Muhammad v. Mathena et al, No. 7:2014cv00142 - Document 73 (W.D. Va. 2015)
Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 7/14/2015. (tvt)
Download PDF
<![CDATA[
eL : OFFI u. . Dl cour ERK' CE s sm AT > NVILE. L vA FI LED I THE UNI STATESDI TRI COURT N TED S CT FO R TH E W ESTER N D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A ROANOKE DI I O N V SI J 1ù 2 1 UL 25 J m c. u B :jDEPO y j w M A LCO LM M U H A M M A D, Pl ntf , ai i f M EM O M N D U M O PI I N N O R .M A TH EN A ,e al, t . D ef endant s. By: CLERK C i lActon No.7: c 00142 vi i 14- v- V. L R H on. ks L.K i er Jac on s Se or U ni e St e D i t i tJudge ni t d at s s r c M acol M uha m a aVigi ai ae pr ee ng pr K , ie a cvi rght a to l m m d, r ni nm t oc di o fld i l i s ci n purua t 42U. C.j 1 s nt o S. 983.Pli ifna c rci ofiil wiht Vigi a antf mes ore tonal tcas t he r ni De rme ofCore tons(ç pa t nt rci $ VDOC')a RedOni Stt Prs (( ' nd on ae ion iROSP' asdee ns ' ) fnda t. Pl ntf c ai if ompli t the di notr evec ran i s ofhi s c i i t E ion Le ans ha d ec i e ti s ues s ubs rptons o t s pr gal Ne '(TLN' amont ypei iala S na Ca1'awe kl r lgi pei c l i tmey ws' C ' ) hl rodc , nd Ti l 1, ' e y ei ous rodia,n i l f s i n De e d n sfldamo inf rs mmayj d me t a dPlitf r s o d d ma n t e a h o . fn a t ie to o u r u g n , n anif e p n e , kig h m a trrpef diposton. A fe r viwi t r or , 1g a De e nt 'moton f s ma y te i or s ii 1 tr e e ng he ec d r nt f nda s i or um r ' J udgm e . nt 1. Pl i ifi aVDOC i t who wa i a ce a e a ROSP untlAprl2,201 whe he antf s nma e s nc r r t d t i i 4, n wa tansere t Ke M oun ai Core tona Ce e .Pur ua t VDOC Ope a i Pr e e s r f r d o en t n r c i l ntr s nt o r tng oc dur (ç ' 8 2,a1i omi publc tonsaer e da t i tt i lve befr t ar çOP' 03. 1 nc ng iai r eviwe t he nsiutonal e l o e hey e ) r e ve by i aes I apublc ton i nota ove a t i tt i lve,i i f wa de t ec i d nm t . f iai s ppr d t he nsiutonal e l t s or r d o Muhammad v. Mathena et al t VDOC' Publc tonRe e Commite(: 'frf t rr e Duet prorltgai he S iai viw te $ PRC' o urhe eviw. ) o i ii ton Doc. 73 be w e n PLN a V D O C, t e nd howeve , i on s a far s r pr s t f e uppos d t s nd a PLN i s de e m i d e o e ny s ue t r ne t be i ppr pr a e unde OP 803. diec l t A .Da d Robi on,t V D O C Chi fof o na o i t r 2 r ty o vi ns he e 1 ddn ta toiePlitf' rs n et teAns rp ru n t Rue1 a()C) a dPlitf ma no l i o uh rz anifs epo s o h we us a t o l 2()l( , n anif y t a n ac mplittr u hag me ti ab ifo p sn s mmayj d me t Cla i e v Mc vt 5 5F.d me d o an lo g ru n n re p o ig u r u g n . o nnc r . Dt i 5 3 z t 3 4 3 6(t Ci. 0 9 . 