Obataiye-Allah v. Unnamed Defendants, No. 7:2014cv00570 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2014)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/31/2014. (kab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
V @ > *: Y FI u. Dl cG J CE s sT. r A q A o i,A T osx v FiFr t i I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI O F VI CT RGI A NI ROANOKE DI SI W ON U H U R USEK O U O BA TA I A LLA H , YE- OCT 3 2 1 94 J I c. ' E CL Rk ULA 'M E BK DEP L ERK CA SE N O .7: V0057 14C 0 Pl ntf , ai if M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI HAROLD CLARK, AL , ZI By GlnE. nr d : e Co a C hi fU ni e St t D i t i tJudge e t d a es s r c Dee da t) f n nts. Pl ntf Uhtw sekou Oba aye- l h ha fld apladi t the ttes ç clr ton i ai if u t i Ala s ie e ng ha il : t a a i n De S p o to Prl n r Ij n to a d Te rr Re tanng Or e a M oin f rF rh r u p r f ei a y n u cin n mpo ay sr ii mi d r nd to o u te Relef' The c tconsr d a doc t d pl ntf s s i .' our tue nd ke e ai if ubmi son as a moton f i e l ut y si i or nt roc or ijmcie rle,a wela a n w cv lrg t c mp an u d r4 U. C.j 1 8 ,s e i a nt tv eif s l s e ii ih s o lit n e 2 S. 9 3 e kng antf ubm s i n he ta f ra r ns e way fo wese n Vigi a. Ahe r vi ofpl i ifss iso , t cour fndsno 'm r t r r ni 1 r e ew ti g o n o whih itro uo y ij nci erle i wa rne a d c n l e t a t i cvi a to r u d n c n el c tr nu tv eif s ra td n o cud s h t hs i l cin mu tb sl rl d s s e t e 4 U. C.j 1 9 e a,f rfit et e h us a miitaie s el mmaiy imis d md r 2 S. 9 7 () o alr o x a t d nsrtv l r m e es e di . Backzround I t i t ntm oton,pl i if c pl i a n he ns a i a ntf om a ns boutt f l i i s . On Se e be 26, he olow ng s ues pt m r 201 whie pli if wa i t s 4, l antf s n he howe ,Ofk e s Stnly,M a tn a t o ot s c r f r a e ri nd w her ondude a d s down of hi c l at Re Oni St t Prs hake s el d on ae ion. Afe wa d,pl ntf f tr r ai if ound a fda t a fi vis nd Obataiye-Allah v. Unnamed Defendants pa r k r a e t hi pe ng l ws t i font of hi ce l Ofk e M a tn al ge y t d pe wor elt d o s ndi a ui n r s l. t r ri le dl ol Doc. 2 pli if t op your l ui a so flng pa m or a t ngs wil ge ea ir f you. antf , t Dr aws t nd t p ii pe k nd hi l t se or ' ' ( mpl 1) Co . . 1 Pl ntf orgi l fl t s moton i Cas N o. 7: ai if i naly ied hi i n e 14CV00159 whi i s t be rpe on ch s oon o i moto f s ins or ummayj dg n . Pu s a tt c u to d r tece k rmo d plitY smo in fom t t r u me t r u n o o r r e , h lr e ve an i to r ha cas and r e edocket i asa s r e cvi ac i ed t epa at i l ton. Dockets.Justia.com Pl ntf as alege t the hasme al r quie nt t be plc i a s r ga i t t p ai if lo l s ha t l e r me s o a ed n eg e ton t e s dow n pr r m ' t tw oul a l hi t e r i r s d pr vie s Of i r ha a l ge y t d og a ' ha d low m o a n nc ea e i l ge . fce s ve le dl ol hi howe r t thet tge s tbec us of( s lws t co ai nga consa l flng m, ve ,ha t won' t hi a e hil a ui, mpl ni nd tnty ii pa r k.' ( mpl 1. Pli ifas sae t thi fmiy ha rceved lter hemaie t pe wor ' Co . ) antf lo tts ha s n l s e i e t s ld o t m fo Red Oni i Se e be ,a hi i om i ma lt kest n daysf de i r Pli if he r m on n ptm r nd s nc ng i a e or lve y. a ntf beleve t ta i tga o i so ng hi mai i r a iton f pl ntf sg me be s p. i s ha n nvesi t r s t ppi s l n etla i or ai if ang m r hi On Aug t1 201 ofi e spl c pl ntf on t odiid srp c l' butneve cha ge us 4, 4, tc r a ed ai if ç fe ti el, m ' r r d hi wih a dic plna y i r to . W he pli if r ceve hi pr ry agan, s ve a m t ny s i i r nfaci ns n antf e i d s ope t i e rl m oto fom hi pe ng l ui,Ca e No.7: 4CV001 