a t wh c r q iec e iiiy d tr n to s' sl r j dg n c n o b ivo d. Da s 6 0 ih e ur rdb l ee miain , l t ' mma y u me t n n t e n ke vi, 0 F. a 460. I 2d t d. B . St t e o Li iat o a ut f m t i ns Fe e a cvi rg t a to st e Bie o 4 U. C.j1 8 aeg v me b t esa e d rl i l ih s ci n md r v ns r 2 S. 9 3 r o e d y h tot o lmiain f r p ro a ij de i t e sae wh r te alg d c n t i n l v oain f i tto s o e s n l n u s n h tt ee h l e o si o a i lto s e mt ns o c ce . See Ow e v Okle 48 U. 2 5 2 - ( 9 9 ( 1 8 ) Ren l v Ev r,1 7 c u d6 t , 8 S. 3 , 3940 1 8 ) j 9 3 ; ibod . es 8 r . F.d 3 8 3 8n.1 ( t Ci.1 9 )( v ns.Vigna sa p ia esaueo lmiain i t 3 4, 5 0 4h r 9 9 Bie ) r ii' p lc bl tt t f i tto s s wo ye r fo t etmewh n a a to a c e .Va Co eAn j8. - 4 ( . as rm h i e n cin c nls . d n. 012 3 A) A f de a c am a c ue whe t pl ntf knowse ug a e rl li c r s n he ai if no h boutt hn m do t hi t he r ne o m o b ig hslws i. S eNa i v. a d n M d. us o Cor, 4 F.d 9 ,9 5( t Ci.1 9 ) rn i a ut e sm W r e . Ho e f r.6 3 51 5 4h r 9 5 (n ba )(egadi j1 3 cam a r a) A pds ne' fdea cvi cam i de me fld fr e nc r r ng 98 li cc u l. o rs e rl i l li s e d ie o 6 l t Bi ns decso , t Suprme Cour r cogni d a R n he ve iin he e te ze damage r med de ine t vi c t s e y sg d o ndiae voain o c nsiuin lrg t b fd rla tr. Halv Clno 2 5F.d2 2 2 4(t Ci. 0 0 .Be a e ilt s f o ttt a ihs y e ea cos' l . itn, 3 3 0 , 0 4h r 2 0 ) cus o o ' s c arme yi smi rt a a t n a an tsaeotcasu d r4 U. C.51 3 c u t ge u nl rl o c s u h e d s i l o n ci g is tt f il n e 2 S. 98 , o rs q e ty ey n ae a o i lw 9o j 1 8 a t n i rs lig camsu d rBie . S eAs co v Iba.5 6U..6 2,6 57 (0 9 a m 9 3 ci s n eovn li n e v ns e h r R . q l 5 S 6 7 -6 2 0 ) o (mdn ta aBie sa to i teRe ea a lgt s t b o g ta antsaeot asu d r. . 1 8 3(nen l f ig h t v n cin s h fd rl nao o ui r u h g is tt f l n e . j 9 3' itra s ki q oainsa dctto so te ) u tto n iain mitd . 6 pur es of a sa t of lm iai ns when he ç i r hi pl a ng t prs n a horte f r pos tm e i t to ' G ve s s e di o i o ut iis o del f r r ig t te c u tcek. Le sv.Rih n Ciy PoieDe t 9 7 F. 7 3 7 (t o wa dn o h o r lr ' wi ' c mo d t l c p', 4 2d 3 , 35 4 h Ci.1 9 )( ing Ho so v La k,4 7 U. 2 6 ( 9 8 Aslng a t c mplh ti tu r 9 1 ct i u t n . c 8 S. 6 1 8 :. o s he o a l s h s dee d fld wihi t lm iai nspe i t a ton i tme y.l me ie t n he i t to rod, he c i s i l d. W e l y kne s fc e f c sa ade w uf i nt a t boutt hn m donet hi by Lasersa l d f l est he r o m t ' lege aim o pr t c li a i ti t as a twhe t a s ul occ r d on J y 10, 0,a wihi s ve a o e t lm gans nma e s ul n he s a t ure ul 201 nd t n e r l we kst r a tr whe La t rt d hi a e he e fe , n se ol m boutt i onna ' c l Forpu pos soft so ni n, he nf nts al. r e hi pi o t c twila sl et tW e kly' cli sa i tLase ac nld on orbe or Aug t1 2010. he our l s lm ha a e s am ga ns tr c e f e us , Fr m ta d t, h dt ye r ( 3 d ys t fl tmeyBi n camsa ans La