Taylor v. Colvin, No. 7:2013cv00536 - Document 19 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/4/2014. (lab)

Download PDF
co t ntpan,wea s i e r m iis irt e bowe s nd o e a i om ni ' Pli ifnow nsa i kne s n xte te , riabl l y r m , nd ns a. a ntf m ai ai t s hasr m a ne diabl d t t pr s nttm e. The r o d r ve s t M r .Ta or nt ns hat he e i d s e o he e e i ec r e al hat s yl m e t i ur d s a usr quiem e soft A c t ough t f t qua t rof2009, not he e t r t he ns e t t e r nt he t hr he ourh re but t r afe . Seege r l 42U. C.jj41 i a 423() nealy, S. 6() nd a .Cons que l Mr.Ta ori enildt dia lt e nty, s yl s tte o sbiiy i ur nc be ft onl i s hasesa ihe t s be a edia e f a1 f msofs t i ns a e ne is y f he t bls d hat he c m s bl d or 1 or ubsantal ga nf e pl e ,w ihi t m ea ng of t A c ,a s e poi be w e n A ugus 5,2009 a i ul m oym nt t n he ni he t t om nt t e t nd De mbe 31 2009.Seege r l 42U. C.jj423a . ce r , nealy, S. () M r . Ta or s applc ton f be is was de ed upon i ta c i r ton a s yl ' i ai or neft ni nii l onsde a i nd r c i r i She t n rquesed a rceved a éç novo he rng a r viw beor a e onsdeaton. he e t nd e i ai nd e e fe n Adm i sr tveLa J nita i w udge l a opi o da e J 21 201 t La J . n n ni n t d une , 2,he w udgea s c ude M r . l o oncl d s Ta ordi not omedia e a a i prort t t r i to ofi ur dsa us TheLa J yl d bec s bld t nytme i o he e m na in ns e t t . w udge f undt t d i t r e tpe i pl i i fs f r d f om s ve e i paim e s i udi obe iy, o ha , ur ng he el van rod, a ntf uf e e r e r m r nt , ncl ng s t fb o aga a dd g n rtv j it ie s o t l mb rs i e Be a eo t e ec n iin ,h i r my li, n e e eaie on d sa e f he u a p n . c us f h s o dto s t e La J w udge nze t tpl ntf be am e di a e f rhe pas r l ntwor prort Dec m be 31 l d ha ai if c s bl d o r t e eva k i o e r , 20 9 Ho ve,h La J d eh l t a, u igt ep ro i whc panifsil no e is rd 0 . we rt e w u g ed h td rn h ei d n ih litf tl e j y d n u e sat , r . yl rpos e s r sdua f tona c pa t f ralmie r ngeoflgh t us M s Ta o s s ed e i l unc i l a ciy o i t d a i twor TheLa k. w J udge as e s d pl ntf sr i lf to lc pac t asf l w s s s e ai i f esdua unc i na a iy olo : A fe ca e ulc i r ton oft e i e r c d,t unde sgned tndst t t ough tr r f ons de a i he ntr e or he ri i ha , hr t da e l ti ur d, he c ai an hast r s dua f tona c pac t t pe f m a he t as ns e t l m t he e i l unc i l a iy o r or rngeoflghtwok asdefne i 20 CFR 40 1 1 Spect ly,t cli nt a i r i dn 4.567(9. ikal he ama c dlf a orc ry 1 poundsfe ntya 20poundsoc aso ly; oul sa oul it nd/ a r 0 r que l nd c i nal c d t nd a / w a k f s x hour a st f sx ho s i a e ghthotr wor y; c d nd or l or i s nd i or i ur n n i - l kda oul occasi l clm b ram psand s ai s,bal onaly i t r ance,kneel cr l soop,and cr , aw , t ouch;m us t 1M r . Ta or s a 1ge dia lt o e da eofAugus 522009,c r s s yl ' 1e d s biiy ns t t t ore pondst t da f lw i t fna o he y olo ng he i l de son oft Comm i sone den ng h r e r i a i ton f dl a lt i u a be is ci i he s i r yi e a ler pplca i or s biiy ns r nce neft . 