White v. Turner et al, No. 7:2014cv00505 - Document 69 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/8/2015. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
t ct s oyFl U. uju cggr scE , g . ; - srq xoK v . oA k,A IIFD 7 ,L2 BE2 C8 2 5 2 I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STRI T C OU R T C JULA C. ' u FOR TH E W EST ERN DISTRIC T O F V IR G I IA sv: N RO AN O K E D I SI N VI O D DARREL A.W HI TE, Pl ntf, ai if v. DW AYNE A.TURNER,e al, t . De e f ndant. s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) l . E Ci lAci No.7: c 00505 vi ton 14-vM EM ORANDUM OPI ON NI By: Hon. i M chaelF.Ur ki bans UniedSt e Dit c Judge t ats srit Da r lA . hie,a V igi a i a e pr e ng pr K , ie a c vi r g scom pl nt re W t r ni nm t oce di o f l d i l i ht ai p ru n t 4 U.. j1 8 , a n n me o safo t eRe Ono SaePrs n(1 P' a u s a t o 2 SC. 9 3 n mig u r us tf f h d in tt io ç ROS ' s ) de e nt .Pl i ifa lgest tt c tonsofc i me hee re e a ROSP vi a e f nda s antf le ha he ondii onfne nt xpe inc d t olt t Ei h and Foure nt Am e e soft Unie Stt sCo tt i De e he ght te h ndm nt he t d a e nsiuton. f ndan sfld a t ie moi nf rs mmayj d me t a dPli t f e p n e wihac o smo inf rs mmay to o u r u g n , n ani r s o d d t r s to o u r f j d me t ma igti matrrp frds sto Afe r ve ngt erc r , d n Pli tf s u g n , kn h s te ie o ipo iin. tr e iwi h e o d I e y anif moi nfrs mmayj g n a dg a tDe e d n s moinf rs mmayj d me t to o u r ud me t n rn fn a t' to o u r u g n . 1. A. Plitf d ma d d ma e a de u tb ea d ij n tv r l ffrt ef lo n camsl an if e n s a g s n q ia l n nu cie ei o h o lwig li . e @ Cl m 1 ai Pl i ifsmai wa dei r d t t wr c lwhe ea i aewr e ofe i antf l s lve e o he ong el r n nm t ot f nsve c omm e son i be or i wa dei r d t Pli if nt t f e t s lve e o antf. @ Cl m 2 ai White v. Turner et al De e d n J l srf s dt e f reaVignaDe rme t fCor cins(VDOC' fn a t awi e u e o n o c r ii pat n o re to $ & ' ) Ope ai Polc (ç 'byuphol ngaLe l1gre edee nai whih r tng iy 1 ) OP' di ve ivanc tnni ton, c Doc. 69 a l ge y a l le dl lowed de e f ndant Ar rp a Tu ne t S bus gove n e ala ho iy' a t s ti nd r r o s e a r m nt ut r t ' nd o r t i e by kee ng Pl i ifi s gr a i e alat pi a ntf n e eg ton. 1Pl ntf di note e aet cam si t co pl nt buthedi a ai if d num r t he li n he m ai , d doptt cl m nu be sand he ai m r d s rpin u e frDee d ns moinfrs mmayj d n.Co sq e ty tec u t do t tep ris cam ecito s sd o fn a t' to o u r u gme t n e u n l,h o r a ps h at ' li e num besa de crptons r nd s i i . Dockets.Justia.com ' ' @ Cl i 3 am D e e nt Ar rp a Tur ra w e ed Pl i if s i onnalc pl i a f nda s ti nd ne ns r a ntf ' nf om a nt boutt m s l , he e ves w hi pr st i l ons r t i a e ' ofPl ntf . ch ove he r s pi a oral bus s ' c