DiRico v. Virginia Department of Transportation et al, No. 7:2013cv00440 - Document 3 (W.D. Va. 2013)

Court Description: MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 10/02/2013. (rkc)

Download PDF

CLERKS OFFI E U .B.DI cot r C ST. l ATROANOKE,V A FIED L I THE UNI STATESDI N TED STRI COURT CT FO R TH E W E STE RN D I STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A RO A N O K E DIV ISIO N SA LLY D EE D IR IC O , Pl nt f ai i f, V. VI GI A DEPARTM ENT O F R NI TR AN SPO R TA TI N ,ET A L. O , D efendants. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) 2CT C2 2 1 23 J A C. ULI DUDLEY CL ERK BY: Ci lAc i No.7: vi ton 13CV440 M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N N O By:Samue G.W is l lon Unied St es D itri Judge t at s ct Pr s Pli ifSal DeeDi c (( Rio' brng t ss xualdici nai a ton i o e antf ly Rio C c ' i s hi e Di ) s rmi ton ci n for mapau ri underTil V1 oft Ci lRiht Ac of1 42U. C.j2000e e s q. pe s te l he vi g s t 964, S. ,te (0 ) S eh sn me a d fn a t teVignaDe rme to Trns o tto (VDOT' a d 2 06 . h a n d s ee d n s h r ii pat n f a p rain ( $ 'n ) t e VDOT e oye swhoi eviwe he,Da dClr (' ake',Stc Ket (Ã§ ih', hr e mpl e ntr e d r vi ake $ r ') a y ih ; t ' Cl Ke ) a DonnaGrha (( a m') Di c algest tt dee nt fiedt pr ehe nd a m C ha '. Rio le ha he fnda s al o omot r Gr bec us ofhe s a i t d hied a m a w ho w a notased a e qua ii d,o s le For a e r ex nd nsea r n s uc t d, lfe r kil d. t f l ngr as ,hecou twilg a tDi co' a iai t pr e i mapau i he olowi e ons t r l r n Ri s pplc ton o oce d nfor pers; ds s d fn a t Clr e Ket , n Grh m wih u p eudc ; n , n e 28U. C. imis ee d n s ak , ih a d a a t o t rj ie a d u d r S. j 1 5e ( ( (i, imisDi c scamswih u p eu ieb c u ete c nani u fce t 91 ()2)B)i d s s Rio' li ) t o t rj d c e a s h y o ti ns fiin f s. act Di co ha be n e pl Ri s e m oyed by V D OT snce 1 i 999,fr ta a Roa a D e i n Engi e is s dw y s g ne r Te hni i n a m os r c nty asa Cont a tA dm i s r t r l 2011 D i c a i d f a c c a nd t ee l rc nit a o . n , Ri o pple or poston a Cont a tM ana ra t V D OT Chr s i ns lg Re i nc V D OT i e v e e ii s rc ge t he i ta btr s de y. nt r i w d D iki al w ih t o m en,f t posii The i ervi ersi uded Cl ke,K eih,and l co, ong t w o< he ton. nt ew ncl ar t Gr aham ,who appeart be V D OT s vi ors VD O T di notof er Di co t posii i t o uper s . d f m he ton; nsead, one oft m en gott posii he he ton. r Di c alg st a s eha b e s b e t osx l ic i naina dGe ls l e(h ) Rio le e h t h s e n u j c t e ua d srmi to n Ã» elj i s e f k w a t m os qua ii f rt pos ton a i w asgi n t t sm a d t f vo ii m a hi s he t lfed o he ii nd t ve o hi n ue o a rt s nd m bei a m a ' D i c a s alege s i m o e e a e s led,a qua ii d f t pos ton ng n.' Ri o l o l s he s r duc t d, kil nd lf e or he ii ' t nt m a slce ha he n e e t d. l 1. Di c hasna dt eei vi lde e nt whoa eno s jc t s tunde Til V1. Rio me hr ndi dua f nda s r t ube t o ui r te I l i w el es a i hed t ts vi o sa e no la e i t i i vi ualc pac tesunde Til V l . t s l t bls ha uper s r r t i bl n he r ndi d a ii r te I Lisuv.S. sa FoodSvcsI ,159F. 1 1 ( h Ci.1 )(1 a l i ofTil Vl' . nc. 3d 77, 80 4t r 998 C nayss te ls An l ng ge a isr m e a s he e l a ust .,. ncl t ts r i or a e notla e i t i a ua nd t e di l c m e ds o co ude ha upe v s s r i bl n he r i vi c pa ii f Til Vl vi ai . Rahe ,Congr si e dt te o s ndi dual a ctes or te l oltons' ). t r es ntnde ha mplyer s dbela ef Til VI vi ai .J1a 1 houl ibl or te l oltons .. t 81.Theco tt r fr ,dimis wihout ( ur,he eo e s ses t p eu ied fn a sClr e Ket a d Grh m. rj dc ee d nt ak , i n a a h, 1 1. 