2 , 3 4h r2 0 ) Dockets.Justia.com Ope a i ,f r vi w i tad oft t PRC.I Aprl201 Robi on i s d am e o a m t r tons or e e nse o he n i 4, ns s ue m r ndu o a lwa de ,r m i ng t m t tPLN pu i to t ta edia ove a t i tt i llvel 1 r ns e ndi he ha blcai ns ha r s ppr d t he nsiutona e s d bes ntt hi f rr viw a no t t PRC,a am ont lt ri M a 201 t s houl e o m o e e nd t o he nd h ae n y 4, hi pr e e wa i or a e i o OP 803. Naur ly,t a nita i r viw pr es r quied oc dur s nc por t d nt 2. t a l he dmi sr tve e e oc s e r by OP 8 2 ca e s edely be we n whe m a loo sa fr evesapublc ton a whe 03. us s om a t e n ir m t f ec i i a i nd n a i a e r ce vesi . n nm t e i t Th p blc to sa is ei Plitf sCo lit wees b e t oi ta VDOC rv e a e u iai n t su n an if mp an2 r u j c t ni l i e iw t t i tt i na l ve unde OP 8 2. Cera n i s ofPLN a i s i t s c s w e e he ns iuto l e l r 03. t i s ues t s ue n hi a e r er r oneo l f w a de t PR C f rr vi w a t rt y we e di a oved a t i tt i ll ve , us y or r d o o e e f e he r s ppr t he ns iutona e l n hr nol ca de . antf a Pl ntf r ceve c ran i s ofFi lCal a d PLN4i nonc o ogi lor r Pl i if nd ai if e i d e t i s ues na l3 n 2Thepe i c l a is a elmiedt t edes rbedi t Compli a s pplme . Spe tc l t rodias t s ue r i t o hos c i n he ant nd u e nt cii aly, he c esed PLN mo hl publcai a ef t mo hsofOcobe ,Nove ont t nt y i tons r or he nt t r mber a Dec , nd embe 201 a Fe uay r 3 nd br r a M a c 201 t c e td wee ypublc tonsf Fi Cala eis fom Dec mbe 7,1 1 24,a 31 nd r h 4,he ontse kl ia i or nal l r sues r e r 0, 7, nd , 2 l J n ayl 2l 28 2 4; e r ay4,l ,1 , n 25 201 , n Mac 4, 01 ( mpl! l -2, - 2 0 3; a u r 4, , , 01 F b ur 1 8 a d , 4. d rh 2 4. Co . ! 11 253 ; a Su p ( No. 3) 7 . p .ECF 1 ! ) 3Plitf r ceve t is ofFi lCalc le an if e i d he sues na l halngedi t Compl nta t f l ngtmes n he ai t he olowi i : TheDe e e 7 2 1 ,su o J n r 2 , 01 ( mp. 2 ) c mb r , 0 3 is e n a uay 3 2 4 Co l! 6 . , TheDe e r1 , 01 ,su o J n r 2 , 01 (4 , c mbe 0 2 3 is e n a uay 3 2 4 t 3. TheDe e e 1 , 0l,su o Jn r 2 , 01 ( =* c mb r 7 2 3 is e n a uay 3 2 4 j ) # , Th De e r2 , 01 ,su o Fe rlr 20 2 4(# a !29, e c mbe 4 2 3 is e n b t y , 01 j. t ) a . TheDe e e 31 2 3 is eo Jn r 2 , 01 ( .a !2 ) c mb r , 01 ,su n a uay 3 2 4 . t 6 ; $ Th J n ay7 2 1 ,su o Jn ay2 , 01 ( . Rcp.ECFNo 45 1 .) e a u r , 0 4 ise n a u r 3 2 4 Pls s ( ' . ) 5) Th Jnu r 1 , 01 ,sueo F b u r 20 201 ( mp. t 2 ) e a ay 4 2 4 is n e ray , 4 Co la ! 9 ; Th Jn r 2l 2 l ,sueo F bu r 6, 01 ( .a !2 ) e a uay , 0 4 is n e ray 2 4 . .t 8 * U , Th Jnu r 2 , 01 ,sueo Jn ay3 , 4( a !2 ) e a ay 8 2 4 is n a u r 0 201 . t 7 , 1 . Th Fe r ay4 2 4 is o Fe ray6 20 4(4.t!2 ) e b u r , 01 ,sue n b ur , 1 . . 8 , 1a * Th Fe r ay 1 , 01 ,su o Se tmb r1 , 01 ( p ( No. 3 !7 ; e b u r 1 2 4 ise n pe e 2 2 4 Su p.ECF 1 ) ) Th Fe n ay l , 01 ,su o Fe ray2 201 ( mpla !2 ) a d e b zr 8 2 4 ise n bu r 0, 4 Co . t 9 . n , Th Mac 4 2 4 iseo Mac 2 20 4( a T3 ) e rh , 01 ,su n rh 0, 1 . t 0 . 