Muhammad v. Commonwealth Of Virginia et al, No. 7:2014cv00529 - Document 76 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 01/26/2015. (kab)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
r F= s OFFI U.S. em c r d CE Dl AT ROANOKE, VA FlF! IJ7 - J 2 s ,25 AN 21 I TH E U NI N TED STA TES DI STRI T CO UR T C FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A ROANO KE DI SI VI ON ABDUL- U ZA W ALIM UHAM M AD, H JULI C. A D , BK DEP CLERK CASE NO .7: 14CV00529 Pl ntf , ai if V. M EM O M N D UM O PI O N NI CO M M O N W EA LTH OF VI G I I , R N A W K , By:Gln E. nr d e Co a Chi fU nied St e D i t i Judge e t at s s r ct Defndants. e t) Abdull nma W al M ul -- z l i mmmad,a Vigi a i e pr e ng pr x , fl t s cvi r ni nmat oc edi o ied hi i l rght a tonpurua t 42 U. C.j 1 i s ci s nt o S. 983.Asnme ndedby or re erd Ocobe 24,201 hi de nt e t r 4, s c antalege t f l ng camsa ns prs ofii satRe Oni Stt Prs ( ) ompli l s he olowi li gai t ion fcal d on ae ion: 1 M uhn d was micasiid on May 21 201 2) M uha d i not r evi a di mma s l sfe , 4;( mma s ec i ng et c itntwih hi rlgi beif ;( M uha d di notr evea fas mea att e of onsse t s ei ous le s 3) mma d ec i e t l he nd Ra da 201 ( adicplnayhe rngofke wr ul f mdM uha dguit ofsg i ma n 4; 4) si i r ai t r ongf ly ot mma ly htng afe I t Br the a tc d hi onJ uay 5,201 ( ofkesf l t i e v net pr e t tr nmae ac r ta ke m an r 4; 5) t r aied o ntr e o otc M t a d d rng t e J n ay 5 atc ; a () a ds iln r h aig o fc r d nid l mma u i h a u r h ta k nd 6 icp iay e rn fie e e M uhn ma duepr s on J y 23,201 on a c r e t tM uhn a urnaed i a c a soom . m d oce s ul 4, ha g ha mm d i t n l s r M thn a i tm por rl c i a Sus e l Stt Prs whe e he wa ta f red f l mm d s e a iy onfned t s x a e ion, r s r nse r or me ia r ao . He n w mo e fr a p ei n r ij n to dr cig t d n iid p io dc l e s ns o vs o r l ay n u cin ie t mi e tfe rs n mi n ofi i sno t ta f rhi ba k t Red Oni n ora ne r prs Afe r vi oft r c d, fcal t o r nse m c o o ny a by ion. tr e ew he e or Muhammad v. Commonwealth Of Virginia et al Doc. 76 t c tde eshi moton. he our ni s i l t pr e moton,M uhn a s yshef r f hi lf i hei ta f re ba k t t n he es nt i mm d a ea s or s ie f s r ns e r d c o he we t r pa tofVigi a,bas d on t f l ng alege e nt .Afe l ae Br t he a t ke se n r r ni e he olowi l d ve s tr nm t a c r tac d M uha m a on J nua y 5,201 a Red Oni M ul m a was c r d w ih fghtng Br t he . m d a r 4, t on, mm d ha ge t i i ac r Dockets.Justia.com CL ERK M ul mmmad lt robt ne a m it sa e ntfom Br t he ,who de e t tM uhamma ha ae ai d ten t t me ' r ac r nid ha d d f ug wih hi t t da o ht t m ha y. Br t he saed t t he at c d M tha a be us f mer a c r tt ha ta ke l mm d ca e or c rci ore tonalofk e T.Thomps ga hi f s i or ton t t M uha a was a s t h. t r on ve m ale nf ma i ha mm d nic M uhnmma saest tprs i si or di a i hoddy' i s i to oft J r 5 i de d t t ha ion nve tgat s d û s ' nve tgai n he anua y nci nt a wr ngl a c e a he ga m e nd o y c us d not r ng mberofputi at t'on M uha a slf M uhn a tng t ' hi mm d' ie. mm d m s t t tt ee nt l vehi i da rofbeng kil i hei r t r d t Re Oni n. s ers ha hes ve s ea m n nge i led f s e u ne o d o Be a e itro uo y ij n tv r l fi a e ta r ia yrme y te p ry s e ig t c us nel c tr n u cie ei s n xr o dn r e d , h a t e kn he e p ei n r ij n to mu tma eace rs wi Eh th i l eyt s c e do temeis ta r l a y nu cin s k la ho ng l a e s i l o u c e n h rt,h t mi t k he i lkey t s f r ir pa a e hn m i t abs nc ofpr i i r r le ,t tt baa e of s i l o ufe re r bl r n he e e elm na y e if ha he lnc e ute tp i hsfv r a dt a a ij n to i i tep bi itr s. W itrv Nama Re . q iis is n i a o , n h t n nu cin s n h u lc nee t' ne . t l s ' De .Co mcl l c,5 5 U. 7 2 (0 ) Ea h o t e e f u fco smu tb s tsid Re l f t i. n . 