Widener v. Vargo, No. 7:2013cv00516 - Document 19 (W.D. Va. 2014)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/17/2014. (tvt)

Download PDF
CLERK' OFFI U, DI COURT S CE S. SK AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI I A CT RG NI R O AN O K E DI VISI N O JO SH UA DA V I W I ENER , D D Pett oner, ii V. M A R I VA R G O , E Res ponde . nt ) ) ) ) ) ) ) sEF 1? 2 1 21 JuLA l BY: c RK Ci lAci No.7:3-v- 6 vi ton 1 c 0051 M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON NI By: H on.G l n E.C onr e ad Chi Unied St e Dit i tJudge ef t at s s r c J hua D a d W i ne ,a V igi a i a e pr e ng w ih couns ,f l d a pe ii n f r a os vi de r r ni nm t oc edi t el ie tt o o wrto ha e sc r s p ru n t 2 U. C. 2 4,oc alng as ne c i o e b te i f b a opu , u s a t o 8 S. j 25 t h le e e tn e mp s d y h Cic tcour ofSmyt Count W i ne a gue t thi s t nceoflf i prs r ui t h y. de r r s ha s en e ie m ionmentwihout t t ep sblt o p r l f rc mmit gc ptl r e whl aj ve iei u c nsi to a i lg t h osiii f a oe o o ti a ia mu d r i u nl s n o tt in l n ih y n e u o Milr Alb ma U. , 3 S. . 45 ( 1 )(e en he ,h E ilrcam'. f l v. a a , e S. 1 2 Ct 2 5 20 2 h r ia r t e G l li ' 1 u l e ) Re ponde fld amotont dim is a t a ton i rpef diposton. Afe r e ng t s nt ie i o s s , nd he c i s i or s ii tr eviwi he rc r t c u t imis step tto wi o tp eu c a u e a se e o d,he o r ds se h eiin t u rj die s n xh u td. h Fede alha asr e i desg dt gi ç tt c t af 1and f i opporuniyt r be eviw s i ne o ve t a e ours u1 s ar t t o r s vef r c tt tona c am sbe or t ecl msa epr e e t t f de a c t. e ol ede al onsiu i l l i f e hos ai r es nt d o he e r l ours' ' O' ulv nv. e c e, 2 U. 8 , 4 ( 9 9 .ût sbe n stld sn eEx p reRo al 1 7 S lia Bo rk l 5 6 S. 38 8 6 1 9 ) û ha e et i c l e a t v l, 1 U. 2 ( 8 6 ,h t saeprs n rmu t o mal e h u t valbesaej dca rme is S. 41 1 8 ) t a a tt io e s n r ly x a s a i l tt u iil e de a be or af de a co twile e ti hi peii f ha sc pus' Pi r v. f e e r l ur l ntra n s tton or bea or .' ca d Connor 40 U . , 4 S. 270,275( 971.TheSuprmeCour oft Unie Sttsha ç onsse l ad rdt t s 1 ) e t he td ae s t itnty hee o hi c f de a polc f i woul be uns e l i ourdua s t m of g r e f a f r dit i t e r l i y, or t d em y n l ys e ove nm nt or ede al s r c c t o u e a saecour co c i wihouta opporuniy t t sae c t t c r c a our t ps t t t t nviton t n t t o he t t ours o ore t c tt i lvi ai ' I (ntr lquoai maksomitd) onsiutona olton.' d.i ena tton r te . 1W i ne wa as s ntnc t t e co ec i lf s nt esf t r pe,bur ay,a r bbe yt to ured de r s lo e e ed o hr e ns utve ie e enc or he a glr nd o r ha cc r dtrngt smeeve sast mur r li he a nt he de . Ther o d r ve st tW i xne xpr s n edt M ilrdai t t Supr m eCour of ec r e al ha dene ve e e t he le m o he e t Vigi a.W i ne a guesi r pons t t m o i t dim ist lsa ec t e ed e a e r ni de r r n es e o he ton o s s ha t t our r m i s r e use bee us hem es n edt M ilrdam t t Cic tCour o Smyt Count