Hinton v. O'Conner, et al., No. 7:2014cv00197 - Document 47 (W.D. Va. 2016)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/27/2016. (slt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
G ERK' OFFI U., ST. S CE S DI COX 1 AT ROANOV , VA . FI LED . MAt 2? 2 1 26 I THE UNI N TED STATES DISTRI COURT CT FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR I O F W R G I I CT N A R O A N O K E DI I O N V SI JULI . A DU BY: ,CL ERK $ t DONALD LEE HI NTON, Pl nt f , ai i f V. NU R SE O ' O M OR ,e aI, C t . D ef endant s. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) Ci lA c i N o.7: c 001 vi t on 14- v- 97 M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON NI By: H on.M i chaelF.U rbanski U nie St e Di t i tJudge t d at s s r c Donad Le Hi on,aVigi ,a i t pr e ngpr K , ie a cvi rght c l e nt r ni nma e oce di o fld i l i s ompli ant . pu s n t 4 U. C.j1 8 .Th r aetr ecamsrmaniga an tCo rcin lOfi es rua t o 2 S. 9 3 ee r h e li e i n g is re to a fc r (ç O' An e s n M uln a dPr ft n ovn t i alg dc n u ta aho ptl ee ç ' d ro , le , n oi i v lig her le e o d c t s ia wh r C/ ) Pli tf r eve c r a trahe ta tc onM a 28, 2. Spe fcal Pl i ifal ge i a n if ec i d a e fe ar ta k y 201 cii ly, antf le s n cam 111 t a C/ An es n a dMul np a e s c ls as o k l, n ha d ufsto li 41) h t Os d ro n l lc d ha ke , h c bet a d n c f o e tg tyo hm, a i gû x r caigp i (n qmadn ie te l h r t b e t e' n t a ih l n i c usn d c u itn an a d l g t x rmey a d o rah 'a d h t e te eo fc r rf s dt losnt rsri t.I cam 1Vl) C/ An e s n M uln a d h s fie s e u e o o e he etans n li ( l, Os d ro , le , n P oi rf s dt lo e Plitfsr sr it s h c ul c n l t sxca k r a dj iegve r ft e u e o o s n anif e tan s o e o d o sl he i r c es n u c i n me t hi by adoc ort r s li bl s r The e de e nt con i dt rr f s le n a tr o m t o aie ls ood uga . s f nda g tnue hei e u a vç fe Pli ifwa e t m t thewa adibei a ç a ntf m d he ha s a tc nd ç d g i t dibei s k'wiho t woul o n o a tc hoc ' t ut he s c I cam 1VII, litf alg sh e p re c dp y ia ij r vat e eec etp i s' na k. n li ( 1) P an if le e e x ein e h sc lnu y i i v r h s an ' s t tne s ia e anir yce i pilbee us C/ Ande s M ule a Pr k r f e t he p ha ce st t d togl rn l a e Os r on, l n, nd of e us d o l hi c um e t s c m ons he na k. Hinton v. O&#039;Conner, et al. Doc. 47 Dee d nsfldamo inf rs mmayj g n , r un t tPlitf fie t e ha t fn a t ie to o u r ud me t ag ig ha an if ald o x us a lbl ad i sr tver m e es1 A fe r vi w i t r cor , t c ur fndst tDe e nt vaia e m nitai e di . tr e e ng he e d he o t i ha f nda s 1 pat iett dt smmayjd metitepedn st dso eyaddslsr maeilo fl, A ry s nil o u r u j n fh laig,he ic vr n icoue tras n i e e a da yafd vt s o t th r i n ge un ds uea t a ymaeila t Fe R. v P. 6() Maeila t n n fia is h w ha tee s o n le