trr ltdt o h t ae he a wo a s 7 0 a ) o e i l ve s li g i t se eae o t J y 2010as a t he ul s ul. W en e s i t> c kly' niil ompli , fl d J nua y 2, 201 m e e y sa e t t he ha be n ant e a r 2, r l tt d ha d e a s ule at r tme a U SP Le I d d notde crbe e nt t r wih a pa tc a iy ornnme s a t d hid i t e. t i s i ve s he e t ny riul rt La tr as a de e nt The e or ,t c tc nno f t tt iltalco pl i co m e e se f nda . r f e he our n t md ha he rii m ant m nc d W e ke scamsa an t se s a t t lt el tto peidt e j8. - 4 ( . a ly' li g is Lmtr o s o ol h i ai n ro md r 012 3 A) mi The c tco l ,howe r t tW e ll y' fr tn e d c our ncudes ve , ha ace s ls m nde ompl i wa s fce l ant s ufi inty pa tc a ied t t lt lm ia i pe i I lse La t rasa de e nt a cli s 1 a 1 ri ulrz o ol he i tton rod. t it d se f nda , nd a m 2 nd 5 i t docz e saed s t n i ly t s me al ga i a t t c am s no bef e t s n hat tm nt tt ubsa tal he a le tons s he wo l i w or hi c t Alhough W e kly di not sgn a da e t Bi ns pori of hi frt n e d our. t a e d i nd t he ve ton s is m nde c ompl i , he ç t i t ti mus bede m e tl d on M a c 1 201 t day t tW eace ant t our fnds ha t t e d ie r h 2, 2- he ha lly s g d a da ed t sm ula ousy s it FTCA po ton of hi f lng. At t t poi ,onl i ne nd t he i t ne l ubm ted ri s ii ha nt y 589 da ha e a ed f om t tm e W e l y' c a m s a i t La t r a nl Thus t Bi ns ys d l ps r he i ade s l i ga ns s e cc ed. , he ve camsweetmeyfldu d rj8012 ( . li r i l ie n e . - 43A) La tr s tm e ba a gu e poi s t t Arzona c ts dimis s of W e ey' lr t se ' i r r m nt nt o he i our' s s al nkl s is a s co a e d c nd e nd m nde ompl i s a t f tt tli t r ame d c ant nd he ac ha ls hid nde ompli was fld mor ant e e ta t o y a sa riscaz sa c u d Th dà sasweewi utp eu ie ho ve,a h n : e r Ae é lin c r e . e imis l r t v ho rj d c , we r nd we e bas d on t f r oft co a n ,noton t a qua oft f c ualal ga i a i t r e he o m he mpli t he de cy he a t le tons ga ns Lase . The dim is l of t co pl nt alo di no t r na e t a ton is l,a t de tr s s as he m ai s s d t e mi t he c i te f nd m r Vigila l t aci spe nc t l d t nmni oft lmia i pe i r ri aw, he ton' nde y ole he ng he i t ton rod. Se e. ,Va. e, g. Co eAl j8012 ( ( )(x lii t a i al cin i iiitdwi ntel tto p ro , d m. . -29E)1 e p anng h t f ta to s ntae t h i ains e id hi mi l nd f a c us a t sori dimi s d wihoutdeer ni t m e is t tm e s h ac in i c or ny a e ba e a s s se t t mi ng he rt , he i uc to s pe ng s l not be c putd a pa t of t pe i wihi wlih s h a to m a be ndi ha l om e s r he rod t n zc uc c i n y '. ' t ed he br t....)7 Fo t reasons sat , t cou wil de La trs moton t ds s ough r he rt l ny se ' i o imis W en e sBi kly' venscli a tm eba r a ms s i red. C . Exhaus i n ofA dm i s ra i R e edi s to ni t tve m e Un e 4 U. C.j 1 9 ea,a p io e c n o b ig a cv lrg t a to c n enn d r 2 S. 9 7 () rs n r n n t rn ii ih s ci n o c r ig prs n c tonst i hehasfrte