5 S. , 0 2 08 . c f h s o r a t r s e aife . a Tr t Ab u Ob ma I c v F 5 5F.d 3 2 3 7 (t Ci. 0 9 , a ae o oh rg o n s uh o t n . n . . EC, 7 3 4 , 4 4 h r 2 0 ) v c td n te r u d , 55 U. 1 9 ( 9 S. 08 2010) ri tt i r lva pa4bv 607 F. 355,355 (t Ci 201 ( tng , ensaed n ee nt l 3d 4h r. 0) eii W i e ,555U. a 20) M orove ,plitf mus s mor t n aGposi lt 'ofirpa a e ntr S. t . e r anif t how e ha t sbiiy' re rbl h r rte ,h mus s o t a i n n ,çre aa e ij r i l ev i t e a e e o a am- ah r e t h w h t mmie t t rp rbl nu y s i l n h bsnc f n i k ij ncin. W itr 5 5 U..a 2 ( mp a i i o iia) Fnal ,û p ei nay ijmcin nu to ' ne , 5 S t 2 e h ss n rgn l. i ly t rlmi r nt to ' a ma n v ris et prv n a ij r o ham wh c no e n t mo i p ry c n e d wa y e e su o e e t n nu y r r ih t ve he vng a t o tn s s c us d by t wr cli e i t unde l ng a ton. Om ea W ord Tr ve v. TW A,111F. a e he ong am d n he ryi c i ' ' a l a l 3d 1 1 (t Ci. 9 7 )nr Mir s f Ani u tLii s 3 F.d51 , 2 ( t Ci. 0 3 . 4, 6 4h r 1 9 ) l e co o t tt s tg.3 3 3 7 5 6 4h r 2 0 ) r M tha mad m a none of t e s l m kes hes howi . Fis, li a lgatons do not s ngs r t zs le i how a ny lke i i lhood t thi ta f rba k t Red Oni n i i mi n , o t tt pa tg ng û t'o hi lf ha s r nse c o o s m ne t r ha he s a i ' n s ie hi a Re Ono i sili ef c. Th c u tc n tis ij n tv r l fba e o M u n d s t d in s tl n fe t e o r a no sue n u ci e ei s d n h mma ' e me e s c ai n t tht wo d silbe i d r pe ul to ha ul tl n ange a Re Oni Se nd, M ul r t d on. co mmm a doe not d s 2 i cae t t he ha tl d admi sr tve r m e e a Sus e t i or a ho iis of s cii ndi t ha s ie nitai e di s t s x o nf m ut rte pe fc r s t a ta f r t Re Oni n woul e ng r hi lf . l ed,untlhe ha e use ea ons hat r ns e o d o d nda e s ie nde i s xha td a i s r tve r m e es on t s i s he c dm nit a i e di hi s ue, nnno brng a co ta ton a t i ny ur c i bout i. Se 42 U . C. t e S. j 1 e() M orove ,untlhehasgi n prs ofiil t ne sa y i or i an tmet 997 a. e r i ve ion fcas he ce sr nf maton d i o a e shi c ddr s s once n,he c r anno s w t tc ti e v nton i hi onl m e nsf r le . Thid, t ho ha our ntr e i s s y a or e if r M u a d h s ma e n s o n t t te rq e td ij n to t p e e t hs ta se i h mma a d o h wig ha h e u se n u cin o r v n i rn fr s wa r nt d by t baanc ofequii s o s r s t publc i e e t I i wel esa ihed t t ra e he l e te r e ve he i nt r s . t s l t bls ha cou t m us g ne a l avoi e a e nti prs mana mentdec so . Fi ly,M uha ma rs t e r ly d nt ngl me n ion ge ii ns na l m d f ist de i t a pa t t t sl ws twho ha a pe s li ve e i prs ta f r a l o sgna e ny ry o hi a ui s ny r ona nvol m nt n ion r nse d cso s t wa dwho terq e td ijmcinc ul b dr ce e iin ,o r m h e u se nt to o d e ie td. Fo t s r a o ,te c u tmus d n plitf moin f r itro u o y ij n tv r hee e s ns h o r t e y an ifs to o ne lc tr n u cie r le . An a o it or r wilis t s da The Cl r i die t d t s c es oft s ei f ppr pra e de l s ue hi y. e k s r c e o end opi hi me or ndlm opi on a a co nyi or t pl i if m a z ni nd c mpa ng der o antf. ENTER:Ths (Q #d yo Jn ay, 1 . i a f a u r 20 5 Chi Unied St esDititJ ef t at src udge 3
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
