Obataiye-Allah v. Clark et al, No. 7:2014cv00016 - Document 25 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 02/25/2014. (kab)

Download PDF
CL ERK' OFFI U, DI 'COUQT S C: S. Sh . AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED FEB 6 2 1 29 I TH E U N I D STATE S D I N TE STR I C O U RT CT FO R TH E W E STERN D I STR I O F VI G I A CT R NI R O A NO K E D I I O N V SI UH URUSEK OU OBATAI ALLAH , YE- auuA c. l BY: DE p è , CLERK YL ERK CASE NO .7: 14CV0001 6 Pl ntf, ai if V . MEMORAND/M om xl oN HAROLD CLARK, TAL , E By: Gl n E. e Conr ad C hi fU ni e St t D i t i tJudge e t d a es s r c Deendants. f t) Thi cl e cvi a ton i bef e t cour on pli ifs m otons t n e whi h t s os d i l c i s or he t antf i o m nd, c he co tal o c t es as s ki r i t t m en of t a i t t c ts a tve doc t A fe ur s onsnz ee ng e ns a e t he cton o he our ' c i ke . t r ca e u l r viwi pl ntf doz ns of s r f ly e e ng ai ifs e ubmisons a hi pr ed ame e s t c t si nd s opos ndm nt, he our fndsno r % o t r i t t t a to andwildenypli ifsmotons i e n o ensae he c i n l antf i . Uhul se ObaayeAla (t antf ', i t a RedOni Stt Prs fldt s w kou ti - lh G i if) an nmae t pl on ae ion, ie hi or K cvi rght a tonunde 42 U. C.j1 o i l i s ci r S. 983.Pli ifsi ta s si consse of52 antf niil ubmisons itd page ,nn e m or t n 35 pr s ofi i l as de enda s a a s r e conc us y ûc ai s'of s m d e ha ion fc a s f nt , nd s e t d l or i l m ' neglg nc a e of pr es ,a va i co tt i l vi a i . The c pli wa not i e e, bus oc s nd rous nsiutona oltons om a nt s sg e u d rp n l o pej r , d n c h rn sae n o f csi s p o t fe c o te e in d n e e at f ru y ma e o o ee t ttme t f a t n u p r o a h f h s y ca ms a i t a m e i d va i i i nt a r ndom ove t c zs of an l mont li , nd, nse d, ntone rous nc de s t a r he olr e 8h peid. Plitf as mo e f ritro uo yij n tv r l f algn t a h fa e o fc r a ro 1 an if lo v d o n el c t r n u ci e ei , l ig h t e e rd fies t e e Red Oni wer rt itng a i thi f ra uns c s f lws the fl al t1 yea sago on e eala i ga ns m o n uc e s ul a ui ied mos 0 r a ans o t r a a o h r p io S e Tab r v.S t 7: CV0 7 6 ( . Va 20 7 g i t fke s t n t e rs n. e le t mi 05 0 3 W D. . 0 ) h, (u g n e trdf rd fnd n sa tr u ytil. d me t n ee o ee a t fe j r ra) 1 Pl ntf aso na ed s ver ot r i at ast ai if ' and moved t c tf a cl sac i on ai if l m e al he nm es l ntfs' pl o eriy as ton r alaton. Thi m oton i wihoutm ert ast courtcannotc iy a clss i a ac i wher a pr K et i i s i s t i, he ertf a n n ton e o l ia s e st r p e e t itr ssoft ca s Oxe iev. ila , 9F. 1 ( hCi.1 75 . i g nt e k o e r s nthe n ee t he ls . ndn W lims 50 2d 405 4t r 9 ) t The c t e e e a c to l flng o de , r quii pli if t pr de fna i l our nt r d ondii na ii r r e rng antf o ovi i nc a i or ai t alow hi t pr e wihoutpr pa nf m ton o l m o oc ed t e ymen of t flng f e unde 28 U . C. t he ii e r S. j 1 5( . The frtpaagaph oft or rnotfe pl ntf t tuntlhe c i wih t s 91 b) is r r he de iid ai if ha i ompled t hi o d r t ec t'wo l n tû du iaelg la d fcu lmatr ds u s di ete ape dn o r e, h out u d o t j d c t e a n a t a te s ic s e n ih r la ig r a mo in. ( No 6. Ne e tee s plitf h sc niue t fl mo in ,se ig t n n to ' ECF . ) v rh ls, an if a o t d o ie to s e kn o me d ' n t c pli a hi r ss f i e l ut y r i t add m or concus y a l a i a he om a nt nd s eque t or nt roc or elef o e l or leg tons nd na e ne de e n s ort