used a ia ea i s tver medi .Pore v. se, io ondii mtl is xha t va lbl dm nika i e es tr Nus l 5 4U. 5 6 5 4 ( 0 ) Tlse h usinrq ie n a p ist ç l imaes is wheh rte 3 S. 1 , 2 20 2 . l x a to e ur me t p le o i l n t ut, te h y i a i ve ge r lcic sa sorpa tc a e s s ...whehe t y al ge e e sve f c or nvol ne a r um t nce ri ulr piode , t r he le xc s i or e s m e o he wr ' a whe he t f m of r le t i t s ks i a ia e tlo h o t r ong, nd ' t r he or e if he nma e ee s val bl lr ug l e o olow he r oc he e usi of ad i sr tve r m e es L ,s Faiur t f l t requied pr edures of t xha ton m nitai e di . d - prs sadmi sr tve r m e pr s ,i l ng tme lm is orf iur t e us a1lves of ion' nita i e dy oce s ncudi i i t, a l e o xha t 1 e l a nitai rviw i no t o r e usi 'a wilba a i t s j 1 acin. dmi srtve e e s t G pe xha ton' nd l r n nmae' pr 983 to W o d o d v. o 5 8 U. 8 ,9 ( 0 6 . Th j 1 9 ea e h usin rq rme ta p ist o f r Ng , 4 S. 1 0 2 0 ) e 9 7 () x a to e uie n p le o 1 W he a sae' lmiai pe i i a id t a f de a ci lrg saci , t sa e' ac n tt s i ttons rod s pple o e r l vi iht ton he tt s compa ng nyi t lng r l m us as bea i l ls t y a ei onsse w ih f de a lw . Boad ofReae sv.To a o,446 oli ues t lo ppled,m e s he r nc it nt t e r l a r nt m ni U. 4 , 4-5( 9 0 (p ligsaetln lwsi j1 8 a t n . S. 78 48 8 1 8 ) a pyn tt ol g a n 9 3 ci ) i o 8 Bie scams Hilv. Bde 3 7 F. p' 3 6,3 9 (t Ci. u y 1 ,2 0 (mp b ih d v n li . l O' n, 8 Ap x 9 9 4 h r J l 2 01 ) t u ls e ) (iainso te ) ctto mitd . Th Fe ea Bt e u o Prs n C%OP' h s e tb ih d a fu -ird a mi srtv e d rl l a f io s r ' a sa ls e ) o rte e d nitai e r medy pr es f af r lprs ne ç o s e f ma r vi w ofa i s r l tng t a as tof e oc s or ede a io r û e k or l e e t n s ue e ai o ny pec ii/ rown c i me . Se 28 C. R.jj5 1 Ani t s dfrts e t r ol li lshe onfne nt' e ' F. 42.0. nmae houl is e k o es ve ls co ait i or al att i tmtonallvelby pr e i t is t sa f on t r quied mpl n nf m ly he nsi i e es ntng he s ue o t f he e r f m,c or ommo yknown a aBP- 28C. R.j542.3.l uns tsidbyt r pons att BPnl s 8. F. 1 f aife he es e he 8 lve, wili 20 da a t t c lnge i i nt t i a e m a fl a f malwdte e l tln ys fer he hale d ncde , he nm t y ie or tn co aitt t wade onaBP- f m,o ane fom li c msl . 28C. R.j542.4.The mpl n o he r n 9 or bti d ' ls ot eor r F. 1 i t s d r ceve a r c ptf t r m e f r ,a t n t wa de orhi desg eha 20 nma e houl e i e ei or he e dy o m nd he he r n s i ne s cae rda t i tga et ma trde c i on t BP- a pr vi awrte r po e. 28 lnda ys o nvesi t he te s rbed he 9 nd o de itn es ns C. R.j 5 2.1a () 5 2 1 . I n tstsid wih t ewad n' r s o e t e imae h s2 F. j 4 1 ()2 , 4 .8 f o aife t h r e s ep ns , h n t a 0 d yst s b ta a p a o t e a pr p it f r ( 1 )t t ea p o it r go a d rco . a o u mi n p e l n h p o rae o m BP- 0 o h p r prae e in l ie t r 28 C. R.j 542.5. An i t who i no s tsi wih t BP- O r s eha 30 da t F. 1 nmae s t aited t he I epons s