we e m isng,a ong wih lte s i ns r s ndi aws t s 1 59, r si l t e tr , r ps a poe she had w rte Pl n if a s rs t t ofi e s confs a e t e iem s be a e of a , nd m it n. ai t f s e t ha f c r i c t d hes t c us hi pe dn lws t Plitf as camst a o fc r é r p ti gsu fi ( s f o 'b c u eof s n ig a ui anif lo li h t fie s ç e u t t f n hi) o d' e a s . a n t lws t On Oc obe 2,201 he f md a t ob ofhai' on hi f tay,a t ofk e he a ui. t r 4, ot i gl r' s ood r nd he t r r usd t c l f arplc me ta ( ef e o al or e a e nt ry. Compl 3. Unnn dofi r alege yt e tnpli if . ) me fces l dl hrae antf co t nty,c usng hi t f rf hi lf ns a l a i m o ea or s i e. Plitf sae ,: wil oe tmysl a h ta d kl a ma y l i te a p si et an if tts t l prtc l ef nd ur n il s n ol h m s o sbl o sv mylf !' ( mpl4. Ba e o t s alg to s panifakst b ta fre t a o h r a e ie ! Co . ) sd n he e le ain , litf s o e rnser d o n t e ' p io wih te sg e ai n se d wn p o rm o t h v v ro Re On o o t r e j ie rs n t h e r g to tp o r ga r o a e aius d in f s n on d ke f om r t i tng aga ns hi asa l ge r e ala i i t m le d. D i cuss on s i Be a e itro uo y ijmcier l fi a e ta r n r rme y tepa t s e n te c us nel c tr n t tv ei s n xr odiay e d , h ry e kig h e p ei n r ij cin mus ma eace rs o ngiha h i lk l t s c e o t meis h r l a y nun to mi t k la h wi t t e s i ey o uc e d n he rt; e t i lke y t s f ir r bl hn m i t a e e of pr lm i r r i ; t t t ba a s i l o ufer repa a e r n he bs nc e i na y elef ha he l nce of e ute tp i h sfv r a da ij ncin i i t p b i itrs. I o e v r apanifs q iis is n i a o ; n n nu to s n he u lc ne et' d.M ro e , litf ' 2 a s ri t the mi tpos i y i s e ton ha gh sbl ncurir pa a e ha m i t a e e ofco ti er nton i r e r bl r n he bs nc ur nt ve i s is f e tg omd f rrle .I a 2 (mp a i a d d . n u t n r t s o eif d. t 2 e h ss d e ) ki Pl i ifsprm a y ba i f s ki i e l ut y r le i hi f a t ti t f ur Re antf i r ss or ee ng nt roc or ei f s s e r ha n he ut e, d Oni ofi e s wilco i t r tla e a i t hi i vmi wa f hi pendi lws t on fc r l ntnue o ea it ga ns m n ous ys or s ng a ui. Prs ofi i l m a not r t lae agans a i t f e r sng hi c tt i ion fc as y e ai t i t n nma e or xe cii s onsiutonalrght t i o a ce st c qHuds t v.Fi ns 584F. 1 1 ( hCi.1 ) butaj 1 cam of c s he our peh ggi , 2d 345, 347 4t r 978, 983 li r t i ton r r m or t n co l or a l ga i t t ofk e s ac i we e r t la o y. e ala i equies e ha nc us y le tons ha t r ' tons r e a i t r Adnms v.Rie,40 F. 72,7 ( h Ci.1 . Pli ifmus sae f t s ng t thi c 3d 4 4t r 994) antf t tt acs howi ha s e r s ofhi c tt tonalr g w a a s t nta f c o m otva i t r t la o y a ton. Se xe ci e s ons iu i i ht s ubs a i l a t r i tng he e a i t r c i e, eg. W a n rv.W h ee ,1 F.d 8 ,9 - ( t Ci.1 9 ) (iig Mt He lh Ci S h o ., g e e lr 3 3 6 0 91 4h r 9 3 ctn . at y t c o l y DititBoad ofEd ai v.Dovl,429 U. 27 287 ( 977)(e rngplitf t s w :a src r uc ton e S. 4, 1 r quii anif o ho t c uslr ltons p bewe t pr ecede e so andt rt it y a ton' Pl ntf mus a a eai hi t en he ot t xpr s in he ealaor ci ). ai if t as s w t tt r t it y a ton ca e a r e i c on hi e cs ofhi consiutona lo ho ha he ealaor c i us d dve s mpa t s xer ie s tt i l rght.Ameia Ci lLi rksUnin v.W iomio Couny,999 F. 780,786( hCi.1 i s rc n vi be t o c c t 2d 4t r 993) (i ngt tmeei onvenincet ltg ton ef t no a reenought consiut a tona e fndi ha r nc e o iiai fors t dves o tt e ci bl rtlain) eaito . Pli if f l t de onsr t a lkelhood of s ce s on t m e is of hi cai of antf ais o m tae ny i i uc s he rt s l ms r t lai n o any lkelhood of f t e r t iton. Pl n ifs c r c e