vi apr xha t d a e e t he le i o he r ui tf h y a o K m oto t va t Howe r t sc l i i nots ppore by 1 w be us W i ne m us i n o cae. ve ,hi onc uson s u td a ca e de r t . pr entt cai t t hi s sa ec ta pe mit d b sae lw .2 Se j.a 275- Pe es he l m o he ghe t tt our s r te y t t a e ls t 78. r Vig naCo ej8016 4 A) 1, ie rma fl apeiin frawrt fh b a c musdr cl r i i d . - 5 ( () W d ne y ie t o o t io a es o ie ty t t Supr m eCou ofVig ni and t ,W i ne E t rg unde t lw oft St t t o he e rt r i a, hus de r t he i ht has r he a he a e o r s . . . teq eto p e e td' oVigi a' hi tco t3 28U. C. 2 5 4 se aie h u sin r s ne 't r ni s ghes ur . S. j 2 4 *; e O' lva 526U. at845- (e ni ngt ditnci bewe naprs rsrghtt fl a Suli n, S. 47 rcog zi he si ton t e ione ' i o ie nd asaec tsdicei t rviw aha aspetton) tt our' srton o e e be ii . I i no a oprae f t sc tt pr di twhehe t Supr m eCour ofVigi awo d t s t ppr it or hi our o e c t r he e t r ni ul dim ist pe ii duet a sae pr e alr l de r le on t mert,orgr ntr lefon t s s he tton o t t oc dur ue, ny e if he is a ei he pot i ly m e iorousc am a ma t saci n m oot Se Pi a d,404 U. a 275. The ental rt i l i nd ke hi to . e cr S. t e usi r uie xha ton eq r menti ta a omm odai n ofo f r ls t m desg d t gvet St t t s tn cc to ur ede a yse i ne o i he a e he i ta opporuniy t pa supon a c r c al ged vi a i ofisprs ne s f r lrght . I nii l t t o s nd ore t le oltons t i o r ' ede a i s' d. ' Ac r ngl t c tdimis st pe ii f awrtofhabe co pusasunexha td t a l co di y,he our s s e he tton or i as r use o low t Supr me Cour ofVigi at consde W i ne ' M ilrc am . he e t r ni o i r de r s le l i ENTER:Ths / N d yo S pe e , 01 i N a f e tmb r 2 4. ChifUnie St t sDititJ e e t d a e src udg 2W i ne fld t Dr K imotont va t i lds t e'o J 3,201 By lte a opi one er on de r ie he o t i o cae nvai enenc ' n une 3. etr nd ni nt ed Oco e 29 201 ,h Cic i Co r o S t Co nyd nida dds se tepoK moinfrlc o jrs ito tb r , 3 te rut u t f myh u t e e n imis d h r to o ak f uidcin be aus mor t t p oneda ha pa s d snc t s ntnci or rwa entr d,puruan t Rul 1: oft c e e han went ys d s e i e he e e ng de s e e s t o e 1 he Rul oft Supr meCour ofVigi a The ei noe denc t tW i ne a ldt decso t t Suprme es he e t r ni. r s vi e ha de r ppeae hat iin o he e Cour ofVigi ao fl amoto f radelye c i na a lwihi sxmont ahe t dimis or rbe me t r ni r ied in o a d rmi l ppea t n i hs r he s s al de ca fn lp ru ntoVigni Co ej1 .-211o j1 .-212 ia; u sa t r i a d 923 . r 92 3 .. oA lhough W i ne tl apr K pe ii f rawrtofha scom uswih t Cicui Cou ofSmyt Co t i t de r ied o tton o i bea t he r t rt h uny n Api2 03 teCic iCo r ga tdW i n rsmoint vou trl ds s tep tto wi o t rj dc , n rl 0 ,h rut u t rne de e' to o lnai imis h ei n t u p eu ie a d y i h W i nerdi notr fl t habea pettonw ih et rt Cicui Cour ofSmyt Count ort Supr eCour of de d e ie he s ii t ihe he r t t h y he em t Vigi a r ni.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.