ys o s b ta a pe lo t a prp it f r ( I )t te g n r lc t e,who h s4 d yst u mi n p a n he p o rae o m BP- 1 o h e e a oms l a 0 a o r s o d. 2 C. R.j 5 2.5 5 2.8 cam h sn tb e a miitai l e h u td t i e p n 8 F. j 4 1 , 4 1 .A li m o e n d r srtvey x a se mtl l t OfieofGe rlCot e C& ' rs ndsont meist t i t' BP- 1 orf l t he fc nea ms l OGC' epo ) he rt o he nmaes I , ais o r pondwili t tmealote f r pons 28C. R.j542.8. es tln he i l td or es e. F. 1 The BOP ta ksisi aes a nita i r m e esi isSENTRY c m put rdaa s . r c t nm t ' dmi sr tve e di n t o e tba e Se 28 C. R.j 542.8 (çfac e e aRe to Appe i co i rd fld on t daei i e F. 1 & c ptd, ques r I al s nsdee ie he t t s l dit t Admi s tveRe dy I x a rc i dt' Acc di t ShaonW a ,aBOP ogge no he nikai me nde s e eve ' ) or ng o r hl par l lw ho r vi w e W e e sr c ds i SEN TRY ,w lie he w as i r e a ed a U SP Lee a ega e e d akl y' e or n ll nca c r t t fom J y 7 t De e be 1 201 he di notfl a ad i sr tve BP- f m s or a r ul o c m r 4, 0, d ie ny m nitai 9 or ppeas l 9 a bouthi c am si t sl ws ta ne es a y f rpr re usi unde t BOP, pr e ur .8 s l i n hi a ui s c s r o ope xha ton r he s oc d es Bas d on t s r c ds Lase a g s t t W e e di no pr pe l e us a ia e e he e e or , t r r ue ha akly d t o ry xha t va lbl a miitaie rme is hscamsae b re un e j1 9 ea ,a d t e s o l b d s se d n srt e de , i li r ard d r 9 7 ( ) n h y h ud e imis d v wi p eu ie t rj d c . h A prs ne who di no pr ry e us a 1 lvel of t a i sr tve r m e es io r d t ope l xha t 1 e s he dm nitai e di p o e t ema s vv sl r j d me tb d mo tai t a t eg iv n es se wa n t r c dl y ur ie l r mmay u g n y e nsrt h t h re a c y tm s o ng G vaia e't M m- by sa i G acs s wi t the wa pr ve e t o , no f ul of hi ç lbl ' o a ttng i t ho ng ha f s e nt d, hr ugh a t s o fo a aln hms l o t a p oc d r . Grh m v Ge tv 41 F. p' 6 0, 6 ( t wn,' m v iig i ef f h t r e u e' a a . nr , 3 Ap x 6 6 3 4h r ' Ci.2 1 ( n u ls d (iig M o r v Be n t 5 7 F.d 71 , 7 (t Ci.2 08) r 01 ) u p bihe ) ctn o e . n et 1 3 7 25 4 h r 0 ). Ac o dngy ad fn a ti e t ldt sl r j d n ba e o plitf fimet e h us c r i l , ee d n s ni e o l t mmay u pne t s d n anifs al o x a t onl i he ca E how t tt e de e i s one-i d t tno r a ona e f ti rco d fnd y f n ç s ha he vi nc s o sde ha e s bl acfnde ul i t tgheprs r waspr ntdfom e usi hi a nikatverme e .'Hilv.O' in, ha t ionel eve e r xha tng s dmi s i e dis' l Bre 3 7F. p x3 6 3 9( t Ci. uy 1 , 01 )(mpu ls e ) 8 Ap ' 9 , 9 4h r J l 2 2 0 t bih d . I r pons t La t r s e de e of no pr r e usi / eace c e n es e o s e ' vi nc ope xha ton, W lly ont nds t t he ha e used al a i sr tver me e t twe e a l e t hi .9 Afe t a s ta USP Le xha t l dm nitai e di s ha r vaiabl o m tr he s aul t e o J y 1 ,20 0 ofcasplc d W e ke i a s ca h u ig l i Cte S '. W e ke n ul 0 1 , fiil a e n ly n pe il o sn l t û HU' n h ) n ly 8 Onc W eade r c U SP Tuc on, i J nua y 2011 he tld BP- O f