Robinson v. Marion Correctional and Treatment Center et al, No. 7:2014cv00383 - Document 10 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 9/3/2014. (tvt)

Download PDF
cL :oFnccu.s. sm cour ' tol AT > VP ? vA LL FL lEnmotfyp e I THE UNI STATESDI CT COURT N TED STRI FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI CT RGI A NI ROANOKE DI SI W ON A D RI R O BI SO N , AN N Pl nt f , ai i f V. M ARI CORRECTI ON ONAL AND TREA TM E NT C EN TER ,e aI, t . Dee f ndant . s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) sEP C3 2 1 21 2 LAc. Dt c Ul . c B ;éG Y D EPUW CLE Ci lA c i N o.7: 4- v- 38 vi t on 1 c 00 3 M EM OM NDUM OPI ON NI By: H on.Jacls L.Kier ton s Se o Uni e St e Di t i tJudge ni r t d at s s r c Ad in Robi on,aVigi ai ae pr e ng pr K ,fl d aci lrght Compl i ra ns r ni nm t oc edi o ie vi i s ant purua t 42U. C.j1 3.Pl ntf na va i safoft Ma i Core tonala s nt o S. 98 ai if mes rous tf he ron rci nd Trame Ce e (t e t nt ntr CMCTC' asdeenda s Pli ifcompli t thes dha be n ' ) f nt. antf ans ha houl ve e al lowedt a a asa ei untr commime or ra t tde e o ppe l t t nvol a y t nt de nd ha f ndan Sgt Pa ea Shum ae t . m l t di no ma c esofdoc e t i tmef Pl ntf t fl t m i t f r la al.Thi d t ke opi um n s n i or ai if o ie he n wo ede a ppe s s ma tri be or m ef s r ni , purua t 28U. C. 1 A. Afe rviwi Pl nifs te s f e or c ee ng s nt o S. j 915 l tr e e ng aitf s b sins lds s t a to wi o tp eu ief rf iigt saeacam u o whihr l f u miso , imis he cin t u rj d c o aln o tt li p n c ei h e m ay be gr ed. ant l1muS dimisa aci orcl m tldby a i t i ldeer net t a i orcai i fi ousorf l t s s n ton ai ie n nmae f t mi hat he cton l m s rvol ais t saeacam o whihrle ma b ga td S e28U. C. j1 5e() 1 5 b ()4 U. C. 1 9 ec. o tt li n c eif y e rne . e S. j 91 ()2 , 9lA()l' 2 S. j 9 7 () , Thefrtsa r i udescl msba edupon d n i s a y me ils lga t y 'S ai ofi rnge ntofa is t nda d ncl ai s t ndiputbl rte s e l heol 'i ms nfi me a cl Igalit es whih cl ry doe no e s 'orcli whe et dfctllcontnto a ecea l ba el s' Neizke e ner t c ea l s t xit' ams r he ta ta e ins r l ry s es.' t v W iims 4 0U.. 9 3 7(9 9 .Th sc n sa d r itefmia sa d r framoint ds s u d r . l a , 9 S 31 , 2 1 8 ) e e o d tn ad s h a l r tn ad o l i to o imis n e Fe ea Rueo Ci lP o e u e1 0 6, c e t gapanifsfcua alg to sa tu .A c mpan n e sC d rl l f vi r cd r 2 94 )a c pi litf a t l l ain s re o lit e d d n e a s o t n pli sae nt ft cam s o n t th pe d ri e tte t rl f a ds f e tEfa ta h r a d an ttme o he li h wig ha te la e s nild o ei ' n ut n ç jcu l e ki g ale tons...t r s arghtt r ifa lgai o aie i o ele bovet s cultvelve....'BelAt.Co p.v.Twom bl 550U . 5 he pe ai e l ' l l r v, S. 44, 5 5(0 7 (nena q oainmakso te ) A plitf' b ssfrrle ie ursmoeta lb l a d 5 2 0 ) itr l u tto r mi d . anifs ai o eifû q ie r h n a es n t r c n l ins. .' 1 Th rfr , plitf mutt l g fcss fiin t saealheee nso ( e cam. o cuso . . d. eeo e a anif s t l e a t ufce to tt 1t lme t f t l li ' ' ae h ' Basv. lDu n d Ne u s& Co, 2 F.d7 , 6 (t Ci. 0 ) s E.. po t e mo r .3 4 3 61 7 5 . h r20 3. 