Muhammad v. Mathena, No. 7:2014cv00529 - Document 191 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/13/2016. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CL RK'OF I U. DlTC Y E S FCC 3. $ .OUN .. AT Ft.IOKH, S-t4 ) VA FiED l - Jtd 13 2 1 / 25 I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF W RGI A CT M R OA N O U DI I O N V SI ABDUL. AM ZA W ALIM UH AM M AD, H Pl ntf ai if, V. R ANDALL CH ARIES M ATHENA, , W K , JULA . I BY: L Dee n t) fnda ts. ABDILJ HAM ZA W ALIM UHAM M AD, ) ) Pl ntf, ai if ) ) ) DR. HAPPY EART SM I c AL. , TH, , ) ) Dee n t) fnda ts. ) CAS NO. 1 CV0 2 3 E 7:6 0 2 M EM OM NDUM OPI ON M By:GlnE.Conr e ad Ch e Unie S a e DititJ e if td t t s src udg Abd - mza W al M t mm a a Vigi a i a e pr ee ng pr K , ha fl d a ulHn i l ha d, r ni nm t oc di o s ie . doc e tte IORDER TO SHOW CAUSE FOR AN PRELI I um nt ild: E M NARY W J UNCTI Ar ON TESV ORARY RESTRAW W G ORDER PURSUANT TO RULE 65 of Fe R. of CI . d. V Muhammad v. Mathena Doc. 191 P ROC. Th c u t o snzst i s miso a amo inf ritro uo yij n tv r le Th ' e o r c n t e hs ub s in s to o nel c tr nu cie eif e ' he ng of t m o i lss t c e num be s f tle cvi aci ns M uhn a i c e l adi he ton it he as r or lr e i l to mm d s un-nty k ptrui des t t s c ts pro or r a sng hi t t t s pr c ie i i oper ls ng, pie hi our' i r de dvii m ha hi a tc s mpr . M UHA M M AD I AD V I S SED TH AT I H E SUBM I A N Y FU TU RE PLEA D I G W I F TS N TH Dockets.Justia.com . # ) CAS NO. 1 CV0 5 9 E 7:4 0 2 ) ) ) ) ) ) ) 1 ABDUL. HAM ZA W ALIM UHAM M AD, ) CA SE N O .7: 6C V 00034 ) Pl ntf, ai if ) ) ) DR. HAPPY EARI SM I c & , , TH, ) ) ' C MULTPLE CAS NUMBEkS m THE HEADW G, I W I BE S E T LL HREDDED UPON RECEP T. Be a s h sc re tmoi n (d n ia i e c o t tr else c s s ae u try c u e i u rn to s ie tc l n a h f he h e itd a e ) r tel wiho me i,howe r t y mus be de e t ut rt ve , he t nid. M uha ma c e m d ontnds t t he i e tted t c ti e ve i bas on t f l ng ha s n il o our nt r nton ed he olowi r e e nt : o tc r al ge y t e e d M uha a t tt y wo d ha hi Gta d'i ec nt ve s fi e s le dl hr atne mm d ha he ul ve m tr pe n Ph s 2 b Gay Go h m ( Bil) (n wn f r rpng p e i u c l ts re c u e ae y r r n Bo l k o y o a i rv o s el ej b j a s ma ( u a d wo t e t eIlm, h ng (iqIlmi n me j i Ch ita iy a dso fln M h mma q n'd nomc sn c a e hs sn c n ,on rsint , n t p iig l ws t ' t ofi r al gedl fl d f le dicplna y c r sa ns M uhn a i r t la i a uis' wo fce s le y ie as s i i r ha ge gai t ; mm d n e a iton f hi flng lws t a or c or s ii a uis nd/ ompl i f m s a ant or boutqt rofk il ;o M a 24,201 Ofk e he t a s n y 6, t r Qule alg dy c le M t a drcal o fnsv na sa tr ae dt t a a ohe i n l e l ald l mma a ily fe i e me nd h e tne ha he nd n t r l e h o fc rwo l Gl 'M l a d i aca so m wi n c me a ;o M a 2 , 1 , n o t r fie u d jl ' z mma n lsr o t o a rs n y 6 20 6 a fke mp h h alg dy tr ae e t G lm ( ummma l fc d m f;a d o c r alg dl tr ae e t le e l h e tn d o t n M l s d a e o ' n x es le e y h e tn d o wih d s t hol howe s o sde r r a i a r lgi us meas M uhn a c e t t t s r , ut i ec e ton, nd e i o l. mm d ont nds ha he e t e t a e r a ,ba e on t r c a e m spe f m e on li i 201 by a