1 l rs o s t temoinfrsmmayj d me tPanifa u o e g drc iigoh ris e o Fi l n ep n e o h to o u l u g n, litf c wld e e evn te su s f na Cal a f lw s l s olo : Th Oco e 8 2 3 iseo No e e l , 01 ( .sRep.ECFNo 45 l .. e tb r , 01 ,su n v mb r 2 2 3 P1' s ( . ) 5) , Th Oco e 1 , 01 ,su o Oco e 3 , 3(#. e tb r 5 2 3 ise n tb r 0 201 i=; ) Th Oco e 2 , 01 ,su o No e e 1 2 3(4 , e tb r 2 2 3 ise n v mb r 2, 0l .. j3. . Th Oco e 2 , l ,su o De e e 2 2 1 (4 e tb r 9 20 3 is e n c mb r , 0 3 j3; . . 1 TheNove mber5, 3,is onDe mbe l 201 (#.; 201 sue ce r 7, 3 j ) Th No e e 1 a d1 , 01 ,su so a t p cfe d t (d) e v mb r 2 n 9 2 3 is e n n ms e iid ae i.; Th No e e 26 2 l ,su o De e e 2 20 3( ) a e v mb r , 0 3 is e n c mb r , 1 % ; nd Th De e e 3, 3 is eo De e rl 2 3( . e cmb r 201 ,su n c mbe 7, 01 .3. U comm e e t sa ton t vi c t hi rght unde t Fis Am e e ,t DuePr es a nc d hi c i o ndi ae s i s r he r t ndm nt he oc s nd Equa Pr ec i c a e oft Fouree h A m e l ot ton l us s he t nt ndm e ,a t Re i ous Lan Us an nt nd he lgi d e d I tt t n l e PesmsAc o 2 0 (I P ' b c u eheb le e t eis e o Fna Cal nsiui ai d rt o z t î 00 S RLUI A' e a s ) eiv s h su s f i l l a PLN we e dea nd r lyed,de i r d o ofor r orno dei r d ale dl bas o r cala lve e ut de , t lve e lge y ed n a i nd r lgi dic i nai s e i ous s rmi ton. ll. A p ryi e tte t s mmayj dg n it epla ig ,h d so r a dd s ls r a t s n ild o u r u me t f h e dn s t e ic vey n ico u e m a e i so fl a a a fda t s t ral n ie, nd ny fi vis how t t ei no ge nediput ast a m aera f c . hat her s nui s e o ny t il a t Fed.R.Ci P.56() M aeilf t aet ene esayt etbls t elme sofapa t s v. a . tra acs r hos c sr o sa ih he e nt ry' c u eo a to .An e s nv. b rvLo b . n .4 7U.. 4 , 4 ( 9 6 .A g n ieis eo a s f ci n d ro Lie t b y l c, 7 S 2 2 2 8 1 8 ) e un su f ma e i f te ssi,n viwi t r c da alr as bl i e e esdr wn t e r i a t ral ac xit f i e ng he e or nd l e ona e nf r nc a her fom n lg mos f vo a et t non- ovi pa t ar s bl f c -i rco d r t ave di f i ht t a r bl o he m ng ry, ea ona e a tfnde ul eum r ct or t non- nt J. Themovi pa t ha t bur nofs wi - Sha i,poi i outt t he mova . .S 4 ng ry s he de ho ng i t s ntng t o he dititcour - t tt r i an a e e ofe de et s src t ha he e s bs nc vi nc o uppor t nc ovi pa t sc e' t he mm ng ry' as .' Ceotx Cop.v.Cart, U. 31 325( 986) I t mova s tsist sbtr n,t nt le r tet477 S. 7, 1 . f he nt aife hi lde he he nonmova mus s tf t s cii a s i ef c st tde nt t e orh pe fc, dmi sbl a t ha monsr t t e se e ofage ne ta e he xit nc nui is o fc f rtil d. t3 2 2 A p ryi e t ldt s mma yj d me ti t erc r a a sue f a t o ra.l a 2 - 3. at s ni e o u r u g n f h e od s t whol c d notl a a r tona t i roff c t tnd i f vo oft non- ova . W iln sv. e oul e d a i l re a t o s n a r he m nt li m Grfi 952F. 820,823( hCi.1 ) ifn, 2d 4t r 991. 4Pli ifr ei PLN ' Novembe 201 is on J num' 1 , 201 ( a ntf ec ved S r 3 s ue a y 5 4, ComplT25 a t Dec mbe . ) nd he e r 2 3is eo J n ay2 , 01 t =a !2 ) 01 su n a u r 3 2 4 j .t 6. # 5Pli ifha a g d i t Com pli t tDe e t 'alege a t oromisonsvi ae t Ei h antf d r ue n he ant ha f ndan s l d c s si oltd he ght Ame d n, u heh ssn ewi d a t t r u n.