Obataiye-Allah v. Clark et al, No. 7:2014cv00159 - Document 21 (W.D. Va. 2014)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/13/2014. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
CLERK' OFFI U, . 8I COURT S CE B Dl AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED MAt 13 2 1 29 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI CT RGI A NI ROANOKE DI SI VI ON UH URUSEK OU OBATAI ALLAH , YE- J A ULI 3Y: C R CASE NO.7: 4CV00159 1 Pl ntf , ai if V. M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N N O HAROLD CLARK, AL , :Z By:Gln E. nr d e Co a C hi fU nied St e D i t i Judge e t at s s r ct Dee da ts. f n n t) Pl n if a Vigi a i t p oc di pr K ,fl t scvi rght aci n ptr ua t 42 aitf, r ni nma e r ee ng o ied hi i l i s to ls nt o U. C.j 1 8 ,algng ta o fcas a Re Ono S ae P io u e e e sv f re a d S. 9 3 le i h t fiil t d in tt rs n s d xc s ie oc n s be td hm t h rh l i c ndto i De e e o 2 3 a d Jn r o 2 4 No u jce i o as i ng o i ns n c mb r f 01 n a uay f 01 . w, v i pl i if s e t ame t s c antf e ks o nd hi ompli wih cli s c ant t am once i ot is m ng her s ues a e nt nd ve s c pl t l unr a e t t or g na com pl nt A s t t o of t s pr om e e y el t d o he i i l ai . o w he e opos d a e e m ndm e s nt conc r ng pl i ifs r i i dit a a upc ng r lgi f as,pl i if ha alo tld e ni antf elg ous e nd n omi e i ous e t antf s s ie moinsf ritro u o y ij n tv r le Be a s t s camsf rr l fa e et e wi u to o n elc tr nu cie eif c u e he e li o ei r ih r t t e ho m e i o a e notpr pe l r i e i t spe ng l w s t t c tfndst tt m otonst a e rt r r o ry a s d n hi ndi a ui, he our i ha he i o m nd a fri tro u o yij n tv rle mus b d ne . nd o ne lc t r nu cie eif t e e id Pl ntf ofe s f pr e a e ai if f r our opos d m ndme s t hi c nt o s ompl i . Fis,he s eks t a a ant rt e o dd c le t t Red Oni polc t tr uiesi aest as s r ior ofk i l f i a e hal nge o he on iy ha eq r nm t o k upe v s y t as or nm t co ai f ms( No. 1 pp.12. Thi n nd ntmus bede e bec us i i f tl mpl nt or ECF 8- , - ) s me me t nid, a e t s uie. To sae ac u eo a to t e j1 8 ,aplitf mu te tbih t theh sb e d p ie o tt a s f cin md r 9 3 an if s sa ls ha a e n e rv d f rght gua a e by t Consi ton o lw soft Unied Stt . W es v.At ns 487 U. 42 i s r nt ed he tm i r a he t aes t ki , S. ( 988 . I i welesa ihed t ti t ha no c tt i lrghtt aprs gre nce 1 ) t s l tbls ha nmaes ve onsiutona i o ion iva po e te r c dl . r Ad ms v. Rie 4 F.d n c, 0 3 7 (t Ci. 1 9 ) ' r f r, a imaes 5 4h r 9 4 . l e o e n n t ' he di s tsaci wih t m n ri whih prs ofi a sc s ai f ton t he nne n c ion tcil hoos t o r t agre e o pe a e ivmwe pr e e oc dur doesno sae a cai ofc tt i lsgnika e s ast beaci bl unde j1 3. The t tt l m onsiutona i t nc o o tona e r 98 c zt l no a l pli ift a nd t sa ton wih acai t tha no me i on isf c otr wil t low antf o me hi c i t l m ha s rt t a e. l hi s ond pr e a e n s ec opos d m ndment pl i ifwa st a a c am c , antf nt o dd l i once ni of i l r ng fc as' us o ad g t manan o d rdli a i ie to Au u t2 ,2 2 ( No.8 1 p 3 4. e f o o iti r e t ng n ncd n n g s 6 01 ECF r - , p. - ) Thi e nti complt y s pa a e a oc ur e m o et a ye re rirt n t eve son whi h s ve s e el e r t nd c r d r han a a le ha he nt c pl i ifso i nalc antf rgi ompl n i bas To a i t t pr s ntlws tf l af ofRul s 1 a ait s ed. dd t o he e e a ui als oul e 8 nd 20 oft Fe r Rul ofCi lPr e le, g v m igj id ro camsa d p ri . The ef r he de al es vi oc dtr o e n on e f 1i n a tesl r oe t c tde e t snme m e . l pl i ifwihe t pur ue al ws ta tt s201 i i nt he our ni s hi nd nt f antf s s o s a ui bou hi 2 ncde , he m us do s by flng a ne a s par t a ton,on a s pa ae c t o ii w nd e ae c i e r t ompli tf m sgne unde a n or i d r p n lyof ejly. e at p rt r Pli ifa s s ekst a e t add t ne cai sco e ni prs ofi i l 'a tmpt a ntf lo e o m nd o wo w l m nc r ng ion fc a s te s t a co o c mmodaehi Nato ofllm C1 ' rlgi prci s l onepr e n ndme t s in sn NOI' ei ous a tce . n ) opos d me nt ( No.8- ,pp.5- ,heriess ve a c ai sa t me l s r edt hi dtrng pa t ECF 1 6) as e r l ompl nt bout he as e v o m li s ce e r to o t n l b a i ns f he nnual N O1 m o h of f s i nt a tng. Pl i if al o m oves f i e l ut y a ntf s or nt r oc or ij n tv r le t p e e t o e d n ti ye rsfs, ihb gnso J ne28 20 4 ( nu cie eif o r v n prblms mi g h s a ' at wh c e i n u , 1 ECF No 1 ) I a dto , an ifse st a dacam ta t Co nFaeDitp o i e t NOI . 