Noel v. Kumer et al, No. 7:2014cv00200 - Document 41 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/16/2014. (tvt)

Download PDF
CL SOFFI U.. SX COUM ERK' CE 3 DI AT CH ARLOU ESVI E, L VA FIED L J 16 2 1 UL 29 I TH E UN ITED STA TES D ISTR ICT CO U R T N W ESTERN D ISTR ICT O F V IR G INIA R O A N O K E D I ISIO N V R O N N IE A .N O EL , 2L U1 U L YMAR DE Ik K E BY: C I IL A C TIO N N O .7: V 14CV 00200 Pl ntif ai f , V. M EM O M N D UM O PI I N N O LT.C O L.K U M ER ,ET A L. , By: G l E.C onrad en C hi U nied St es Di t ctJudge ef t at s ri D ef endants . Ronni A. e Noel apr ti lde aneepr ee ngpr > f l a c vi rght c pl i , e-ra t i oc di o q, ied i l i s om a nt - purua t 42U. C.j1 3 a i tva i safa e ii asocae wiht Al ma ls nt o S. 98 gans rous tf nd nttes s itd t he be re Chaltes leRe ona J i ('a1'.Prs ntybeor t co taepli ifsmotonf rot vil gi l al k i' e e l f e he ur r antf' i or J ) di c r and m oton t c pe . Pl i if s m oton f di c r a kst c tt m ake s ove y i o om l a ntf i or s ove y s he our o uns c fe def nda s g ve pl i ifa co oft i nt y 1 de c i ng pl i if s pe ii d e nt i a ntf py he nve or og s rbi a ntf pos es i c i ca e durng booki and t J i ' vi r c di ofpl ntf bei booked s s ons onfs t d i ng he a l s deo e or ng ai if ng i o t J l Pl ntf sm oton t c pe as t c tt m a uni ntfed J i s a fr t n nt he ai. ai if i o om l ks he our o ke de ii a l t f e ur pl ntf suni ntted t ega doc e s't hi a t he ga t m t sa f s ve a da a f ai if de ii t l um nt ' o m fer l ve he o t f e r l ys go or phot opyi oc ng. N o def nda hasye r pond t t com pl i , pl ntf ha no c tf e t the e nt t es ed o he a nt and ai i f s t eri i d ha a t m pt t c erwih def nda si g te ed o onf t e nt n ood f ih a a t boutdi c s over A c or ngl pl ntf s y. c di y, ai i f moinsa tdic yaeDENI wiho prj c asprmaur Tot e e pli ifs to bou sover r ED t ut eudie e t e. he xtnt antf moint c to o ompe ca beco tue asamoinf rapr i na yij to t r ueti as l n nsr d to o elmi r nuncin,he eq s s lo D EN I because pl ntf f l t esablsh t he i lkel t suf erir abl har i t ED ai if ais o t i hat s i y o f r epar e m n he a enc ofpr lm i r r le ,he i lkel t s ce d on t m e is oft unde l ng a ton,t bs e e i na y e i f s i y o uc e he rt he ryi c i he baa c o e ui e tpsi hi fv r o t a a ij cini i t p bi itrs.S e eg. ln e f q t s i n s a o , r h t n nun to s n he u lc n ee t e , . , i k W i e v. tla Res De .Councisnc,555U. 7, ( ) Efiinta efci pe l ntr Natr l . f lI . S. 20 2008 . fce nd fe tve na a i s r ton f t r t publc' i e es ,a i vi a f de a c ti t day-o- y dm ni ta i urhe s he i s nt r t nd nvol ng e r l our n he t da a miitaino ac re t n l a it i ac u s t ej dcayg n rlyds p r v so tkng d n srto f o rci a fcl y s o r e h u iir e e al ia p o e f a i . o i Se ,e. ,1 U. C.j3626()2)(û'eco ts l gi s tnta wei t a a rei c e :. 8 S. a4 'f ur hal ve ubsa il ght o ny dves mpa t -h onpublcs ft o t opeai ofac i nalusies tm c us byt pr i nayr lefa i aey r he rton rmi j tc yse a ed he elmi r ei nd s lr pe tt prncpl ofc t ...) Belv. ofs 441U. 5 5 n. 5 1. hal es c he i i es omiy. ' ; l W lih, ' S. 20, 40 23, 48 129 ( 979)(xpli ngt tmai ai ngs c iya o de a opertngi tt i i mana a e 1 e ani ha nt ni e urt nd r r nd ai nsiuton n ge bl f hi a e ' ns de a i ... culary w ihi t pr nc a pr e s ona e r i e of as on r t i r tons pe i l t n he ovi e nd of s i l xpe ts co c r tonsofkil' . oreci f as' ) The Cl r s l s nd a c oft sm e o a e k ha l e opy hi m r ndum o ni a a c pa ng o de t al pi on nd c om nyi r r o l pa tes ri . ENTER:Thi f* s da ofJ y, 2014. y ul f. Chi fU nie St e D it i tJ e t d at s s rc udge

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.