2 ha a d e ve voi ed xpos e t haz r ur o a dous ma hi r t o e d he g s vi a i c ne y, mm t de i ht , br tng s f c , a ci ng ldde s r s a s a f ds a mus ha a de ura es nd lmbi a r , ope , nd c fol ; nd t ve voi d e s i l l ba kg o noi e. xce sve y oud c r und s ( 30) Gi ns har i f ona c ciy, ndatre ierngpli ifsag e ton, TR . ve uc esdualundi l apa t a fe onsd i antf e, ducai a prorw or e re ,a wel ast tm ony f om a voc tona e r , heLa J nd i k xpe i nce s l es i r a i l xpe t t w udge c l ed onc ud t t pr o t t t r i to ofi tr s a us M r .Ta orr t i d s fci ntph i a c pa iy t ha , i r o he e m na i n ns led t t , s yl e a ne uf i e ys c l a c t o pe f s r ls c t lghtwor r e e si i sgnik a num be i t na i e ronn eve a pe ik i k ol s xitng n i t nt r n he tonal conomy. Acc di l t Law J e de e m i d t t M r .Ta or w a no di a e a t t s i no or ng y, he udg t r ne ha s yl s t s bl d, nd ha he s t e ildt apei ofdia lt o dia lt i urnc be ft. Se 20C. R.j40 1 20( .The ntte o rod s biiy r s biiy ns a e neis e F. 4.5 g) La J ge' o ni n wa ado e a t fna de ii n oft Co misone byt Soc a Se urt w ud s pi o s pt d s he i l c so he m s i r he i l c iy Ad i sr ton' Appe l Counc l Ha ng e use al a lbl a nita i r m e e , r . m nitai s as i. vi xha td 1 vaia e dmi sr tve e di s M s Ta orhasnow a al d t t sc t yl ppe e o hi our . W hie pl i if m a be diabld f r c rai f l antf y s e o e t n onns of e o e ,t c uc a f c ua mpl ym nt he r i l a t l dee m i toni whehe pli ifwa dia edf a 1 or ofs t n i l i ul m pl e .Se t r na i s t r antf s s bl or l f ms ubsa ta ganf e oym nt e 42U. C.j423( ( .Theea ef ee nt ofpr whihmus bec ierdi ma ngs h S. d)2) r r our lme s oof c t onsd e n ki uc a a lss Th s ee n saes mmaie a f lo :( )o j ci me ia fcsa d ci ia n nay i. e e lme t r u rz d s o lws 1 b e t ve d c l a t n lnc l fn ig ;2 t o iins ndc n lso so te tn p y iin ;3 s be tv e ie c o ph sc l i dn s ( )he pn o a o cu in fraig h sca s ( ) u jcie vd n e f y ia manie ttonsofi ime s a desrbe t o hacama tst tmony' nd ( t cama ' fsai mpar nt, s ci d hrug li n ' esi , 4) he li nts a ed ai voc i hit y,esdua s ls a a .Vie v. nc 438F. 11 11 60( h uc ton, atonal sor r i l kil, nd ge tk Fi h, 2d 57, 59- 4t Ci.1 71;Und woodv. biof,298F. 85 851( hCi.1 . r 9 ) er Ri c f 2d 0, 4t r 962) Afe a r viw of t r c d i t s c e, t c t i una e t c l t t t tr e e he e or n hi as he our s bl o onc ude ha he Com m i i r' fnal deci i i s ss one s i s on s upport by s t i l e dence. M rs Tayl s f f ed ubs ant a vi . or uf ers rom fbr ya g a, sw el a o he phys c a e oto l a f t tonsge r l as oc a ed w ih s h i om l i a lst r i al nd m i na m niesa i ne aly s i t t uc 3 a c ton. Asno e by t La J ondii td he w udge pro t t t r na in ofi t e sat ,pl i ifas , i r o he e mi to nsz d t us antf lo r e peinc do e iya dd g n rtv j itd s aeo telmb rs nez W h l rc g iigta x re e b st n e