doc o --exn st t hr a s r e l s d wo e t l xn ror d lm n 5 tr m ha M u mm a ha c r ct ied asr pes He alo al ge t ti a he pe ng l ws t he has ha d s ha a erz a . s le s ha n not r ndi a ui, ç le d p o e 't theû ss t p t bea tc e Eec u eao t e lb ld Ei aEnth ' t ra y r v n'ha & e u o ta k d b q a s f r a ee h mq s ic .' a wa k ' Bas d on t e alegai ns M uhn a de a e hes l to , mm d m nds a c tqr r die tng prs ofi i l t our de r c i ion fc as o ta f rli per a n l away fo Re Oni n. r ns e zm m ne ty rm d o Be a s it'o u o y ij ci erle i a e ta r i ay rme y t ep ry s edngt e c u e n elc t r nun tv eif s n x r od n r e d , h a t e l h r p ei n r ijmcinmus ma eace rs o n Gh th i l eyt s c e do t emeis t a r l ay n t to mi t k la h wig t a e s i l o u c e n h rt, h t t k he i lke y t s f rir pa a e ha m i t a e e ofpr i na y r le ,t tt ba a e of s i l o ufe re r bl r n he bs nc elmi r ei f ha he l nc 2 ' nt e ute t i h sf v r a dta a ij n to i i t ep b i itr s.1 W i erv Naurl s q i s i n i a o , n h t n n u cin s n h u lc n ee t' i ps t a Re . . De .Comcl l c,5 5 U. 7 2 ( 0 8 . Ea h o t e e f u fco smus be stsid 1 f t ie n . 5 S. , 0 2 0 ) c f h s o r a t r t aife . d. G sun ap ei n r ij n to ba e o l o ap s iii ö irp r beha i ic nsse t t s ig r l ay n u cin s d ny n o sblt f re a a l nn s n o itn l mi y wih'hefc ta ijmcier l fi ç ne ta r i r rme yt tma o l bea r e u n a t 't a t h tn t tv ei s ç x ro dnay e d ha y ny wad d po e a ce rs o n t a t plitf i e t ld t s c rle . I .a 2 (iai n o te ) Th s la h wig h t he an if s ni e o u h eif' d t 2 ctto mitd . u , t ' pl i if mus s antf t how mor t n a û sbiiy' of ir pa a e ha m- r t r he m us s e ha & i lt ' re r bl r pos a he , t how t t ha i ne t Gre a a l ij r i l ey i t e a s n e o a ij n to ' I .(mp ss i mmi n , l rp rbe nu y s i l n h b e c f n n u cin. d e hai n i k ' o i ia) rgn l. M uha a sm o i f i e l ut y r le doe notde o ta ea lke i mm d' ton or nt roc or e if s m nsr t ny i lhood t the ha wils f rir pa a eha m wihou pr l ufe r e r bl r t t omptc t n e ve to ora lkei our i t r n i n ny i lhood o s ce so t f uc s n he m e isofcai sr lt d t t s aleg to . Fis,he ale t tofi r madeve ba t e t t rt l m ea e o he e l a i ns rt lges ha fce s r l hr a s o wihhol prviege , o hn m hi ort alow hi t behn me a cal d hi r i l of e i t d i l s t r m, o l m o r d nd le m acaly f nsve na e . Suc c r ai ns i t y occ r ar t of sonala dir pe tul butt y do m s h onve s to k f he ured, e mpr es i nd ses cf , he not r pr e a vi ai n of M uha a s consiu i e es nt ol to mm d' tt tonaldght . He le v.Le s 1 Fe s nse wi, 53 d. Ap ' 1 9 1 9 (t Ci.2 0 )(iig Co l v Cu d ,6 3 F.d 8 ,8 7 ( 0h Ci.1 79 px 7 , 7 4 h r 0 5 ctn li . n y 0 2 25 2 1 t r 9 ) ns ( ig ta alg to o v r a a us a d h r sme tb g ad ,wi u mo e d no sae fndn h t l ains f eb l b e n a a s n y u r s t t r, o t tt e ho a y c n ttto a cam) M o e v r Mu n d s moi n is l rfe t t tt e otc r ' n o siuin l li . ro e , h mma ' to tef elcs ha h f e s i alege t e t we e e y o s The c tcn l d hr a s r mpt ne . our nnot fnd t t M thn mad' sa e f ar of i ha l m s tt d e s r t laor physca a tc a i o t e al ge tle t ar s t e evi nceofi mi nt e ai t y i l ta ks dsng