1 Di i o al o a l ge VD O T di c i i t d a i the on t ba i ofs x. W ihoutf c s R c s le s s rm na e ga ns r he s s e t at s fci ntt s uf i e o how t tsm ia l s t t d m en r c ve f vor bl tea m e ove he , he c t ha i l r y iua e e ei d a a e r t nt r r t our fndst tD i c ha f ie t s i ha Ri o s a l d o how t ts hasa pl us bl c a m f r le . ha he a i e l i or e i f Fe R. v. o.8()2)r uie ats t ndpli sae n oft cai s ngt t d. Ci Pr a ( eq rs Ã»hor a an ttme t he l m howi ha t plad i e ildt r i . Unde 28U. C.j 1 5( ( ( (i,acour s l d ta tme' he e er s ntte o elef' ' r S. 91 e)2)B)i) t halÃ§ ny i ' a dimisa i mapau ri co an i i 'aist saeacai uponwhi r le ma be s s n nfor pe s mplit f t t l o tt l m f ch eif y g a ed.' The c tcons r spr s co pl i slbe aly, m pos ng l s sr nge s a r t n r nt ' our t ue o e m a nt i r l i i e s t i nt t nda ds ha f ma pladi d atd bylwyes Se Hanesv. r re a.404U. 51 (97 .A or l e ngs r fe a r. e i Kene t l, S. 9 1 2) com pl ntm us ,how ever,stl cont n s fci f ualm ater accept ast t Ã»st e a cl m ai t il ai uf i ent act t, ed rue, o Ã» at ai ofr ift ti plusbl onisfc ' As r t l l 556U. 662,678( ele ha s a i e t a e. hcof v.gba, ' S. 2009)(uoi Bel q tng l At.Cor v.Twombl 550U. 544,570( ) l p. y, S. 2007). Tosaeacam f dici nai unde Til V1,Ditcomus e tbls . 1 s i a tt li or s rmi ton r te l li t sa ih' ) he s ( me e o apr tce ca s ()s eh ss tsa tr o p ro ma c ; 3 s ewa s be tdt mb r f oe td ls; 2 h a aif co yj b ef r n e ( ) h s u j ce o a ree oyme a to a ( smial st tde oye outi ofhe pr ecedcas dves mpl nt cin; nd 4) i lry iuae mpl es sde r ot t l s r ce ve m or f vo a e tea m e . Se Col m a v. a vl nd Co tofAppe l , F, 1 e i d e a r bl r t nt e e n M r a ur a s 626 3d 87, 1 ( hci. 0) 90 4t r 201 . Di c algesVDOT di no pr ehe be a eofhe s x(nal eda re Rio le d t omot r c us r e a leg dve s e oyme tacin)a i ta hie amael se ae s le a qualfe t nher She mpl n to nd nse d rd l es duc td, kild, nd iid ha . hasnot ho e r a l ged Jtw t m al w a l s e a e s le orqua i i * D i c has w ve , le z he e s es duc t d, kil d, p lfed. Ri o , sm pl s a e t ts be i vesV D OT di crm i t d aga ns he ,buthe t ea r r c t l i y t t d ha he le s i na e i t r r hr dba e e ia s c ani ufce f t matrt s t tasmial st t (rls q lfe mae onti ns fiint acual te o how ha i lry iuaed o e s uaiid) l e pl m oyee r ce ved f vor bl tea m e . W hie t pl a ng r e do no i pos a e tng e i a a e r t nt l he e di ul s tm e n xac i sa d r o Di c , h mu t fe s mef cst s p r aj d me ti h rfv r l t er tn a d n Rio s e s o fr o a t o u po t u g n n e a o . n h i a e c ,hec u t ld s s Di c ' c mpan a an tVDOT wi o t rj dc . bsn e t o r wil imis m o s o li t g is t u p eu ie h Fo t ef r g igra o ,h c ur wi ga tDi c ' a p iaint p o e di o ma r h o e on e s ns te o t l r n Rio s p lc to o r c e nf r l pa pe i' imisdee d n sClr e Ket a dGrha wi o t rj dc ; n ,md r2 U. C. u rs d s s fn a t ak , i n a m t u p eu ie a d l e 8 S. , h, h j1 5 e( )B)i) ds s Di io scamswi u p eu ief rfiu et saecam u o 91 ()2 ( (i, imis l c ' li t t t rj dc o alr o tt li p n ho whi h r le m a be gr e c e if y ant d. , ,/ EN TER :Oc obe 2, 201 t r 3. z' . . z y*# TED STA TES D I STRI J G E CT UD *D i c > EEOC cha ges soutVD OT, e a ton f t hii c c K...wefnaly s lc e anot r l os ki r et s xplnai or he rng hoie:< i l ee t d he ca daewhowebelevem or cos l f t poston' r uie e sa t stm e. V DOT' r s asr l dt ndi t i e l ey ks he ii s eq r m nt t hi i ' ' S ea on, eaye o D i c by Hum a Re our s w a t tt chos nca daeha e re c i c r tm onio i Rio n s ce , s ha he e ndi t d xpe inc n ontac t rng.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.