dim isc am sagans pr vi l na m w f nda t o s s li i t e ousy med de e n s Pli tf t n f nda t . a n if he fl d a moton t vol a iy wihdr w t l ws t whih t c tgr nt d. The ne da ie i o unt rl t a he a ui, c he our a e xt y, howe r pl ntf s ve , ai if ubmit adeca aton sa i t the di no wa t wihdr w t s tafe ted lr i ttng ha d t nt o t a he ui tr a l l t a he fl t a tonalmotonst a nd. l. nse d, ied wo ddii i o me Th c u t a o fn i t b i teitrs o j tc t ri tt tepanifsa to t e o r c nn t i d t o e n h n ee t f usie o ensae h litf cin o t a tve doc t a i smpl doe not c pl wih t mi mum sa r f a cvi he c i ke , s t i y s om y t he ni tnda ds or i l c mplit Fe e a Ru eo Cii Pr c d r 8a ( )rq ie aG h r a dpli sae n o te o an . d r l l f vl o e u e ()2 e ur s t o t n an ttme t f h s cai s l m howi t t t plade i e il d t r le . Pl i ifs alega i do not sa e an ng ha he e r s ntte o ei f' antf ' l tons tt a tona e cli unl s he û e ds f c ua c e t tal ws t c tt d aw t r a ona e c i bl a m e s i a a t l ont nt ha lo he our o r he e s bl pl i e e e t t t def nda i la e f t m ic nfr nc ha he e nt s ibl or he s onduc al ge ' As r t v.I l 556 t le d. ' hc of qba , 1 5. 1 S.Ct 1 7. 662, 29 . 937,1 ( 949 2009) Bel Ata i Cor v.Twombl 550 U. 544,570 ; l lntc p. y, S. ( 2007) (i ng dimis a o it whee pl ntf f t fndi s sal ppr prae r ai ifs acualalegai do not s por l tons up t G lu il' cam f rr le Th c u tsd t t c n tu apr . pan ifspe dng mo e ç a sb e' li o eig. e o r' uy o o sr e o K litf la i s r p lbe aly t t e fl by a a t ey doesno r quie t c tt c tuc a tona e cai s i r l h% hos ied n tom t e r he our o onsr t c i bl l m f pli tf fom t ls ofde e nt,pa a a ofba e l ga t ores sa of gre or a n if r he it f nda s r gr phs r e l he i , t cks ivanc e f m s a t omwc e e bis a m uli e,t k- a nd e s he has s or nd mc t d xhi t , nd tpl ac on me m nt ubmit ted. Se e 2 Be u etv Ci o Hn tn,7 5F.d 1 7 ,1 7 - 8 ( t Ci.9 5 ( tn t a tp rn ils a d t . t f mpo 7 2 2 4 2 7 7 4h r1 8 ) noig h t G licpe v l rquii ge ousc tucin ofpr s c ai sa eno , ve , t lmis). e rng ner onsr to o e ompl nt r t howe r wihout i t' Plitf s s b sin as fi t c mpl wih t r ls g v r n t e j i e o anif u miso s lo al o o y t he ue o enig h ond r f mul pe camsa d d fn a t i t e s me lws i. Un e Rue 1 () a p an ifma b ig t l li n ee d ns n h a a ut d r l 8a , litf y rn i muli e c am s r l td or no ,i a lws ta i ta sngl de e nt Howeve ,i or r t tpl l i , e ae t n a ui ga ns i e f nda . r n de o n me oh r d fn a t i te sme lws i,t e panif mu t stsy Ru e 2 ()2 ,whih n te ee d n s n h a a ut h litf s aif l 0 a( ) c p r t j i e o mutp ed fn a t o l wheet erg tt rle a s re a an tt e a ie emis ond r f lil e e d n s ny r h ih o eif s etd g is h m rs s o oft s meta a ton orocc r e a conc r acommon quesi of1w orf t On is ut he n r ns c i u r nce nd e ns ton a ac . t f e pl ntf s c ac , ai if ompl n a pi e e l n e e s brngi muli e t eatd cli s ait nd ec m a m ndm nt, i ng tpl, mr l e am a i tdoze ofde e gans ns f ndan s dono c t, t ompl wih t s rzes y t he e tl . Fi l e n i t co twe e t r i tt t aci pl i ifsmotonsf i e l ut y naly, ve f he ur r o ensa e he ton, antf i or ntroc or ijmcier l fd n tsaef cswa rni s c a e ta r i ay rme y Th p ry s e i nt tv ei o o tt a t ra t u h n xr od n r e d . e a t e kng e ng t prl n r ij ncin mus ma e ace rs o ng t 1 ta h i lk l t s c e d o t e he ei a y nu to mi t k la h wi t ) h t e s i ey o u