ai i f * Cl i 4 am De e nt Tur ,Arrp, ndLt Da pl e Pl ntf i s gr a i wihoutnotc ora f nda s ner ti a . y ac d ai if n e eg ton t ie f m a I hea i or l CA rng. * Cl i 5 am De e nt Tur ra Lt D a ha Pl i ifm ove t a i ol ton c lt thad f e on f nda s ne nd . y d a ntf d o n s a i el ha ec s t i i oft c l doorbewee Aug t7 a 21 201 De e ntArrp kne a he nsde he e l t n us nd , 4. f nda ti w bout t f ce butdi no do a hi t r m ovei. he e s d t nyt ng o e t * Cl i 6 am On De mbe 1 201 de e nt Co e o St wa t Lt Da c ce r 0, 4, f nda s uns l r e r and . y onduced a t r t no he I hea i t tke Pl i t f i s r ga i i vi l to ofa O P. CA rng ha pt a n if n eg e ton, n o a i n n @ Cl i 7 am OnN o mbe 1 201 de e ve r 2, 4, f ndan Lt St nl ss r i t c t . a y' ubo d na e onduc e a l he rng t d n CA a i t tr om m e d kee ng Pl ntf i s gr ga i ha ec nde pi ai i f n e e ton. . Cl i 8 am Dee d n sM ao Gieh atLt S a l Bu li S p r io M ilr a Tt e wee f n a t j r lr e r, . tny, idng u e vs r le , nd mlr r dei r t l i fe e t a al ge s rousrs ofhn m f cngPl i ifa ar ul ofa lbe a ey ndif r nt o n le d e i ik r ai antf s es t n i t hoa di f ce i a he c l.On Aug t21, 4,Lt Da a Tur rha nma e r hg e s n not r e l us 201 . y nd ne d Pl i ifmovedt t f r e celofa i aewho hashe tts t r byputi Pl i if antf o he o m r l n nm t pa ii, he e tng antf a rs ofc r c i he tts t ik onta tng paii . B. D e enda se a n t r as nsf Pl i if s c i d, nt m z e c i m e i f nt xpl i he e o or a ntf ontnue uni e pt d onf ne nt n s g e ai ni s p r o t i moinf rsl r u g n .Beo eFe r ay2 3 P an if e r g to n u po t f her to o l mma yj d me t f r b u r 01 , litf w a a RO SP,whi h us s a goalore e i e i - e s gr ton hous ng pl n. W he s t c e - i nt d, nc ntve bas d e ega i i a n i a e e bi pos tve be vi s a s c d i co pl tng es a i he goa s oft pr r m , nm t s xhi t ii ha or nd uc ee n m e i t bls d l he og n t y a e r w a de w ih m or pr vie s vi t i s c z iy cl s ica i n. RO SP' Sec iy Le l he r e r d t e i l ge a he r e lr t as i to S urt ve S i a e ar a s s e a as i d t t f l i s c liy l ve s ls e f om m os t l s nm t s e s e s d nd s gne o he olow ng e trt e l , i t d r t o ea t 2 r srcie I tnsveM a a e n (l ' 1 - , M- ,M - , n I - ;S e il a g me t e titv : ne i n g me t çM ' M 0 1 1 I 2 a d M SL6 p ca M na e n ç ) (1 ' SM - SM - SM - a SM- StpDown- ve VIGe r lPopulton;Stucurd GSM' ) O, 1, 2, nd SL6; e Le l ne a ai rte Li ng- e 1 a Pha e 2;a Se urt Le l5 G e r Po a i vi phas nd s nd c iy ve ne al pul ton. Pli ifhadbe n as i antf e sgnedt s gr ga i a s urt lvelSM - TheI tmto o e e ton t ec iy e 2. nsi i nal Clsiiai nAuh rt (I ' rv e dPlitf' ca sfc to i Fe r ay 2 3a d a sfc to t o i $CA' e iwe an ifs lsiiain n b u r 01 n y t ) uli t l r edhi t St cur d Li ng Phas 1.Pl i ifm ove t