msa e l y ea hed s n a r , ie I or boutt USP Le saf' he e t fs alg dfiuet p oethm.Th rgo a dr co rjce W eklysBP- Oa p asbe a s te weet i l l e alr o rtc i e e e in l ie tr eetd a e ' I p e l c u e h y r mt y me fld i t i orec r gi ofke a W e kl fie t sae t r le he s ie n he nc r t e onal t nd a ey ald o tt he eif ought W e kly t n fld BP-I1 . R e he ie fr ,whih wee rjce o t sme po n s l i l ip td ta tee a miikaie rme y ato s oms c r ee td n he a u d . t s mdsue h t h s d ns tv e d cin , dimis d onpr dur gr s se oce al oundswiho co i r ton oft me isofW e kly' cai ,di no co tt epr r t ut nsde ai he rt a e s l ms d t nsim ope e h usinofteBOP rme yp o e ue s a t stsy j1 9 ea rq ie ns W o do d 5 U. a 8 8 x a to h e d r c d rs o s o aif 9 7 () e urme t. o fr , 48 S. t 3-4 (mdn ta t ni l o oh r s p o e ual d fcie a mi srtv g iv nc' d e no c mpl wi f ig h t t tmey r tewie r c d rly ee tv d nitaie re a e' o s t o y t u h 91 7 (); .. lv,Cu co e 65 F.d 1 6 1 5 ( Ci.2 1 Cte e h usinrqurme to t ePLRA i 99 ea) P Hi t l rin . 7 3 1 , 2 2d r 01 ) h x a to e ie n f h s stsidb a t i l fl g o api v n ej i i a cptda d cd d o temei b te a p o raepio aife y n mtmey ii f e a c f t s ce e nd e ie n h rt y h p rp it rsn n s a toi )(mp ssa d d . uh rt e hai d e ) f' 9 weke ' algainsao thsehusinatmpsa US Le aecnane i svrlrso sv é lys l t b u i x a to te t t P e r o ti d n e ea eg nie e o sb sin ( No . 8 6 , 8 91, neo whihi v rfe ( No. 2 .Al o ghW eklyd e no tl t s u miso s ECF s 5 , 2 8 , ) o f c s eiid ECF 6 ) t u h a e o s t le hi t s s i asan a fda tordeca ain,t c tc ude t i mus be c i r d asQhe e vae ofa ubmison fi vi lr to he our oncl s hat t t onsde e qui lnt n o p sn asd vto sl r u g n p r o e'o tee h u t nis .W il ms95 F.da 8 . p o ig f a ifr l yj d me t u p ss' n h x a si sue la , 2 2 t 23 mma o i 10 a lgest the s nttwee tyi t dic rt i ntt o hi t tt m , a a s ashe le ha pe û ks r ng o s ove he de iy f s mi ea ' nd s oon ' ie tfe t m, tidt e ha s a miitaierme is ( No 5 , t2. Healg st a d n iid he he re o x u t d nsrtv e de . ECF . 8 a ) le e h t Gh e p o e l fld b t BP- sa d BP- sr q sswih h sc re to a c u eo t r s le û l r p ry ie oh 8 n l 9 e uet t i o r ci n l o ns lr o e ov is s'eltdt t J y201 asa ta USP Le b neve r eve a rs e . ( No. sue 'r ae o he ul 0 sul t e, ut r ec i d ny e pons s ECF 6 a 2. Afe t etmef rtewad n t r s o t t BP- h d ea s d, e ke alg d y 2, t ) tr h i o h r e o ep nd o he 9 a lp e W a ly le e l ak dhi c t eo ( os na hed e n trc l f raBP- O f r s hec ul p e r a s e s oms lr wh e me o s o e al o ) I o m o o d rpae n a a t t r ona diecor ppe l o he egi l r t .The c ouns l al dl r f e t pr vi aBP- O f r ,s yi eor lege y e us d o o de I o m a ng t a t i a p a wo l us b rj ce be a eW e k e d dn th v BP- a dBP- r s ns st h t hs p e l udj t e ee td c us n ly i o a e 8 n 9 epo e o a tc t i. W e kly c e t t wihout t sam orl r quied BP- O f r ,t BP- O ta h o t a e ontnds ha t he