Harris v. New River Valley Regional Jail et al, No. 7:2013cv00520 - Document 25 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 11/22/2013. (kab)

Download PDF

a - e: oFFp 4 :1 - I ::p 4% > A RFI O ,a T ON v A LED N0V 22 2 1 23 I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I STR I T O F VI G I A C R NI RO ANOK E DI SI VI ON NOAH JASON HARRI S, Jub z BK D # cuERK CL ERK CASE NO .7: 3CV00520 1 Pl nt f , ai i f M EM O R AN D U M O PI O N M V. N EW R I ER VA LLEY R EG I NA L JA I V O L, Et aL, . By: Jam esC .Tur k Seni Uni e St esD i t i tJudge or t d at sr c Deendants. f t) Noa J o Hani ,a Vigi a i ae pr e ng pr K ,fl d t s c vi rght a ton h as n s r ni nm t oc edi o ie hi i l i s c i . p ls a tt 4 U.. j 1 8 ,algn t a j i o fcasha e fie t p o i e hm wih fe t u n o 2 SC. 9 3 l ig h t al fiil v ald o r v d i t r e r e m e a he t te t nt i vi a i ofhi c tm tona rght . Upon r vi w oft r cor t nt l alh r a me , n olton s onsi i l i s e e he e d, he cour fndst tHa rs co aitmus bes ma iy dimi s d asl ga l fi ous t i ha ri ' mpl n t um rl s s e e ly rvol . Ha sal ge t the hasbee di gnos d a te t d i t pas f s ve alm e a he lh ni le s ha n a e nd r a e n he t or e r nt l at dior s i udi bi a dior r a pos tax tc sr s dior r He cli s t twhie s der , ncl ng polr s de nd t r lma i tes s de . am ha l i c r eae te Ne Ri rValy Re in lJ i (t j i' ,h h s no r c ie a e u t n ac rtd h w ve le go a al Ã§he al) e a t e ev d d q ae t ' te t ntf hi m e a he lh c tons a has s f r d uns cii d c r a me or s nt l at ondii nd ufe e pe fe omplc tons Ha rs ia i . ri a srs t a t e j i s o l p o i e hm wih fe me tlh at te t n ,bu ise d ji se t h t h al h u d r v d i t r e na e l r ame t t n ta , al h ofi a s ha r peaedl tre t ge' Hari t s a docor who woul c r hi f fcil ve e t y Ã§ i d o t' rs o ee t t d ha ge m or te t n . Ha rsh sc mp an d t t eVigni De rme to Co rci n (VDOC' a o t rame t ri a o lie o h r i a pat n f re to s t & ' bu ) telc o me tl e l te t n a t ej i, t n rs o s fo t eVDOC. h a k f na h at rame t t h al wih o e p n e r m h h Harss e t j i a d te VDOC,s e i g a rle $ 5 , 0 i d ma e f rp i a d ri u s he al n h e k n s eif 2 000 n n g s o an n s fei . He as s e sijmcier l fo d rn j i ofiil t pr vd p o rme tlhe lh u frng lo e k nt tv ei r eig al fcas o o ie r pe n a at e te t n t imae i teftzeo f c co u eo tej i. rame t o n ts n h ul r a e l s r f h al1 r The cour i r r t dim is a aci or c am fl d by a prs r agans a t s equied o s s ny ton l i ie ione i t go r nt le iy orofi e i t c tde e mi st a to o cam i fi ous m ai i us ve nme a ntt fc r f he our tr ne he c i n r li s rvol , lc o , o fist sae acam o whc rle ma b g a td. 28U. C.j 1 5 b ( ) To sae a r al o tt li n ih eif y e rn e S. 91 A( )1. tt c us of a ton unde j1 a pl ntf mus etbls t the ha be n de i d ofrght a e ci r 983, ai if t sa ih ha s e prve i s g a e d by t Consiu i or lws of t Unie St t s a t tt s de i ton r s t d uar nt e he tt ton a he t d a e nd ha hi prva i e ule fo c r m onduc c t omm itd by ape s n a tng t rc orofsa e lw . W es v.At ns 487 U. te r o ci mde ol tt a t ki , S. 4 (9 8. 