i ton of t e alege e ai to r i i uur eala i aitf' ha a t rzai hes l d ve ba t e t a o he r c e nt a r t la or i s ultve a co l or whih i r l hr a s nd t r e ent ve s s ea it y s pec ai nd ncus y, c s i ufk i nt t r Adams t sa e a a tona e cai . The m e e f c t t unpl s t or ns t e mde o t t n c i bl l m r a t ha ea an i onvenintha ni occ whiet im a ei purui al ws ti nots t ints nc e ppe ngs ur l he n t s s ng a ui s ufk e uppor f t or a c ai t t t oc ur e e w e e s t nta l m o i t d by t t l w s t N or has pl i if l m ha he c r nc s r ubsa i ly tva e ha a ui. a ntf de onsr e how any oft s e nt ha ca e or i lke y t c e m or t i onve e e m tat d he e ve s s us d s i l o aus e han nc ni nc t hi m ndi ttg ton e f t Fo t e r s ns t e ur m us de pl i ifs m o i f x o s ng ii a i fors. r hes ea o , he o t t ny antf ton o itro u o yijmcier le ne lc tr nt tv eif The c t a s fnds t t t a ton m us be dimi s d f f lle t e us our lo i ha he c i t s s e or aitr o xha t a nitai rme esa r quied t r42 U. C.j1 () Ast mao iy o pan ifs dmi srtve e di s e r mde S. 997ea . he j rt f litf cli si ttsa ton oc ured l st n a mont be or he fl t saci n i ea l Ocobe , i i am n li c i c r es ha h f e ied hi to n ry t r t s cla t the hmsno ye had tmet exha tad i sr tver di sast t cl m spr s nt d. e r ha t t i o us m nitai eme e o he ai ee e z Pl itf as ha no ye pr s nt d a pr pe c an if lo s t t e e e o r ompl i ,nn ng de e nt or sa i s c fc ant mi f nda s ttng pe ii f c s a ut e c de e a t bo a h f ndr t s a tons i vi a i of hi rght or w he t e a i oc ur e ' ci n ol ton s i s n hos d ons c r d. S e W e tv At is 48 U. 4 ,4 ( 9 8 (i ig ta j1 8 cam r q ie s o n o e s . kn , 7 S. 2 8 1 8 ) fndn h t 9 3 li e urs h wig f conduc c t ommitd bypes aci t rc orofsaelw) Rahe t n atmptt pas out te ron tng mde ol tt a . t r ha te o re whi i a of pl ntf s a lga i s es a pos i e c am t ti c r nty e used,t ch, f ny, ai if le tons àt sbl l i ha s ure l xha t he c u twilds s t e t e a to wi o tp eu iet e j 1 97 () An a p o it o d r o r l imis he ni cin t u rj dc md r 9 e a . r h p rprae r e wilis t sda l s ue hi y. The Clr i die t d t s nd c pi of t s m e a z opi on a a ompa ng ek s rce o e o es hi mor ndlm ni nd cc nyi or rt pl i if de o a ntf . ENTER:Thi - I d yo- tb r201 s ï V- a foco e, 4. Chi fUnie Stt Diti tJ e td a es src udge 2 Pl i if' curents ison alo s f sfom anot rl det i . I i nota pr s ufer r he egal k ency t s a ntf s r ubm s i operci l vi ri scom pl nt becaus i brngsunr a e cl m sagai tm uli e i vi s,i vi aton ofRul 1 ght ai , et i elt d ai ns tpl ndi dual n ol i es 8 a 20oft Fe r RulsofCi lPrc d e Un rRue 1 () whihgo l sj nde ofcams a nd he deal e vi o e ur. de l 8a, c ve' oi r li , n pl ntf may brng muli e cl m s r a ed ornot i a l ui agai ta snal def ai if i tpl ai , elt , n aws t ns i e endant Howe ,i . ver n or e t na ohe de e a t i te sme lws t te plitf mus stsy Rul 20 a ( ) whih d r o me t r fnd n s n h a a ui, h an if t aif e ( )2 , c go r j n ro pa te . Rul 20 a( )p r t j n ro muli e d fnd nt o y wheet e rgh t vens oide f ris e ()2 e mis oide f tpl e e a s nl r h i to r i ass rt agai tt elef e ed ns hem ars outof t s e tans i or occurence and conce ns a com mon ies he am r acton r r gue to o 1w o fc . Plitm spr s n s mison do sno s tsy et e o t es j nd rr e . I sin f a r a t ani e e t ub s i e t a if ih r f h e oi e uls f pl ntf w ihest pur ue oneorm or oft cl msm entoned i hi curentm oton,hem us fie apr r ai i s o s e he ai i n s r i t l ope compl ntt tcompleswih bot oft e r es. ai ha i t h hes ul 4
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