t t iy e r I o m he I a a t t r i na diecor a welast s e ntBP- a pe t t OGC,we e not ppe l o he eg o l r t , s l he ubs que 11 p al o he r G v ia l't lm f rp p o e o j1 9 e a. t alb e'o z o u s s f 9 7 () a i I r pl Lase ofe s e de e t t W e kl y' a c n e y, t r f r vi nc ha n e s c ount of hi a lged e usi s le xha ton a t sa U SP Le i co r r t BOP polc a pr c ie. Tho asPul r who wa as i ned tempt t e s nta y o iy nd a tc m ve , s sg asW e kly' c r to lco ms ora USP Lee sa e t ta trfve yea s he doesno r cal n e s oreci na t el t , tt s ha fe i r, te l s cii i er c i hehadwih W e e Pul re ans howe r t tasac ms o , ke pe fc nt a tons t akly. ve xpl i , ve , ha ot elr he pt a1 go terme yf r h is e t imae ; s b t af g o t tlgr g r igr me is o f h e d o ms e s u d o n t s he u mis a e f ha o e a dn e de he is d be wee t daes o J y 7 a No mbe 1 , 201 1 I a i t ha as d f ra s ue t n he t f ul nd ve r 0 0.0 f n nmae d ie o BP- f r Puve wo d h v d cl ne i h s l g () t imae s nn a d r gse 8 o m, l r ul a e o l td n i o : a he n t' me n e itr me ml e ;()t e I n mbe o t e BP 8 rme y f r ()te d t h g v t tfnn t t mb r b h D u r f h - e d o m; c h ae e a e ha o o he i t ()t daet imaert ne t BP- f m t Pul rf rflng;( t de rme nmae; c he t he n t eur d he 8 or o ve o ii d) he pat nt d sg tdt ivetg t a dr s n t teBP- c mplit ()t ed t t ef r wa p o i e e inae o n siae n epo d o h 8 o an ; e h ae h o m s r v d d t asafme e i t a d p rme t a d ( t ed t t tsa f mb rrt r e t eBP- Thee o tf mb r n h t e a t n ; n 9 h ae ha tf me e eu n d h 8. r 1 ( e De sRe l Ex 1Ata h 1A) ECF No 8 -)( S. Le Co ny Vigna 20 0- Uni H 0 S e R' py . tc . ( , . 9 1 U. P. e u t, r ii, 1 t lfr l s lto BP 8BP- Lo )(i elg.) noma Reouin -/ 9 g fh o ' t ' i no s ttme lmi f a sa fm e rt r s s e i i t or tf mbe o e pond t a BP- r s o 8 e pons . Pul rs 1 i c t s e ve ' og ndi a e , howe r t tsa fr s ve ,ha t f e ponde t t BP- f mswihi t t s ve da . d o he 8 or t n wo o e n ys Puv rsae t tG ifif r l( 8 r s lto wa n ta c mpls e a d t eimae le tts ha G q n o ma BP- j e ou in s o c o ih d n h n t l d sr dt p o e dt t f r l e d p o e s'Puve wo dt nh ve ()is e ta imae e ie o r c e o he o ma rme y r c s, l r ul he a : g su d h t n t ' aBP- f r ; h lg e ted t h is e t BP- f r t t imae a d()r c r e t d t 9 om ( ) o g d h ae e su d he 9 o m o he n t; n i e o d d he ae t imaertm e t ec mp ee BP- f r t Puv rf rfl . S cin j5 2.4b)i iae he n t eu d h o ltd 9 o m o le o ii ng e to 4 1 ( ndc ts t a i itk sG lu u ual ln p ro (o lif ma r s lto atmp s' tteBP- sa e t h t f t a e t l n s l o g eid fr nbr l e oui n te t'a h a y 8 tg ,he i t may r que ta extnso oftme i whi t fl hi BP- f t t wa de Se 28 nma e e s n e in i n ch o ie s 9 onn o he r n. e U.. j 5 2.5 a, b . La tras ponso tta i W e ke ddn trc i ars o s t h s SC. j 4 1 () ( ) se lo i t u h t f n ly i o e eve e p n e o i BP- f r wihi t 20 da al ted t r t r l to he co d pr e t fl a BP- O 9 