m hes le d lr a s e ufki nt de m ne , ir pa a ehn m worhy oft r que t i e l ut r r le . r e r bl r t he e sed ntroc o y ei f ' M uhamm ad alo r ue t a tm por r r tai ng or . Te por y r sr ni or sar is d onl s eq ss e ay esr ni der m ar e tai ng der e sue y rrl whe temo a tp o e ta hewi s fe ijr i rl fi n tg a td b fr tea v rep ryc ud b aey, n h v n r v s h t l u fr nuy f ei s o rne eoe h d es at o l e l e n tfe a dh v o p rl t t rs o d.S eF d R. v. 6 () S c a od rwo l o l ls u tl u htme oiid n a e p o t y o ep n e e . Ci P. 5b . u h n re ud ny at nis c i mi a ah aig o apei n r ijn to c ul bearn e . Asi i ce rfo teo te ta Mu mma i n t s e rn n rl ay nu cin o d ra g d mi t s la rm h us t h t ha d s o e tldt ap ei n r ijncin,h c t'fn n b ssu o whiht ga t m atmpoayrsriigod r nie o rl ay nu to te out ids o a i p n c o rn hi e rr etann r e. t mi Se ond,M uhn a a lge t ofi r br ug f le dici i r c r sagans hi c mm d le s hat fce s o ht a s s plna y ha ge i t m. S h a s rinsao d no gv rs t a y c nsiuin lcam a to a eu d rj1 8 . S e uc se to lne o t ie ie o n o ttto a li cin bl n e 9 3 e Rih r s n v. y 49 Fe . p' 3 5 3 6 (t Ci. 1 )(i dn ta a s n s mee ie c c ad o Ra , 2 d Ap x 9 , 9 4h r 20 2 fn ig h t b e t o vd n e t tc le d dicplna y c c i wasi ope l o ane i ae' as e ton t tc r ha halnge s i i r onviton mpr ry bt i d, nm t s s ri ha ha ge wa f lec n tsae j1 8 cam) Fre nv. d o t 8 8F.d 9 9 9 2 5 ( d Ci.1 6 s as a no tt 9 3 li ; e ma Rie u , 0 2 4 , 5 - 3 2 r 98 ) ( od n t a, olnga c ranp o e u a rq ie n saes tsid meealg to o fliid h li g h t s o s e ti r c d r l e ur me t r aife , r l ain f asfe e e i e c o mic n u trp rs wi u mo e d e no saeacam) v d n e r so d c e o t, t t r , o s t tt li . ho Thr ,M u n d ce ry fld t s mo in fr i tro uo y ijmci e rle b fr id h mma la l ie hi to o nel c tr n t tv eif eo e e usi a nita i r m e e , r r ng t o fc r ' c le d a tons I i we l xha tng dmi sr tve e di s ega di he fi e s ha lnge c i . t s l e tb ih dt a u d r4 U. C. 1 9 ea,ap io rc l tb i ga y c u t cinc n en n sa ls e h t n e 2 S. j 9 7 () rs ne amo rn n o r a to o c r i g prs c tonsuntlhehasfr te useda ia ea i sr tver medis Po trv. se ion ondii i ts xha t va lbl dm nita i e e . re Nus l , tq * 5 4U. 51 , 2 ( 0 2 . 3 S. 6 5 4 2 0 ) Fi ly,M uhn a has notme t t r a f urh ee e s oft W i e anays s nal mm d t he hid nd o t lm nt he ntr l i . The c t'n t fnd t tpds budg t r ne ort publc i e e twilbe s r e by t our c nno i ha on e a y eds he i nt r s l evd he c tspa tcpa i i t pr e sofdecdi whe he M uhn a c n be s f l i a c aed a our' rii ton n he oc s i ng t r mm d a a e y nc r er t t Re O ni n. d o As M thn mad ha f ie t m a t nec s a y f c ua s l m s al d o ke he e s r a t l howi f i e l ut y ngs or nt roc or ij ci r l fo a kn ,hi mo in f rs c r le wilb d n e . An a p o rae o d r nun t ei f ny id s to s o u h eif l e e id ve e p r p it r e wilis t s da The Cl r i die t d t s nd c es of t s m e o a l o zi a l s ue hi y. ek s rce o e opi hi m r ndlm pilon nd ac om pa ng or rt pl i tf . c nyi de o a n if ENTER M :Th s l d y o Jme 2 6 i % a f t , 01 . / Chi fUnie St t D i ti tJ e t d a es s r c udge 4
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