ip t s o n tra fc. d. Ci. 5 a. tra fcs Dockets.Justia.com aee tte t sl r j d me t e a s Plitf ddn t x u ta alb ea miitaie r n ild o l mmay u g n b c u e anif i o e ha s v ia l d n srtv r ne e . e A di s Thee usi r uie e ti mandaor a Sa ist a 1i a es t a xha ton eq r m n s t y nd tpple o 1 nm t uis boutprs ion l e .' Po trv. sl, 3 U. 51 , 2 , 3 ( 0 2 .S o re h u to d ma d i g ' re Nu se 5 4 S. 6 5 4 5 2 2 0 ) ç pe x a sin e n s f j pr c plq ewih à age y' de i a ohe c ii lpr d a r l s' W ood or v. om i nc t n nc s adlnes nd t r rtca oce ur l u e . ' f d Ngo, 5 U. 81 90( 48 S. , 2006) W he aprs pr vi sa a nitai giva pr d e t . n ion o de n dmi srtve re nce oce ur ,he i t mus fl agre nma e t ie ivanc r sng apa tc a cli a plruei t ough a 1a ia e lvel e aii riul r am nd zs t hr l va lbl e s o a pe l oç r pel e ha s. Jl; x nv. c , 91F.d4 5 4 0 91( t Ci. 0 2 . f p a t t o ry x u t' -sDio Pa e 2 3 8 , 9 - 7h r 2 0 ) p '1 . çAl a mi srtv rme yi n tc n i ee t ha eb e a alb ei ap io e,h o g n ç n d nitaie e d s o o sd rd o v e n v ia l f rs n r tr u h o g f tofhi o wa pr ve e fom a ii hi s l ofi 'M oor v. nnet ,51 F. 717, aul s wn, s e nt d r valng m e f t' e Be te 7 3d 7 (t Ci. 0 ) G W j e p io o fcasp e n imae fo ushgt ea miitaie 25 4 h r 2 08 . t h n rs n fiil rve t n ts ' m i h d n srtv g r pr s ...t pr s t te sso pa rbe m e una ia ei r lt ' Ka v.St pp,458 oce s , he oce s ha xit n pe co s va lbl n eaiy.' ba e F.d6 , 4( t Ci. 0 6 .A d fn a th steb r e t p o ea i maesfiu et 3 78 68 7h r 2 0 ) ee d n a h u d n o r v n n t ' alr o e us avalbl a nitai rme es J sv. k,549U. 199, 6( ) Onc a xha t ia e dmi srtve e di . one Boc S. 21 2007 . e de e ntpr s nt e de eofaf l et e us, hebtr n ofpr s fst t pl i ift f nda e e s vi nc aim o xha t t lde oof hit o he antf o s how,by apr po r nc oft e de e t te usi oc ur e ora i sr tver me e e nde a e he vi nc , ha xha ton c r d dm nita i e di s a et enec s yt e tbls t el nt ofapa t sc eofacin,Andes v.Li rvLo r hos esar o sa ih he emç s ry' aus to ron bet bbv,I ,477U. nc. S. 2 2 2 8(9 6 .A g n i ds ueo maeila t xit i,nve n terc r é a1 e s n bei ee c s 4 , 4 1 8 ) e une ip t f tra fc e ss f i iwig h e o d nd 1ra o a l nfrn e dr wnt r fom ilalghtmos f vor bl t t no movi pa t ar as a he e r r i t a a e o he n- ng ry, e onabl f c-i rco d rt r ave dit e a ttnde ul e un r c f t nonor he mova . I Themoki pa t hast bl de ofs ng - Sha i,poi i outt t dititcour nt d. ng ry he z n howi r ' t s ntng t o he src t t tt r i a a e eofevi et s ha he e s n bs nc denc o uppor t nonmovi pa t sca e. Cel e Co o. Car t 477 U. 31 the ng ry' s ' otx r v. tet ' S. 7, 3 5(9 6 .lt mo a tstsisti b r e ,h nt n n- va t s stfrhs cfcfcst t e n tae 2 1 8 ) fhe v n aite hs u d n te he o mo n mu t e o t peii at ha d mo srt tee itn eo ag n n ds ueo fc frkil I. t3 2-4 A p ryi e