4 Deer ni whet rac t mi ng he ompl ntsa e aplusbl cai f r i i (ac e -pecii t kt tr quiest ai tt s a i e l m or elef s i ontxts fc as ha e r he rve n c u toda o i j dca e p re c a dc mmo sn e' Asco v lb l5 6U. 6 2, 7 - 9 e iwig o r t rw n t u iil x ein e n o n e s . h r : .q a, 5 S. 6 6 8 7 s ' (00 ) Th s ac ut ce nngac mplitu d rRue1 ( )6 c nie tf pe dn sta aen te tldt a 2 9 . u , o r s re i o an n e l 2 b() a d niy la ig h t r o nie o n t asum pto oft t be aus t conss ofnom o et n lbel a concusons I Alhough1lbe al c t ea s in ruh c e hey it r ha a s nd l i . d. t i r ly onsru nr .K o c mpan, ie v Ken r 4 4U.. 9 5 021(9 2, d no a t sa imae' a v c t, u s o e o litHan s . re, 0 S 51 , 2 - 1 7 )I o t c a n n t s d o ae s a p nt de o ng saut y a c tt tona cli snotcla l r ie i ac pli . Se Br kv. rol,107F. 241, velpi t t or nd onsiui l am e ry as d n om ant e oc Car l 3d 2 3(t Ci. 9 7 ( ti, ,c n u i l Be u et . t o Ha tn 7 5F. 1 7 1 7 (t Ci.1 8 ) s4 4h r 1 9 ) Lu t J, o c n ng; a d tv Ciy f mpo , 7 2d 2 4, 2 8 4h r 9 5 ,e g .e as God nv Leke 5 4F.d 147 l 51(t Ci. 9 8 (e o nzn ta adsrc c u tsn t x ce t lo ro . e , 7 2 1 , 1 4h r 1 7 ) rc g iig h t itit o r i o e petd o asum et r eofa s he ol dvocaef apr K pant t. t or o li i) f , l a e ha a c tt tona rg t r as bl ac es t co t t c l nget r nm t s ve onsiu i l i ht o e ona e c s o urs o hale hei c ci nsorvi c t t i consiutonalrght . Se Boundsv.Smih,430 U. 81 8 onvi to ndia e her tt i i s e t S. 7, 38 ( 977 .Therg ofr s na ea c st c t çsa layt t undel ngcli wihout 1 ) iht ea o bl c es o ours ' ncilr o he ryi am, t i whih apli ifca ha s fr ij ybybei s outofco t' Cl sophe v. c antf nnot ve ufeed nur ng hut ur.' uit r Habur 536U. 403, 1 ( r v, S. 4 5 2002) Thus i or rt pladaba r l ngdenilof . ,n dç o e ckwa d ooki a r as na e a ce st c t cli ,Pli ifmus s ii al i ntf anon-rvol l alc am e o bl c s o ours am antf t pecfc ly de iy fi ous eg l i t ta de e n ' a tonspr ve e hi fom ltgai I a 41 1 Le sv.Cas v,51 U. ha f nda ts c i e nt d m r ii tng. d. t 5- 6; wi e 8 S. 343,35 n. (1 .Thi rquieme mea Pli ift tcomef wadwihs mehi 3 3 996) s e r nt ns antf t mus or r t o t ng m or t n va a c l or a lga i ofi ve e ordely i hi i tga i or e ha gue nd oncus y le tons ncon nince a n s nsi ton pr ec i ofl ala tons ...Thef c t ta i t ma notbea et ltgae i e ty t os uton eg c i . a t ha n nma e y bl o ii t n xacl he mn n rh d sr si n ts fkin t d mo srt t a t l nu yee n o a a c s t c u t n e e e ie s o u f e t o e n tae he cua ij r lme t f n c e s o o rs cl m . Godfe v.W as nc on Cn v.Va.She if No.7: c 001 2007 U. Dit LEXI ai ' ' ry hi t t . . rf , 06-v- 87, S. s . S 6051 a *39,2007W L 2 28,a *1 ( . Va. 9, t 4057 t 3 W D. Aug.1 2007 ( k,J)(ii Le s 518 7, ) Tur . ctng wi, U. a 3 ) S. t 51 . Pli tf i nttest e c vi pr e di t whi h a es t c t wa a lgedl a n if de ii hr e i l oc e ngs o c cc s o ours s le y fusr t a uns i a r taed: n pecfed ppea t t Supr m eCour oft Unied St t ;Adre v.Unknown, l o he e t he t aes in a a n ppea t t Cour ofAppe l f t Fo t Cic t a a a a t t Supr m eCour of l o he t a s or he urh .r ui; nd n ppe l o he e t Vigi a f a i lmtr c r ni or n nvo t a y omm im e o de e e e by aVigi acic tc t Pl i ifdoe t nt r r ntr d r ni r ui our. antf s notdes r be a ba i f a oft a c i ny s s or ny he ppea s Cons q