0 . n d iin plitf e k o d li h t he mmo r e r v d d o i a e i t Vig ni De rm e ofCoreci nsi l sf nm t s n he r i a pa t nt r to ncude oodspr bie by t NOlr lgi ohi td he ei on a s o l b rvie t c re t t s d fc ( nd h u d e e s d o o rc hi ee t ECF No 82 p 7 9 . Plitf as s e . - , p. -) anif lo e ks l Un e Rue 1 ()whih g ven j id ro cams apantf m a brngm uli e cai s rltdo n t tpl l m , eae r o, d r l 8a, c o rs on e f li , 1 i if y i i alws ta i tasngl dee nt Howe ,i o de t na ohe de e nt i t s melws t t pli if n a ui gans i e fnda . ver n r r o me t r f nda s n he a a ui, he antf mu tstsyRue20a() whc g vens on e o p ris Rue2 ()2 pemisj id rofmutped fn a t s aif l ()2 ! ih o r j id r f at . l 0 a( ) r t on e e l l ee d ns i onl wher t rghtt r l asere a ns t a iesoutoft s me ta aci oroc ure e a co e nsa y e he i o elef s td gai t hem rs he a rns ton c rnc nd nc r common que tonoflw orf t Asg e pl ntf ' curents gi a ac. ltd, ai ifs r ubmisonsdonotcompl wiht er e . si y t hes uls p ei n r ij n tv r le rg r igte editis e ( No . - a d 83 . r l a y nu cie eif e a dn h s e s u s ECF s 8 2 n - )2 mi Agan,t e ne c am sa ie fom tans tons a e nt e iey s pa ae fo t e i hes w l i rs r r ac i nd ve s ntr l e r t r m hos e nt r s d i pl i if s i tal c pl i . The a e ve s ai e n a ntf nii om a nt m ndm e t a s i ves de e nt not n l o nvol f nda s i tfe a havi a i ve nti t cai sr ie i t t ryi c pl nt Be aus den ii d s ng ny nvol me n he l m as d n he mde l ng om ai . c e te a n me t tuss e t b i camsn tp o e l j ie t plitf so ii lcams i h me d ns h e k o rng li o r p ry on d o anif rgna li , n vi ai n ofRul 1 a 20, hec tde est a e ol to es 8 nd t our ni he m ndme a t bot c am s nt s o h l i . Fo asmia ra o pan ifsmoinsf rp ei nay ij n tver le r ltdt t e e r i lr e s n, litf to o rlmi r nu ci eif eae o h s mij ie n w camsaen tp o el b f r t c u ti t i c s . CAIp ei n r ijmci n son d e li r o r p ry eo e he o r n hs a e G r l a y nt to I mi ma n ve is e t p e e ta ij r o h r whc n te e te mo n pat c ne d wa y e r su o rv n n nu y r n m ih o v n h vig ry o tn s s c us by t wr cai i t t ryi aci ' OmeaaW ord Tr ve v.TW A,111F.d a ed he ong l med n he mde l ng ton.' l a l 3 1 1 ( hCi.1 ;I r M i os tAnttus Lii ,333 F.d 517,526 ( h Ci.2003) The 4, 6 4t r 997) n e cr of ir t tc. 3 4t r . ijmci r le plitf s e r g r i gh srlgo de a d fa td y aen tdr ce t wa d n t t eif anif e ks e ad n i eiius it n e s a r o ie td o r ve pr ve i pot ntalha e ntng e i nns t tw oul r ul f om t w r ha d es t r he ongs cl i ed i t o i nalc pl i . am n he r gi om a nt Th rf r ,te c u td nis panifsmo in f ritro uo y ij n t rle rg r ig h s e eo e h o r e e litf to s o n elc t r nu ci eif e a dn i ve rlgo b l f ( No 8a d 1 ) a p o raeod rwi is et i d y. eiius ei s ECF . n 0 .An p r p it r e l su h s a e l TheClr i die t d t s nd c esoft sm e a e k s r c e o e opi hi mor ndum opi on a a c pa ng ni nd c om nyi or rt pl ntf. de o ai if y - y 01 ENTER:Ths 1 N da otM a , 2 4. i . : ChifUnied St t DititJ e t aes src udge 2 Pli ifsc re s miso aen sg edun rpe al ofpeju don i niys cfc antf urnt ub sins r ot in de n t y rty, otde tf pe ii def ndant t t r i ousdi cl m s and do notsat f t concer ng def e s o he elgi et ai , t e ac s ni endant 'actonsorom i i s i ssons i vi ai n o hi rg t. Thee o e te c u twilno c tu t s s miso a ne j 1 3 n olto f s i h s r f r , h o r l t onsr e he e ub s ins s w 98 compl nt . ai s
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