( . Rep.ECFNo 45 3 . n me tb t a ic t rwn ha ag me t Pls s ( h ' . ) 7) 11 1. A sf t i s s ofPLN a Fi lCa lt tPl i ifr ce ved,e t routofor r o or he s ue nd na l ha a ntf e i ihe de r deaye Pl ntf f ist e tbls avi a i ofaf r lrght TheFis Am e e pr e t l d, ai if al o sa ih olton ede a i . rt ndm nt ot cs i aes rg st t fe e r i eofr lgi a c ac wih s ey vi m a l Se e. , nm t ' i ht o he r e xe c s e i on nd ont t t ocit a i. es a. Thor c v.Abbot,490U. 401 407( 989 ;Pr unirv. a tnez 41 U. 3 40809 nbur h t S. , 1 ) oc e M ri , 6 S. 96, ( 974) Lovea ev. e, F.d 1 4,1 ( hCi. 1 ; lc Le 472 3 7 99 4t r 2006) Ge r l t prvaltnavoltt . nealy,o e i ) i aim oft Fis Ame e ,t prs he rt ndm nt he ionerm us s t how t taprs n a ton orr gulton i not ha io c i e ai s r a o a l r ltdt pe o o ia itrss Tu n rv. aly 4 2U. 7 , 9 9 ( 9 7 . e s n by eae o n l gc l ne et. r e S fe , 8 S. 8 8 - 0 1 8 ) Fa t srl nti deemi ngt ras blnes ofaprs ac orr ultoni ude( )t cor eeva n tr ni he e ona e s ion t eg ai ncl 1 he c n e to b t e t ea t rr g lto a dalg t t, e ta g v l n p m o e ()t o n cin ewe n h c o e uain n e ii e n ur l o emme t u s ,2 he ma e itn eo atr ai eme n o e e csn t rg t ()t ei a ta c mmo ai no t erg t x se c f l n tv a s f x r iig he ih , 3 h mp c c o d to f h ih e woul ha on g ds ohe i ts a prs r oures a ( t abs nc ofr dy d ve uar , t r nmae , nd ion es c , nd 4) he e e ea atr tvest t ae orr ulton.L.a 89- .l a yi t ef tr ,hec t t lenai o he t eg ai ds t 91 n ppl ng hes aco s t our mus u kes tt deemi tonsofprs ofiil. Unie Sttsv.St t,925F. 83,86(t Ci. s pec he tr nai r ion fcas' td ae ' ots 2d 4h r 1 ) Unde Tur r t i t hast bu de t diprvet vai t oft prs rgulto 991 . r ne ,he nmae he r n o s o he ldiy he ion e ain. Overonv. zz t 539U. 1 1 ( t Ba eta, S. 26, 32 2003) . l t si t nc t VDOC' polc i r s na y r a e t a lgii ae s urt it r s. n hi nsa e, he S iy s ea o bl elt d o e tm t ec iy n e e t P ru n t OP 8 32 alic migp b iain aes be t or ve a t i t ui n l e e u sa to 0 ., 1 n o n u lc to s r u j c t e iw the nsi to a lv l t be or t y a er c ve b i t s I apublc ton i nota ove i i f wa de t o fcal f e he r e ei d y nma e . f ia i s ppr d, t s or r d o fi i s i Ri hmond,Vigi a f a fna dee m i ton.Eve when apublc ton i a ove t n c r ni, or i l tr na i n ia i s ppr d, he r e pr s nec s a iy c us s eviw oce s e s rl a es ome dea bet enwhe apublc ton i r cevedi t ly we n i a i s e i n he R O SP m air loom a whe i i r c ve by t i na e. A r vi w ofa li nd n t s e ei d he m t e e l ncom i publc tons ng ia i , r r es oft i poltc orr lgi a fla i i nec s a y t m ai a n s curt i VD O C ega dl s he r ii al e i ous f ii ton, s e s r o nt i e iy n 4 f c ltesbe us t s f t ofi aes prs saf,a t publc i o oft prmar a iii ca e he a e y nm t , ion t f nd he i s ne he i y f n tonsofpr s a i s r to 6 Se Cute v. W ikns n, 4 U. 7 9 7 5( 0 ) i on dm ni t a i n. e t r u ci li o 5 4 S. 0 , 2 20 5 (t