tte t s mmayj d me tite h xse c f e uie ip t f at o a. d a 2 2 . at s nild o u r u g n f h r or asawhol c dnotl d ar i tiroffc t fndi f oft nonec d e oul ea atonalre a t o i n avor he mova t W ila v. if 952 n . lims Grfm, F.d8 , 23(t Ci. 991.t l r u s p o tds e uain. .sn t n u ht d fa asmmayj d me t 2 20 8 4h r 1 ) t ee n u p re p c lto . i o e o g o ee t u r u g n s moin' En i v. tlAs' o Bu . Ed c Ra i.nc, 3F.d5 , 2(t Ci. 9 5. A plitf c l t s a to . ns Na' sn f s & u . do I .5 3 5 6 4h r 1 9 ) ' anif amo u e rs ns t amoinfrsmmayj d me t oa ndo c re t c mpan c aln e b temoinfrs mmay epo e o to o u r u g n t me r o rc a o lit h le g d y h to o u r j d me t Cla ia rv. De i 5 5F.d3 4, 3 (t Ci. 0 ) u g n. o nn e Mc vt 5 3 2 3 6 4h r2 09. t 2 we euna ia et ough no f ul oft pl i if e. g.Tuc lv.Gr ve ,660 F. 1 r val bl hr a t he antf.Se e. , ke o r 3d 249, 1 5 ( 0hCi. 0 ) 2 4 1 t r 2 11. VDOC De a t n Opeai Pr c d r (G ' 8 6 1 % fn e Gre n eP o e t e' p rme t rt ng o e u e 1 ' 6 .,s e d r iva c r c dt , OP ) of r' pr dest a i sr tver medisf i t st r ol c ovi he dm hita i e e or nma e o es ve ompl i s a ala nita i ant , ppe dmi sr tve de sons a c l cii , nd halengepolc e andpr e e . Thepr e spr de c r to l oc s ovi s oreci na ii s oc dm s2 a i sr t sme nst i ntf potnta pr blm sand,i ne ès a y,core tt epr e si a dm nitaor a o de iy e il o e f c sr r c hos oblm n tm el mn r Al is sa e g i va ee e is sa i y nne . 1 s ue r re bl xc pt s ue boutpolc e , oc dur ,a de ii ns i i s pr e es nd cs o oft Vigi a Pa ol Boa d;dici i yhe rngpe li a o pr e a e r s sa ea he r ni r e r s plnar a i nates nd/ r oc dur l ror ; tt nd f r lcour decsons lws a r ul tons a ot rm at r be ede a t ii , a , nd eg ai ; nd he te s yondt VDOC' co r . he S ntol A n i a e m us fl a r ul rgre nc w ihi t ry c e r da f o t da e o t nm t t ie eg a i va e t n hit al nda ys r m he t f he o c re c o icd n . N oa l ,e ulrj iva c st td n t e t esl r q ie nso c u rn e r n i e t3 tby r g a re n e ha o o me t h i e urme t f ng OP 8 6 1 l eb i fldlt, r rj ce a drt r e t t eimaewihnt wo kn d ys 6 .,i eng ie ae ae ee td n e un d o h n t t i wo r ig a k fom t da eofr ept4 An i aem a a r he t ec i . nm t y ppea a i a de ii n by s ndi t g va ea l n ntke c so e ng he de nc nd t i a decsont ar ina ombuds nwihi fveda ofr c pi he ntke ii o ego l ma t n i ys e ei . Pl i ifbe n flng r a g i va so J y 1 201 a tt t e r mai ng antf ga ii egulr re nce n ul 9, 2, bou he hr e e ni camst a alg dyo c re o Ma 28 20 2. Th g iva c sweerj ce u ni tk a li h t le e l c u r d n y , 1 5 e re n e r ee td po na e s untm ey fl d.OP 866. al wedPl i ift a i l ie 1 lo antf o ppea t i a de sons butPli iff l t l he nt ke cii , a ntf aied o tmeya pe la1 h rj ce r g a g iv n e e e to e Plitf fldta p riu a i l p a 1t e ee td e ulr re a c s xc p n . an if e h t a t lr c 2I nmatsaeore e t t i aegreva epr edu ewhe t y e e t VDO C' c t andwhe e r intd o he nm t i nc oc r n he ntr he S usody n t yar tanse r t ot rVDOC f ltes he e r fred o he aciii . 