Johnson v. Mathena, No. 7:2014cv00079 - Document 2 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 02/27/2014. (kab)

Download PDF
*7 ' e F*m:Alyj b,:, :4 > I d r /. % r TROANOKE,VA FIED L FEa 2 7 2 , gj I TH E U NI N TED STATES DISTRI T C O UR T C FO R TH E W ESTERN DISTR I T O F V IR G I IA C N R O AN O K E DI I O N V SI LAR R Y R AY JO H N SO N , JULA c. . # ' I ) t ' . BK u j cu j j uaK DE CLERK CA SE N O .7: 4CV 00079 1 Pe ii r tt one , V. M EM O M ND U M O PI I N N O RANDALL C.M A THENA, ARDEN, W By: H on.Gln E.Conr e ad Chi fU nied St e D i t i Judge e t at s s r ct R e ponde . s nt La r Ra J on,a Vigi a i ae pr e di pr K ,fl t spe ii n f a wrtof r y y ohns r ni nm t oc e ng o ied hi tto or i . ha ascopus plrln t 28U. C.j2254.Upon rviw oft peii t co tc udes be r , zslnt o S. e e he tton, he ur oncl ta i mus b sl rl d s se wih u prj d c ,b c us J h o ha sae n rg tt htt t e l mmaiy imisd t o t eu ie e a e o ns n s ttd o i h o r l ft e j2 4. ei md r 25 1 e Ha asco puspe ii a e ge r ly r s r e f r a tc on t f c ordtr ton oft be r ttons r ne a l e e v d o ta ks he a t la i he peiiners c i me . Se Prie v.Rodra , 411 U. 475, 500 ( 973 . J on tto ' onfne nt e esr iuez S. 1 ) ohns e es l saest the i notc le ng hi sae orf de a convitonsors ntnc ,howe r xpr sy t t ha s hal ngi s tt e rl ci e e es ve . Rahe ,he ase t t t t c ts a i ton of Prs Lii ton Refr Ac (TLlA' tr s rs ha he our' pplcai ion tgai om t 1 t ' ) pr sons ha t ovii s t undul i ie 'hi c tm to l rght t due pr es a t a e s t y mpar d' s onsi i na i s o oc s nd o cc s he c u t. S e 2 U. C. j 1 5 a, () a d ( ) 2 U. C. j1 5 b ( ) 4 U. C. o rs e 8 S. 91 () d , n g ; 8 S. 91 A( )1 ; 2 S. 1 Un e Rul 4b o te Rue Go enn j2 4 Cae, tec utma s mmai ds s a j22 4 d r e () f h ls v rig 25 s s h o r y u rl imis y 5 p tto çifiplil a per fo tep tto a da yatc e e hbi ta tep tto e i n te tte t rl f ei n çq t any p as rm h ei n n n t h d x i t h t h ei n r s o n i d o ei i l i a s i l e i t dikitcout' n he s c l ' : i j1997 c( . A srlef i t s habeas acton, J o a kst co tt alow hi t 5l i e()2)2 ei n hi ohns n s he ur o l m o en f r pau rscv l iht a to , oo d rhi rmo lto aj ds ito wiha c s t al tt o ma pe i ii rg s cins t r e s e va t u dcin t c e s o l sae t & fd r l o rs'o t o d rh m it ûe e a c t d i daey. 3( No 1 a 1 . e e a c u t, r o r e i n o l d r l uso y mme itl ' ECF . , t 9) ' f ' The c tc our nnnotfnd t tJo on ha sae a gr i ha hns s ttd ny ound f t rle t rj 225 or he eif mde 4. J ms s co tt i lc lnge t t PLRA r titons on hi a lt t fl cvi a tons ol on' nsiutona hale s o he esrc i s biiy o ie i l ci w ihoutpr pa e of t flng f e ha no bemi w ha s ve on t f c or dur ton of hi t e ym nt he ii e ve ng t oe r he a t ai s c n ie n . Th ,te d no p e e ta y c g ia l j2 5 h b a cam. Net e d o fn me t4 us h y o t r s n n o nz be 2 4 a e s li ih r o J h o sc ncus r alg to s a o toh r s be tmatrhe ma wih t rie i a cv l o ns n' o l