a S rztze Li ng tma ey educ m o nz t e vi e antf d o t t tr d vi c Pha e 1 c l on M a 1 201 s el y , 3. Thr we kslt ri M ay 201 Pli ifwa ta f n'd t Sus e IStt Prs n ee e a e n 3, antf s r ns e e o s x a e io (t sx' f me c teame .Duet hi Se urt Le lScls ii to Suse hous d s e ' or dialr t nt sus ) o s c iy ve a sfcain, s x e Pli ifi s r ga i whe ehe i ured sx dicplna y i r tonsd i hi o - a say. antf n eg e ton, r nc r i s i i r nfaci urng s ne ye r t Onc Pli ifr t ed t ROSP i M a 201 Pl ntf r ei d anotc t tt l e a ntf eum o n y 4, ai if ec ve ie ha he CA woul c d onduc hi c a s fc t o hea i Pl ntf w aspr e a t I he r ng on M ay 29, t s l s ii a i n rng. ai i f es nt t he CA a i 201 whih uli a ey r s t d i Pl ntf sco i d a sg e i s e ton a Se urt 4, c tm t l e ule n ai if ntnue s i nm nt n egr ga i t c iy Le lS. Si er t ni t ROSP,Pl n ifhasr m ane .i s gr to a i ured a l a t ve nc eur ng o aitf e i d n e egai n nd nc r t e s eghta tonaldicplna y i r c i . i ddii s i i r nfa tons I l. Pli ifa dDe e d n sag ta te aee tte t s mmayj d me t A p ryi ant n fn a t r ue h t h y r n ild o u r u g n . a t s f e tte t s mmayj d me t f h p e dng ,heds o ey a dds ls r maeil o fl, n nild o u r u g n i t e la i s t ic v r n ico u e tras n ie a d a yafd vt s o ta te ei n g n i ds u ea t a ymaeil a t Fe R. v P. 6a . n fi a is h w h t h r s o e une ip t s o n tra f c. d. Ci . 5 () M a e i lf t a e t e nec s ar t es a i h t e e e sofa pa t sc us ofa ton. t r a ac s r hos e s y o t bls he l m nt ry' é e c i An e s nv. b rvLo b s n .47 U. 2 2 2 8( 9 6 .A g nun d s u eo mae l a t d ro Lie t b y l c, 7 S. 4 , 4 1 8 ) e ie ip t f tda f c e s si ,i vi w i t r cor a al r as na e i e e s d a t r f o i a lg m os xi t f n e ng he e d nd l e o bl nf r nce r wn he e r m n i ht t f vor bl t t non- ovi pa t a r as bl f t fnde c d r t n a ve di tf t nona a e o he m ng ry, e ona e ac - i r oul e ur r c or he mova .L. Themovi pa t ha t btr nofs wi -tha i,poi i ou t t ditit nt d . a ng ry s he lde ho ng ç t s ntng t o he src t c t t tt r i a a e e ofe de e t s our - ha he e s n bs nc vi nc o uppo tt no ovi pa t s c s ' Cel e r he nm ng r y' a e. ' ot x Co p v. tet47 U. 31 3 ( 9 6 .I temo a tstsist sbu d n te t en n r . Cart, 7 S. 7, 25 1 8 ) f h v n aife hi r e ,h n h o m ova m us s tf t s c fc, i s bl f c st tde ons r t t exi t nc ofa g nui nt t e orh pe i i adm s i e a t ha m t a e he s e e e ne ds u eo fc frtil I a 3 2 2 .A p ryi e tte t s mmayj d me tft erc r a a ip t f a t o ra . d. t 2 - 3 a t s n i d o u r u g n i h e o d s l whol co d notl a a r tona tiroff tt fnd i f vo oft non- o .W ila sv. e ul e d a i l re ac o i n a r he m vant lim Grfi, 2F.d8 0 8 3( t Ci.1 91.t eeu u p re s e uain . .sn te u ht ifn 95 2 2 , 2 4h r 9 ) t r ns p o td p c lto . i o