3Prort s itng agre nce t i t mus makeagood fih e fr t i or ly r s vet is i o ubm ti iva , he nmae t -at fo t o nf mal e ol he s ue b s ti ani o ma compl ntf m,whi i avalbl i housngunis y ubmitng nf r l ai or ch s ia e n i t. 4A co oft i a de son i ke i t i t sgre nc fl . py he ntke cii s pt n he nmae' iva e ie 5Pl ntf a De e nt fld c e ofgre nce i t sc e, a Pl ntf i or r td c esof ai if nd f nda s ie opis iva s n hi as nd ai if nc po ae opi i or alc pli s r gulrgre nce ,a r ssf s r c heha fld wiht sc ti a t raci nf m om ant, e a iva s nd eque t or e vies d ie t hi our n nohe ton, Hi o v.O ' me ,No. 1 cvntn Cor r 7:4- 00392. 3 g iv n ea o t h tg t e tan sd suse i cam 111 o J y 1 , 01 ( 1 -v- 0 9 re a c b u t e i h r sr it ic s d n li (1) n ul 9 2 2. 7:4 c 0 3 2, ECFNo 2a 2 -4. Th giv nc wa rj ce a u tmey a dt er go a o u s n . t 32 ) e re a e s ee td s n i l, n h e in l mb d ma a fr dt a rj cin. fime h t ee to Pl i ifsa glme t thi m e c lc ton a te t e m a i i antf r l nt ha s dia ondii nd r am nt de t mpos i et fl sbl o ie g iv n e wihnt it d y o M a 28 2 2 i n t e s a i e OP 8 6. j ( ( )alwsa re a c s t i hry a s f y , 01 , s o p ru sv . 6 1 VIA) 1 lo gre ncet befl d wihi t ry da Ee e i i t nc s...be i va o ie t n hit ys çxc pt n nsa e yond t ofe r s he f nde ' c nr l. .' ( 1 -v- 01 7 ECFNo. 6 1a 1 . Plitf sae t a hewa r la e fo o to . . 7:4 c 0 9 , ' 3 - t 0) an if tts h t s ee s d r m l t hos t lon M a 31, 2;washous d i t prs sm e c lde m e on Jme 1 201 he pia y 201 e n he ion' di a pm nt t , 2; a wa r t r t hi housng pod on Jme4,201 Ther or e tbls st tPli ifhad nd s e u ned o s i t 2. ec d sa ihe ha a ntf a c st admi sr tver m e e upo r tlni t t housng pod be us hepur ue c es o nitai e di s n elr ng o he i ca e s d num e ousa nita i r m e e a r dmi sr tve e dis boutva i ma tr a e ry a Jme5,201 Eve i t rous te s s a l s t 2. n f he c twe et t lt bre pe i be wee M ay 28,201 a J 5,201 Pl ntf sild d no our r o ol he if rod t n 2, nd une 2, ai if tl i t fl ar gul rgre nc wihi t s eq ntt rp da pe i i t a he waiedun i J y 1 ie e a iva e t n he ubs ue hit y rod; nse d, t tl ul 9, 201 2. Pli ifhasnotpr vi d a e de t ta nita i r m e e we enota ia et antf o de ny vi nce ha dmi sr tve e di s r val bl o hi o t thepr rypurued a ia ea nita i r m e esasr r by OP 866. . m r ha ope l s val bl dmi sr tve e di equied 1 . ' . Ac o d n l, fn a t aee tte t sl r u g n pls a t o4 U. C. 1 9 ea . c r i gy Dee d ns r nild o l mmayj d me t t u n t 2 S. j 9 7 () r ENTER:Thi XD s $ 1 da ofM y , 2 1 6. ë . . * > . Unied St e Di i tJ t at s s c udge 4
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