e eai e on ie s f h t a pi . l ie e o nzn h t pl i ifste tng physc a a ate tng r lm aol itpr e fndi whih i cae t t antf ' r a i ii n nd r a i he l t og s oduc d i ngs c ndi t ha pl ntf w a unabl t wor on a r gul ra s t i d bas s t La J ai if s eo k e a nd us a ne i , he w udge opi d t tt r por s ne ha he e t oft tea i phys c a w e e no s he r tng i i ns r t uppor e by a o i t c i c not tons TheLaw J t d ppr pra e lni al a i . udge c t d ie t e r i radm i s r tveopi on on pl ntf str t pplc ton f be tt , sw e la a r por fom he a le nit a i ni ai if i s a i a i or ne i s a l s e t r a none m i ng sa eag nc physca i concudi t tpl ntf r t i s fcintf nc i xn ni t t e y i in, n l ng ha ai if e aned ufi e u tonal c pa iy f lght w o k a tviy a a lr l va tm es pr o t t t m i ton of i ur d s a us a c t or i r c i t t l e e nt i i r o he er na i ns e t t . H o e r t c tco l w ve , he our nc udest ts h r la e i m i pl e The s a e a nc phys c a di not ha uc e i nc s s ac d. t t ge y ii n d ha t o r t iy t e m i M r . yl , di t boar ce tte r um a ol s , r J e ve he ppo tm t o xa ne s Ta or as d he d rii d he t ogi t D . os ph P.Le m e . A c r ngl t c tm us c l t t m uc of t La J m r co di y, he our t onc ude ha h he w udge' r s ng i s ea oni n de ng pl i if sa i a i f bene iss m pl i nots nyi a ntf pplc ton or ft i y s uppored by s t ntale de e. Gi n t ubsa i vi nc ve t r por sofDr Lem m e , w e last e oft f m iy phys c a D r Robe tSol o t c t he e t . r as l hos he a l i i n, . r om n, he our beleve t tM r . yl r ha m e t bur n ofpr i es a ihi t ts w a di a e f al i s ha s Ta o s t he de oof n t bls ng ha he s s bl d or l f m s of s t nta ga nf e pl ym en a of t dat of di a lt ons tale or ubs a i l i ul m o t s he e s biiy e l ged i he s c n r e ond a i a i f be ft . pplc ton or ne is The r um a ol s ,D r Le m e ,fr ts w M r .Ta oron N ove be 9, he t ogi t . m r i s a s yl m r 2009,on r e r l ef r a f om pl ntf s f m iy phys c an, Dr Robe t Sol m o Dr Le m e s m a i e pl i i f s r ai i f n l ii . r o n. . m r um r z d a ntf s m pt at og asf l s y om ol y olow : 2TheLa J w udgedee mi dt t ai ifse otonal oblm swe enot e e,prort t r na i ofi ur tr ne ha pl ntf' m i pr e r s ver i o e mi ton ns ed sa us W hiet co t tt . l he ur doesnotbelevet t r r s i hathe eco d upporst c usont tM r . yl se o i difc tes t he oncl i ha s Ta or' m tonal fiuli w eenots s r ast sgniia l lm ihera lt t pef m wor a tvii frwhihs wasot r s physcal r o eve e o i fc nty i t biiy o ror k ci tes o c he he wie i ly c pa l, e c n r l 2 C. R. 0 1 21t ec r fn s t n e e sr oa d e s s Ta o ' e to a p o e . a b e s e e e al 0 F. j4 4.5 ,h ou ti d iu n c sa yt d r s Mr . ylrs moi n l r blms v, I Novembe 2001 afe hyse e omy a c e yse t n r tr t r ct nd hol c t c omy, s de o d he velpe g ne ai eda hi i t ba k a t lgs Pai hasbe n va i bl i s ve iy snc e r lz c ng n he c nd he e . n e ra e n e rt i e butpr es i a no ha be m e m or pe ssen . Cure ar as ofpan i ogr sve