Yates et al v. Sylvain Turcotte et al, No. 7:2014cv00144 - Document 60 (W.D. Va. 2014)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 12/11/2014. (ssm)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
Yates et al v. Sylvain Turcotte et al Doc. 60 Dockets.Justia.com empl yedby De e ntTr ns tBi ,aCa din co por ton,a t tmeoft a i nt I o f nda a por zz na a r a i t he i he ccde . d. a !5.Defnda W ila Ne e ,aNe Yok ctz n,k drvi hi ta t -rie'whe t t e nt lim mir w r iie ( was i ng s rcortalr' n he ai , t s e ks 5 li or e s i nd ac i ntocc r d. I .I t orgi lcom pl nt Ya e s e $1 milon f Sos bee' pan a c de ure 1 d n he i na s f rngprort hi deah,a welasf hi l tea ni a o he da a .l Sm ih,aN o t ufe i i o s t s l or s os r ngs nd t r m ges d. t rh Ca olna ctze s ks$1m ilon f pan and s f rng, e c e ns ,l te r ngs a r i ii n, ee li or i ufe i m dial xpe es os a ni , nd ot rda he mage . 1 s d. O n J ne 1 201 N em i rf l d a m oton t di m i sY a es s c pl i pu s tt Rul u 8, 4, e ie i o s s t ' om a nt r uan o e 1 b)1 oft Fed a RulsofCi lPr edur Doc tNo.1 Ne e ar st tYae lc 2( ( ) he erl e vi oc e, ke 6. mir gue ha ts a ks sa ng,be aus s f l d t qua iy a t perona r pr s nttveofSos be sesae i tndi c e he aie o lf s he s l e e e a i e e' t t n Vigi aprort tlngt c pli .Nemiralo a gu t tt c ts d dimisYa e s r ni i o ii he om ant e s r es ha he our houl s s t s' de ndfrc ma o ompenstonf rSos be spana s frngpurua t Rul 1 b)6)oft ai o e e' i nd ufei s nt o e 2( ( he Fede alRul ofCi lPr e e, ca et eda a sa enotr ove abl unde Vigni s r es vi oc dur be us hos m ge r ec r e r r i a' wrngf de t saut Va. o ul ah tt e, Codej8. - e sq.whihpr desYae ' s er yhe e.Se 0150 t e , c ovi tss ol emed r e Doc tNo.1 a 3,On Augus 6,201 Tur otea Tr ns t z fld a sm ia motont ke 6 t t 4, c t nd a por Bi z ie i l r i o ke dim isa gui t tYa e lckssa ngi t sc t2 D oc tNo. 30.N oneoft de e nt s s r ng ha t s a tndi n hi our. he f nda s c lng Sm ih' sa ngort s fce y oft orgna c pli tasfl d by hi . hale e t s t ndi he ufi inc he i i l om a n ie m Thepl i if i ta l r s nd byar ng t tYa e wasti t pr e so bei antfs niily e po ed gui ha t s tn he oc s f ng a ntd g Sosbe spes lrpr e ai li .vigi a. Do tNo. a 1.The ltr ppoi e as e e' rona e esnttve n.. r ni ' cke ' 23 t y ae fl docume ss ied nt howi t tYaesquaiid aspe s lr pr en a i ofSos be sesa e i ng ha t lfe r ona e es t tve e e' tt n 1DCfndantCa lAl n M c mi , aSout Ca olnaciie , wa empl by De e tUniedPa c e r vi cor ck h r i tz n s oyed f ndan t r el Se vi s I .an llnoi co por i a t tmeoft a i nt The defnda sha notfl am oto t dim is r ce , nc, li s r aton, t he i he ccde . se e nt ve ied in o s s t orgi lc pl nt he i na om ai . 2Def ndan sTur te a Tr ns r Bi z alo fl d a t r pa t c pl i t Doc tNo. 9whih s eks e t co t nd a po t z s ie hid ry om a n , ke 33 c e c n rb to u de Vigni Co e j8013 fo o h rtu kd ie swh we ea s alg dy i v l e i te o tiu i n n r r i a d . - 4 r m t e r c rv r o r lo le e l n o v d n h a cd n . d a !2 Th s t idpat d fn a saen taf ce b t ep n n mo i n . c i e t I . t ( 6. e e hr ry ee d nt r o fe t d y h e dig to s l t sca e,Yaes af ei a nitaor ha notye qua iid a Sos be spe s n hi s t , or gn dmi sr t , d t lfe s e e' r onal r pr enttvei Vigni whe t pli if i ta e t slws t Ya e t r f r lc d sa ng e es a i n r i a n he antfs niit d hi a ui. t s he e o e a ke t ndi t s i t sc t Ha s fld t slws taone, hec t o ue n hi our. d he ie hi a ui l t our woul be c tanedt dimi she d onsr i o s s r c ompli wihoutc i rng he m oto t a e Se J nson M e . p. Baz m o e,67 ant t onsde i r i n o m nd. e ob t m Hos v. e r 2 S. 2 8 8 8 0 6l( . 