o m t n he ys lo t mde he egu ai n, ul oc ed o ie I a p a t ter go a a mi srtr S e28U. C.j5 2.8Cç tei maed e n tr c i a p e l o h e in l d nitao . e S. 4 1 l h n t o s o e eve f r s ewihi t tm ealote f r pl ... he i t m a c i rt a e e ofar pons e pons t n he i l td or e y, t nma e y onsde he bs nc es e t b ad nila t t1ve.) Puv rsr me y 1g d e n ti iaet a heis e aBP- f r o e e a t ha e l'. le ' e d o o s o ndc t h t su d ' 8 om o a BP- f r t W e kl y f ac r 9 o m o a e or ompli a ant boutt J y 201 i a eas a t he ul 0 nm t s ul. W e kly doe no de t tPul rwashi c a e s t ny ha ve s ouns l ra U SP Le ort Pul r s1 i eo t e hat ve ' og s a a he i r cor He m e ey poi st m i da e dic e ncis on Pul rs l a a lges n ut ntc e d. rl nt o nor t s r pa e ve ' og nd le t ta c e o woul notha had t co pu e i ed l wih li t r co d f m she is d ha ouns l r d ve he m t rz og t lm o e r or s ue f nns t W e kly i t SHU . Ho ver Pul r s d t ie 1 does i f c ,ls a BP- f m o o n e n he we , ve ' e a ld og , n a t it 8 or he m e diti e t W ea ey on Se e r24,201 f a c srbut d o kl pt mbe 0, or ompl i a ant boutSHU f 11 Furt r or , ood. W en e s f cua a c kly' a t l c ount i r s ns t def nda ' e de e i rddl d wih c i a n e po e o e nts vi nc s i e t dtc l i or ton ga .W e ce doe no doesnotalgeordoc nt t a o maedaet)whe nf mai ps ally s t le ume : he ppr xi t t s n he pur tdl o ane orco plt d hi BP- f pore y bt i d m ee s 8 onns t i or ai n he sa e on e c f m ; ; he nf m to tt d a h or 1 Acc dig t t 1 , W e kly r t r t c 1 or n o he og a e e uned he ompltd BP- a ee 8 boutSI f on Septm be 27, 201 4U ood e r 0; t f m Wa is t saf t ts meda a ar s ewasr tr d onOcobe 3, 0;noBP- wa is d. he or s sued o t f ha a y, nd e pons eu ne t r 201 9 s s ue how a whe he de i r t c m plt d f m st t c nd n lve ed he o e e or o he ouns l r fom t SHU ;how l he e o r he ong wat d f rBP- r s ie o 8 e pons s how a whe he o ane a fl BP- f m sfom t c e; nd n bt i d nd ied 9 or r he ouns l e or wiho a r or ofli havi fl a BP- f t ut ny ec d ls ng ied 8 onn;wha he sa e i t BP- f m st t t t t d n he 9 or o he wa de o why he doe notha ar c ptf t e f r s I ed,W e kly f ist sae f t r n; r s ve e ei or hos o m . nde a e a l o t t acs s howi how he c d ha m a ge t fl tm ey BP- f msa BP- whe i alege y t ng oul ve na d o ie i l 8 or nd 9, n t l dl ook G eks'a trt a s ul f hi t fnd s e t pr dehi BP- f m si t SHU . t we ' fe he s a t or m o i om one o ovi m 8 or n he Ra he , W e kl y c e t r a e ontnds t t t BOP r m e pr edur s i ge r l a e no tu y ha he e dy oc e n ne a r t r l a ia e,be a e ofi e s r r l r s val bl c us fc r a ey e pond t i aes BP- f o nm t ' 8 onns or BP- f r s i tun,he 9 o m ; n t' a srsta wih u BP- a BP- r s o s s BP- O a dBP- 1a p asaesl rl rj ce se t h t t o t 8 nd 9 e p n e , I n 1 p el r l mmai ee td y a de eci a a e, t , t vaiabl For e mpl , he s is s l- r a e doc e s s f tve nd r hus ma l e. xn e ubm t efc e t d um nt p r re l s o n t a o 1 a mi itaie r q ss( 9 fr ) s b te o o beo e u po tdy h wig h t f 00 d nsrtv e uet BP- oms u mitd n r fr De e r 3 ,2 3 a Tuco Fe ea Cor ci n lCo e ( c mbe 1 01 , t s n d r l re to a mplx C TCC Tu c n),8 p re to s o ' 2 ec n f t e r quesswe e ne rr ponded t by t desg t d prs ofk i l1 Eve i pr n t , hos e t r ve es o he i na e ion t a . 