nd w s co e r it t r nt e i n d r asngor rofs ve iyi l t m i ba k,o ba k, pa 1 r on,es e ec e i de e rt ncude he d c l w c hi nd eg egi l s r s t n ms f e ,ne k a s de . Pan i a a t by a tvii s h as o he r , e t c nd houl r i s ggr vaed c i tes uc hous wor i l ngva uumi doi dihes waki s e k ncudi c ng, ng s , l ng, hoppi a sa ng f ng nd t ndi or l pe i . l i hel d s m e t by t tec ng,'Tyl ,hot s ong rods t s pe o wha d r thi ' enol s howe a r nd Exce i Thee hasbe n s mepufi s i t ha a kne butno j nt drn. r e o fne s n he nds nd es oi s eli pe s Ther has be n s if s ofi t r i t d a i i vi t w lng r e. e e tf ne s nde e m na e ur ton nvol ng he fnge s kne s a hi . Pai i oc as o l s ve e a now i ca es na e i r , e nd ps n s c i naly e r nd t us us a. Di a lt i l s biiy nc udeshous w o k, t he w or ga de ng,t a li a vi ii e r kic n k, r ni r ve lng nd stng. ( 2 ) Up nciia e n n to ,h d co l tdt f l wigmu c l s eea tn ig : TR 91. o l c l x miai n t e o tr i e he ol n s uo k ltli dn s n s o The e i mode ae t nde nes oft poserorc r c ls ne,m i beli s ofbot r s r t e r s he t i e via pi d le h ta i m us e , pa as a a mus ultle upper qua a butoc lt r l r pezus cls r c pul r c a tr , dr nt t k, a e a e c yl oft e bow s a e i b ts oft knee , nd t oc nt rc r gi oft pi ond e he l , ns rne tr a he s a r ha e i e on he hp . Alj it h veaf l rng o moin wih u p i s lig, e d r e so is 1 on s a ul a e f t o to t an, weln tn en s r de or iy. f mt ( 292) DrLe rdi nos dge rlz dmyaga a a t agiswihtnde nsconsse TR . . mme ag e neaie lis nd rhrl a , t e rpoit itnt wihc oni pans omefbr l as ome.TR 292) t hz c i yndr /i omyagi yndr ( . M r . yl co i s Ta or ntnuedunde hec r ofDr Sol rt a e . omona Dr Le me .Shes w Dr Le me nd . m r a . m r f f l - on J y 2,201 A t t t tm e,D r Le m e cons de e pl ntf s f b o ya gi or olow up ul 0. ha i . m r i r d ai i f i r m l a s om e t be m ode a e a unc yndr o r t nd hange Dr Le m e opi d t tpl i ifm e t t A m e i a d. . m r ne ha a ntf e s he rc n Coleg ofRhe a ol y c iera f f br ya gi a t the co to c n beexpe t d t pe ss l e um t og rt i or i om l a, nd ha r ndii n a c e o r it fra lat wev mo t .( 31 ) Hec n iee hsd a n sso fb o ag at b c nsse t o t e s t le nhs TR 2 . o sd rd i ig o i f i rmy li o e o itn wih pli ifspan,ftgue se pdior r a muli etnde poi s ( 31 . Dr Le r t antf i ai , le s de , nd tpl e r nt. TR 2) . mme r por e t t bec us ofhe fbr m ya gi , r . yl woul beuna e t w or on a s t ne bas s e t d ha , a e r i o l a M s Ta or d bl o k us ai d i m o e t n t o ho s i a e g hour wor da a t t s w o d fnd i ne s ar t t r ha w ur n n i ht k y, nd ha he ul i t ce s y o ake uns he e wor bra .( 31 .Dr Le ropi dt tpli ifsphysc lmiai wer c duld k e ks TR 3) . mme ne ha antf iali ttons e prs nta t s me lvela itnst a ofAug t5,2009. ( 314 . Att tme oft e e t he n e nd ne iy s us TR ) he i he a nita i hea i t voc tonal xpe tesii dt t hewor r lt d lm ia i i ntfedby dmi sr tve rng, he a i e r t tfe ha t k-ea e i ttons de ii Dr Lemmerwoul prve pero ma eofa wokr ei t naina ec . d e nt fr nc ny r ol n he to l onomy.