0 )( odn t a ap ro a rp e e ttv wh fie t q aiyi E.d 5 , 6 - Va 20 9 h lig h t es n l e r sn ai e o ald o u l n f Vigi abe or flng awr ulde t aci n co d no nons the c am ,a C l ga pr e ng r ni f e ii ongf ah to ul t ui r l i s i e l oce di no ( jpendi 'obenons td) W hitv. m .739S. 2 25 268( CtApp. 3)($Aj was ng't uie ; t Co , E.d 4, Va. . 201 1g n atmp t a n ap e dngp eu p s sav ldisr me ta a o j c.Be a s t egla i ) te t o me d la i r s p o e ai n tu n s n be t c u e h p e dng wasi ld,heewasnot ngt a nd.)(ntr lciai o te . nvai t r hi o me ' i ena ttons mitd) ' Ya e i nott onl pl i i fi t s c s how e r A st de e ant ha not d,Sm ih ts s he y a ntf n hi a e, ve . he f nd s ve e t h ssa dn a dh sc mpan i n ts be tt d s sa h r.Th c u t t h rf r c n ie a tn ig n i o lit s o u jc o imisl e e e o r mus t eeo e o sd r hi m oto s ki lavet a e t c s i n ee ng e o m nd he ompl i .Rul 1 oft Fe r Rul sofCi lPr e e ant e 5 he de al e vi oc dur drcsc u t t Cr ey gv la e(oa n )whe j sies r q ie . l S eFo n v Da i, ie t o rs o t e l i e e v t me d f n u tc o e u rs' d. e ma . v s ' 371U, 1 1 ( 962)(Cft unde l ngf t o crumsanc srle uponbyapli ifmay S. 78, 82 1 t he ryi acs r ic t e eid 1 antf b ap o e s be t fr l f h o h t b afr e a o po tnt t t s h scam o te e r p r u j c o ei , e ug t o e fo d d n p ru i o e t i li n h e y meis' ; o s nv. o a Fo d Co.7 5F.d5 3 5 9(t Ci.1 8 )( gl a et a n a rt.) J hn o Or we t o s , 8 2 0 , 0 4h r 9 6 'l e v o me d ' tp e dngs o l b d ne o l whe t ea n me two l b prj d ca t t o p sn pat, la i h ud e e id ny n h me d n u d e eu iilo he p o i g ry t r ha be n ba fihont pa toft mo ngpa t ort a nd ntwoul beftl.'. hee s e d at he r he vi ry, he me me d uie' ) The c tfndsno r s t de Sm ih l ve t a e he e. The e i no e de e t tt our i ea on o ny t ea o m nd r r s vi nc ha he motons e ngla t a ndwa ma i badf t o t t dee nt wilbeprj ce by i e ki e ve o me s de n aih, r hathe fnda s l eudi d tea n me t Th a n e c mplit i tl , r p ryj isYae a c - litf nti a to . h me d n . e me d d o an ,n u' p o el on ts s o panifi h s ci n n Se Fe R. v. 20()(ttngt tpli if ma bej ne i o a toni t i camsars e d. Ci P. a sai ha antfs y oi d n ne ci f her li ie fom t s e t a a ton oroc ur e a a co m on que ton o 1 w o f c w ila i e i t r he am r ns c i c r nce nd ny m s i f a r a t l r s n he 4 a ton) l t a ci . n he mende c ant Yae alge t ts qualte a apes lrpr s nai of d ompli , ts le s ha he ii s s rona e e e ttve Sos bee' e t t i V igi a a s a esa c a m f rr i funde V igi a' wr ngf de t s a ut . e s s a e n r ni nd t t l i o ele r r ni s o ul a h t t e SeeDoc tNo. a 4,7ke 56 t 8.Be a et a c us he mende c d ompl i r me e t co e nsr ie by t ant e di s he nc r a s d he de e nt 'm o i nst dim is t em otonswilbede e f nda s to o s s , hos i l ni d. Concl i us on Fort r a onssaed, hepl ntfs moto f rl a t fl a a e he e s t t t ai if ' i n o e ve o ie n m ndedco pli ,Doc t m a nt ke No. wilbegr nt d.The de e nt motonst dim is Doc t No.1 a 30,wilbe 56, l a e f nda s' i o s s , ke s 6 nd l denid. Clr i die t d t doc tt ame d compli i t smat r Doc tNo.5 a t e The e k s r c e o ke he nde ant n hi te , ke 6, nd o s nd ce tte c e Oft smemor ndum opi on a t a ompanyi or rt a1 couns of e rii d opi s hi a ni nd he cc ng de o l el r co d. e r N y Ex 'ER: 'hi la' da ofo e em be ,201 r r s c r 4. 4 Chi U nie St t sD i ti tJ ef t d a e sr c udge
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