rs n sc rt i ac mp ligsaeitrs. Cr fo v. e 1 0F.d 9 7 9 ( t Ci. tplio e u iy s o eln tt n ee t' o tn Ro , 7 3 5 , 61 9h r g ); 1 9 )( odn t a atmpo ayd lyi ted l ey o p bl ainsr s ligfo p io 9 9 h lig h t e rr ea n h ei r f u i to e utn r m rs n v c ofi i l s urt i pe to doe no vi ae i t 'Fis Am e fc as' ec iy ns c i n s t ol t nma es rt ndmen rg sbe a e ad i y t i ht c us d c pol ofdi r i publc tons t ough t pr r y r ve tng i a i hr he ope t oom i r as bl r l t t t prs si e es s e ona y e a ed o he i on' nt r t i i s e tn mal o c n rb nd' (ii Sz mo ey W ilfr , 2 F.d6 , 0( t Ci. n n p ci g i f r o ta a ' ctng ie r , l o d 8 9 2 08 61 7h r ) i 1 8 )(mp a ii gt a t rl algn a ioltdd lyo s meoh rrlt eys or-e 9 7 e h szn h t d ey l ig n s ae ea r o te eai l h ttnn, me e v non c e - s d di r pton i t de i r ofi a e r a ng m a e i sw ilno s ont ntba e s u i n he lve y nm t e di t ral l t uppo t...a r c eofa ton gounde upont Fis Ame me l.Cons que l t VDOC rvi aus ci r d he rt nd nf') e nty,he e ew pr es a isr uli dely a e r as bl r l t t l ii a epe ogia i e e t. oc s nd t es tng a r e ona y e aed o eg tm t nol c l nt r ss Pl i ifc e t the hasnotr e ve PLN i s f om Oc obe 201 a M a c a ntf ont nds ha ec i d s ues r t r 3 nd r h 201 Def nda sa e una e t ac untf t w he ea 4. e nt r bl o co or he r bout oft s t o i s s ofPLN . s he e w s ue Des t VDOC polc t t c r r t Oc o r201 is ofPLN wa ero ousy pie iy o he onta y, he t be 3 s ue s r ne l f wa ded t PRC a notdei r d t M uha mad.1 Pli iff rhe c e t theha no or r o nd lve e o m s t a ntf u t r ont nds ha r e ve S he Fe ua y 201 ' na Ca li s s and by pr e s ofe i i to f rhi r c i of ec i d i r br r ot 4' Fi l l s ue , oc s lm na i n o s e e pt ot ris si Fe a y i 201 t is t whih Pl ntf ma lke y r f ri t Fe u r 25, he s ue n bnlr n 4, he s ue o c ai if y i l e e s he br a y 201 i s ofFi Ca l 4, s ue nal l . Conce ni bot t em isng is sa a s t de a d i s sofFi lCala PLN , r ng h hes s i s ue nd lo he l ye s ue na l nd Pli iff l t esa ih avi ai n off de allw .Ale tonst tprs n ofk i l antf ais o t bls olto e r a l gai ha io t as 6Tot ex e del i dei r c beatrbut t sa ffii t pr ry f l VDOC polci a he t nt ays n lvey an ti ed o tf alng o ope l olow i es nd po e u e,eifi n t v ia l u d rj1 8 .S e es, c i v Cnv. fF ifx 9 7F.d 1 5 ,1 6 ( t Ci. rc d rs rl s o a albe n e 9 3 e . -.Rico . t o ara , 0 2 4 9 4 9 4h r e . 1 9 )(odn ta i saelw g a t moep o e ua rg t ta t Co si to rq ie, saesfi r t a ie 9 0 h lig h t f tt a rns r r c d rlihs h n he n tuin e urs a tt' al e o bd t u b ta 1w i n tafd r l u po esis e. y h t a s o e ea d e rc s su ) 1Defndant donotbeivet y hav dia ove orde e t M arh 201 is ofPLN i e e s le he e s ppr d nid he c 4 sue ntndedf or M uha m a m d. i e i ly orne i nty de i d a i t ofhi pr ry whieaci outi t s opeof nt ntona l glge l prve n nma e s ope t l tng sde he c ofs i lpolc orc t do nots a e a c ns iutonalc a m i a m e ni f pos - prva i tca iy us om t t ny o tt i li f a ng ul t de i ton rme f t l si a ia e e dy or he os s valbl.Huds nv. l r 468U. 51 533( 984) Part v. vl , o Pame , S. 7, 1 ; rat Ta or 451U. 527( 981,over ldj irl ntpa t . Da el v.W ila ,474U. 327,330S. 1 ) rue . reeva r by ni s q lims S. 31 ( 986 .Pli ifposesesapos- prvai rme unde Vigi a1w be i t i t 1 ) antf s s tde i ton e dy r r ni a sdes he nmae gre ncepr durs t Vigi aTor Cli Ac (ç iva oce e ,he r ni t ams t i VTCA') Se Va. '. e Codej8. - 3. 01195. çsec i 1 w a i t nde t pr e to y f de a r g s g r nt e by f r ll w ,a nott t i ton 983 s n e d o ot c nl e r l i ht ua a e d ede a a nd or cli f whi h t r a ea uaer medi unde sa el w.'W rg v. lns 766 F. 8 a ms or c he e r deq t e es r tt a ' i ht Coli , 2d 41, 8 ( hCi.1985 .Adsofsmpl neglg nc dono af dPlitf r i vi j 1 49 4t r ) i e ie e t for anif elef a 983.Da es nil, 474 U . a 328. S. t Pl i iff ist e t ih t thewasteaed dif r ty fom smia l st t i t s antf a l o sabls ha r t fe en l r i lry- iuaed nma e asar s tofpuposf dici nai Se e. ,M orio v.Gara y,239F. 648,654( h eul eul srmi ton. e. g. rs n r ght 3d 4t Ci. ) Pli iff t rfist esabls t ta delyornon-ec i oft rlgi r 2001. antf urhe al o t ih ha ny a r ept he ei ous perodi a Fi lCal consiu e a s tntalbur n,e pe a l snc Pli ifc i c l na l tt t d ubsa i de s cily i e antf nnnotr l o hi ey n s l be sa c l i t s tf t t ta lga i a he,a tedl r ceved ne ry a1oft m . a l nd onc usons o e orh ha le ton nd dmit y, e i a l l he Sç s anoe3;s se. sBelAt.Com.v.Twombl 550U. 544,555( e upr t ee c. l l y, S. 2007)( i a notng pli ifsbai frr le Sequie mo et nlbesandc l ins....) Lovelcev.Lee antf ss o eif û rs r ha a l r oncuso '; ' a , 472F. 1 1 (t Ci.2006 ( i ngat ubsa ilbur n'onr ii e riea 3d 74, 87 4h r ) detni i tnta de ' elgous xecs s s S ki s t ilprsur ona a rntt modiyhi beha ora t vi aehi beif,o ç tng) ubsanta e s e n dhee o put f s vi nd o olt s les r . . . f r g )ap ro t c o s b t e f lo ngt ep e e t o h rr l o a df retn o ci ng e s n o h o e ewe n olwi h r c p s f e ei n n o fiig gi L venme a)be lt,ont oneha a a ndoni oneoft pr e sofhe rlgi ... go r ntl neis he nd, nd ba ng he ec pt r ei on o t ot rha ' (nt na q ttonsa cttonso te ) Eve i Pl nifha etbls d n he he nd. i er l uoai nd iai mitdl. n f aitf d sa ihe ' as tnta bur n, hedely a non- hr ogia dei r ofnea l a loft is Fi l ubs a i l de t a nd c onol c l lve y ry l he s ues na Cal we e ar ul oft a nita i r viw ofi l r es t he dmi sr tve e e ncomi m al whi h s r esa c ng i, c e v ompe lng li gover ent i er t nm al nt es . IV . Fo tefr g igr a o s lg a t fnd n s mo inf rs mmayj d me t r h o e on e s n , rn Dee a t ' to o u r u g n . ENTER: s l lhd yo J y, 2 5. Thi Q' a f ul 01 ' 1 i . r j -. . v - .. .; f $ .Se rUnied St t D i ti tJ ni t a es sr c udge . .
]]>
Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You
should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Service apply.