( 8 . TR 2) Dr Le m e ' fndi a opi on fnd s po ti t m e ca r t f om t f m iy . m r s i ngs nd ni i up r n he di l epors r he a l phys c a D r Sol o A spr ous y not d,Dr Sol on r e r d M r .Ta ort Dr Le m e ' i i n, . om n. evi l e . om ef r e s yl o . m r s c r Dr Sol ae. . omonha te t plitf sncea lat2007.( 92) l arpor d tdM a 8,201 s raed anif i t e s TR . n e t ae y 2, Dr Sol onr a e ha M r . yl s f r f om f b o yal a, t tau a i s r ss om e, . om el t dt t s Ta or uf e s r i r m gi pos -r m tc t es yndr and de es i Heno edci c fndngsi l ngm uli eti rpoi s o iy, nxit i omni pr son. t lnial i i ncudi tpl rgge nt , best a e y,ns a, a d pr s i Bec us ofhers ve e pan a r l e ma f sai ,Dr Sol nd e e son. a e e r i nd eatd nie t tons . omon o ne t t pi d ha M r . yl i una et st sa a wal f m o et n t hour on a s t i d ba i i ar gul s Ta or s bl o i, t nd, nd k or r ha wo s us a ne s s n e ar wor da ( 377) Hef rhe opi dt therco tonwase sntalyt s asofAugus 5, k y. TR . ' t r ne ha u ndii se i l he mne t 2009.( 3 ) Thevoc tona e r t tfe t tt wor rlt lmiai i ntfe byDr TR 78 . ai l xpe tesiid ha he k-eaed i ttons de iid . Sol omonwoul prve tpef ma eofa wor r e.( 8182 . d e n ror nc ny k ol TR - ) I s t c t a y t t A dm i s r tveLaw J e' obs va i n, ta a st tbo h oft n hor, on r r o he ni t a i udg s er to i ppe r ha t he teai physc a r pore clni a fndi ofmuli eti ge poi s a o he m a f sai r tng ii ns e td i c l i ngs tpl rg r nt nd t r nie t tons c i t nt w ih a di gnos s of fbr yal a,a l as as e ry as Aug t 5, 2009. D r Le m e ons s e t a i i om gi t e t al us . m r s ii lyco l pec fca l nc udedt t r . yl ' c i c tndi s ha M s Ta or s lni al i ngs uppor a di gnos soffbr yal aunde t a i i om gi r t c ie i esa ihed by t Ame ia Cole of Rhe t ogy. Bot tea i ph i ins he rtra t bls he rc n lge uma ol h r tng ysca pr oduce tndi whi ht voc tona e r c i r d t bei c tveoft a dia lt f a1 d i ngs c he a i l xpe t onsde e o ndia i ot l s biiy or 1 f msofr a o bl wor a tviy.Si pl sa e i ac ei whi ht cai ta lgesdia lt or e s na e k c i t m y tt d, n as n c he l man le s biiy on t ba i offbr m y gi i i dit c tt i ag ne wha gr t rm e tr ofpr t c ai an he s s i o al a, t s fi ul o m i t ea e asze oof he l m t coul pr d esent . 6 I t r sofo ni e de ,t onl r porswhih s n em pi on vi nce he y e t c ugges r sdua ca ct f r ulr t e i l pa iy or eg a wor a tviy w e e t e gene a e by t sa e a nc phys c a . A s f pl ntf s physca k ci t r hos rtd he t t ge y i i ns or ai if i l c pa t f wor t Adm i sr tve La J a ciy or k, he ni ta i w udge c t a s a e a nc r por pr ied t t ge y e t oduc d by Dr J e . ohn Sadlro J nuay21 2011.