no g o M d fa as mmayj g n mo in' Er sv. tl sno Bu . Ed c Ra i. n .5 F.d ee t u z ud me t to . mi Na' As ' f s & u . do l c, 3 3 ' 5 , 2( t Ci.1 9 ) A p an ifc n o u ear s o et amoin f rs mma yj d me t o 5 6 4h r 9 5 . litf n n t s e p ns o to o u r u g n t a n o c re t c mp an c alng dbyad fnd n ' mo inf rs mmayj g n .Se me d r o r c a o lit h le e ee a ts to o u r ud me t e Cla ig rv. c vt 5 5F.d3 4 3 6( t Ci. 0 9 (o igta aplitf yn t o nn e M De i 5 3 2 , 3 4h r 2 0 ) n tn h t an ifma o t a n ac mpan tlo g ag me ti ab ifo p sn s mma.j d me t. me d o litl u h r u n n re p o ig u l u g n) r y 111. De e nt a guet tcli 5 i ba r d be a ePl i iff ie t e us ad i sr tve f nda s r ha a m s re c us antf al d o xha t m nitai rme isa ia l vi Op rtn Pr c d r (ç ' 8 6 1 wh c i tea mi itaier me y e de valbe a eaig o e u e < ) 6 ., ih s h d nsrtv e d OP' pr n f rVDOC i t .OP 866. pr de i t st a lt t r ol c ogr m o nma es 1 ovi s nma e he biiy o es ve ompli s ant , a ala i sr tvede sons a c lngepolcesa pr e es2 Al is a e gre bl ppe dm nitai cii , nd hale i i nd oc dur . 1 s ues r iva e e pti tt i c ctonsa m a tr beyond t VDOC' c r . xce nsiutonal onvi i nd te s he S ontol Prort s i o ubm itng a gdeva e, he i a e m us m a a good- aih e f ' t i or l ti nc t nm t t ke f t f ol o nf maly t r s ve t i s by s i tng a i or a co pl ntf e ol he s ue ubm ti n nf m l m ai onn, hi h i a ia e i ho i l is w c s va l bl n usng m t . How e ,a i a e i notr r d t fl a i onna co pl ntt r por i s s ofs xua abus ver n nm t s equie o ie n nf l m ai o e t s ue e l e. 2I tsa eo intd t t i t g iva epr dur whe t e ert VDOC' cusod a whe nmae r re e o he nma e re nc oce e n hey nt he S t y nd n t ar ta fn'dt ohe VDOC fciii . hey e rnse e o t r a ltes I t i s i no i or a l r s ve t i a e m us fl a r ul. gr e nce wihi f he s ue s t nf m ly e ol d, he nm t t ie eg a i va r t n t r y c l nda da f o t da e oft occ r nc ori i nt3 Re a g i va e t tdo not hi t a e r ys r m he t he ur e e nc de . gul r r e nc s ha mee t flng r quie t he ii e r ment ofOP 8 1a er t ne t t i t wihi t wor ng da s 66. r eur d o he nma e t n wo ki ys fom t da eofr eptwih i tuci ns whe pos i e,a uthow t i a emayr me a r he t ec i t nsr to , n sbl bo he nm t e dy ny de i i nc .4 A n i a e m a ap a a i a dec s on by s ndi t greva a l t i a fce y nm t y pe l n nt ke i i e ng he i nce rd he nt ke de son t ar gi om buds a wihi fveda ofr cept The e i no f rhe r viw oft cii o e onal m n t ni ys e i . r s ' t r e e u he i a dec s o nt ke i i n. Forc ai 5,Pl i ifa l gest tde enda sTt m e a D a pl e hi i a c l wih lm a ntf le ha f nt u r nd y ac d m n e l t f c on t dooron A ugus 7, 4.H ow e r t e i no r co d t tPl i iffl d a r ul r e es he t 201 ve , her s e r ha a ntf ie eg a gre nc a iva e boutt f ce on