2 18) Hars c an f l t nn a pr defnda s Hec ri' omplit ais o me ny oper e nt. nnnotptruea j1 cai ls 983 l m a ans t ej i o t eVDOC,a net e o te ee tte i n ta Ã» ro 's be tt s i t e g i t h al r h s ih r f h s niis s o Ã» s n' u j c o ut md r pe 1 1 8 . Se Prv lv.Re o 2 3 F.d 8 ,2 0 W L 2 5 ,a # ( t Ci.J n.1 ,2 0 ) 9 3 e ea n , 0 3 21 0 0 0 91 t 1 4h r a 3 0 0 (n bih d ( u tn W ilv. ih a nDe to S aePoie 49 U. 5 ,7 (98 )( ig u pu ls e ) q o ig l M c ia p' f tt lc , 1 S. 8 1 1 9 fndn t a Co n at a d is a e ce a e n tp ro s u e j1 8 ) 4 co v.Ch s p a e h t mmo we 1h n t g n is r o e s n nd r 9 3 ;A c y ea e k Co rcin lCe tr 7 8 F.S p 8 0 8 3 9 ( D.Va 1 9 )(i dng ct ji i re to a n e, 8 u p. 9 , 9 -4 E. . 9 2 fn i iy al mmun fo e rm s ta dn tap ro f rp r os so j 1 8 ) Th r f r, ri'camsa an tt e ed fn a t ui n o e s n o u p e f 9 3 . ee o e Hars li g is h s e e d n s 1 Hari i advied t he smpl hasno sandi t vi cat t rght ofal f r prs sat rs s s hat i y t ng o ndi e he i s l um e ioner t j i,a he i atmp ig t do. M o eLod eNo.l v.I i,407U. 1 ,1 ( 97 )( ltga he al s s te tn o os g 07 rvs S. 63 66 1 2 a ii nt Ã§ ssa dig t se rdrs f ij isd net hm,bu ma no se rdesfrij i do t s tn n o e k e e s or nure o o i t y t e k e rs o nures ne o ha ot r ';Hu rv.Dat n,65 F. 621 6 626( t Ci.981 ( dngt tpr s prs ne ma n hes' mme ) lo 7 2d , 25 4h r1 ) holi ha o e io r y ot s r ea aÃ§ nihter n 'f rohe imae , u ma ony se t e f c h so rg s . e v s Ã§ g ra t' o t r n ts b t y l e k o n ore i wn iht) k mus besl rl dimisd underj 1 5A( ()a lgaly fi ousz An a o it or r t lmmaiy s se 91 b) 1 s e l rvol . pprprae de wilis t sda l s ue hi y. Fo t r ao sae t ec u t s se Ha i ' c mplitwi u p eu ie pls a t r he e s ns ttd,h o r dimis s n ss o an t t rj dc , t u n ho r t j 1 5 b ( ) f rfiu et saeacam. Hi ma y p n i moi n i t i a to wilb o 91 A( )1, o alr o tt li s n e dng to s n h s ci n l e dim is a m oot s s ed s . The Clr i die t d t s nd c es of t s m e o andum opi on a ac om pa ng ek s rce o e opi hi m r ni nd c nyi or rt pl i i f de o a ntf . ENTER:Thi * > s y ofN o mbe , 3. ve r 201 . Se ' o 4 nie Stt Diti tJ td aes src udge 2 I any event Ha s c mpli f i t algef css ig a y a to bl j 1 cai n , ni ' o ant al o le a t Ã tn n cina e 983 l m s a ans gi t a on Fr hi s redeciton o e e s i i ce rta j i ot asha rpe tdl ofrdt ny e. om s pas srpi f v nt,t s la h t al fkil ve e ae y fee o pr de Har i wih ac ovi rs t cesst ment healh te m ent whih he has r it See Esele v.Gambl 429 o al t r at , c es sed. t l e, U. 9 1 ( 97 (i i t a o y d lbe ae idif r n et i t ' s ro me c lne dsvolt s S. 7, 02 1 6) fndng h t nl ei rt n fe e c o nmaes e ius dia e i ae t e Ei t Ame dme , a me c n glg nc i i u t int t i iae c nsiui al rg t) h ghh n nt nd dial e ie e s ns fk e o mplc t o tt ton ih s. M or over w hie t s e mus notdeny an i eaccesst ne s y medi car t aloc i oft e , l he Gt t nmat o ces ar cal e, he l aton he c s f t tte t n i amatrofsaelw a i no a ton bl un rj 1 3. S Ciy ofRe r v. o t or ha rame t s te tt a nd s t c i a e de 98 ee t ve e M asa h et Ge e a Ho pi , 3 U. 23 2 ( 98 . s c us ts n r l s ll46 S. 9, 45 1 3)

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.