nty,Pl i iff is t i ntf a nonl. e ue l a ntf a l o de i y fi ousl ga ca m t twa r t d consiutona l pr ece a ce st c t.2 rvol e l li ha ran e tt i ly ot td c s o ours 2Fed alcou tr co dsr ve a a alt t Supr m e Cour oft Unied St t sby Pl ntf i Robi on v. er r e r e al n ppe o he e t he t ae ai i f n ns Bar k H.Oba No.11708 TheU. DititCour f t Ease nDititofVigi aa Cour ofAppe s ac ma, - 9. S. src t or he tr src r ni nd t al f t Fourh Cic tdimis t unde l ng a ton a a l r pe tvel asfi ous.Robi onv. or he t r ui s sed he ryi ci nd ppea, es ci y, rvol ns Obama , No. :1c -0 0 , l o a 2( D. . g. , 01) a p a dimisd No. 17 8 (t Ci. 0l ) Th 11 -v0 8 8 si p.t E. Va Au 3 2 1, p e l s se , l - 0 9 4h r2 1. e p Furhe mor Pli iff ist i ntf t def nda who f u tatd ac es t t Su e e t r e, antf a l o de iy he e nt r sr e c s o he pr m Cour ofVigi af a a aloft saecic tcour' i l a y c t r ni or n ppe he t t r ui ts nvo unt r omm ime or n3 Se t nt de e Fiherv.W as ngonMeto. e TrnstAut .690F. 11 11 43( hCi.1 , s hi t r Ara a i hor, 2d 33, 42- 4t r 982) a oaa e pqot Rr br t d her ounds)yCnt ofRie sdev. c . y. v ri M Laughln,500U. 44( 991 i S. 1 ) . (e ogni ngj 1 r quiesas ngofperonalf tont patofadee r c zi 983 e r howi s aul he r fndantet rbasd ihe e o t def nda ' pe s lco n he e nts rona nduc ora t r sc t no he ' onduc i exe uton oft de e ntspolc e tn c i he f nda ' ii s o c t ) M orove ,hef tt tprs saf ma notha co idwihcore tona r usoms. e r t ac ha ion t f y ve mple t rci l polci orpr edur sdoesnotsa ea c tt tonalc am . See e. , t d Stt sv.Ca e es i es oc e tt onsiu i li . c.Unie a e cr , 4 U.. 41 7 2 5 ( 9 ) Ricov. t o F ifx 9 7F.d 1 5 ,1 6 (t Ci.1 9 ) 40 S 7 , 5 - 5 1 78 ; c i Cny. f ara , 0 2 4 9 4 9 4h r 9 0 . Fo tef rg i r a o s Ids s t eCo litwi u p eudc f rf iigt saea r h o e ong e s n , imis h mpan t t rj ie o aln o tt ho cai upon whi r le m a be g a e Bec us Pl i ifspe ng moton t a nd doesnot lm ch ei f y r nt d. a e antf ndi i o me r emedyt i ufi i y oft Compl i a s e onl l a t fl a ame he ns tcenc he ant nd e ks y e ve o ie n nded c ompl nti ai n t f me t motont n ndi denidasf tl See e. , d. Ci P.1 a( ;Fo nv. he ut ,he i o me s e uie. . a.Fe R. v. 5()2) ma Davi,371U. 178,182(96 . s S. 1 2) ENTER: i Y cgd yo S pe r2014. Ths a f e tmbe , m ' Se ' Unie Stt sDititJ or t d a e src udge Supr meCour oft Unie Stt hasde e Pli ifspeii f awrtofce tor r. e t he td aes nid antf ' tton or i ri ai Fede a cour r cor as r ve t tt appe i Adre v. r l t e ds lo e alha he aln in Unknown wa dimis bec us t Co tof s s sed a e he ur Ap e l lc e jrs ito o e tea peldo d rwhihwa n tt l roh r s a p aa l.No. 27 8 si p as a k d uidcin v r h p ae r e, c s o i o tewie p e lbe na 1 -5 5,l p o a 1( t Ci. a 28 201 ) p. t 4 h r M y , 3 . 3Inot t tPl ntf ale st tt i untr commime or re erd i No mbe 201 wa vald f e ha ai if lge ha he nvol a y t nt de nt e n ve r 3 s i or o y l da andt tprs ofi al woul havet fl ar es wiht saecicui c tt r new t nl 80 ys ha ion fci s d o ie equ t t he tt r t our o e he iv u tr c mm i n f ra o h r1 0 d y p ro Se VA. E j 3 .- 1 , 7.- 1 4 n oln a y o t t o n t e 8 a e id. e COD j 72 8 7 3 2 8 7. me

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.