hi door Pli ifsc l i n, t he e s s . antf' onc uso wihouts uppor t tt gre nc q ha he iva e r co dsar fa e f ist s scen l e tbls t tl ny de e t i e usi we e ... e r e r udul nt al o uf i ty sa ih ha i a f c s n xha ton r pr ur fom t a ton ori ci ofprs n ofi i l.'Aguia - la dav. re l 478 F. oc ed r he c i na ton io fc a s' l rAvel ve Te r l, 3d 1 2 ,1 2 (0lCi. 0 7; enc nv Su h l 3 4F.d1 3 ,1 3 -3(0hCi. 0 ) 2 3 2 5 1 t r2 0 )Jria . tc el 0 3 0 0 0 23 1 t r20 2 . 1 , Ac o dngy Dee da t aee tte t s mmayj d me tfrcam 5d et Plitf fiu e c r i l, fn ns r nild o u r u g n o li u o anifs al r t e us a l e adm i s r tve r m e es o xha t vaiabl ni t a i e di . 1 . V Dee d nt aee tte t s mmayj g n fra1o Plitf se h use cams fn a s r n ild o u r ud me t o l f an if x a td li . Pli ifco pl i t thi mai wa de i r d t t wr i ae, a ntf m ans ha s l s lve e o he ong nm t who wr e ofe i ot f nsve c m e son t m ai t tPl ntf l t rr ce ve Pl i ifdoe notalege a def nda ' om nt he l ha ai if a e e i d. a ntf s l e nt s pe s li veme wih t scai a Pl i ifdoe notde c i t de i ton ofargh r ona nvol nt t hi l m, nd antf s s rbe he prva i i t 3ReB a g i anc m a r ei t eelvel ofr viw . A fcly' wad no speitn e t o d cs ulr rev es 4 ec ve hr e s e e aii s re r u rned n cn ut t t fr t S e ll'rvi I t l aei uns tsi wiht Leve Ideer i ton,he i aem a a alt he is,t ve ' e ew. f he nm t s aifed t he l t m nai t nm t y ppe he dee m i ton wihi fveda ofr ei t Lev I,whih i us ly doneby ar gi ombuds an.Fo m os tr na i t ni ys ec pt o el l c s ual e onal m r t is ,Le 1 i t fnallvelofr ew.Fort fw is sappe a et Lev 11 t i a ema a alhe sues vel 1 s he i e evi he e sue albl o el 1, he nm t y ppe t Lee 1d tr nto wi i fv dy o rcitt teDe t Dietro Dietro teVDOC. v l14 emiain t n ie as f eej o h puy rco r rco fh e h A copyoft i a de son i ke l t i ae' g iva efl he nt ke cii s pt n he nm t s re nc ie. 5 p oe tdb f d rllw. S e eg, nesv. il ms 47 U. 3 7 3 0 31( 9 6 ; ihe v. r tce y e ea a e p ..Da il W li , 4 S. 2 , 3 - 1 8 ) F s r a W a hnlo Mer Ar aTrn iAuh r, 9 F.d 1 3 ,1 4 - 3( t Ci.1 8 ) Vin d ev. s i n to. e a st to .6 0 2 1 3 1 2 4 4h r 9 2 ; n e g Gi ,55 F. 926,928( h Ci 1 .Si lry,Pl ntf c ansa Defnda s bbs 0 2d 4t r. 977) mial ai if ompli bout e nt' r pons t hi gre nc ,butsae i t sdo no ha ac tt i nal pr e t d rg t es es o s iva es t t nma e t ve onsiuto ly ot c e i ht o a c s g iv n ep o e urs Ad msv Rie 40F.d7 , 5( t Ci.1 9 ) çll ln a an ta c e s re a c r c d e . a . c , 3 2 7 4h r 9 4 . ç tu ig g i s l p o e o a a mi srtv c mpli t o sn t a s o c nrbuet ( c nsi in l ds n r n n d nitaie o an d e o c u e r o ti t o a o tmto aj vi ato 'a t çheei nolabiiyunde j1 f aprs a nitaorsrs ns t a ol in' nd hatt r s i lt t r 983 or ion dmi sr t ' epo e o giva eora agq'Br v.Va. p' ofCon' No.6: c 00033,200 U. Dit LEXI re nc ppe l.' own De t . , 07-v9 S. s. S 3 2 , t* - 9, 09W L 8 4 9 a *1 ( . Va J n. , 0 )( o n J) Plitf n no 0 2 a 484 20 7 5 , t 3 W D. . a 9 20 9 M o , . an ifc n t . hol D e e nt labl as s r i or unde r nondea s ror a he f is t es a i h a d f nda s i e upe k s s r es t upe i , nd a l o t bls ny de e ntsdei r t i fe e e Se e. , onel v. p' ofSoc.Se vs,436 U. 658,663 f nda ' lbe a e ndif r nc . es :.M l De t r . S. n. ( 9 8 ; ha v S r u ,1 F.d 7 1 7 9( t Ci. 9 4 .Plitf' alg to sta 7 1 7 ) S w . to d 3 3 9 , 9 4h r 1 9 ) anifs le ain h t de e nt vi a e va i o r tng pr edze o polc e do noti plc t f de a duepr s f nda s olt d rous pe a i oc lr s r ii s m iae e r l oce s a aeno c nia ecams Ricov.Cnt ofFara VA,907F. 1459,1 ( hCi. nd r t og z bl li . c i y. ifxp 2d 469 4t r 1 ) 990 . Pl i ifaloale st thewa bre l plc i a c l wih f ce ont door Eve i antf s l ge ha s ify a ed n el t e s he . nf t e, hi c ton i nots a ypi ala t co tt e a ls g fca ha ds p o t i a e i nz t s ondii s o t c s o ns iut çi ni i nt r hi n he nm t n r lto t t eo diayicd n so p io l e' S n i v Co n r 51 U. 47 48 ( 9 5 . f eain o h r n r n ie t f rs n i . a dn . n e , 5 S. 2, 4 1 9 ) c . f' , Be eai S t,1 0F.d5 0 5 3(t Ci. 9 7 ( o dn t a a miitaies g e ainfr v rt v. mi 2 3 0 , 0 4h r 1 9 ) h l ig h t d nsrtv e r g to o h sx mont wih ve mi htma wase;foodedt lt t a a ehe ;c d f i hs t r n; l n t l oie ' mbe r bl at ol ood;dit c ot ng, , ry l hi lnens a be ng;l rpe i i c l no ou s de r r a i no e a i i , nd ddi onge rods n el; t i ec e ton; duc tonalorr lgi e i ous sr c ;a l sf wa nots ay c a t i esgnii ntha ds p) Ftrhe e, e vies nd es ood s o tpial s o mpos i fca r hi . lt nnor Pl i ifhasnotpr s nt any e de e ofa s r ous m e c lo e otona de e i a i c us d. a ntf e e ed vi nc ny e i di a r m i l t r or ton a e by t alege e he l d xpos et a he i t sil s o f c . Se eg. Sti klrv. ae s 989 ur o not r nma e' lne s r e es es . , rc e W t r , F. 1 1 0( h Ci.1 . 2d 375, 38 4t r 993) Pl i ifscas i a i hea i orr s t di notvi a eduepr e s TheFouree t antf' l sfc ton rngs e uls d olt oc s . t nh Am e e tsDuePr e sClus pr e t pe s a i tde i tonsoflf ,lbe t or ndm n ' oc s a e ot cs r ons gans prva i ie i ry pr pe t To pr ve a vi a i ofdue pr s , he i a e m us be a e t s o ry. o ol ton oce s t nm t t bl o how t tt ha he gove ue de i d hi ofalbe t it r s. Se .e. ,Sa n,51 U . a 478- To nu nt prve m i ry n e e t e c. ndi 5 S. t 79. d mo taeal ryitr s, imaemu ts o ( )ted na o mln ee t h tc naie e nsr t i t n ee t ml n t s h w 1 h e il f itr s t a a rs be et e fo t Co siuin i efo fo saelwso poiis a dt t 2 t d na i s d ih r r m he n t to t l r r m tt a r l e , n ha ( ) he e ilmpo e t s c onhi a aypiala sg fc thads p.Preov. ake 780F.3d245, ( hCi.201 . m n t c nd iniian r hi it Clr , 251 4t r 5) Eve i asa el w o polcyr quiesbot s tntve c ie i a apr edur lpr s t m a n f tt a r i e r h ubsa i rtra nd oc a oce s o ke c a sfc ton decsons t lw orpolc doe no c e t ac tt i ly pr t t d lbe t l s ii a i ii , he a i y s t r ae onsim ona l o ece i ry i e e ti ar vi wi a hort hast dic e i t o ni acas ii a i de son pr e nt r s f e e ng ut iy he s r ton o ve de l sfc ton cii opos d unde t 1w orpolc Sl a v. t 21F. 590,595( h Ci.1 . r he a iy. ez k Evat 3d 4t r 994) TheDie t roft VDOC c e t d acls ii to s tm ,OP 8 1 ptr ua t Vigi a r co he rae a sfcai n yse 30., ls nt o r ni Co ej5 .- 2..VDOC' OP 8 01p o i e o po tnte f rrv e a drj cino te d 31 3 1 S 3 . r v d s p ru iis o e iw n ee to f h I Scls ii ton r c me tonsa doesnotma t apa tc a cl sfc ton de ii . CA' a sfca i e om nda i nd nda e ' i ulr as ii ai r c son Cons que l neihe Vigi aCodej53.- 1norOP 8 1c e t ac tt i ly e nty, t r r ni 132. 30. r aes onsiutonal pr e t lbe t i e es f rPl i ift be i apa tc a c t c a sfcai ot ced i ry nt r t o antf o n riulr usody l s ii ton. Si e Pli ifhasno lbe t it r s i be ng ho ed a a pa tc a prs or nc antf i ry n e e t n i us t ny riul r ion cl sfcai n wih l sr titveco to ,Pl n ifsi r e ai n a ROSP doe notvi a e as i to t es esrc i ndii ns aitf nca c r to t s olt d ep o e s S e eg, e c u v. n 4 U. 21 , 2 - 5( 9 6 ($ ec n ito h s u r c s . e s ..M a h m Fa o, 27 S. 5 2 4 2 1 7 ) 1 Th o vcin a s ici nty e i s t de e nt slbe t i er s t e pow e t St t t c uf e l xtngui hed he f nda ' i r y nt e t o m r he a e o on/neii i lm n a yo isp io . Ac o dn l De e a t aee tte t sl r j d me t a dPlitf n f t rs ns' c r igy, fnd ns r nild o l ). mma y u g n , n anifs moin frs mmayj g n i d n e . to o u r ud me t s e id Fo t ef r g i gra o s Dee d ns moinf rsl r j d me ta t alfd rl r h o e o n e s n , fn a t' t o t o mmay u g n s o l e ea cai i gr nt d.Thec tg a sPli ifsmotonst a ndhi m oto f rs ma y l ms s a e our r nt antf ' i o me s i n o um r j d me tp ru n t Fe ea Rueo CiiPr c d r 1 a dFo nv. vs 3 U. 1 8 u g n, u s a t o d r l l f vl o e u e 5 n ma Da i, 71 S. 7 , 1 2( 9 2 .Th c u t e e Plit fsmoin f rs mmayj dg n ,ods s d fn a t' 8 1 6 ) e o r d nis ani f to s o u r u me tt imis ee d n s mo inf rs to o ummayj d me t t srk , o s cin , o p y ia a dme tl vau to s a d r u g n ,o ti e f r mlto s fr h sc l n n a e lain , n f Q nty ofpr e ton on Pli ifspe s n pr pe t 'a m e ils a unwa r nt d. The c t or t r e ot c i antf r o o ry' s rte s nd ra e our ds se a ysaelw camswi u p eudc p ru n t 2 U. C. 1 7 c () imis s n tt a li t t rj ie u s a t o 8 S. j 36 ( )3 . ho EN TER : Thi s l da ofD e m ber 201 y ce , 5. 5 f* 4 .J /.W A Unied St t Diti tJ t aes src udge '
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