o y l ai n b u te u j c te e y s o as n ii a ton, c e i e es i f c m e ca c e a m a l pr e s a dit uli s ge tng ci onc m ng xc sve or e, di l ar nd i obl m , nd fk te ti pa r k fom prs ofi i l t fl ci l aci . Suc chal nge t c tons of pe wor r ion tc as o ie vi tons h le s o ondii c v n me tfl welo tie tec r o ha e sc r u s b e tmatra mu tb r ie ,i a o e n al l u sd h o e f b a o p s u j c te nd s e as d f t a 1 i a c vi a ton unde f de alo sae 1w a ns t r s i e prs of i l . Se e. , 1, n i l c i r e r r tt a gai t he e ponsbl ion fc a s e, g. Nelo v.Cn sn mpbel,5 U. 637,643( 4) l 41 S. 200 . Be a e J c us ohns s cli s do no ,i a r s c ,c le t f tor dtr ton ofhi on' am t n ny e pe t hal nge he ac la i s c i nt he has sae no Found fr r i unde j2254. Theef e,t c twil onfneme , ttd o elef r r or he our l s m a iy di m i shi pe ii A n a opra e or rw ili s t sda um r l s s s tton. ppr i t de l s ue hi y. 2 Seto 1 5a a d()rq iep io e lt a t t b as se tef lfl gfefr:1 gacvj a ton, cin 91 () n b e ur rs n r ii ns o e ses d h ul ii e o j g n n j l ci b t l w te t q aiyt p ytru hisal nsfo terimaetuta c u t.S cin 1 5 e, 1 5 b u al h m o u l o a ho g ntl t rm h i n t r s c o n s e t 91 () j 91 A( , o f me o a d l 97 ()2 alw smmayds sa o a imae' q aiyn cvlato i i i gioo ,maiiu , rfi n 9 ec() lo u r imisl f n n t s u l ig ii cin f ts v lus lco s o al f s t saeacam.Un e j1 5g , n ea imaeh sa q rdtrep irRtie'(ae ds se a fioo , o tt li d r 91 () o c n n t a c uie he ro srk s' c ss imis d s rv lus maiiu ,o frfi r t saeacam) h c n o p o e d wi a yne cvlato u ls ( )hepa stefl lco s r o al e o tt li , e a n t r c e t n w ii cin nes 1 u h y h ul flngf orhes ii ee howshei tt ri ne da s lmde mmi nt ngerofphysca har ' Thes r ti i , i l m.' e esrctons howe r do no ap y t ve , t pl o h b a c ru peiin .S eCas nv.o n o ,1 2F.d8 8 8 0(t Ci.1 9 ) a e s op s tt s e ro J h s n 1 3 1 , 2 5h r 9 7 . o 3Re odsidiaeta i J l 2 3 Jh o wa c n ce o fd rlci na c ag sa dsne c dt a c r n c t h tn uy 01 , o nsn s o vitd n e ea rmi l h r e n e tn e o to lof240m ont i prs Se Unle Stt v.J on,Ca eN o.2:2CR0001 Hi a ali pe ng. o hs n ion. e td aes ohns s 1 5. s ppe s ndi I ac rlte ,J on me i t tt PLRA ha pr ntd hi 9om flng a ci lrght a ton t n ove e tr ohns ntons ha he s eve e m ii vi i s ci o c lnge sae ofk i s'aleged f iur t c cult co r ty hi good co hale tt f al l al e o al ae recl s nducttm e. W hie a cam c m i i l li once ng de i to ofcedi f r e r g d cond ttm e agans a i a e' sae s nt e m i be aci bl l der prvain r t o a ned oo uc i i t n nm t s tt e enc ght tona e m j2 5 Jh s nma e n s c cam i hsc retp tto 2 4, o n o k s o u h li n i urn eiin. The Clr i dieced t s nd c e oft s me or ndlm opi on a a c pa ng e k s r t o e opi s hi m a l ni nd c om nyi or rt pe ii r de o ttone . ENTER:ThsJ 9 d yo Fe ray 201 i a f b ur , 4. ChifUnie St t sDititJ e e t d a e src udg 3

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.