( 11 1 .UnlkeDr Le ra DrSol n, . dlrha not e na r , TR 4- 6) i . mme nd . omo Dr Sa e s t e t d M r . yl . The e i no i c i t Dr Sa e hass e pl ntf on any oc as o Hi rae s Ta or r s ndi aton hat . dl r e n ai if c i n. s c i r ton ofpl ntf s c s w a bas d on a r vi w oft m e ca r cor l r vi w i t ons de a i ai i f a e s e e e he di l e ds. n e e ng he r or ,Dr Sa e di no ha t o r uniy t co i rt a s s e of Dr Sol on a t ec ds . dl r d t ve he ppo t t o ns de he s es m nt . om so pli ifsr i f nc i ca ct a ofAugus 5, antf esdual u tonal pa iy s t 2009.Des t t f c t tDr Sa erdi no pie he a t ha . dl d t pe s ly e r ona l xmni M r . yl , nd de piet f c t t hem edi al e or r vi w e by Dr Sa e ne s Ta or a s t he a t ha t c r c ds e e d . dl r d d not i ude a1 of t e pr i ncl l hos oduc d by t t e tng phys c a t A d i s r tve La J e he r a i i i n, he m ni t a i w udge dee mi dt gi Sgea weght'oDr Sade ' opi o ( 35) Thec t tc l t t tr ne o ve ûr t i 't . lrs nin. TR . our mus oncude ha t st e t e oft m e ca r co d i nots hi r a m nt he di l e r s uppore by s t tale de e. td ubsan i vi nc I i w e ls tl d t t w hie notcon r lng o bi ng upon t C o m i s one , he r pors t s l e te ha , l t oli r ndi he m s i r t e t a opi onsf om te tng physci ns s d be ac or d gr a e wei i a di a lt e l ton nd ni r r a i i a houl c de e t r ght n s biiy va ua i t n t e ofno xn i ng physca ,unl st te tng physcins r porsar be ef ofa ha hos ne m ni iins es he r a i i a ' e t e r t ny a tonals ddii uppori evi nc J hns v. r r, F. 650,65 ( h Ci. ) Huntrv. tng de e. o on Banha t434 3d 4 4t r2005 ; e Suli n, F. 31 35( hCi.1 ;Ca l Bowen, F. 1 1 0( hCi. ) lva 993 2d , 4t r 992) mpbelv. 800 2d 247, 25 4t r 1986 . Thi s prncpl i e s ame i i e s mbodidi t go r nga nitai r gultons Under20 C. R.j e n he veni dmi srtve e ai . F. 404.5 d)1 ,ti e i typrvi dt tge rly, ewei wilbegi nt t opi onof 1 27( () i s xplcil o de ha, neal mor ght l ve o he ni ame ia s u c wh h sa t l e a n dt cama t Mo e v r 2 C. R. 4 4.5 7( 2 d c l o re o a cual x mie he li n . ro e , 0 F. j 0 1 2 *( ) y di e t t t g r l m o e w e g s ul be gi n t opi o f om t e tng s c ,s nce s h r c s ha , ene aly, r i ht ho d ve o ni ns r r a i our es i uc pr es i s a e m o e lke y t pr vi a de a l d,l t na pi t e oft c a m a ' m e c l of s onal r r i l o o de t ie ongiudi l c ur he l i nt s di a i nne sa lmiai .Fi ly, r20C. R. 404.5 ( )5)ii not t tmor wei mpai nt nd i ttons nal unde F. j 1 27 d ( ,t s ed ha e ght i pr ry ac or d t t o ni ofa s cals a s ope l c de o he pi on pe i it boutmedialis r l td t t a e of c s ues e ae o he r a s alt peci iy. l t i t ntc s ,i i cl a t tDr Sol on qua ii a a t e tng ph i i M o e r n he ns a a e t s e r ha . om lfes s r a i ys c an. r ove , M r .Ta orhasal o be tea e by D r Lem m e ,who i a boa d c r ii d r um a ol s . Bot s yl s en r t d . r s r e tf e he t ogi t h ph i i nsdi g e fbr yal a ofdi a i s ve iy.Bot phys c a not d c i ca fndi of ysc a a nos d i om gi s blng e rt h i i ns e lni l i ngs muli eti rpoi t , c s ges t pr e eoftbr tpl rgge n s whih ug t he es nc i omyagi .Bot doc o sopi t tM r . l a h t r ned ha s Ta ori una et wo k f rm or t n a tt hour a atm e o ar