c e n h ( meis ( )h i lk l t s fe irpaa l h nn i tea s n eo p ei n r rle ; 3 t t h rt; 2 e s iey o u fr re rb e a n h b e c f r l a y eif ( ) ha t e mi baa c o e uiistp i h sfv r a d ( )a ijmcin i i t epu lcitr s.z Re lTrzh ln e f q te is n i a o , n 4 n nt to s n h bi nee t' a t ' t ' Ab u Obn . n . FEC, 7 F.d3 2 3 6 4 ( t Ci. 0 9 , a ae o oh ra omd , 5 o t ma I c v. 5 5 3 4 , 4 - 7 4h r 2 0 ) v c td n t e r t s 5 9 U. 1 8 ( 01 ) r isae i rlva tp r b 6 7 F.d 3 ,3 5 (t Ci.2 0 ( u tn S. 0 9 2 0 , en ttd n ee n a t y 0 3 55 5 4 h r 01 ) q oi g W itrv Nau a Re olc sDee eCo n i.n .5 5U.. , 0( 0 8 n e . t rl s t e fns u cll c, 5 S 7 2 2 0 :. r Plitf smoinsf ritro uo yij n tv rle aeb s do c ncu o y alg to s an if t o nel c tr n u cie eif r a e n o ls r le ain o ofr t iton f t l ws the l ta ti lye sa Tha l ui al ge us ofe s i f ce eala i or he a ui os t ra ar go. t aws t le d e xce sve or 2 Te por y r tai ng or sar is onl r el , w hen t m ovantpr m ar esr ni der e s ued y ar y he ovest the w ils f ha l ufer ij y i r le i n tva td beor t ea e s pa t c l b n tfe a ha op runt t r s nd. nur f eif s o ne f e h dv re ry oud e o iid nd ve po t iy o e po Se Rul 6 b) Fe rlRulsofCi lPr e r Su h a o de woud o y l tu i s h tme a a e e 5( , dea e vi oc du e. c n r r l nl as ntl uc i s h ai onaprlmi r ij ncinc l b arn d.Asii ce rfo teo te t tplitf i no e rng ei nay nu to oud e ra ge t s la rm h ust ha anif s t e tte t a pr i n r ij c i ,t e c r fn no ba i u n whih t g a t hi a t mpo ay nild o el a y nun ton h ou t ids mi ss po c o rn m e rr r tai ng or . esr ni der by o t e s a W al ns li St t Prs n. Some de e fk r t le tdge ae io f ndan s fom t t o1 lws t a e no t r ha d a ui r w empl oyed a s r s y ofk i l a Re Oni s upe vior t a s t d on. Pl i if a lges t t va i Re Oni antf le ha rous d on ofi i s ha n fcal ve, mong o he t ngs r us d hi ou sde r r a i a s t r hi , ef e m t i ec e ton nd howe s on oc son, r ca i denid hi mea sort i e hi f e m l ant d s ood,f le y c r d hi wih adici i r ofe e,c ic t d a s l ha ge m t s plna y f ns onfs a e or de t oye hi pe s l pr r y, ve baly t e t ned hi , a pl ed hi i s gr t d s r d s r ona ope t r l hr a e m nd ac m n e ega e confne e ,pur tdl al i r t iton f t o1 lw s t Pl ntf doe not sae f c s i m nt pore y 1 n eala i or he d a ui. ai if s tt a t, howe r c ve , onneci ofi e s a tonsa Re Oni n t t pas lws ta te nt a W al ns tng fc r ' c i t d o o he t a ui bou ve s t le Ri dge. M or r he smpl does not sa e f c s s eove , i y tt a t uppori a fndi t the i i i i nt tng i ng ha s n mm ne dange ofir r bl ha m wihoutt r quese c ti e ve i n. r repa a e r t he e t d our ntr nto For t saed r a ons t c t fnds no gr he t t e s , he our i ound o whih pl ntf i e il d t n c ai if s ntte o r i tt m e oft saci a wilde pl ntf ' pe ng m o i t n e 'heac i wa , ensa e nt hi ton nd l ny ai ifs ndi tons o m nd. I ' ton s a dwi rman, imis dwi o t eu iet panifsp ruto o eo mo eo hscamsi n l e i d s s e t u prj d c o litf u s i f n r r f i li n l h anew a s pa a eco pl ntt tco ple wih Rul 8,1 a 21. An a oprae or rwil nd e r t m ai ha m i s t es 8, nd ppr it de l i s t sda s ue hi y. The Cl r i dieced t s nd c es oft s me or ndtm o ni a a c pa ng e k s r t o e opi hi m a l pi on nd c om nyi o de t pl i if r r o antf. ENTER:Thi XG da ofFe u r 201 s y br a y, 4. ChifUnie St t DititJ e e t d aes src udg 4

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.