2 n f ove rue t s sa itc,howe r doesnotunde c i an way t a c la y oft BOP' a i sr tve hi t tsi ve , r ut n y he c tr c he s dm nitai r m e r co d ke pi orde e ntse de . M o eo r W e ll y hi s l wa a e t obt n e dy e r e ng f nda ' vi nce r ve , ace m e f s bl o ai a fl BP- a BP- a a s a U SP Tuc on wihoutBP- a BP- r pons i ha nd ie IO nd 11 ppe l t s t 8 nd 9 es es n nd; wll.h s a pe l we erj ce t elc o lwe lv l e p ns swa no ctda ar a o f r l et e e p as r ee td,h a k f o r e e r s o e s t ie s e s n o i t erj cin. h ee to I s r,W ea e salegai nsa e de esmpl do notunde mi def nda ' r c d n ho t kly' l to nd vi nc i y r ne e nts e or e de s i t tW e kl y neve pr r y f l d BP- orBP- f r s a U SP Le a r qube vi nce how ng ha a e r ope l ie 8 9 om t e se d f rpr re usi Fi ng t tno r s bl f c tnde c d c l fom t e de o ope xha ton. ndi ha ea ona e a t s r oul onc ude ' he vi nce r t t W e e pr l e use ad i sr tve r m e e o t t he was pr nt om ha akly opery xha td m i tai e di s r ha eve ed 1 W e kly sa e t theditle t ssaitc9om c e oft rm e i x f rt prs f ciiisof 2 a e tt s ha sild hi t tsi opis he e dy nde o he ion a lte FCC Tus n,obt nedt oughaFr edom ofI o main Ac r s t t r me c r naora t sc co ai hr e nf r to t eque t o he e dy oo di t t hi omplx. e 13 a Me ng pr pe e usi t ough no ful ofhi o t c twilgr ntLa tr smoton f c vi o r xha ton hr a t s wn, he our l a se' i or sl r j d me t Be a s i i ce rt tW e l y no h sno f rh rBOP a mi srtv l mmay u g n . c u e t s la ha ade w a ute d nitaie r m edis a lbl t hi r ga di li c am s a e e vaia e o m e r ng ls l i boutt 2010 i i nt a USP Le t c t he nc de s t e, he our wil imist e ecamswihprj d c . ld s s h s li t eu ie 1 1 C onc us on 1. l i Fort r as sa e t c tc ude t tat he e ons t t d, he our oncl s ha lhough La t r stm eba a gu e f is se ' i r r m nt al , h i e t ld t sl r j d me tb s d o W e kly' fi le t p o el e h us a ia l e s ni e o l t mmay u g n a e n a e s al r o r p ry x a t valbe t a miitaierme isi 2 0 a rq ie t e j1 9 e a. Th r f r ,h c u twi d s s d nsrtv e d e n 01 s e ur d md r 9 7 () e eo e te o r l imis l W e ke scamso t i g omdwi p eu ie An a prp it o d rwil su tl d y. n ly' li n h s r t t rj dc . p o rae r e l is e ls a h i The clr i die t d t s nd c e of t s m e or ndlm o ni n a a c e k s r c e o e opi s hi m a l pi o nd c ompa ng nyi or rt pli tf a t c de o a n if nd o ouns ofr c d f de e nt el e or or f nda . da Augu t2015. s, ENTER: Thi . lsf y of sY U Chi fUrie Stt Diti tJ e lt d a es src udge 14
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