gul ra s t ne bass yl s bl o r o e ha bou wo s t i n e a nd usai d i a w iho t ki t s hed e br ks The voc tona e r t tf e t ts h lm ia i r nde nd t ut a ng m c ul d ea . a i l xpe t es ii d ha uc i t tons e r pl i ifdi a e f al f m s ofs bsantalga nf e pl ym e . The cou tconc udest tM r . a ntf s bl d or l or u t i i ul m o nt r l ha s Ta orhasm e t bu de i esa i hi diabiiy f a l or sofs t nta ga nf e pl en yl t he r n n t bls ng s lt or l f m ubs a i l i ul m oym t a ofA ugus 5,2009,a a l ge i he s c a i a i f be f t . s t s le d n r e ond pplc ton or ne is l pa sng,t c tnot t ti t Com m i s one ha r a on t dou t ac ur y or n s i he our es ha f he si r d e s o bt he c ac c i t nc oft phys c fndi a o ni pr d by Dr Sol m on and Dr Le m e ,t ons s e y he i al i ngs nd pi ons ovi ed . o . m r he Com m i s one had f la hort t r quie M r .Ta ort a a f a c ula i e l ton by si r ul ut iy o e r s yl o ppe r or ons t tve va ua i a i pe ntmedia s ils de i tdbyt saeag nc Se 20C. R.jj40 1 7a n nde nde c l pecait sgnae he tt e y. e F. 4.51 nd 404. 51 N o s h c ula i exa i to wascom m i s one b t s a edi a lt a nc and, 1 8. uc ons t tve m na i n s i d y he t t s biiy ge y, asi now s a ,t fndi a opi o a t pl i if s i biiy t e ge i s t i w or t t nds he i ngs nd ni ns s o a ntf na lt o nga n us a ned k a tviy a e es e i ly undi pu e by a e m i ng ort e tng s c Fo t s r s , he c t c i t r s nta l s td ny xa ni r a i our e. r he e ea ons t our c l st tpl i ifha m e t bur n ofpr i e t bls ng t t ld s biiy f a1 f m s of onc ude ha a ntf s t he de oof n s a ihi o a i a lt or 1 or s t nt a ga nf l m pl e .Thec r c l ubs a i l i u e oym nt ou t onc udespl n ifha m e t b ld n i t bls ngt t ai tf s t he tr e nes a i hi ha s wasdia edwihi t mea ngoft Ac a ofAugus 5, he s bl t n he ni he t s t 2009,a a l edi c s leg n onneci wih ton t he s c applca i f r a pe i ofdi a lt a di a lt i ur nce be t t r e ond i ton o rod s biiy nd s biiy ns a ne i s. Fo t r s s a e t c ti c ta ne t c l t tt Com m i s oner s fnal r he ea ons t t d, he our s ons r i d o onc ude ha he si ' i d cso i n ts p o tdb s b tn il vd n e Dee d n ' moinf r u r u g n mu t e iin s o u p re y u sa ta e ie c . fn a ts t o s mmayj d me t s o be de ed.Upo t fndi t t a n ifhasm e t bur n of oofaspr crbe by a pur ua ni n he i ng ha pl i tf t he de pr es i d nd s nt t t eAc,u g n wil ee tr df rp an if efn l e iino t Co s in rwil e o h tj d me t lb nee o litf.Th i a d cso f he mmiso e l b r ve s d a t c er om m it d t t Com m i sone f c put ton a a a d ofa opr a e e r e nd he as ec te o he s i r or om a i nd w r ppr i t b n ft.A j d me ta do d ri c n o miywil ee trdt sd y. e eis u g n n r e n o f r t l b n ee hi a The Cl r i diec ed t s nd ce tfe c e oft s o ni t a1 cot s ofr cor ek s r t o e rii d opi s hi pi on o 1 m el e d. Ex rsR : Thi s V-& d y ofseptm ber 2014. a e , rf Chi fUnie St t s D it i tJ e t d a e s r c udge 9

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.